Kate's Song (10 page)

“And what do you think you have there?” Mamma said as she came into the kitchen.

Kate gave her mother a half smile. “It is a gift, Mamma.”

“A gift! Another gift from that boy I am not supposed to know about? If he wants to be secretive about his courting, he should think better about bringing you a present every time he comes.”

“They are not just for me, Mamma, or I would never have accepted them,” Kate said. “They are for all the family.”

Mamma laughed. “Ach, does that young man think I just fell off the turnip truck? Soon I will have to move out of the house to make room for all the gifts that aren’t really yours.” Mamma bustled over to the kitten and bent down to run her hand over its soft fur. “Did you tell him I am not keen on animals in the house?”

“I did not have the heart. He was so excited to give it to me.”

“You do not have the heart to ever disappoint him, I think,” Mamma said. When Kate did not reply, she added, “She will be a very beautiful cat.”

“I can keep her in my room,” Kate said.

“For a few more weeks, until she is old enough to look after herself. Then she stays in the barn with Rollie and the cows,” Mamma insisted.

“What will I tell Nathaniel?”

Laughing, Mamma stopped her ears with her hands. “Ach, do not say his name! How are you supposed to court in secret if your mother knows so much? It is lucky that you did not betray his last name. Still, you have gotten my curiosity up. Now every time I meet a ‘Nathaniel’ I will look at him and wonder if he is your boyfriend.”

Kate joined in the laughter. “Oh, Mamma. The secret courting happened in Grandmammi’s day, not now. But when you see my mystery boyfriend, perhaps you should tell him you will soon be living in the barn to make room for all his gifts.”

“I could never scold the poor boy. He could not be more altogether-turned-every-which-way in love with you. He has enough to worry about.” Mamma’s cheerful expression faded, and she grasped Kate’s hand. “If you leave us, leibe, you will let him down softly?”

Unable to speak with the boulder-sized lump clogging her throat, Kate nodded.

“Jah, I know my Katie.” Mamma gave her hand a squeeze. “Will you separate the cream and make the butter before you mop?”

“Jah, of course.”

Mamma smiled weakly, picked up the compost bucket, and hurried out the back door.

Kate couldn’t help but feel a slight twinge of resentment that Mamma felt concern for Nathaniel King’s feelings and seemed to disregard Kate’s. But she immediately regretted that unworthy sentiment. Of course her family cared about Nathaniel. He was one of the community. Kate felt more like an outsider every day.

She playfully fondled the kitten’s ears, feeling renewed gratitude for Nathaniel’s gift. She would be a beautiful cat, as Mamma said.

“He’s taking a great risk, you know.” Kate snapped her head up and saw Elmer, arms folded, leaning against the doorframe.

“Don’t sneak up on me like that,” she said. “You shaved ten years off my life.”

“I was just standing here. It’s not my fault you never notice me. The kitten saw me.”

Kate rolled her eyes.

“The big question is, did Mamma see the kitten?” Elmer said.

“Jah. She’s been banished to the barn as soon as she is old enough.”

Elmer knelt next to Kate and rubbed the kitten’s head. “It’s too bad you had to come to the one house in Apple Lake that does not welcome furry creatures. Mamma is very hostile about cat hair.”

“She is pretty, though, isn’t she?”

“A gift from Nathaniel?” Elmer said.

“Jah. How did you know?”

“That is probably the dumbest question you have ever asked, and I’ve heard some dumb ones.”

Kate cuffed Elmer on the shoulder before he could scoot away from her.

“You can’t keep anything from me. I’m your brother. And smart. Too smart to be fooled.”

“And humble.”

“Jah,” Elmer said. “Humility is my best quality.”

Kate lifted the kitten into her arms and nuzzled it against her cheek. “A kitten is a practical gift. Nathaniel has a gute head on his shoulders, you know.”

Elmer scratched his head. “If that is true, why is he taking such a chance with you?”

“What nonsense are you spouting?”

“Just in case you haven’t noticed, Nathaniel is well-liked and highly respected. He cares for his dat, and he employs eleven or twelve men in his business. He’s the first to help solve problems with windmills and propane tanks or rebuild after a fire.”

“Jah, of course people regard him highly. He is a gute man. I know that.”

“He has made it perfectly clear how he feels about you,” Elmer said. “To everyone. When it comes to Kate Weaver, we all know right where he stands, even though no one is sure how you feel about Nathaniel. He doesn’t hold anything back or try to be anything less than honest about his intentions.”

Kate lowered her head and looked at the floor. “Jah, I know. It is one of the things I love about him. But you cannot blame me for that.”

“No, of course not. I don’t. But, Kate, if you reject him, the entire community will know, and they will pity him. They might treat him with uncommon kindness, but he will still feel their pity. And such a man as Nathaniel surely would dislike being pitied by anyone.”

Kate couldn’t meet Elmer’s eyes. She handed him the kitten then stood and pulled an empty pitcher out of the cupboard. “If you tell me this to make me feel worse, it’s working.”

“Don’t go along your merry way, searching to discover yourself, and forget that Nathaniel has feelings too.”

“Do you really believe me to be that uncaring?”

“No, but I see that other things pull at you besides Nathaniel King.”

Kate lifted the spigot jar, full of last night’s milking, from the icebox. “You are my little brother, Elmer. What do you know?”

“I was the only member of our family who came to your farewell recital, remember? Everyone else thought it would be improper. With all the applause, you smiled so wide I could count all your teeth. I know you took three extra bows at the end of your performance. I know you love to sing. That would be hard enough to leave behind. But you also like the attention from people who admire your talent.”

Instead of responding, Kate opened the spigot and let the milk drain into the pitcher. She closed the spigot when nothing was left in the jar but the cream from the top. “Do you think I’m wicked, Elmer?”

“Aaron and Ada believe they are qualified to judge such things,” Elmer said. “But not me. Last week at the dairy, Matthew Eicher told me I had a head of cheese.”

Kate couldn’t help but chuckle. “I have always believed that.”

Elmer laughed too. “No, no. I mean a head
for
cheese. He said the batches I make are especially good, and from now on, he wants me to supervise making the cheddar. I would never tell this to anyone but you, but I am tempted to be proud. Someone sees that I am good at something, and I am glad for it. Is it wrong to feel that way? Is it wrong to feel satisfied that I have done a job well and maybe brought in more business for the dairy? I do not know. Is it wrong for Aaron to plant the most beautiful, best-tended garden in the community? Does he take pride in his work?”

“Of course not.”

“But is he tempted? And what about Mamma? She is a very good cook, but no one other than Nathaniel has ever praised her for her skill. Does that make her sad?” Elmer put the kitten by her bowl of milk and unfolded himself from the ground. “Here,” he said. “Let me help you.”

Kate handed him the churn and he nimbly turned the crank on the top of the glass jar that rotated the blades inside, which would eventually transform the heavy cream into butter.

Elmer glanced at Kate. “I think about you a great deal. When you are gone to the academy, I wonder if you are happy. Wonder if the attention brings you what you are looking for. I don’t have any answers, but I know a little bit how you feel.”

“I truly want to do God’s will. You believe that, don’t you?”

“I do not believe. I know.”

“Going off to school two years ago, I was sure that I had chosen the right direction for my life. I wanted to sing. And I am afraid that my own desires shout so loudly, I won’t be able to hear the will of God when He speaks to me. This talent I have, the talent God has given me, can open so many doors for me. No one in the community but Nathaniel knows anything of my success at the academy. I’ve already attracted the attention of the people at the Met National Council auditions.”

“Is that important?”

“It is a feather in my cap, to be sure. I’ve won two singing competitions this year, and my vocal coach, Dr. Sumsion, she says I could be a big star someday.”

“I can guess what she thinks of the Plain life,” Elmer said.

Kate heard Dr. Sumsion’s voice in her head. “
Go back to that Amish town, and what will you become? An Amish farmer’s wife, never knowing how far you could have gone with your voice.”

“My own people know nothing of what I have accomplished in this other world. And, jah, I know it is the grossest pride to wish they knew, to want my family to be pleased. But none of you really care.”

Elmer momentarily paused the cranking. “It brings you much pain.”

Kate fell silent. She had already trusted Elmer with too much information. She did not want him to think badly of her. And he didn’t know the half of it. Only days before she left Milwaukee, she had auditioned for
Romeo et Juliette
, the student opera, and was waiting to hear if she got the title role. Who in her family would want to hear that piece of news?

“I’m sorry,” he said.

To most people, Kate’s choice would be easy. Who would not jump at the chance of celebrity and riches? But Kate had grown up in a place where, until recently, she felt love permeating the very atmosphere. How much acceptance did Kate feel from the other girls competing for roles? Or the judges and critics who analyzed every sound that came out of her mouth? The world of auditions, competitions, and self-promotion could be very cold.

Even after the most stunning performances, majestic concert halls were left empty and dark. Would that be her fate? She might live her life being admired but not loved—her fans not caring about her as a person as much as they cared about her as a celebrity.

At school she convinced herself that she could still visit her family, could still be a part of them. After all, as long as she was not baptized, they would be allowed to see her. Shunning only took place after a baptized member went astray. But she knew she was only fooling herself. A music career such as the one she wanted would take her to the coast or, more likely, to Europe, and she would not see Mamm and Dat for months or years at a time. They certainly would not travel to visit her and never dream of actually seeing her perform. When she could come back for a rare visit, they would welcome her, but she would be a guest and not one of them. She would be a stranger in her own home, an interloper in the Amish community she loved so dearly. Only now was she beginning to see the stark reality. Her family would be lost to her forever.

Elmer looked at her doubtfully. “I shouldn’t say this. I know it’s unfair, but…” He looked down at the churn in his hands. “Please stay, Kate. You have no idea how happy I’ve been since you came back. Remember how we used to sit out on the porch and talk until Mamm scolded us to get to bed?”

“Or we’d hide from Aaron, and I’d sing to you?”

“Or make faces at each other during services?” He frowned. “Kate, if I lose you, I’ll be devastated.” He stared at her, his eyes full of emotion.

Kate felt a tear slip down her cheek. “I am sorry about all this.”

“Now here I’ve made you cry, when all I wanted was to make you feel guilty.”

They laughed, and Elmer handed her the churn. “I’ve got to get to the dairy. While I am gone, think on this. Some of the blessed apostles were nothing but humble fishermen—and the Lord Jesus, a carpenter. They did not need to be famous. Perhaps you do not need fame either.” He took his hat from the stand and opened the door. “Tell Joe and Ben that if they are not at the dairy in ten minutes, I will make them do the mucking out.”

Wrinkling her nose, Kate took up the churning.

Despite all her struggles, she took comfort in the thought that Elmer trusted her motives. So did Nathaniel. That was all the reassurance she needed.

Kate opened the front door to see Nathaniel standing there with his permanent smile. He always sent her heart racing.

“Ready?” he said.

“Jah, denki for the ride.”

She, Nathaniel, and Nathaniel’s mamm were taking a trip to La Crosse with an Englisch friend Nathaniel had met through his cabinet business. By buggy the ride would certainly be a long trek, but by car the trip took less than an hour.

Nathaniel let her lead the way to the car and opened the door for her.

“It is fortunate that your need to travel to La Crosse happened at the same time as my plan to visit a vendor in the city,” Nathaniel said.

Kate inwardly vowed to be more careful about what she told Nathaniel. She had mentioned that she needed to go to La Crosse, and in less than a day, he had the entire trip arranged. She smiled at his readiness to do anything for her, and she would never willfully take advantage of his abundant kindness. But once the words were spoken, the trip to La Crosse became inevitable. Nathaniel would hear no objections.

Kate climbed into the backseat with sheer dread. A ride to La Crosse sitting next to Nathaniel’s mamm—who, on good authority, did not approve of Kate—didn’t seem like a pleasant way to spend the morning.

Nathaniel’s mother, Miriam, was as reserved as Nathaniel was cheerful. Kate remembered Miriam from her childhood as the woman who brought over foul-tasting concoctions when Kate or one of her siblings fell sick. Mamma would insist that Kate drink every last drop of the mixture that tasted like dandelion juice and rancid milk blended together.

“Gute maiya, Miriam,” Kate said, hoping she sounded sufficiently humble and deliriously chipper.

Nathaniel’s mamm nodded and forced a half smile.

Kate busied herself fastening the seat belt. “Thank you very much for driving us, Dr. Delange.”