Star Wars on Trial (2 page)

Read Star Wars on Trial Online

Authors: David Brin,Matthew Woodring Stover,Keith R. A. Decandido,Tanya Huff,Kristine Kathryn Rusch

BOOK: Star Wars on Trial
8.54Mb size Format: txt, pdf, ePub

FOR THE PROSECUTION:

David Brin

FOR THE DEFENSE:

Matthew Woodring Stover

 

INTRODUCTION By David Brin
1

INTRODUCTION By Matthew Woodring Stover
7

OPENING STATEMENTS
15

FOR THE PROSECUTION: David Brin
17

FOR THE DEFENSE: Matthew Woodring Stover
55

CHARGE #1: THE POLITICS OF STAR WARS ARE ANTI-DEMOCRATIC AND ELITIST
81

FOR THE DEFENSE: Keith R. A. DeCandido
83

CHARGE #2: WHILE CLAIMING MYTHIC SIGNIFICANCE, STAR WARS PORTRAYS NO ADMIRABLE RELIGIOUS OR ETHICAL BELIEFS
97

FOR THE PROSECUTION: John C. Wright
99

FOR THE DEFENSE: Scott Lynch
121

CHARGE #3: STAR WARS NOVELS ARE POOR SUBSTITUTES FOR REAL SCIENCE FICTION AND ARE DRIVING REAL SF OFF THE SHELVES
135

FOR THE PROSECUTION: Lou Anders
137

FOR THE DEFENSE: Laura Resnick
151

FOR THE DEFENSE: Karen Traviss
159

FOR THE DEFENSE: Kristine Kathryn Rusch
169

CHARGE #4: SCIENCE FICTION FILMMAKING HAS BEEN REDUCED BY STAR WARS TO POORLY WRITTEN SPECIAL EFFECTS EXTRAVAGANZAS
183

FOR THE PROSECUTION: John G. Hemry
185

FOR THE DEFENSE: Bruce Bethke
199

CHARGE #5: STAR WARS HAS DUMBED DOWN THE PERCEPTION OF SCIENCE FICTION IN THE POPULAR IMAGINATION
217

FOR THE PROSECUTION: Tanya Huff
219

FOR THE DEFENSE: Richard Garfinkle
233

CHARGE #6: STAR WARS PRETENDS TO BE SCIENCE FICTION, BUT IS REALLY FANTASY
245

FOR THE PROSECUTION: Ken Wharton
247

FOR THE DEFENSE: Robert A. Metzger
263

FOR THE PROSECUTION: Bruce Bethke
279

FOR THE DEFENSE: Adam Roberts
287

CHARGE #7: WOMEN IN STAR WARS ARE PORTRAYED AS FUNDAMENTALLY WEAK
303

FOR THE PROSECUTION: Jeanne Cavelos
305

FOR THE DEFENSE: Bill Spangler
329

CHARGE #8: THE PLOT HOLES AND LOGICAL GAPS IN STAR WARS MAKE IT ILL-SUITED FOR AN INTELLIGENT VIEWER
341

FOR THE PROSECUTION: Nick Mamatas
343

FOR THE DEFENSE: Don DeBrandt
357

CLOSING STATEMENTS
369

FOR THE PROSECUTION: David Brin
371

FOR THE DEFENSE: Matthew Woodring Stover
379

THE VERDICT
383

Other books

Midnight Outbreak by Jeffus Corona, Brandy
Take Me All the Way by Toni Blake
The Descendants by Kaui Hart Hemmings
The True Adventures of Nicolo Zen by Nicholas Christopher
Sneaky People: A Novel by Berger, Thomas
Someday Angeline by Louis Sachar
In Your Corner by Sarah Castille