Read Odysseus in America Online
Authors: Jonathan Shay
frigidity, 273
n
Fukuyama, Francis, 156, 249, 284
n,
297
n,
299
n,
301
n
Gal, Reuven, 225, 291
n,
293
n,
295
n,
296
n
Galloway, Joseph L., 277
n
GAR,
see
Grand Army of the Republic
Gardner, John, 273
n
Gardner, R., 272
n
Garvey, Mary, 79
gastÄr
(stomach, hunger), 12-13
Gates of Fire
(Pressfield), 210
genocide, 251
geras
(Greek military prize of honor), 239, 267
n
German army:
cohesion in, 209, 212-13
demobilization in 1918, 295
n
in Weimar Republic, 295
n
Germany:
Freikorps death squads in, 222, 296
n
leadership practices in, 226
“stab-in-the-back” mentality in, 95, 273
n
veteran employment opportunities in, 59
Gibbs, Philip, 20
GI Bill, 135
Gibson, James William, 22
gift exchange, 274
n
Glass, Albert J., 293
n
“going native,” 166
Golden, Leon, 283
n
Golden Calf, 102
Goodall, Jane, 301
n
Gould, John P.A., 275
n
government:
hiring preferences of, 51
veteran attitudes toward, 47, 177
Grand Army of the Republic (GAR), 41
grandiosity, 160
Graves, Robert, 31-32
Greely, J. N., 292
n
grief, 35, 85
function of, 80-81
and recovery, 168, 169
and visit to the Vietnam Veterans Memorial, 170, 174
Griffis, Sally (VWAR), xiv, 197
group therapies, 168-69, 174, 177
at Vietnam Veterans Memorial, 173
“Guardians” of the state, Aristotle's notion of, 157
Gudmundsson, Bruce I., 277
n,
295
n
guest-gifts, 119, 274
n
guilt, 109-10, 112, 152
existential functions of, 80
and penance, 153
survivor, 76, 78-80
ways of living with, 154
Gulf War, 220
Guthrie, Woody, 108
Haber, Samuel, 292
n
Hainsworth, Brian, 282
n
Hall, H. Palmer (VWAR), 194, 288
n-
89
n
Halverson, R. R., 287
n
Harvey, Mary, 175
Harvey, M. R., 287
n
Haubold, Johannes, 6, 268
n
health, worries about, 88-89, 160
Hector (Trojan commander in chief, killed by Achilles), 231, 267
n
Hedrick, C., 270
n,
279
n,
285
n,
299
n
Hegel, G. W. R, 156, 249
Helen of Troy, 37, 65, 66, 89, 231
and Trojan Horse ruse, 233
Helios (sun god), 102, 272
n
Heller, Charles E., 295
n
Henderson, William D., 213, 292
n
Herakles, 299
n
Herman, Judith, 168, 243, 271
n,
283
n,
286
n
Hermes (messenger god and trickster), 66-67, 69
heroes, 2, 242-43
heroin, 38, 94-95
Hesiod, 92, 299
n-
300
n
Hesk, John, 275
n,
279
n,
285
n,
298
n
Heubeck, Alfred, 99, 278
n
Hexter, Ralph, 273
n
hiring preferences, 51-52
Hitler, Adolf, 161, 273
n,
285
n
Hobbes, Thomas, 156
hobos, 155
Hoekstra, A., 278
n
Hoffman, George “Sonny,” 86, 105, 276
n
holy, experience of the, 242, 287
n
home, idea of, 245-46
homecoming:
Odyssey
as allegory of, 1, 2, 3, 36, 106
of veterans, 56
Homer, 103, 278
n
honor, 95, 156
deference and, 250
in the
Iliad,
250
for military personnel, 252
Hoover, Herbert, 155
Hoplite ideology, 298
n
Horace (legendary Roman warrior Horatius), 153
Hornblower, Simon, 275
n
hospitality and generosity, testing of, 129
hubris,
law on, 161
Hudnall-Stamm, Beth, 276
n
human nature, 162, 247, 248, 251
Hurbis-Cherrier, Katherine, 270
n
Hurbis-Cherrier, Mick, 270
n
hypochondria, 88-89, 160
ideals, 157
and recovery, 168, 174
IDF,
see
Israel Defense Forces
idiÅtes
(those ignorant of public affairs), 7
Iliad,
xv, 6, 61, 62, 77, 82, 105, 140
Achilles' portrayal in, 237, 243
Agamemnon's portrayal in, 239-40
audience for, 104
author of, 103
biÄ
of Achilles in, 205
fascination of death in, 91-92
funeral games for, 243
mÄtis
in, 235
Odysseus' portrayal in, 238
Odysseus' reconnaissance in, 231-32
Sirens as voice of, 89
surface story of, 267
n
themis
betrayed in, 206
violence and honor in, 250
incarceration, of Vietnam veterans, 27
income, of Vietnam veterans, 136
individual replacement system, in U.S. military services,
see
replacement system, in U.S. military services
injury, PTSD as, 149-50
IN MEMORY program, 195-96
insomnia, 38, 39, 54-55, 246
Institute for Defense Analyses, 215, 302
n
institutional validation, 168-69
“Instructions for the Government of Armies of the United States in the Field” (Lieber), 225
intergenerational transmission of trauma, 175
Internet discussion groups, 5, 41, 178-80, 198-201
IN TOUCH program, 196
Ion
(Plato), 103
Iphigenia, 102, 112
irony, Homeric (or lack of), 69, 101, 272
n,
278
n
Ismarus, raid on, 20, 26, 32, 34, 35, 43, 61, 236, 256, 269
n
isothumos
(equal citizenship honor; not an ancient Greek term, modern coinage), 161, 250
Israel:
aversion to military casualties in, 213
leadership practices in, 226
veterans, 50
Israel Defense Force (IDF):
breakdowns in, 218
cohesion in, 213, 219
Ithaca, Odysseus' return to, 3-4, 121, 124
jargon and speech rhythms, of combat veterans, 89-91
jobs,
see
employment and career opportunities of veterans
Jodies, 124, 136
Johnson, Lyndon, 103
Jones, F. D., 291
n,
293
n,
296
n
Jones, Franklin, 225
jus ad bellum,
291
n
jus in bello,
291
n
jus in militaribus,
291
n
justice, divine, 105, 124, 272
n
Kang, H. K., 290
n
Kant, Immanuel, 249, 252, 301
n
katharsis,
153
Kelley, Michael, 290
n
Kelman, Herbert C., 286
n
kerameikos
(Athens's military cemetery), 5, 287
n
Kerrey, Bob, 110-12, 154, 279
n,
283
n,
297
n
guilt as motivation for, 152
on Puller's death, 183
Khe Sanh, siege of, 235
king or steward of the winds (Aeolus), 52-56, 59, 256
Kirkland, Fans R., 168, 216, 217, 287
n,
291
n,
294
n
Kissinger, Henry, 103
Kitfield, James, 222
Klann, Gerhard, 110-12
kleos
(fame), as motive, 48, 297
n
Kohut, Heinz, 156, 284
n
Korean War:
replacement system in, 209-10
veterans of, 155
Koziak, Barbara, 299
n
Krulak, Charles C., 223, 296
n
Kulka, Richard A., 270
n,
281
n
Laertes (father of Odysseus), 132, 145
Odysseus' reunion with, 138-39, 143-44, 259
Laestiygonians, 60, 61, 63, 64, 236, 256
Laird, Melvin, 90
language, 247
Laocoön (Trojan leader), 234
Larsenn, S., 290
n
Lateiner, Donald, 280
n
Law enforcement, veteran career opportunities in, 22
“lawful combatant,” 110, 224
lawfulness, in conduct of nations, 250
Lawrence, T. E. (Lawrence of Arabia), 42, 44
Lazenby, John F., 279
n
leaders,
see
civilian leaders; military leaders Leakey, Richard, 300
n
lÄthe
(forgetting), 92
Leukos (soldier of Odysseus, killed in
Iliad
), 140
Lewis, Mark, 296
n
Lidz, Brett T., 281
n
Lieber, Francis, 225
Lieber Code, 225
Linderman, Gerald F., 212, 293
n
Lloyd, Janet, 277
n
Longinus, 278
n
Lotus Eaters, land of, 36, 38, 41, 256
love:
among military comrades, 196, 211, 212, 269
n
philia (philotÄs
in Homer) and, 158-59
“Love and Whores” (Spector), 71-72
Luttwak, Edward, 293
n
lying and deceit:
cowardice and, 236
fear and, 236
as military skills, 151
of Odysseus, 121-22, 126, 127, 132, 151, 237
in Trojan Horse incident, 233-34
Lynch, James (VWAR), xiv, 197
MacArthur, Douglas, 64
Makary, C., 287
n
Mallory, Jack (VWAR), xiv, 186, 288
manic-depressive behavior, 40
Marine Corps, cult of death in, 91
Marine Expeditionary Units (Special Operations Capable), 220
marriages, of veterans, 57, 59, 68, 69, 84, 94
intimacy and sex in, 114, 116-18
suppression of emotion in, 137
Marshall, George C., 108-9, 295
n
Martin, Richard P., 299
n
Mason, Patience C. H., 137, 262, 281
n
Mason, Robert, 281
n
Masters of Truth in Archaic Greece, The
(Detienne), 92
materialism, 247
Matsakis, Aphrodite, 39, 118, 137, 262, 271
n,
279
n,
281
n
McBride, Bill, Web site, 261
McCarthyism, era of, 155
McCombs, Mike, Sr., 188-89
McGlew, James R, 285
n,
299
n
McMaster, H. R., 278
n
McNamara, Robert, 102
McVeigh, Timothy, 95
MedEvac, 23, 29, 199
medicinal purgation, 153
megalomania, 161
megalothymia, 299
n
Mehlum, L., 290
n
Melantho (faithless maid), 131-32
memorial validation, 169
memory, 92
loss of authority over, 38
resuscitative function of, 80
and truth of Kerrey mission, 111
Menelaus (king of Sparta, husband of Helen), 37, 104, 140
Telemachus' visit with, 231
mental clarification, 153
mental health professionals, 177-78
“Mentes” (Athena in disguise), 144
“Mentor” (Athena in disguise), 145
meritocracy, 104, 279
n
mÄtis
(cunning, deception), 14, 46, 47, 125, 151, 161, 205, 231, 243, 272
n,
297
n
biÄ
and, 206
in Iliad,
235
of Penelope, 74-75
Meyer, Edward “Shy,” 226
Milford, L., 284
n
military education and training, 214-16, 222-23, 229
and cohesion, 211
COHORT program, 214-17
ethics and, 223-25
recommendations for, 265
retraining component of, 217-18
military intelligence, in Vietnam War, 234-35
military leaders, 61-62, 225-27, 229
abuse of authority by, 224
betrayal of “what's right” by, 240
careerism of, 167, 228, 264, 286
n
and COHORT program, 217
creation and maintenance of trust by, 206, 226, 227
ethics and, 227-30
“going native,” 166
love and fear in, 211
Odysseus, 6-7, 61, 62, 231, 236-37, 241
and prevention of psychological injury, 6-7, 225
truthfulness of, 228
and U.S. defeat in Vietnam, 103
military personnel policy:
on career management systems, 286
n
obsolete assumptions about, 263
and prevention of psychological injury, 5-6
recommendations for, 265-66
on retirement system, 265
military service, peace and, 252
military unit associations, 40-41, 91, 92, 265
and prevention of psychological injury, 221-22
Web site, 261
Miller, William I., 272
n,
279
n,
293
n
mind, 162, 247-48
money, veterans' lack of interest in, 57
Moore, Harold G., 277
n
moral education of citizens, arts and, 242
More, Thomas, 19
Morris, Ian, 279
n
Morrison, A. P., 284
n
mortality, awareness of, 248
Mortality of Vietnam VeteransâThe Veteran Cohort Study 1997,
290
n
MOS (military occupation specialty), 209
Moses, 102
motivational tools, Agamemnon's, 240