Life on Wheels (5 page)

Read Life on Wheels Online

Authors: Gary Karp

Tags: #Health & Fitness, #Physical Impairments, #Juvenile Nonfiction, #Health & Daily Living, #Medical, #Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation, #Physiology, #Philosophy, #General

BOOK: Life on Wheels
10.16Mb size Format: txt, pdf, ePub
People with MS or ALS typically establish a working relationship with a neurologist. However, if the neurologist is attending to many people with other conditions, she might not gain the same detailed experience as someone working in rehab who spends her time with people with a given condition. Cynthia Bishop of Shepherd’s MS center notes:

 

Neurologists may have a very small percentage of patients with MS. The patient might be getting good medical treatment from her neurologist, but the doctor is not able to be completely current in the many developments happening in MS and its treatments. We might see patients and notice that they’re starting to experience foot drop and will refer them to our brace clinic and help them with their gait in therapy. A neurologist might not notice that. A person with MS commonly has issues with bladder or bowels. A neurologist is not an expert in that type of thing. You really need someone who knows rehab.
Transition from Childhood Disability

 

The rehab system discussed in this chapter is largely targeted to adults, many of whom already work or are educated. Many disabilities are work related; conditions such as MS typically occur in adulthood. Children with disabilities such as cerebral palsy, spina bifida, or muscular dystrophy are serviced under a different system.
With the passage of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act in 1975, children began to be integrated into public schools, and those systems were required to provide services to those children. In effect, rehab for children gets delivered through the school system—although parents and schools sometimes find themselves in conflict over the extent and nature of these services. Physical therapists work with children with disabilities at the schools. Equipment and medical services continue to be supplied by charitable organizations.
The difficulty with this delivery system is what happens when children become adults. For some, the transition is not smooth. This man with muscular dystrophy is angry about what happened once he became an adult:

 

Throughout my childhood and adolescence, these agencies were very good about providing various things I needed such as wheelchairs, orthopedic shoes, braces, clinics,
etc.
Unfortunately, when I became an adult, they forgot I existed. I no longer fit their marketable, “dying child” image.
Once children with disabilities leave the school system where they were receiving medical and therapeutic services, they need to establish a relationship with physicians and facilities qualified and equipped to address their needs. New issues also appear in adulthood, such as weight gain, the start of sexual activity, living independently, driving, or alcohol use. People in such transition need a specialized set of services, and the family doctor is not in a position to provide them. As Stanford Hospital’s Jody Greenhalgh describes the transition:

 

When they turn 18, where do they go? Hopefully the children’s services doctors refer them to a rehab doctor, but it doesn’t always happen. If they get a job and go on an HMO program, they get assigned a primary physician who may not know much about their disability. The physician may not know their equipment needs or that they need ongoing therapy.
Dealing with Insurance

 

Many medical professionals believe that insurance companies have gained excessive control of medical treatment. Spending limits tie the hands of physicians, whether limits are set by a health maintenance organization, private insurance, or government programs like Medicare. Medical professionals chafe at decisionmaking control being out of their hands. Insurers complain of cost pressures, rising prices, shrinking profits, and a healthcare system too expensive for many people to afford. Business owners trying to provide coverage with minimal employee contributions to premiums also add pressure to insurers. Because the insurers are demanding lower costs, we, as a result, receive less coverage. The issue is too complex to simply demonize insurers.
Alex Barchuk of the Kentfield Rehabilitation Hospital in northern California states:

 

All these new products coming out are great, but no one can afford to buy them. Insurance doesn’t pay for them. We’ve all transitioned into managed care. We get reimbursed at a per diem rate. No matter what we do in the hospital, the insurance company doesn’t care—they pay us a certain amount. Somebody can cost us $2,400 a day, and the insurer pays $750 a day. In that situation, you have to go with cheaper medications that have good efficacy. You can’t compromise somebody but, a lot of the new wheelchairs—the ones that stand or recline—the insurance companies don’t want to go with. We have to really fight for those.
Cynthia Bishop of the MS center at Atlanta’s Shepherd Center knows that inpatient stays are very effective in certain situations for people with MS:

 

We have all the research articles about the value of inpatient stays for people with MS, because the difficulty we have is getting insurers to pay. Since MS is a progressive disease, the insurer’s position is, “What’s the point? You can rehab them now, but they’ll only be worse later.” It seems ridiculous, but that’s what they say. The insurance people can see that if you have a spinal cord injury, there’s a major life change and you need rehab. It’s one time, and then they’re done with it. But, with MS, a person might need rehab five different times. It’s a hard sell.
The new insurance environment has affected a critical piece of equipment for Bob Mauro, a writer and disability activist with significant postpolio syndrome. His Medicare coverage—now administered by a private HMO—has begun to deny coverage for a second ventilator, which allows him flexible mobility by use of one by his bed and the other on his power wheelchair. More importantly, the second ventilator is a backup in case the primary ventilator breaks down—which they inevitably do.
I cannot express the terror these routine denial letters give me. I only have two ventilators, and both are vital. I must have two ventilators to stay alive! I am permanently disabled, will not get better, and will probably get worse as I age.
By the Book

 

The services and coverage you get are increasingly defined by manuals and policies developed at hospitals and insurance offices. Managed care can lead to cookie-cutter classifications and treatments, with some danger of not seeing the case or person as a whole. According to Jody Greenhalgh:

 

Insurance has disability ratings, and people get plugged in. “This is how many days you’re going to be seen; this is where you should go.” But not everyone fits the mold of the way insurers see these cases. There might be other conditions along with the one they’ve rated, and it makes a big difference in what someone really needs. There’s a lot of education [needed] to get insurance to look at the bigger picture.
There can be advantages to these automated, modular approaches to care. Once you have been given a disability rating, any member of your healthcare team might recognize a certain condition. By reporting it, they will initiate a trigger that automatically leads to a pathway of treatment. When these triggers and pathways are clearly defined, the doctor is spared having to diagnose and prescribe every last detail of treatment. It makes her job more efficient and can get you into the treatment process sooner, keep you from losing strength, and get you back to your life sooner. In the process, the insurer saves money, which helps.
Managed care has attempted to improve the efficiency of a medical system laden with immense demands and expense, while trying to ensure that care is appropriate for the individual. Your medical care cannot be entirely automated. There needs to be flexibility to adjust to changes.
The Rehab Team

 

You have arrived at rehab, which means that a group of dedicated and highly trained professionals are at your service—the rehab team. The team consists of a case manager and others in patient services, a physician, and a range of therapists, depending on your needs. The team is committed to helping you reach the highest possible level of function with your disability.
Dr. Gary Yarkony of the Rehabilitation Institute of Chicago observes:

 

The foundation of a comprehensive rehabilitation program is an interdisciplinary team. The staff must be willing to work together while breaking down the boundaries of individual disciplines for the betterment of those they serve.
2
Jody Greenhalgh of Stanford University Hospital notes that the respective roles of team members are important:

 

Regardless of what discipline you are from, when you go in to assess rehab needs, you find yourself advocating for the patient’s needs. Although I’m an occupational therapist, I’ll point out a physical therapy need, when I see it.
You, your family, and peer supporters will also function as part of the rehab team.
Patient and Family Services

 

Patient services—often referred to as the social work department—will deal with finding resources, determining insurance coverage, and making sure you get all the benefits to which you are entitled. Even before you arrived, your case manager was looking into insurance policies and participating in the admissions process. Case managers deal with insurance adjusters; bureaucrats at federal, state, and local levels; charitable agencies; and the team at the facility who will serve you.
The people who do this work might have a social work degree or not. Bonnie Sims explains:

 

We have counselors with varied degrees in our department, but all have a master’s degree in their field. We hire with an eye to experience as well as a degree, which gives us differing viewpoints.
Your case manager or social worker is a key member of the team with whom you might develop a close relationship. Sandra Loyer, clinical social worker at the University of Michigan Medical Center in Ann Arbor states:

 

I am often one of the first people to make contact with the patient and the family. That is a chance to develop a close relationship from the start. I try to make them comfortable enough to ask me whatever questions are on their mind, and then I get the chance to find out more about their needs. I often discover important details that I pass on to the rest of the rehab team.
It is a challenge for a case manager or rehabilitation counselor to spend as much time as they’d like on each person’s case. With the pressure to contain costs and the complexity of the job, there is only so much time available to be a good listener. Many times case managers feel they can do their best for you by getting back on the phone to explore services and benefits to meet your needs. Bonnie Sims observes:

 

The counseling relationship can be very supportive to some people. However, the opportunity to create this relationship has become limited. Counselors spend so much time on the financial and discharge issues that it becomes difficult to spend quality time with patients.
You might be unaware of some of the benefits you have. For example, you might have credit card insurance or a policy for your mortgage or auto loan that makes payments if you become disabled. A case manager should ask these questions and help you research all possible ways to ease your financial burden.
Unfortunately, much of the case manager’s time is spent trying to make up for coverage you don’t have. Sims notes:

 

When people buy insurance, they assume they have coverage for all their needs, including healthcare. This is usually not the case, and so much of their care ends up falling to the family.
Often people must take extreme measures to qualify for state Medicaid to fill the gaps left in home care or equipment. They are required to spend their savings and assets before they qualify for assistance. Basically, they become paupers to get the care they need. There is a huge array of details involved in government programs like Medicare, Medicaid, workers’ compensation, or vocational rehabilitation; in the particulars of any given policy from any of hundreds of insurers; in the offerings of charitable groups like Easter Seals or the local Rotary Club; and in programs offered by centers for independent living (CILs), and so on. Sims says:

 

We have to spend almost as much time researching as we do working on the actual cases. I spend an inordinate amount of time just keeping up with changes and what programs are out there, trying to keep current and keep my staff current. I don’t have time as a supervisor to actually take cases. We’ve got so many resource listings, packets, and handouts—it can be overwhelming just keeping up.
There are many preparations to make for the day you leave rehab and return to your daily life in the outside world, a process that begins even before you arrive. Patient services might arrange transportation, set up the relationship with a home healthcare agency, or assist you with finding personal assistance services, as necessary. Sims finds that discharge is often difficult:

 

The transition out to the community is always chaotic. We never know why everything breaks down at the last minute. You get the whole thing set up, you get the home health agency ready to come in, then the patient gets sick and you have to cancel everything. Or when you implement discharge, you forget something, so the transportation goes awry, and so forth. Some chaos is typical.
Take good advantage of the patient services staff. Get to know them early and learn all you can. Start planning for departure as soon as possible, and you’ll have a better chance of making a smooth transition from rehab.
The Physician

 

The physician—most often a “physiatrist,” who is a specialist in physical medicine and rehabilitation—is the leader of the team. The physiatrist coordinates the members of the team, is responsible for maintaining clear records that everyone on the team will share and contribute to, and oversees the common strategy. The physiatrist relies on input from other team members who are spending time with you. Dr. Scott explains:

Other books

Death in Tuscany by Michele Giuttari
The Koala of Death by Betty Webb
(1929) The Three Just Men by Edgar Wallace
Keys to Love by S. J. Frost
Salvation by Stephanie Tyler
Mary Stuart by Stefan Zweig
Torchlight by Lisa T. Bergren
The Pot Thief Who Studied Einstein by Orenduff, J. Michael