Authors: Gail Levin
Regardless, Krasner liked the outcome. “The show is really very very beautiful & alive and excitingâ¦. The âTimes' reviewed the showâ¦. The opening was mobbedâBut none of your snobbish friendsâand Hans was aware of itânot even Sandy [Calder]âSweeney hasn't seen the show yet but he will.”
52
Krasner felt that Howard Putzel had been “wonderful throughoutâHe really likes Hans' workâ& he helped & plotted with usâHans feels a great deal will depend on whether Sweeney approves or notâand to a great extent He's right. If he doesâit may break up that taboo which exists in that small but useful little groupe [
sic
]âOf course I'd prefer to use a bomb. The results would be much more to my likingâYes you certainly picked the right winter to be away from N.Y.”
53
Krasner wanted her close friend to return to New Yorkâwhat she called “this nice nest of snakes in the east.” She also confided: “Jackson censors my letters so He says I can't tell you that Dr. Hubbards little pills are showing resultsââon him.' He's amazed that those silly little pills lessen the desire to drinkâI'm keeping my fingers crossedâRemember How we poopooed Herbert when he suggested Hubbard?” Lee informed Mercedes, “By the way I gave her a good talking to about her ignorance of painting (modern). Did you know Cezanne used Homeopathy? That's what started itâI mean my lectureâAlso probably modern art.”
54
Though Krasner believed in Hubbard and was grateful to Herbert Matter for recommending him, she felt that she had to enlighten the doctor about art.
Lee also wrote that Jackson's mother had just come east and stayed with them for two weeks. “We had a wonderful time eating a new cake every dayâeach one better than the one before.” Though she also asked how Herbert's show had gone in Chicago, she was preoccupied by anxiety about Jackson's relationship with
Art of This Century and Peggy's contract with Jackson that guaranteed him a minimal monthly income. This concern held her focus: “July 15th draws near & Peggy is not renewing the contractâShe's still as interested as ever in his paintings but she can't stand âties'âShe's been uncomfortable about it since the day she signed it. That's why she's probably had 4 husbands & is getting ready for a 5th. Strangely enough I can understand itâMaybe that's why I don't get married.”
55
Lee boasted that Jackson had “just finished the largest & possibly his best canvas to dateâ56 x 96"âPeggy is coming to dinner Sunday to see itâMy painting stinks but I won't give upâThe horrible thing is that I'm painting every day (much more painting time than Jackson) but it still stinks.”
56
She was writing about
Pasiphae,
a canvas Pollock had not finished in time for his solo show in November 1943. She also reminded the Matters not to miss buying the April issue of
Harper's Bazaar,
which featured Sweeney's article “Five American Painters” and included a color reproduction of Pollock's canvas
The She-Wolf
(1943).
57
The others featured were Gorky, Morris Graves, Milton Avery, and Matta.
Though Krasner did not save Mercedes's letters to her, she did retain George Mercer's letters. After Mercer visited Lee and Jackson in New York in the spring of 1944, he wrote on April 17, 1944, to tell them he had enjoyed seeing them and the “victory” dinner that they had shared. Pollock was celebrating getting a contract for another year after all. “I should have told you of my faith in order that the pressure could have been eased,” Mercer wrote to them. “But then, that might have removed the necessity or desire for an excursion with Bacchus. Those things can be fun.”
58
Clearly Mercer did not grasp the danger of alcohol for Pollock. He probably appreciated, even envied, that Pollock was free from military duty and able to paint. Another visitor was her friend and Hofmann School chum Ray “Buddha” Eames, who was visiting New York with her husband.
In June 1944, Lee wrote to Mercedes, this time from Cape
Cod, where she and Jackson, having sublet their place in the city, planned to spend the summer: “Now we are settled in P-townâ15 Cottage St. and things seem a little more settledâI suppose you've seen Buddha by now.” Lee complained that her time with Buddha in New York had seemed like “two seconds” because they could not really talk in the presence of Jackson and Charles Eames. “At the moment we are living most happily and I am truly gratifiedâP-T. is beautiful as you know and we are one block from the farm so we can stay off of the muck around center of townâWe came up with Hans and Meetz [Miz]âHans left from the hospital directly on to the Cape Coder.”
She reported how well Hofmann was doing after his hernia operation, though expressed concern that his recovery was a bit slow. Fritz and Jeanne Bultman were among those whose presence she noted, while going on to gossip about another Hofmann student, the jewelry, furniture, and interior designer Ward Bennett, who was staying at the Hofmann house, asking if he had been “âElsa K.'s' l'amourâyes?” Krasner asked about how things were with “Herbert & Pundit”: “Do you think you'll be out west much longer now that the end of the war is so close? I heard about Herbert's show in Chicago & someone told me He is or has shown in Los Angeles. Tell me about it,” she implored.
Krasner also noted, “Howard Putzel is coming up in a few days and I understand he quit his job (with Peggy). Sounds serious but I won't know anything until I see him.” She also wrote that she had seen a show of work by Mercedes's fatherâArthur B. Carlesâand found his paintings “very wonderful.”
59
For his part, Jackson wrote to his mother and his brother Sande, and his wife, Arloie, “Provincetown looks much better to me nowâwe are at the west end of town and within walking distance of the beach. We get in for a dip at least once a dayâ¦. Haven't gotten into work yet. Howard Putzel came up last nite [
sic
] for [a] two week stayâwe had dinner with the Hofmanns. Hans still has to take it pretty easy.”
60
By September 7, 1944, Pollock had changed his mood again, writing to Herbert Matter in Los Angeles: “I have definitely decided I don't like P-town. Perhaps Truro or Wellfleet is more sympathetic to painting,” he opined. The small town of Truro, where the much more politically conservative Edward Hopper painted realistic views of the landscape, was, however, an unlikely place for Pollock.
“Neither Lee nor I have touched a brush since we are here. Am anxious to get back to 46 E. 8th and down to work. I have a brother at 901 E Hyde Park, Inglewood. If you're able to get around look him up and I'll tell him to do the sameâhe's a swell guy and politically leftâI feel he supports me in that direction.”
61
Hofmann also wrote about that summer to Mercedes Matter, observing, “neither Lee nor Jackson worked. They have been every day on the beachâwellâwho can blame themâhe worked so hard throughout a long time and Lee was exhausted I think from being the wife of him.”
62
Hofmann already thought of the couple as married, although they were not then.
Krasner had to leave suddenly to tend to her ailing father in Huntington, Long Island. With no one to answer to, Pollock got arrested for being drunk and disturbing the peace. Hofmann explained that Jackson's behavior suffered when he drank excessively: “he offends everyone in his surroundingsâthe end is always a collapse.”
63
This episode perhaps exemplifies Pollock's pathologies and why his letters to the Matters differ from Krasner's cheery accounts.
For his part, Hofmann admired Krasner and recognized Pollock's talent, but, as he wrote to Mercedes Matter in October 1944, he feared the change that came over Pollock when he drank to the point of collapsing: “I feel sorry for such a constitution because in the end it must be of tragic consequences. Jackson is highly sensitive, he is a wonderful artist, he is in reality good-natured, but his companionship is hard to stand when he is off the normal. Lee
will have a hard time with him, but she stays with him and I respect her for this.”
64
Â
K
RASNER'S FATHER DIED ON
N
OVEMBER
17, 1944. G
EORGE
M
ERCER
, who had recently visited with Krasner and Pollock in New York, sent his sympathy for her “unhappiness and discomfort” before discussing his own efforts at painting.
65
“This is the first painting that hasn't been tortured into a Hans Hofmann format. It is delightful to be free of the restraints of the âold school.' I'm sure it has its bad features and its good ones. The parts of this painting do not have to answer the question âIs it plastic' but rather âIs it right?, Does it work?' I'm sure Hofmann's [
sic
] would be in agony if he saw the painting but I am excited because I have found things and colors (in paint, of course.).”
66
Inspired by Persian miniatures, Mercer explained, he had to paint small. The army kept him from having both enough free time and a studio in which to produce larger works.
Mercer reported that “it was nice to see Jackson. We had a short talk but didn't quite get our hooks entangled. I was too self conscious about my wisdom tooth which had been taken out the week before. I like his new paintings. I âsaw' them for the first time and should like to be painting what he isâbut of course that is impossible. I think they are very important and soundâif that has any meaning
as criticism
of painting.”
67
Toward the end of December, Lee wrote to Mercedes, “It seems as if you've been away 10 yearsâIt (California) couldn't be that bad or you wouldn't have stayed that longâI hate N.Y. and every body in itâSorry to splash ice water on your firey [
sic
] dreams of N.Y. We're isolated ourselves in a senseâNo openings no cocktail parties as little of 57th St and all its shit as possibleâEven at that some creeps through and the stench is terrific.”
68
Krasner's desire not to mingle represents a change for her that
most likely had to do with her desire to protect Pollock from too many opportunities to drink. When she was with Pantuhoff she had often gone to art openings and hung out at the Jumble Shop.
Krasner also complained about James Johnson Sweeney, “whom I must still be respectful of (at least publicly) because of his continued interest in Jacksonâ¦I might add slightly cooled interest, from time to time [he] commits outrages [
sic
] actsâand I must keep my mouth shutâYour Sande [
sic
] Calder just had a show of his recent worksâAnd in all honesty they are dull.”
69
Krasner had an even lower opinion of “
Jackson's
Peggy Guggenheim,” who, she said, “is still part of our life. But oh my isn't she a rest less ladie [
sic
]âHere to-day but then there's to-morrowâA new star loomed on the 57th StâskyâHoward Putzelâformerly with P.G. has his own Galleryâ67 East 57th StâIts backed by McPherson [
sic
]âRemember him? He's the man (I mean be careful how you use that word) that shares Peggy's house and has more money than Peggy (be careful what you say about him he buys Pollocks).”
70
Kenneth Macpherson, an openly bisexual and debonair Scotsman, poet, and novelist moved into his own apartment in Peggy's town house on East Sixty-first Street and comforted her during her divorce from Max Ernst.
71
Krasner could be somewhat caustic, especially when defending Pollock. She told Mercedes, “
Our
Hans is painting and exhibiting all over the placeâSome good some not so goodâOur relationship Pollocks Mr. & Mrs. & Hofmanns Mr. & Mrs.âis a little touchy right nowâIt's silly and not worth going into except to say that it was produced mainly by Meetz's [Miz, Mrs. Hofmann] stupid tongue. She however is so much better now as a person that it seems unfair to mention it at all. Particularly don't you mention it.”
72
It's notable that Krasner referred to herself as “Mrs. Pollock” though not yet married.
The reference to Mrs. Hofmann's troubling tongue may have come from an incident that Robert Motherwell recounted years later. Motherwell described a visit he and Pollock made “to Hof
mann's studio, hung with works by Léger, Miró, Braque, etcâ¦. We were drinking from a jug of wine when there was a phenomenon like changing gears in a car; Pollock's whole expression changed, literally in seconds, and his eyes became glazedâa real Jekyll and Hyde.” He became either too drunk or too belligerent to walk. Motherwell complained: “Jackson and Hofmann both lived on the top floors of their buildings, so Hofmann, in his sixties, and I had to drag him down five or six flights, then along 8th Street to his building's foyer. We buzzed his apartment but no answer.”
The drunken Pollock teased them, refusing to give them his key so that they could help him upstairs. In the midst of his antics, Pollock fell, hitting his head against a marble surface, which knocked him out cold. At first they were frantic, thinking that he was dead. When they realized that Pollock was still alive, they retrieved the key and struggled to drag his limp body up the stairs. “We were trying to open the apartment door when Lee opened it; she'd been there all the time but wasn't answering. I was so enraged by that, we just dropped him. And to this day I have no idea what was going on in her mind.”
73
Then only in his twenties, Motherwell seems to have assumed that Lee actually heard the buzzer. In the heat of the moment, he did not stop to consider that she might have been in the bath, listening to loud music, or sound asleepâor that the buzzer was not even working. Much better off economically than Lee or Jackson, Motherwell might not have imagined living in a walk-up apartment on the top floor without a working buzzer. Nor did he show the least bit of concern for a woman confronting her live-in companion's inert body dumped on the floor in front of her.