Finding Rebecca (3 page)

I don’t remember doing it, but at some point during the night I made it to the bedroom. I woke the next morning lying across the bed, clutching my pillow. I felt exhausted, even though I had slept through the night. I propelled myself out of bed and to the bathroom, where I saw something in the mirror that I didn’t like.

My eyes were surrounded by dark circles and were swollen almost shut. My entire face was red and puffy. I prayed that I could make myself presentable in case Neil decided to drop by that morning. I wanted to be with him, but I didn’t want him to see me like that. That’s why my heart almost stopped when I heard the knock at the door.

I threw some cold water on my face and hoped for the best. It didn’t take away all of the signs of my horrible night, but it did help reduce some of the redness in my cheeks.

“Coming!” I called out as I ran the hair brush through my hair to tame it a bit.

I tentatively looked through peep hole in the door, hoping that it was the super coming to fix my dishwasher. No such luck. I saw Neil standing there with a huge box in his arms. What was he up to this early this morning?

“This is a surprise,” I said when I opened the door.

“I thought you might like breakfast,” he said with a huge smile.

His smile faded quickly when he saw my face.

“You look like hell. What’s wrong?”

The concern in his voice made my heart ache. I really didn’t want to tell him what had happened, but I didn’t even have a remotely believable lie to cover it up.

“Come on in and I’ll tell you. What’s for breakfast?”

“You get some plates while I take it out,” he said walking past me to the kitchen.

I grabbed some plates from the cabinet and put them on the table. Neil had uncovered a full breakfast consisting of bacon, eggs, hash browns, and toast.

“Where did you get this?” I asked while I started the coffee.

“I cooked,” he said proudly.

“You cooked this?” I couldn’t hide the surprise in my voice.

“Don’t be so shocked. There are a lot of things I can do that you don’t know about yet. Now tell me what’s wrong.”

As soon as I started, the words and emotions poured out of me. I told him everything. I could see his anger building as I talked. It was a good thing that he wasn’t there last night. He would have probably killed Kyle.

“You should have called the police. More importantly, you should have called me. There was no reason for you to spend the night alone after that happened.”

“I know. I didn’t want to get the police involved, especially after he left. I also knew that you had plans with your friends. I didn’t want to cause a problem there. You needed a night out after this last week.”

“It wouldn’t have caused a problem,” he scolded me. “I would have come right over and taken care of you. Do you think he is really staying in town all week-end?”

“I don’t know. He might have gone back home after all of that.”

“To be safe, you’re not staying alone this week-end. You can either stay in my apartment, or I can stay here with you. You pick.”

“That’s not necessary,” I assured him. “If he comes back, I won’t answer the door.”

“That won’t stop him,” he warned. “If he thinks you’re here, he might break in just to get to you. We’re not taking that chance.”

There wasn’t any point in arguing with him. Neil was going to win, and to be honest, I didn’t mind spending the night with him.

“This will all work out great anyway,” he continued. “I have a friend that I want you to meet. I invited her to come over to my apartment tonight. I was going to talk to you about it and make sure it was all right.”

“You know I love meeting your friends. What did you have planned?”

“Not much. I thought we would get some pizza and beer and play it by ear from there.”

“That sounds good. It’ll take my mind off of the episode last night. Tell me about her.”

“We both interned together at a firm several years ago. We hit it off the first day we met. She’s really cool, not to mention gorgeous.”

“Is this an old flame?” I teased.

“Oh no. Nothing like that. I mean, we did have a little fun together, but nothing ever serious. I guess you could say she was like a friend with benefits.”

“Should I be jealous or worried here?” I continued to tease.

“Not at all,” he playfully defended himself. “She knows that when I’m with someone, I’m with that person monogamously. It’s the same with me where she’s concerned.”

Neil was right. Carly was beautiful. She was about four inches taller than me. Her jet black hair and almost black eyes complimented her olive skin tone. She had the body that I had always wanted. She wasn’t skinny, but she wasn’t overweight either. She had perfectly proportioned curves that would have made any man, and some women, drool.

I was in Neil’s kitchen, getting all of us another round of beers when he walked up behind me and kissed the back of my neck.

“Are you having a good time?” he asked.

“I’m having a great time,” I told him. “This was a perfect evening.”

“What do you think about Carly?”

“I like her. She’s really nice.”

“I noticed you staring at her a couple of times. What do you think about her physically?”

I wasn’t quite sure where he was going with his questioning, but I had just enough of a buzz from the beer to answer him honestly.

“She’s quite attractive.”

“Would you fuck her?”

That question took me completely by surprise and I almost dropped the bottles. I didn’t know what to say.

“She likes you,” he continued. “She just told me that she would love to fuck me and you together. If you don’t want to, I understand. It might be fun though.”

“I’ve never done anything like that before,” I confessed to him.

“You mean a threesome or another woman?”

“Either. You forget that I’ve lived a rather sheltered life,” I reminded him.

“I told her that I wasn’t sure if you would go for it. I’ll just go tell her that you aren’t into it.”

Neil was almost to the kitchen door when I called him back.

“Is it something that you want?” I asked.

“I’m not going to lie and say I don’t want to watch you two fuck each other, but if you aren’t comfortable with it, it’s okay.”

“I’m game,” I said finally. “That is, if you two will be patient with me.”

He put his arm around me and we walked back to the living room together.

“Let’s take this party to the bedroom,” he said as soon as we were back in the room with Carly.

I can’t deny that I was nervous. I had no idea how much of a participant they wanted me to be in their adventure. I knew that I had no idea what to do with another woman. I wondered briefly if I had made the right decision, until Carly stripped out of her little black dress. I had assumed that her breasts were held perfectly in place by a bra. Imagine my surprise when I realized that she had on no undergarments at all under that dress.

My eyes traveled over her entire body, absorbing her beauty. Her breasts were plump and round with small nipples protruding from the middle of quarter-sized dark circles. Her abdomen was flat, but had well defined muscles. Her moderately wide hips drew my attention to them and her shaved mound.

Neil was standing behind me and reaching around to unbutton my blouse. Obviously he was taking too long for Carly. She walked over to me and helped him take it off of me. She gently rubbed her hands over the smooth material of my bra and squeezed each of my breasts in her hands. I closed my eyes and leaned my head back into Neil’s chest. He leaned over and was gently kissing and sucking on the side of my neck as he unzipped my skirt. It fell to the floor and I stepped out of it. His fingers went to work on the clasps of my bra while Carly sucked on my hardening nipples through the material.

I wanted to caress her body, but I also wanted to stroke Neil’s hard cock, which I could feel pressing into my back. Not knowing what I should do with my own hands, I let my arms hang limp at my sides. Neil slid my bra from my shoulders and I could feel Carly’s soft lips on exposed skin. She licked and suck on each nipple while Neil’s hand slid down my stomach and into my panties. His fingers spread my lips and stroked up and down from my clit to my opening. I was dripping wet.

“I think she is enjoying this so far,” he said smiling at Carly.

“I know something that she will really enjoy,” she said taking my hand. “You get undressed and let me work some magic.”

Carly led me to the bed and eased me down on it. When I lay back, she pulled my panties off and tossed them on the floor.

“Move to the middle of the bed,” she whispered. “I need plenty of room to work.”

She straddled my hips and I could feel the heat from her pussy against mine. She slowly moved her hips back and forth and our lips touched, mingling our juices together. When she leaned over, her breasts pressed into mine. Her soft voice in my ear sent tingles through my body.

“I’m going to show you what it’s like to have someone lick your pussy that knows how to appreciate one.”

I couldn’t control my breathing as she lightly drew a path between my breasts and down my stomach with her fingernail. I’m not normally a ticklish person, but my skin was extremely sensitive to her light touch. Her lips followed the same trail as her tongue, making me squirm even more.

Her soft lips gently brushed over my clit, making me gasp loudly. Neil was standing beside the bed with his erect cock in his hand. He stroked it slowly as Carly licked up and down my wet slit. Her tongue moved wildly around my clit and between my lips. I grabbed handfuls of the bedspread and raised my hips to meet her mouth. Her arms wrapped around my thighs and held my legs apart as she penetrated me with her tongue.

“Does that feel good?” Neil asked when he climbed on the bed beside me.

I stared up at him and nodded my head. I was still amazed by his beautiful taut body. The bedroom was light casting a halo around his head making him even more gorgeous, if that was possible. I desperately wanted his cock.

As if he were reading my mind, he leaned over and I ran my tongue up the length of his shaft, feeling every bulging vein on the underside of it. My lips circled his engorged head and he slowly pushed it farther into my mouth. I licked and sucked his large member as his hips moved back and forth.

Carly slid two of her fingers inside of me and concentrated her expert tongue on my clit. She pressed hard into it and pushed her fingers deep inside of my dampness. I sucked Neil’s cock harder and she fucked me harder with her hand. I felt my muscles tighten and I pushed my hips upward as the orgasm took over my body. Carly tried to hold me still, but I bucked against her strong grip.

Neil pulled his cock out of my mouth and stroked it while Carly eased herself on top of me. Her firm breasts touched mine and her fingers wrapped around his shaft. She began stroking and licking its throbbing head. I could see a thin line of his white cream trail from its origin to her tongue.

My hand had found its way in between Carly’s thighs and I tentatively started to explore her pussy. Her lips were small and her clit was engorged. There was an intense heat being emitted from her. She was moving her hips in time with my slow strokes.

I raised my head and licked one side of his cock as Carly licked the other side. Neil groaned and unleashed his load on both of us. She and I licked furiously, not wanting to lose a drop of his cream. Carly kissed me and I could taste his saltiness mixed with her strawberry flavored lip gloss. I couldn’t get enough of her.

“You want to lick her pussy,” Neil asked me.

I didn’t know what to say. I did, but I had never been with a woman and wasn’t sure I knew what to do.

“Of course she does,” Carly answered for me as she eased herself off of me.

I was so nervous that I was shaking.

“Come here,” she said, almost in a commanding tone. “I’ll help you out.”

She laid down in front of me with her legs wide open. Her pussy was one of the most beautiful things that I had ever seen. Her tiny lips looked like little pink rose petals. She spread them apart with her fingers.

“Have you ever tasted pussy?” she asked.

All I could do was shake my head from side to side.

“Take a small taste. Just ease your tongue up slowly and savor the flavor.”

Not wanting to disappoint, I did as I was told. Her sweet musky scent was hypnotic. My tongue moved slowly upward between her lips and I discovered how wet she was. I was no stranger to oral sex, especially since I met Neil, but I had never experienced the flavor of another woman. She didn’t have to give me anymore instructions.

I licked up and down her slit, finding her clit and tugging on it with my lips. I circled it and moved back down to her opening. I sucked her lips gently into my mouth and ran my tongue back and forth between them. I wanted to consume as much of her as I could. I was completely oblivious to anything else at that moment, until Neil pushed his cock into me from behind.

His hands were gripping my hips and he was plowing into me. Carly was pushing her hips upward and I push my tongue into her. Her pussy was literally oozing with cream and I couldn’t get enough. My head was spinning with the sensations that I was feeling. I was trying to hold back the orgasm, but my efforts were useless. I came hard as I pushed back into Neil. He exploded at almost the same time, digging his fingers into my flesh. Carly was writhing under me and her juices were flowing. I tried to lick up every drop as she came.