Behind His Eyes - Convicted: The Missing Years (21 page)

Judge Jefferies asked, “Counsel, have you reached a settlement?”

The US Attorney replied, “Yes, Your Honor. The people have agreed to four years in a minimum-security federal prison camp, minus time served, $75,000 in fines, and probation.”

Emily gasped and turned to John and Jane. In a stage whisper she asked, “Tell me that isn’t all that he’s getting. Tell me there’s more.”

John reached for her hand and silently tried to soothe her.

Judge Jefferies continued, “Mr. Rawlings, do you know that by pleading guilty you lose the right to a jury trial?”

“Yes, Your Honor.”

“Do you give up that right?”

Tony never wavered, “Yes, Your Honor.”

“Do you understand what giving up that right means?”

“Yes.”

“Do you know that you are waiving the right to cross-examine your accusers?”

Tony replied, “Yes.”

Judge Jefferies continued his questions, “Do you know that you are waiving your privilege against self-incrimination?”

“Yes.”

“Did anyone force you into accepting this settlement?”

“No. No one forced me.”

“You are being charged with two counts of conspiracy to commit murder and one count of kidnapping. Are you pleading guilty because you in fact conspired to kill Allyson Burke Bradley and Simon Johnson?”

“Yes.”

“Are you also pleading guilty because you in fact transported Claire Nichols across state lines without her knowledge or consent?”

“Yes.”

“From where to where did you transport Ms. Nichols?”

“From Georgia to Iowa, Your Honor.”

Emily’s shoulders shuddered as the proceedings continued.

“Did you know that what you were doing was illegal?”

Tony’s shoulders lifted and fell, but his chin remained high. “Yes, Your Honor.”

Judge Jefferies concluded, “Mr. Rawlings, you are hereby sentenced to four years in a minimum-security federal prison camp. I am also making the recommendation that while incarcerated you attend counseling with a state-appointed therapist. While not at the suggestion of the counsel, I believe it would be an excellent use of your time and helpful for your future. Upon completion of your sentence, you will serve two years’ probation. Is that clear?”

“Yes, Your Honor.”

“Do you have any questions before we adjourn?”

“No, Your Honor.”

Judge Jefferies addressed the attorneys, “Any further questions or comments, Counselors?”

“No, Your Honor,” came from both tables.

“Mr. Rawlings, as agreed upon, your sentence will begin immediately.” Addressing the courtroom, “Ladies and gentlemen, you were permitted to attend this closed hearing. Be aware that it was closed for a reason. Any information regarding this hearing that is released to the press without the written approval of this court will be evidence to hold you in contempt.” Hitting his gavel, Judge Jefferies proclaimed, “We are adjourned.”

Phil watched as Tony shook Brent’s hand, leaned across the bar and hugged Courtney, and was then led away by the waiting bailiff.

Once the judge and Tony were gone from the courtroom, the people from Rawlings murmured amongst themselves as Patricia dabbed her eyes.

Emily’s voice rose above the whispers. “How could you?” she asked Marcus Evergreen. “With all of the charges against him, how could you agree to four years? What happened to sexual assault? What happened to murder? Allyson Bradley is dead! Simon Johnson is dead!”

Take the first step in faith. You don’t have to see the whole staircase, just take the first step.

—Martin Luther King, Jr.

“And you!” Emily growled toward Brent. “You claim to be Claire’s friend. How could you in good conscience defend him?” She pulled her arm from John’s grasp. “I’m not stopping. I want answers!”

“Not. Here,” John implored.

Jane whispered, “Emily, this is a conversation to be conducted in private.” Turning to Marcus, she asked, “Mr. Evergreen¸ could we possibly enter a private room and discuss what occurred?”

“I’ll see what I can find,” Marcus said as he closed his briefcase and stepped away.

Emily’s moist green eyes peered up at her husband, but it wasn’t sadness that he saw: it was full-out rage. Though they’d discussed Anthony’s pending charges
ad nauseam,
they’d never come to a conclusion like the one they just witnessed. “It will be all right. At least he isn’t free. Four years is a long time.”

“Not long enough, not after what he’s done to my family. I don’t understand. How could this happen?”

“I found a room,” Marcus announced.

“Brent and Courtney?” John asked. When they both looked his way, he said, “For Nichol’s sake, would you join us? It won’t change the outcome, but it may help us better understand.”

Courtney looked to her husband and nodded. Brent replied, “Yes.”

Courtney was the one who added, “Thank you for asking. Please know, we’d do anything for Nichol and for Claire.”

Courtney squeezed Patricia’s hand as she and the others filed from the room. Before leaving, Tim came up to John. “I know this isn’t a good time, but I’d like to discuss something with you, when you can.”

John looked questionably at Tim. “If it’s about the things we’ve said about Anthony—”

Tim shook his head and interrupted, “Not directly, but I’d like to talk to you. I guess I could say it’s indirectly about Claire.”

At the mention of her sister’s name, Emily looked their direction. She’d been shaking her head and twisting from side to side as she spoke quietly with Harry.

“This way,” Jane announced. “We don’t have the room for long.”

Tim handed John his card. “Please call and hear me out…” His eyes widened. “…for Claire.”

John took the card. “For Claire,” he repeated as he placed the card in his jacket pocket. Taking Emily’s hand, he gave it a squeeze and walked with her to the small conference room. As they neared, he whispered in her ear, “Please, hear them out.”

Inhaling deeply, she pressed her lips together and nodded.

The table only had six chairs as Marcus, Brent, Courtney, Jane, John, and Emily made their way to seats. John began. “Thank you for discussing this with us. I hope you can understand my wife’s outrage as well as our disbelief in what just happened. Mr. Evergreen, could you please explain to us the charges and how the plea agreement was reached.”

“Many things were taken into consideration. This is part of the closed negotiations. I’m sure you’re aware of the gag order.”

“We are,” John answered. “However, our special dispensation allows us—”

Brent interjected, “I believe everyone present is aware of the importance of confidentiality.”

“Yes,” Emily murmured. “We’d hate for the great Anthony Rawlings to have more bad press.”

John silenced her with his stare. “Thank you, Brent. We want to understand what happened and how it happened.”

Evergreen began, “Many of these crimes have been under investigation by the FBI for a long time. Although the use of actaea pachypoda is highly unusual, it’s been documented in the death and poisoning of individuals who were initially thought to be related in some way to Anthony Rawlings. With his help, it was discovered that although he was connected, he wasn’t the culprit. As you know, it was—”

“Catherine London,” John answered.

“Yes, I can’t go into specifics, but Mr. Rawlings was instrumental in helping them put the pieces of the case together. Prior to their return from the South Pacific, Mr. and Mrs. Rawlings had worked out a deal with the FBI.”

Emily covered her mouth, stifling the sound of her gasp.

“There was no money trail for the FBI or the Iowa City police to follow that specifically connected Mr. Rawlings with Allyson Bradley’s death. The only information they had was his confession. The same can be said about Simon Johnson. And although they had his confession, it couldn’t be substantiated by physical evidence. Mr. Rawlings admitted to paying for a crime. He paid to have Simon Johnson’s plane sabotaged. The NTSB verified that the plane was in perfect flying condition. Mr. Rawlings’ hit man didn’t do his job.”

“Then why did Simon crash?” Emily asked.

“I don’t know. If the FBI knows, they aren’t saying.”

“Okay, so that’s why the murder charges were reduced to conspiracy. What about the sexual assault?” John asked.

Brent answered, “Again, there was lack of evidence. The court can’t use a book as evidence without physical evidence or Claire’s testimony.”

Jane replied, “There was testimony, during her 2012 defense. She told us all about it. I took it to
you
.” She nodded toward Marcus Evergreen.

“That testimony was not made in a court of law or under oath. It can’t hold up in court.”

“This is ridiculous,” Emily sighed.

“That isn’t all,” Brent added. “In Iowa, there’s a statute that nullifies the charge if the two individuals are living together as husband and wife. The book claims that the assault occurred while Claire was living with Tony, in his house. And they later became husb—”

Emily interjected, “
In his house
, where he’d kidnapped her and taken her against her will. Where he’d trapped her!”

Marcus spoke calmly, “Mrs. Vandersol, that leads us to the most serious charge that Mr. Rawlings faced: kidnapping and transporting across state lines. As you know it’s a federal offense…” He went on to explain how he fought to keep that charge above everything.

“But
four
years?” John asked. “As a federal offense it can be punishable by up to twenty years, in some cases, life.”

Marcus replied, “There are many different stipulations that go along with kidnapping. Ms. Nichols was not a minor. There’s a stiffer penalty with minors. She was not sold into human trafficking. That too has a stiffer penalty. By her own admission, she had opportunities to flee and didn’t.”

“Because she was scared.” Tears coated Emily’s cheeks in a visible display of her frustration. She turned to Courtney. “You were her friend during that time. You know she was scared, don’t you?”

Courtney sat forward. “Emily, I had a feeling—a gut feeling—that something wasn’t right. Please know that I did, and still do love your sister. I asked her over and over if there was a problem. She never once told me there was.” She paused. “Well, not until later, after she was out of jail.”

“Jail!” John said. “What about filing a false report? Claire didn’t try to kill Anthony, yet she served fourteen months.”

Marcus cleared his throat. “The state of Iowa is responsible for that. I won’t admit to that publicly so don’t ask me to. But honestly, Mr. Rawlings woke in the hospital not knowing who poisoned him. The evidence, including video evidence, all supported that it was Mrs. Rawlings.”

Emily shook her head. “So that’s it. He pays $75,000, which to him is like pocket change, and he gets a slap on the wrist.”

“He confessed. He pled guilty,” Brent reminded her. “If he hadn’t, he would be free right now and exercising his rights as a free man.”

Emily’s green eyes opened wide. “He’s not getting to my sister or my niece. Not now, and not in four years. I didn’t protect her in 2010. I will now.”

“Thank you. Thank you for explaining this all to us. We’re not happy, but at least we understand.” John’s words were the dismissal for the meeting. Slowly, everyone rose from their seats, murmured their goodbyes and silently made their way out of the courthouse into the hot, sunny Iowa afternoon and through the throng of reporters.

“Mrs. Vandersol, could you give us a statement?”

“Mr. Vandersol, how do you feel about Mr. Rawlings’ sentence?”

“Did he really plead guilty?”

“Mr. Simmons, tell us how your client feels…”

No one replied as they made their way to their cars.

Nichol rocked back and forth on her knees as she giggled and inched forward toward the brightly colored toy in front of her. A little progress and she was back to her tummy, arms and legs flailing in glee. With single-minded determination, she made the distance and reached for the soft black and red rattle. Once it was hers, she took it straight to her lips, her little jaw moving up and down.

“I think she’s teething,” Emily said.

“I thought babies were fussy when they teethed,” replied John.