“Come sit by me?” It’s a question, not a command. I oblige. I sit down next to Lloyd again with a long sigh, dropping my head onto my chest.
“It was nice that he brought you flowers,” Lloyd says.
“Whatever.” I squint up at him. “Has she tried to get into your pants yet? ”.
Lloyd seems to blanch a little, but ignores the question. “I wish you would come see the house. It’s coming along really nice. We plan to be open by next month. I hope you’ll at least come for the opening party.”
Mr. Tompkins has wormed his way between Lloyd and me. He settles his front half over Lloyd’s left thigh and his back over my right.
I sigh again. “Lloyd, I thought it was clear when I came down last time. I can’t put myself in a place where I’m going to get hurt once more. I’m not going to get my hopes up only to find you can’t make a commitment.” I pause. “At least with me. You had no problem making a commitment with Eva.”
“I miss you, Jeff,” he says simply.
I make a sound of annoyance. “You
can’t
just come knocking at my door like this.” I look at him. “Especially not with
her
in tow.”
“Why don’t you like her, Jeff?”
I laugh. “It’s not about liking or disliking. She’s obviously threatened by me and tries to neutralize me any chance she gets.”
Lloyd huffs. “Well, maybe
you’re
feeling threatened, too. Otherwise you wouldn’t react so strongly.”
I look at him.
“Don’t.
Don’t start playing Dr. Freud with me. You know I hate that.” He sighs, resting his head on the back of the couch. “Besides, what’s to feel threatened about? You have your life; I have mine. ”
“I guess you do.” Now it’s Lloyd’s turn to sound a little piqued. “Who’d have thought some guy you met on New Year’s Eve would
still
be here?”
I shrug. “I’m surprised myself.”
Lloyd scoffs. “I have never in my life known you to put up with someone in your space. It took you
two years
to get used to
me.
What’s changed, Jeff? Why do you let him stay?”
I don’t know the answer. Part of it may be that I’m not writing, so I don’t feel the need for privacy the way I used to.” Back in the days when I toiled over my computer banging out freelance articles in our second bedroom, I’d needed silence to hear the muse sing. Now it doesn’t matter when Anthony turns on MTV first thing in the morning. I just flop down next to him on the couch and we watch that cute gay kid and his military boyfriend on
The Real World.
“There’s just something about Anthony,” I say. “Something that intrigues me.”
“Well, he’s very attractive,” Lloyd says, sighing, as if that were the reason.
“No. I mean, yes, he is, but that’s not what intrigues me.” I pause. “Maybe it’s because I’ve gotten kind of hooked on finding out more about him. He’s like an assignment, in a way. Who is.he? What’s his story? Where’s he from?”
Lloyd looks at me dumbfounded. “You mean you
still
don’t know?”
I shake my head. “No. Just a few clues here and there.”
“Jeff, he could be an
ax-murderer,
” Lloyd says.
“Yeah, he could be. But I bet it’s something more interesting than that.” I lean in close to Lloyd. It feels good to be this near him, even with all the issues between us. “He’s a mystery. Once a week he goes out and doesn’t come back until the next day.”
“Have you asked him about it?”
“At first. But I didn’t want to seem like I was prying. He’s paying rent now—just a token, really, but he buys his own food. So he doesn’t have to report in to me.” I run my hand through my hair. “Early on, all he’d say is that he’d gone to see a friend. Now he says nothing at all, and I don’t pursue it. But as far as I know, he has no friends in Boston other than me and Henry and a few of the other guys. And he’s not seeing them.”
Lloyd makes a face. “Sure he’s not sleeping with Brent? It would be just like Brent to want to keep that a secret.”
“I thought of that, but I don’t think so. Anthony can see through Brent. He’s told me so.”
Lloyd strokes the back of Mr. Tompkins’s head. “So what else makes him mysterious?”
“He never talks about his past. No relationships. No jobs. No family. He’s admitted to coming from a suburb of Chicago, and once he said his father was an asshole. Another time he said something about not doing well in high-school algebra. But that’s it. That’s about all I know.”
I don’t tell him about the laminated photograph of Robert Riley. I just can’t. I still feel guilty about going into Anthony’s wallet. I’ve been wanting to dig further, maybe try to find where the photograph came from, but something stops me. I just can’t do it.
Lloyd looks at me with concern. “Do you think he’s hiding something?”
I sigh. “Hiding, running away, covering up—I don’t know. Something.”
Lloyd takes my hand in his. “Jeff, if you’re living with him, having any kind of relationship with him, you
should
know all you can about him.”
“Oh?” I raise an eyebrow. “And are we following our own advice?”
He backs off a little. “That’s different, Jeff.”
“How so?” He’s given me the perfect opening; I’m not going to let it pass. “Maybe I only knew Anthony a few hours before I let him move in, but how much longer had you known Eva? A few months? Come on, Lloyd. Isn’t Eva as much a mystery to you as Anthony is to me?”
He shakes his head in that stubborn, obstinate, superior way of his, the one that used to drive me mad when we lived together. “Jeff, I know a lot about who she is,” he insists. “
Too
much, sometimes, even.” He pauses. “Though I’ll admit that a friend of hers tried to tell me something, but I cut him off.”
“Why would you do that?”
He looks at me as if the answer is obvious. “Because she’s a
friend.
And I don’t like talking about friends behind their backs.”
I lean in closer to him. I can smell his aftershave. I’ve missed that smell. Part of me just wants to kiss him and forget all this. Suddenly, in my mind it’s eight years ago, and Lloyd and I are vacationing on St. Croix, and we haven’t a care in the world and man, he looks so hot in that bright-blue Speedo. We dive into the water, splashing each other. We make love on the beach. But I catch myself. I have to say what I’m thinking.
“Lloyd, I’ll be blunt with you. I think Eva is far more likely to turn out to be an ax-murderer than Anthony is. I think she’s unstable. I get the sense she could go a little loco on you if you don’t live up the image she’s got in her head.”
“Oh, please, Jeff...”
“I mean it, Lloyd. It’s
you
she wants. Not a guest house in Provincetown. You could be opening up a
laundromat
together and she’d be just as into it.”
His face grows stern. “Jeff, I meant what I said. I appreciate your concern, but I’m not comfortable talking about her behind her back.”
Oh, if this isn’t so typical Lloyd. “So you think I ought to be running around doing background checks on Anthony, but it’s not okay for you and me to discuss
Eva!”
“Jeff, the two situations are very different.”
“Come on, Lloyd! You’re—”
The door opens. We turn to look up at Anthony and Eva coming back inside, their cheeks rosy. They’re smiling and laughing together.
“The store was closed,” Eva says, “but what a wonderful time we had throwing snowballs at each other!”
“She’s so much
fun!
” Anthony exclaims to Lloyd, who just smiles tightly.
“I felt like a teenager again,” Eva gushes, hugging Anthony around the waist.
I stand and walk into the kitchen. This is all just too far out. Why the fuck did Lloyd come here today, anyway? He messes up my head with those damn flowers and then pulls back yet again, all hands-off, when I dare to talk about Eva. God, I
hate
her.
But I hate even more feeling so petty.
I turn around. Anthony has come into the kitchen behind me.
“Jeff,” he whispers, his face all red and shiny from the cold, “if you and Lloyd want to be alone, I can go stay somewhere else tonight.”
“No, no.” I look from him over at the flowers he brought me, sitting on the top of the refrigerator. “Lloyd’s not staying. They’re going back to Provincetown tonight.”
Anthony smiles. “Well, I’m glad. I have to admit I feel a little jealous. I know that’s stupid, but I do.”
My heart melts. Damn, it sure has a habit of doing that.
“It’s not stupid at all,” I tell Anthony. “And hey. I really appreciated the flowers.”
“Happy Valentine’s Day,” Anthony says. I smile.
When we get back to the living room, Lloyd is putting on his coat. “Do you want to have dinner with us?” he asks. “After we get back from Pottery Barn?”
Eva takes my hands in hers. They’re icy. “Oh, I’d so love for you to join us,” she says, looking up at me with those eyes, as if I hadn’t been nasty to her earlier, as if she were really being sincere. “You and Anthony both.”
I look from her over to Lloyd. There’s no question I would like to spend Valentine’s Day with him. No question I’d like to sit across from him at a restaurant with a bottle of wine. No question I’d like to be with him tonight, so many happy Valentine’s memories living between us. But not with
her
along. Not with her going on and on about all they have to do and all the plans they’re making.
They, they, they.
“Thanks, but I promised Anthony we’d go out,” I say at last. I feel awful, especially when Lloyd looks away in disappointment. But in exchange I see a small, grateful smile creep across Anthony’s face.
“Are you
sure?”
Eva’s asking, busy with her gloves. “Oh, well, some other time, then. You must come down and visit us soon, Jeff. I’ll cook a marvelous dinner!”
Anthony extends his hand to her, but she moves in for a tight hug instead. “Thank you so much, Anthony. I so enjoyed spending time with you. You
must
come with Jeff when he comes down to the Cape.”
Lloyd comes over to me. We embrace. “Happy Valentine’s Day, Cat,” he whispers.
My throat is too tight to reply.
After they’re gone, I let out a long sigh.
“I think Eva is going to write to you,” Anthony says as he heads into the shower.
I look after him, puzzled. “Write me? Why?”
“I don’t know. She asked for your E-mail. I hope it’s okay that I gave it to her.”
Whatever she has to say, I’m not sure I want to read it. My heart feels all melted down to nothing. I press my face into Lloyd’s daisies, inhaling their tangy fragrance. From the shower I can hear Anthony singing:
“I’m naked without you
...”
His voice seems to dislodge Mr. Tompkins from the couch. The cat jumps down, stretches, then walks over to the door from which Lloyd has so recently departed. Plopping down his enormous body, he completely obliterates the doormat. As always, he’s determined to wait there until Lloyd has returned.