Authors: Steven G. Mandis
M
ASSIMO
T
ONONIGovernment:
Italian deputy Treasury chief, 2006–2008Goldman:
Former partner, 2004–2006M
ALCOLM
T
URNBULLGovernment:
Member of the Australian House of Representatives since 2004Goldman:
Chairman and managing director, Goldman Sachs Australia, 1997–2001S
IDNEY
W
EINBERGGovernment:
Vice-Chair, War Production Board, during World War IIGoldman:
Worked at Goldman from 1907 to 1969J
OHN
W
HITEHEADGovernment:
Under secretary of state from 1985 to 1989; former Chairman of the Board of the Federal Reserve of New YorkGoldman:
Worked at Goldman from 1947 to 1984. Was co-senior partner with John L. WeinbergK
ENDRICK
W
ILSONGovernment:
Adviser to Treasury Secretary Henry PaulsonGoldman:
Senior investment banker at Goldman, where he worked from 1998 to 2008R
OBERT
Z
OELLICKGovernment:
President, World Bank, since 2007Goldman:
Vice chairman, Goldman Sachs International; managing director and chairman, Board of International Advisors, 2006–2007
A reminder: I am not judging the involvement of these individuals—good or bad. This is merely to present a selected group as data.
1
A spokesman of Goldman stated: “We’re proud of our alumni, but frankly, when they work in the public sector, their presence is more of a negative than a positive for us in terms of winning business. There is no mileage for them in giving Goldman Sachs the corporate equivalent of most-favored-nation status.”
2
Appendix D
Value of Partners’ Shares at IPO
A list of Goldman partners at the time of the IPO is shown in
table D-1
. The names, percentages of shares, shares outstanding, values at IPO, and values at close are all provided. This analysis is based on reported percentages from the
New York Times
.
TABLE D-1
Percentages, shares, and value of partners’ shares at the IPO and first closing prices
Name | Percentage | Implied shares outstanding | Value at IPO price ($53) | First closing price ($70.38) |
Henry M. Paulson Jr. | 1.100% | 2,915,210 | $154,506,120 | $205,172,466 |
Jon S. Corzine | 1.100% | 2,915,210 | 154,506,120 | 205,172,466 |
Robert J. Hurst | 1.100% | 2,915,210 | 154,506,120 | 205,172,466 |
John A. Thain | 1.050% | 2,782,700 | 147,483,114 | 195,846,445 |
John L. Thornton | 1.050% | 2,782,700 | 147,483,114 | 195,846,445 |
Daniel M. Neidich | 0.900% | 2,385,172 | 126,414,098 | 167,868,381 |
John P. McNulty | 0.900% | 2,385,172 | 126,414,098 | 167,868,381 |
Lloyd C. Blankfein | 0.900% | 2,385,172 | 126,414,098 | 167,868,381 |
Michael P. Mortara | 0.900% | 2,385,172 | 126,414,098 | 167,868,381 |
Richard A. Friedman | 0.900% | 2,385,172 | 126,414,098 | 167,868,381 |
Robert K. Steel | 0.900% | 2,385,172 | 126,414,098 | 167,868,381 |
Jacob D. Goldfield | 0.825% | 2,186,407 | 115,879,590 | 153,879,349 |
Jon Winkelried | 0.825% | 2,186,407 | 115,879,590 | 153,879,349 |
Mark Schwartz | 0.825% | 2,186,407 | 115,879,590 | 153,879,349 |
Patrick J. Ward | 0.825% | 2,186,407 | 115,879,590 | 153,879,349 |
Peter A. Weinberg | 0.825% | 2,186,407 | 115,879,590 | 153,879,349 |
Philip D. Murphy | 0.825% | 2,186,407 | 115,879,590 | 153,879,349 |
Robert S. Kaplan | 0.825% | 2,186,407 | 115,879,590 | 153,879,349 |
Steven M. Heller | 0.825% | 2,186,407 | 115,879,590 | 153,879,349 |
W. Mark Evans | 0.825% | 2,186,407 | 115,879,590 | 153,879,349 |
David B. Ford | 0.725% | 1,921,388 | 101,833,579 | 135,227,307 |
Gavyn Davies | 0.725% | 1,921,388 | 101,833,579 | 135,227,307 |
Gene T. Sykes | 0.725% | 1,921,388 | 101,833,579 | 135,227,307 |
J. David Rogers | 0.725% | 1,921,388 | 101,833,579 | 135,227,307 |
John S. Weinberg | 0.725% | 1,921,388 | 101,833,579 | 135,227,307 |
Robert B. Morris III | 0.725% | 1,921,388 | 101,833,579 | 135,227,307 |
Robert E. Higgins | 0.725% | 1,921,388 | 101,833,579 | 135,227,307 |
Robert J. Katz | 0.725% | 1,921,388 | 101,833,579 | 135,227,307 |
Thomas E. Tuft | 0.725% | 1,921,388 | 101,833,579 | 135,227,307 |
Barry L. Zubrow | 0.650% | 1,722,624 | 91,299,071 | 121,238,275 |
David A. Viniar | 0.650% | 1,722,624 | 91,299,071 | 121,238,275 |
Eff W. Martin | 0.650% | 1,722,624 | 91,299,071 | 121,238,275 |
James P. Riley Jr. | 0.650% | 1,722,624 | 91,299,071 | 121,238,275 |
Kevin W. Kennedy | 0.650% | 1,722,624 | 91,299,071 | 121,238,275 |
Lee G. Vance | 0.650% | 1,722,624 | 91,299,071 | 121,238,275 |
Leslie C. Tortora | 0.650% | 1,722,624 | 91,299,071 | 121,238,275 |
Richard A. Sapp | 0.650% | 1,722,624 | 91,299,071 | 121,238,275 |
Richard E. Witten | 0.650% | 1,722,624 | 91,299,071 | 121,238,275 |
Robin Chemers Neustein | 0.650% | 1,722,624 | 91,299,071 | 121,238,275 |
Sharmin Mossavar-Rahmani | 0.650% | 1,722,624 | 91,299,071 | 121,238,275 |
Terence M. O’Toole | 0.650% | 1,722,624 | 91,299,071 | 121,238,275 |
Thomas B. Walker III | 0.650% | 1,722,624 | 91,299,071 | 121,238,275 |
Barry S. Volpert | 0.600% | 1,590,114 | 84,276,065 | 111,912,254 |
Christopher A. Cole | 0.600% | 1,590,114 | 84,276,065 | 111,912,254 |
David W. Blood | 0.600% | 1,590,114 | 84,276,065 | 111,912,254 |
Donald C. Opatrny Jr. | 0.600% | 1,590,114 | 84,276,065 | 111,912,254 |
Eric M. Mindich | 0.600% | 1,590,114 | 84,276,065 | 111,912,254 |
Eric S. Schwartz | 0.600% | 1,590,114 | 84,276,065 | 111,912,254 |
Gary D. Cohn | 0.600% | 1,590,114 | 84,276,065 | 111,912,254 |
Gregory K. Palm | 0.600% | 1,590,114 | 84,276,065 | 111,912,254 |
J. Michael Evans | 0.600% | 1,590,114 | 84,276,065 | 111,912,254 |
Joseph H. Gleberman | 0.600% | 1,590,114 | 84,276,065 | 111,912,254 |
Masanori Mochida | 0.600% | 1,590,114 | 84,276,065 | 111,912,254 |
Paul M. Achleitner | 0.600% | 1,590,114 | 84,276,065 | 111,912,254 |
Peter C. Gerhard | 0.600% | 1,590,114 | 84,276,065 | 111,912,254 |
Peter S. Kraus | 0.600% | 1,590,114 | 84,276,065 | 111,912,254 |
Robert J. O’Shea | 0.600% | 1,590,114 | 84,276,065 | 111,912,254 |
Scott B. Kapnick | 0.600% | 1,590,114 | 84,276,065 | 111,912,254 |
Scott M. Pinkus | 0.600% | 1,590,114 | 84,276,065 | 111,912,254 |
Steven T. Mnuchin | 0.600% | 1,590,114 | 84,276,065 | 111,912,254 |
Sylvain M. Hefes | 0.600% | 1,590,114 | 84,276,065 | 111,912,254 |
Thomas K. Montag | 0.600% | 1,590,114 | 84,276,065 | 111,912,254 |
Wiet H. Pot | 0.600% | 1,590,114 | 84,276,065 | 111,912,254 |
Byron D. Trott | 0.550% | 1,457,605 | 77,253,060 | 102,586,233 |
George W. Wellde Jr. | 0.550% | 1,457,605 | 77,253,060 | 102,586,233 |
Jim O’Neill | 0.550% | 1,457,605 | 77,253,060 | 102,586,233 |
John J. Powers | 0.550% | 1,457,605 | 77,253,060 | 102,586,233 |
Michael S. Sherwood | 0.550% | 1,457,605 | 77,253,060 | 102,586,233 |
Richard S. Sharp | 0.550% | 1,457,605 | 77,253,060 | 102,586,233 |
Andrew M. Alper | 0.525% | 1,391,350 | 73,741,557 | 97,923,222 |
Carlos A. Cordeiro | 0.525% | 1,391,350 | 73,741,557 | 97,923,222 |
Charles B. Seelig Jr. | 0.525% | 1,391,350 | 73,741,557 | 97,923,222 |
Daniel W. Stanton | 0.525% | 1,391,350 | 73,741,557 | 97,923,222 |
E. Gerald Corrigan | 0.525% | 1,391,350 | 73,741,557 | 97,923,222 |
E. Scott Mead | 0.525% | 1,391,350 | 73,741,557 | 97,923,222 |
John L. Townsend III | 0.525% | 1,391,350 | 73,741,557 | 97,923,222 |
John O. Downing | 0.525% | 1,391,350 | 73,741,557 | 97,923,222 |
Jonathan R. Aisbitt | 0.525% | 1,391,350 | 73,741,557 | 97,923,222 |
Joseph R. Zimmel | 0.525% | 1,391,350 | 73,741,557 | 97,923,222 |
Kendrick R. Wilson III | 0.525% | 1,391,350 | 73,741,557 | 97,923,222 |
Lawrence H. Linden | 0.525% | 1,391,350 | 73,741,557 | 97,923,222 |
Michael J. Zamkow | 0.525% | 1,391,350 | 73,741,557 | 97,923,222 |
Michael R. Lynch | 0.525% | 1,391,350 | 73,741,557 | 97,923,222 |
Reuben Jeffery III | 0.525% | 1,391,350 | 73,741,557 | 97,923,222 |
Simon M. Robertson | 0.525% | 1,391,350 | 73,741,557 | 97,923,222 |
Sir Peter D. Sutherland | 0.525% | 1,391,350 | 73,741,557 | 97,923,222 |
Suzanne M. Nora Johnson | 0.525% | 1,391,350 | 73,741,557 | 97,923,222 |
Timothy J. O’Neill | 0.525% | 1,391,350 | 73,741,557 | 97,923,222 |
Anthony G. Williams | 0.475% | 1,258,841 | 66,718,552 | 88,597,201 |
Armen A. Avanessians | 0.475% | 1,258,841 | 66,718,552 | 88,597,201 |
Arthur J. Reimers | 0.475% | 1,258,841 | 66,718,552 | 88,597,201 |
Edward A. Mulé | 0.475% | 1,258,841 | 66,718,552 | 88,597,201 |
Frank L. Coulson Jr. | 0.475% | 1,258,841 | 66,718,552 | 88,597,201 |
Henry Cornell | 0.475% | 1,258,841 | 66,718,552 | 88,597,201 |
Howard A. Silverstein | 0.475% | 1,258,841 | 66,718,552 | 88,597,201 |
Joseph D. Gatto | 0.475% | 1,258,841 | 66,718,552 | 88,597,201 |
Joseph Della Rosa | 0.475% | 1,258,841 | 66,718,552 | 88,597,201 |
Lawton W. Fitt | 0.475% | 1,258,841 | 66,718,552 | 88,597,201 |
Peter G.C. Mallinson | 0.475% | 1,258,841 | 66,718,552 | 88,597,201 |
Richard G. Sherlund | 0.475% | 1,258,841 | 66,718,552 | 88,597,201 |
Robert Litterman | 0.475% | 1,258,841 | 66,718,552 | 88,597,201 |
Robert V. Delaney | 0.475% | 1,258,841 | 66,718,552 | 88,597,201 |
Tracy R. Wolstencroft | 0.475% | 1,258,841 | 66,718,552 | 88,597,201 |
Connie K. Duckworth | 0.425% | 1,126,331 | 59,695,546 | 79,271,180 |
Danny O. Yee | 0.425% | 1,126,331 | 59,695,546 | 79,271,180 |
David L. Henle | 0.425% | 1,126,331 | 59,695,546 | 79,271,180 |
Esta E. Stecher | 0.425% | 1,126,331 | 59,695,546 | 79,271,180 |
Gary W. Williams | 0.425% | 1,126,331 | 59,695,546 | 79,271,180 |
Michael G. Rantz | 0.425% | 1,126,331 | 59,695,546 | 79,271,180 |
Peter D. Kiernan III | 0.425% | 1,126,331 | 59,695,546 | 79,271,180 |
Thomas J. Healey | 0.425% | 1,126,331 | 59,695,546 | 79,271,180 |
Ann F. Kaplan | 0.400% | 1,060,076 | 56,184,043 | 74,608,169 |
Cody J. Smith | 0.400% | 1,060,076 | 56,184,043 | 74,608,169 |