Twelve Years a Slave - Enhanced Edition (32 page)

O’Neal, William.
The Life and History of William O’Neal
. Edited by Sue Eakin. Bossier City, LA: Everett Co., 1988. Originally published as
The Man Who Sold His Wife
(St. Louis, MO: A. R. Fleming and Co., 1896).

———.
William O’Neal, The Man Who Sold His Wife
. Edited by Sue Eakin. Bossier City, LA: Everett Companies, 1988.

Pellet, Elias P.
History of the 114th Regiment, New York State Volunteers
. Norwich, NY: Telegraph and Chronicle Power Press, 1866.

The People v. Alexander Merrill and Joseph Russell, No. #3 (Oyer and Terminer Jan. 6, 1855).

People v. Alexander Merrill and Joseph Russell, XIV New York Reports 75-77 (Court of Appeals of the State of New York 1888).

The People v. Merrill and Russell, No. # 3 (Oyer and Terminer Jan. 6, 1855).

“The People vs. Alexander Merrill and Joseph Russell.” In
Reports of Decisions in Criminal Cases Made at Term, in Chambers, and in the Courts of Oyer and Terminer of the State of New York
, compiled by Amasa J. Parker, 590-605. Vol. II. Albany, NY: Banks, Gould, and Co., 1856.

Pernaud, Rene B. Rene B. Pernaud to Sue Eakin, May 22, 1999. Sue Eakin Papers. Louisiana State University Alexandria, Alexandria.

Perrin, William Henry. “Southwest Louisiana: Historical and Biographical 1891.” In
Southwest Louisiana: Historical and Biographical
. Baton Rouge, LA: Claitor’s Publishing Division, 1971.

Prichard, Walter. “Outline of Louisiana History.” Unpublished manuscript, Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge, LA, 1930.

“A Probable Kidnapper.” Editorial.
The National Era
III, no. 394 (July 1854).

Robert, Carl. “Cheneyville.” Sue Eakin Papers, Louisiana State University Alexandria, Alexandria, LA, 1958.

Robert, Carl. Carl Robert to Sue Eakin, March 1962. Sue Eakin Papers. Louisiana State University Alexandria, Alexandria, LA.

———. Letter, August 1963. Sue Eakin Papers. Louisiana State University Alexandria, Alexandria, LA.

Robinson, W. Stitt, Jr.
Mother Earth: Land Grants in Virginia, 1607-1699. Jamestown Booklet No. 5.
Charlottesville, VA: University of Virginia, 1980.

Root, Lewis Carroll, and William H. Root. “The Experiences of a Federal Soldier in Louisiana in 1863.”
Louisiana Historical Quarterly
19, no. 3 (July 19, 1936).

Sale Between Abraham and Mary Ann Tice and Solomon Northup.
275 Grantee Index, Warren County, State of New York
. N.p., May 16, 1853.

The Salem Press
(Salem, NY). “Recovery of a Free Negro.” January 25, 1853.

“Sale of Land, Document 7862, John Parkes to Edwin Epps.” Unpublished manuscript, St. Landry Parish, Opelousas, LA, March 10, 1852.

Sandy Hill Herald
(Sandy Hill, NY). “Uncle Sol.” March 22, 1853.

Saratoga Whig
(Saratoga, NY), October 22, 1852.

Schafer, Judith Kelleher.
Slavery, the Civil War, and the Supreme Court of Louisiana
. Baton Rouge, LA: Louisiana State University Press, 1994.

Smith, Pete. Interview by Sue Eakin. LA. October 1964.

Solomon Northup v. Washington Allen (Court of Common Pleas of County of Saratoga, NY 1838).

Stafford, George Mason Graham.
Three Pioneer Families of Rapides Parish: A Geneaology
. Baton Rouge, LA: Claitor’s, 1946.

———.
The Wells Family of Louisiana and Allied Families
. Alexandria, LA: Wells, 1969.

Staples, Brent. “Editorial Observer: Wrestling with the Legacy of Slavery at Yale.”
New York Times
, August 14, 2004. Accessed August 14, 2004. http://www.newyorktimes.com.

“Sugar and Slavery in Louisiana. From ‘Hill’s Monthly Visitor.’”
Southern Cultivator
, October 1847.

“The Sugar Crop of Louisiana. From the ‘New Orleans Delta.’”
Southern Cultivator
, December 1847.

Sylvester, Nathaniel Bartlett.
History of Saratoga, New York
. Philadelphia: Evarts and Ensign, 1878.

Tarver, John. Interview. Baton Rouge and Bunkie, LA. 2003-2004.

———. Telephone interview by Sue Eakin. Baton Rouge and Bunkie, LA. 1992.

Taub, Sonia. Sonia Taub to Sue Eakin, April 23, 1993. Sue Eakin Papers. Louisiana State University Alexandria, Alexandria, LA.

Taylor, Joe Gray.
Negro Slavery in Louisiana
. Baton Rouge, LA: Louisiana Historical Association, 1963.

Temperance Helper
(NY). “The Northup Kidnappers.” February 15, 1855.

Theophilus Freeman v. His Creditors, 15 Louisiana Annual #397 829 (Louisiana 1860).

Thompson, Edgar T. Plantation Societies, Race Relations, and the South: The Regimentation of Populations to
Selected Papers of Edgar T. Thompson
. Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 1975.

Tyler-McGraw, Marie, and Gregg D. Kimball.
In Bondage and Freedom: Antebellum Black Life in Richmond, Virginia-1790-1860
. Richmond, VA: Valentine Museum, 1988.

“
Uncle Tom’s Cabin
--No. 2.” In
The Salem Press
. Salem, NY, 1853. Previously published in
Albany Evening Journal
(Albany, NY), July 26, 1853.

Vandereedt, John K. John K. Vandereedt to Sue Eakin, July 17, 1995.

Van Namee, I. M. “Letter to the Editor.”
Washington County People’s Journal
(Washington County, NY), July 1854.

Van Woert, Nathaniel. “Diary.” Unpublished Civil War manuscript, n.d. Private collection of George Windes, Brea, CA.

Waddill, John Pamplin. “Diary.” Sue Eakin Papers. Louisiana State University Alexandria, Alexandria, LA.

Ward, Harry M.
Richmond: An Illustrated History
. Northridge, CA: Windsor Publications, 1985.

Washington County People’s Journal
(Washington County, NY). “How the Sol. Northup Case was Disposed Of.” March 8, 1855.

Washington County People’s Journal
(Ballston Spa, NY). “An Individual Identified by Solomon Northup...” July 13, 1854, 2.

Washington County People’s Journal
(NY). “Sol. Northup’s Kidnappers.” July 20, 1854.

Washington County Post
(Washington Co., NY). “The Arrest of Solomon Northup’s Alleged Kidnappers.” July 14, 1853.

Wells, Doris. Doris Wells to Sue Eakin, July 15, 2003. Sue Eakin Papers. Louisiana State University Alexandria, Alexandria.

Wells, Gilbert. Interview by Sue Eakin. Cheneyville, LA. 1970?

Whittington, G. P.
Rapides Parish, Louisiana: A History
. Alexandria, LA: Alexandria Committee of the National Society of the Colonia Dames of Louisiana, n.d.

Wright, Esther Boyd. Interview by Walter Fleming. Sue Eakin Papers, Louisiana State University Alexandria Archives.

Wright, Porter, and Barbara Wright.
The Old Evergreen Burying Ground
. Rayne, LA: Hebert Publishing, 1990.

Writers Program of Works Progress Administration, comp.
Louisiana: A Guide to the State
. NY, NY: Hasting House, 1941.

Wyckoff, Edith. “Autobiography of a Family.” Unpublished manuscript, n.d.

———. Letter, n.d. Family documents. Edith Wycliff, Locust Hill.

———. Telephone interview by Sue Eakin. Locust Hill, NY and Bunkie, LA. 1990-2000.

Wyckoff, Edith Hay.
Autobiography of a Family
. Fort Edward, NY: Washington County Historical Society, 2000.

Notes To Introduction

1. “People vs. Alexander Merrill and Joseph Russell,” Oyer & Terminer, January 6, 1855, Document 3, Deposition by James H. Birch.

2. Benjamin Owen Sheekell, in an appearance before a magistrate in Washington, D.C., on January 18, 1853, concerning a complaint from Solomon Northup by his attorney, Henry Northup, testified that he and Birch had been partners prior to 1838 and “after that time he was a partner of Theophilus Freeman, of New Orleans. Burch bought here - Freeman sold there!” (Solomon Northup,
Twelve Years a Slave
[1853]), 315.

3. Joan D. Hedrick,
Harriet Beecher Stowe
(New York: Oxford University Press, 1994), 118.

4. Bibliographic assistance provided through personal correspondence from librarian David Fiske, Ballston Spa, NY, to Sue Eakin, Bunkie, LA, June 7, 2003; Solomon Northup,
A Freeman in Bondage or Twelve
Years a Slave
(Philadelphia: Columbian Publishing Company, 1890); and Solomon Northup,
Twelve Years a Slave,
eds., Sue Eakin and Joseph Logsdon. (Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press, 1968).

5. In addition to
Twelve Years a Slave,
Wilson also penned
The Life of Jane McCrea, with an Account of Burgoyne’s Expedition of 1777
(New York, 1853);
Henrietta Robinson: The Veiled Murderess
(Auburn, NY, 1855);
A Narrative of Nelson Lee, a Captive Among the Comanches
(1859); and is reputed to be the author of
Life in Whitehall: a Tale of Ship-Fever Times
(Auburn, 1850).

6. Personal correspondence from Carol Senaca, Historical Society of Whitehall, NY, to Sue Eakin, Bunkie, LA, September 11, 2003; phone conversation of Carol Senaca with Sue Eakin, March 13, 2004.

7. Clarence E. Holden, “Local History Sketches,”
Whitehall Democrat
, February n.d., 1852.

8.
Ibid
., 1870.

Chapter Notes And Historical Context

Composed by Sue Eakin

Chapter One

1.
Though Solomon Northup was a freeman in New York, one should not assume he enjoyed all of “the blessings of liberty” in his native state. In reality, as a free man of color and citizen of New York, he lacked the rights provided whites. Documentation for this assertion includes the following: “Although the first steps toward equality had been taken more than twenty years earlier [than 1821], the Negro had, and for many decades continued to have, inferior status socially, politically, and economically” [See Ellis et al., 225].

Such policies did not change even amid the intense hostility against slavery in the 1850s or even later. According to these authors:

[t]he Negro population suffered much inequality both within and outside the law. The Constitution of 1822 discriminated against free Negroes by requiring them to meet a property qualification higher than that required by white voters. Although the property qualification for whites was abolished in 1826, that for the free Negroes was retained. On three occasions, 1846, 1860, and 1867, the public refused to approve a constitutional amendment permitting equal suffrage for Negroes. It required the Fifteenth Amendment to eliminate the property qualification imposed on Negroes. In addition to legal inequities, the Negroes met the usual round of discrimination and lack of opportunity. The Irish immigrants in particular fought desperately for the jobs as manual laborers, waiters, and domestic servants which previously had offered Negroes their best opportunities for employment. [See Ellis et al., 281]

In the Bayou Boeuf plantation area of Louisiana where Solomon Northup lived twelve years as a slave, the population of African Americans in the total population was around eight blacks to ten whites; blacks in the New York population in 1855 comprised 1.3% [See Eakin, “The Plantation System in the Lower Red River Valley,” 21]. A booklet,
A Heritage Uncovered: The Black Experience in Upstate New York, 1800-1825
, published by the Chemung County Historical Society in 1988, provides insights into the lives of three small towns in New York, and specifically something of the lifestyle of Solomon and Anne Northup in Saratoga Springs:

Solomon Northup, perhaps the best known of Saratoga’s antebellum year-round residents, and his wife, Anne, illustrate the employment options available to early nineteenth century black Saratogians. First arriving in Saratoga Springs in 1834, Northup generally worked summers as a hack driver for Washington Hall, a local boarding house, and winters as a violinist. He supplemented his income with a brief stint as a railroad laborer for the Troy and Saratoga line while it was under construction and at various odd jobs at the United States Hotel. Anne found regular employment as a cook. [See Armstead, Horne, & Sorin, 28]

While Solomon’s wife regularly left their home at the end of the season for the Saratoga Springs resort business, Solomon faced each “off season” without a job and with the uncertainty of finding work until the new resort season opened. Menial jobs of one kind or another were his only choice. As for the violin or fiddle affording means for regular employment, engagements depended upon dances or other social occasions in which the fiddler was contracted, and this was sporadic, not dependable, sustained income. Regarding the “off season,” Solomon states, “Anne, as was her usual custom had gone over to Sandy Hill, a distance of some twenty miles, to take charge of the culinary department at Sherill’s Coffee House, during the session of the court” [See Northup, 28]. Anne had a job as a cook, the same kind of job she held at the United States Hotel; her husband did not have that security.

2.
The reference, of course, is to
Uncle Tom’s Cabin
by Harriet Beecher Stowe, published on March 20, 1852, less than a year before
Twelve Years
a Slave
. The contract with the publisher gave Stowe 10-percent of sales, which resulted in about $10,000 in royalties in the first three months of publication—“‘the largest sum of money ever received by any author, either American or European, from the sale of a single work in so short a time,’’ the press noted” [See Hedrick, 223].

On April 10, 1853, about the time Solomon’s ghost writer, David Wilson, began work on
Twelve Years a Slave
, Stowe sailed for England and “made her triumphant tour of Great Britain, where sales of
Uncle Tom’s Cabin
were more than triple the phenomenal figures of the United States, reaching a million and a half in the first year” [See Headrick, 233].

A contemporary review of
Twelve Years A Slave
from 1853 compares the two books:

THE NARRATIVE OF SOLOMON NORTHUP. READ WHAT THE REVIEWERS SAY. Next to ‘Uncle Tom’s Cabin,’ the extraordinary Narrative of Solomon Northup is the most remarkable book that was ever issued from the American Press. Indeed, it is a more extraordinary work than that because it is only a simple unvarnished tale of the experience of an American freeman of the ‘blessings’ of Slavery, while Ms. Stowe’s Uncle Tom is only an ingenious and powerfully wrought novel . . .” [See “Narrative of Solomon . . .”]

3.
The declaration by Solomon Northup that this is his truthful story of his slave experience on Bayou Boeuf is meant to establish that Solomon vouches for every observation. However, it is important to note that ghost writer David Wilson interviewed Solomon, and portions of the story may have been embellished with his own views. (There were other contributors too, including that of Attorney Henry Northup.) The basic facts of Solomon’s journey to Louisiana and his movement through the Bayou Boeuf plantation country during his twelve years as a slave have been validated and provide the framework on which the story is based. Names of people and places are unquestionable. Some of the events said to have transpired, however, are open to question. Some errors noted may have resulted from the speed with which this book was written and published, and incorrect names may have been supplied to David Wilson, or he may have simply improvised.

Wilson accomplished the impossible: completing the book and seeing it published within a little over three-months’ time. Attorney Henry Northup spurred him on and gave all the assistance he could. Attorney Northup’s goal was to see the book published as quickly as possible while newspapers were giving wide coverage to the ordeal of Solomon and his rescue. The attorney correctly figured that information from the forthcoming book would reach readers who could and would identify the kidnappers [See all Wyckoff documents. Edith Wyckoff was a direct descendant of Henry Northup.].

4.
With the indirect reference to
Uncle Tom’s Cabin
by noting
“works of fiction,”
ghost writer David Wilson emphasizes his attempt to establish Northup’s book as a firsthand account of slavery and to differentiate it from the famous novel.

That Northup and Wilson were successful in persuading many news editors that Northup was providing an accurate firsthand account is shown in such articles as this one:

From the
Union Gasette
.

Northup’s Kidnappers.

Solomon Northup has suffered twelve years of Slavery through the agency of these men. He was born free as they, and with a better heart. He resided in Washington county at the time he was stolen, and were it not tha the left warm and influential friends behind him, his subjugation to the Slave-whip would have been lifelong.

As it was he spent twelve years under the hands of Southern task-masters. How he was finally released is a familiar story and need not be repeated. And now that the men who robbed him of twelve years of a freeman’s life are caught, what punishment can any one, who will for a moment imagine himself the wronged, deem too great! Kidnapping, like Murder, ‘hath miraculous organs.’ So many years have elapsed since Northup was sold into Slavery that difficulty was apprehended in proving the guilt of Merrill and Russell—but these apprehensions are dispelled. Testimony of the most unimpeachable character is at hand.

In 1841, when Northup says, in his narrative, that he was beguiled to Washington by Merrill and Russell, Thaddeus St. John, Esq. of Fulton county saw them with a colored man at Baltimore and in Washington. Mr. St. John not only suspected their design, but intimated his suspicions to Russell.

On his return from Washington Mr. St. John met these men again in the car without the colored man. Mr. St. John is a gentleman of the highest intelligence and character. [See
Albany Evening Journal
, Feb. 15, 1855; Feb 22, 1855]

With the support and contribution of Henry Northup, a passionate abolitionist who had gone on a risky 5,000 mile journey to Louisiana and met with Avoyelles Parish officials, Wilson had all of the ingredients for a successful telling of a remarkable story. The time was right for
Twelve Years a Slave
, with abolitionists kindling passions in people hungry for such a book, as the North-South controversy continued to intensify.

The success of both books owed a great deal to the hostile debate over the Fugitive Slave Law of 1850 and the later increasingly furious controversy over the status of Kansas: free or slave. Stowe’s biographer, Joan D. Hedrick, explains:

Passed by Congress and signed by President Fillmore in September 1850, the Fugitive Slave Law had, as Henry Ward Beecher observed, provisions odious enough ‘to render an infamous thing consistently infamous throughout.’ Section Five commanded citizens ‘to aid and assist in the prompt and efficient execution of the law, whenever their services may be required.’ Under Section Seven, persons who gave shelter, food, or assistance to an escaping slave were liable for a fine of $1000 and six months in prison. The Fugitive Slave Law effectively abrogated individual rights such as habeas corpus and the right of trial by jury and provided what abolitionists called bribes to commissioners by awarding them $10 for every alleged fugitive they remanded to slavery, but only $5 for everyone they determined to be free. [See Hedrick, 203]

The debate over Kansas worsened the dispute. In the heat of the North-South arguments,
Twelve Years a Slave
appearing as a firsthand account served in part to confirm Stowe’s narrative and added fuel to the flames between the sections.

The close association of
Twelve Years a Slave
with
Uncle Tom’s Cabin
was quickly and often noted in New York newspaper accounts. In
The New York Daily Times
: “[Northup’s] nine years that he was in the hands of Epps, was of a character nearly approaching that described by Mrs. Stowe, as the condition of ‘Uncle Tom’ while in that region” [See
New York Daily Times
, January 20, 1853]. In the
Albany Evening Journal
: “Literary News, The success of ‘Uncle Tom’ was the incitement to a great many trashy novels on the same subject.

But none have equaled it in pathos and interest. The true narrative of ‘Sol. Northup’ came nearest to the fiction of ‘Uncle Tom.’ . . . [See “Literary News,” June 6, 1856]. In the
Salem Press
:

‘Uncle Tom’s Cabin’
—No. 2
: The rescue of Solomon Northup, a Free Man who was Kidnapped and sold into Slavery, of which he had TWELVE YEARS experience, has given the public another view of the practical workings of that peculiar Institution. NORTHUP’S NARRATIVE is ‘UNCLE TOM’S CABIN’ without its Romance . . . The book, though less exciting than that of Mrs. Stowe, is deeply interesting, and will be extensively read . . . [See “
Uncle Tom’s Cabin
—No. 2,” July 26, 1853]

5.
Mintus Northup, father of Solomon, was emancipated not once but twice. The first came in 1797 with the will of Captain Henry Northup. Mintus Northup is the subject of an interesting paragraph dealing with his second emancipation in a book published by the Vermont Historical Society:

On the 25th of April [1822] in the same year, Mintus Northup of the town of Fort Edward, being duly sworn, said that he had always understood and verily believed that he was born in the town of North Kingston, in the State of Rhode Island, and that he ‘was borned free,’ and at that time he was of the age of forty-five years and eight months, and that since he had arrived at the age of twenty years he had acted and continued as a free man. The affidavit was sworn to before Timothy N. Allen, a justice of the peace; and Timothy Eddy made oath that he had been acquainted with Mintus Northup for twenty years and upwards, and verily believes that during all that time the said Mintus was always considered a free man; and John Baker, one of the judges of the court, certifies that this proof is satisfactory to him, and that he is of the opinion that Mintus Northup is free according to the laws of the State of New York . . . [See Bascom, 162]

Mintus Northup (1791-1826) worked for various people in New York including Henry B. Northup’s half-brother, Clark Northup, who lived in Granville, New York. Family genealogist Edith Wyckoff, a great-granddaughter of Henry B. Northup, who rescued Solomon from slavery, wrote:

In 1909 John Henry wrote a letter to my grandmother [Edith Carman Hay] about Solomon and his father. ‘Mintus’ said John Henry ‘lived a mile or two east of Fort Edward.’ John Henry said that when he was a boy ‘Mintus used to come to Sandy Hill and make little beds in the garden for each of us children . . .’ Mintus and his son were well known to the Northups of New York, especially Henry B. (the attorney who rescued Solomon). [See Wyckoff,
Autobiography of a Family,
121]

6.
Henry B. Northup (1805-1877), one in a long line of Henry Northups, was the seventh child of John Holmes Northup of Hebron, New York. At sixteen Henry left the farm to sail to New England where he hoped “to seek a berth on a whaling boat.” After a rather tempestuous adolescence, young Henry B. Northup, supported by his father, prepared himself to become a lawyer. He graduated from Middlebury College in 1829 and studied law in the office of Henry C. Martindale. As the protégé of Martindale, he became district attorney. Later he was named as a judge in the court of common pleas. He became a congressman and a leader among Whig politicians in the state. His law office stands on Center Street, Hudson Falls, New York. Wyckoff states the history of Henry B. from that time: