Tug of War (27 page)

He bent to examine the right arm, again cutting away remaining shreds of fabric. ‘No sign of an old wound to the upper arm visible.’

Puzzled, he looked at the man’s face. ‘Either of you got a working torch? Thank you, Charles. Shine it closely on the face, would you, there on your right, his left. There! Are there
signs of a blow to the head? Too faint to make out. The features are decayed, extremities show depredations by rodents. Broken cheekbone, though, I think. Premortem? Someone kicked him unconscious
and, as he lay there, stabbed him to death?’

He looked at Dorcas, the doctor’s appalling mime of Thibaud’s nightmare performance vivid in their minds.

‘Check, Joe, can you see if his hands were tied? He wouldn’t have just knelt down to wait for the blow, would he?’

Joe lifted each hand in turn. ‘Hard to tell, honestly, without a microscope but there’s something there. On both wrists. A slight mark. A ligature he struggled against? It’s
possible. And, significantly – it’s been removed. The man has been overpowered, we must assume, here on this spot, kicked unconscious and repeatedly stabbed.’

‘But who on earth could perform such a despicable act?’ said Charles. ‘Hard to believe that anyone we know and who – we must presume – was acquainted with his
victim, could kill in this cruel and brutal way.’

‘Oh, I don’t know . . .’ said Joe bitterly. ‘I’ve known much worse meted out by men who hadn’t even been introduced to their victim.’

He got to his feet, clicked shut his knife and dusted off his knees. ‘That’s all for the moment. I think – and it doesn’t please me to say this – that we now find
ourselves in a position where we have little choice but to go along with some of Aline’s suggestions. Or were they orders? We must turn this sad relic over to the men to have it conveyed
upstairs. And – opening a bottle? I could do with a whisky if I may make a suggestion of my own.’

‘Right. Right,’ said Charles, shuffling his feet in the dust. ‘Look, Sandilands, why don’t you go on ahead? Speak to Aline? She’ll be expecting it. She’ll be
in the salon. Planning her next move and rehearsing her lines, shouldn’t wonder. You’ve been warned! Leave me to make all the necessary arrangements for our friend here. I’ll have
the local undertaker sent for.’

Joe smiled and mimed stiffening his shoulders to take a command.

‘
Bon courage, mon ami!
’ said Charles as Joe stalked away down the corridor.

Chapter Twenty-Five

Joe went first to the stables, aware that he was dragging his feet, reluctant to encounter Aline once again. He took off his jacket, and stripped off his shirt, and began to
wash his hands and arms and face thoroughly, making use of the cake of carbolic soap available in the grooms’ earthenware sink. He dried off on a towel hanging on a hook and finally, feeling
clean but smelling disgusting, he put on his things again. He straightened his tie, squinting into a cracked looking-glass and grimacing at his strained face. ‘Can’t put it off any
longer, Sandilands,’ he confided to his image. ‘Shift yer arse!’

Crossing the courtyard he encountered a stern-faced Georges. ‘My mother’s in the salon,’ he said curtly. ‘She’s not obliged to – don’t think it –
but she’d like to have a few words.’ And, challenging and suspicious: ‘What have you done with Dorcas?’

Joe was suddenly angry. ‘What the hell do you
suppose
I’ve done with her? Knocked her on the head and sealed her up in an alcove? Not the kind of behaviour we go in for in my
family! She’s with your uncle, desperately trying to clear up
your
family’s mess!’

Georges’s head went back as though he’d been slapped and to Joe’s dismay tears began to trickle. He sniffled noisily and put a large hand in embarrassment across his face.

Instantly, Joe threw out both arms and seized the boy in a tight hug. ‘Forgive me, Georges, old man. Awful thing to say! Insensitive! Unforgivable! Be kind and put it down to strain
– the strain of having to go in there and speak to your mother – will you?’

Georges nodded his understanding.

‘And, I say – before you rush off to find Dorcas – any chance you could rustle up a drink?’

Georges gulped, raised a dim smile and found his voice. ‘A twenty-year-old Glenfiddich?’ he offered. ‘Would that fit the bill?’

‘Well, I wasn’t quite sure what would appear round the door,’ she said. ‘The local gendarmerie flourishing handcuffs perhaps? I didn’t hope for a Scotland Yard
commander bearing a tray of refreshments. I’ll have a large one, please. Neat, no ice.’

He poured out her drink, taking the same measure for himself, and they sat and sipped the whisky silently.

Her hat and hymn book had been abandoned on the floor at her feet and she was sitting perched anxiously on the end of her chaise longue, puffing rather inexpertly on a small cigar. Her tawny
hair was dishevelled, her face tear-stained. She looked small and frightened and Joe could no longer imagine what about her had so disconcerted him in the cellars. But, whatever that quality, it
was not so much to be feared as this new show of vulnerability, he decided, taking out a little insurance.

A few more sips and puffs and she had recovered sufficiently to look up and sketch a wan smile. ‘I’m sorry I frightened you all,’ she said. ‘Making an appearance like
that and spoiling your moment. I didn’t go to church. Guilty conscience, I suppose, made me fear to leave what you’d probably describe as “the crime scene” for too long. Not
with a sharp and determined bloodhound like you within a few yards of a concealed body.’

He was relieved to hear her light tone.

‘So you know about Edward?’ she said.

‘I couldn’t say that with any confidence,’ he replied. ‘I know that the body we have just found is that of Edward Thorndon and that he died here while sheltering under
your roof in late July 1917. I know that your husband Clovis disappeared at the same time. I know that you, Aline, were observed dragging the body into its hiding place and giving instructions for
it to be immured.’

‘Yes, yes,’ she cut him short. ‘Georges has just told me what he saw. My poor boy! All those years . . . out of loyalty . . . I had no idea . . . I am much to blame for never
realizing.’

Her head went up and she held out her glass for more whisky. Joe was glad to oblige and poured a second generous measure. He had never suspected that this might be the way to melt Aline’s
ice crust. She delicately invited him with a gesture to refill his own glass.

‘But I did it for
him
, you know. For Georges. I couldn’t bear to lose him.’

‘I think you’re going to have to explain that,’ he said.

‘But first – I want you to tell me what you have deduced from that terrible scene down there. No!’ she added, seeing his cynical surprise. ‘No! I did not see the murder,
I certainly did not play a part in it. I came across the body of Edward. There was no one about. Clovis had been stamping and raging all day and I feared his temper might lead to some sort of scene
. . . but I never expected this madness. A servant told me they’d gone down to the cellars. Together. And they were both in uniform. Both about to go back to the front. You can imagine what I
thought – some sort of awful duel! Clovis was capable of anything. Do you think they fought a duel, Commander?’

Joe outlined as simply as he could the evidence he had drawn from the murder scene and linked it with the doctor’s report. ‘. . . so, I’m assuming Clovis, having lured Edward
down there – issuing a challenge or an invitation of some sort, “Sabres at seven,” “Why don’t we find a quiet place to discuss this?” – ambushed him,
overpowered him and tied his hands. Perhaps some exchange of views took place and as a result of what was said, Clovis kicked him in the head as he knelt begging for his life.’

Joe hesitated, wondering how much of his knowledge he should share with her. ‘Oddly enough,’ he said, ‘like a terrifying echo from the past . . . a recorded scream you might
say if you were being fanciful, we know exactly what was said by the victim with his last breath. His words scored themselves on to the mind of his killer to be replayed like a phonograph recording
years later in the course of a nightmare. Dr Varimont observed and noted. And that last desperate plea being wrung from him in his native language – in English – was the reason for my
involvement. For good or ill.’

He repeated Edward’s dying words and her head drooped, heavy with grief.

‘Having stabbed him to death, I’m supposing Clovis himself cut the ties from Edward’s hands, though I can’t imagine why . . .’

‘A cavalryman like Clovis would never want to be accused of killing a restrained man, Commander. It’s a matter of honour. Like shooting a sitting duck. He would want it to be thought
– if discovered – that he had killed a worthy opponent in fair combat. But this is worse, much worse, than I had ever envisaged. My poor Edward . . .’

She dragged herself free from the cold grasp of her imaginings, steadied her voice and started on the explanation Joe was waiting for. ‘It was a difficult visit. I had quarrelled with
Clovis. He made it clear that he had no regard for me – suggested I return to my parents in Paris when the war ended. He was sure that it would be over by the end of the year. And he proposed
to go on living here with Georges.

‘If he survived! But I think he wasn’t seriously expecting to survive the next battle. He was clearing up things here. He knew I loved Edward. It must have been obvious even to him.
And I cannot be certain that Edward did not tell him. He was a very uncomplicated character. Open and good-hearted. He was not, by nature, an intriguer and what was going on here was, on one level,
a torment to him, I knew that. I warned him to be discreet but, knowing him, he would have seized an opportunity of telling Clovis all.’

‘Do you mind telling me exactly what
was
going on, madame?’

‘Well, a love affair,’ she smiled. ‘You remember the doves? I was speaking of Edward, of course. We had met in 1915. In September. I’d cycled back from my shift at the
hospital in the village to find the house full of troops. I assumed they were
our
troops – that Clovis had come back on leave – and I hurried off to the stables where they told
me he’d gone. Clovis would never waste a minute waiting about. It was dark in the corridor but there he was coming in through the back door. He was wearing Clovis’s old clothes –
his own uniform was in the tub. His fair hair was gleaming in the sunshine, he was being trailed by Georges and the dog. I was sure it was Clovis and I ran to him and threw my arms around him.
Silly thing to do – he was carrying two bottles of champagne in from the cellar. The last thing he could have expected was a bloodstained nurse hurling herself at him and kissing him! He
picked me up and swung me away from the broken glass and I realized.’

Her cigar had long gone out though she still clutched it, and Joe gently took it from her and put it in an ashtray.

She breathed unsteadily and her eyes filled with tears. Hardly able to speak she battled on, accepting that nothing she could say would convey the depth of her feeling but impelled to try.
‘Two seconds! I told you! Nothing we could do about it! Nothing! To say we fell in love is a bit weak – we recognized each other. We belonged to each other from that moment.’

Joe was becoming uncomfortable with the high swell of her emotional revelations. ‘And Clovis ran into a confession from Edward, you think?’

‘More than a confession. He was determined to tell him that, if he survived the war, he would come back for me and we’d make a life together in England with Georges. He refused to
leave Georges behind.’

And Joe understood. ‘A dynastically minded man like Clovis with his honour challenged would never accept that. And he loved his son. He thought he was not likely to return from his next
encounter . . . where did you say he was bound? The Chemin des Dames? Ah, yes. He would have known his chances of surviving that were low. He would not want to ride off leaving behind his wife and
his son to be acquired by a despised Englishman who’d usurped his position, stolen his life. Aline, this was always going to end disastrously! It was madness to think otherwise.’

‘Madness? What are you talking about? We were surrounded by madness! We lived in a daily hell of madness. Every day could have been our last. Our love was an escape from that – it
was the only sane thing in our world.’

‘Not quite the only thing that meant a good deal to you, I think,’ said Joe. ‘This conversation started with Georges . . .’

‘I couldn’t let it ever be discovered that my son’s father was a murderer. He was a clever boy, Commander. I was certain he would work it out. I had to hide the body. It was
for his sake I hid it. Concealing it in the cellar was the easy part! I had to get rid of their horses in the night so it would appear they’d gone off to rejoin their troops. I rode one and
led the other. I let them loose within a whinny of a French army camp where I was sure they’d be welcomed with open arms. They were good horses, it broke my heart to let them go. And I walked
back through the lanes and helped Felix finish the wall.’

Joe was smitten by the reserves of strength, emotional as well as purely physical, that unforgettable night must have called for from this woman.

And he still had not guessed at the extent of her resilience. She gave him a calculating look. ‘There’s not a great deal you can do about this, I think, Commander? You have a corpse
to which it will be difficult to assign an identity – I was not deceived for long by your confidence and your sleight of hand. And what authority is going to be interested enough or have
sufficient time on their hands to get to the bottom of it? There are thousands of bodies coming back to the surface every year. The land itself disgorges them: French, German, British, Belgian, men
from the colonies, they still appear. And you know as well as I do – better perhaps – how the authorities work. The French will hand the file over to the British who will hand it back
again with a few superior and dismissive phrases. And it will spend more months . . . years . . . gathering dust on a shelf somewhere. Eventually all those who might have an interest or a memory
will be gone themselves.’