He stood by the lamp post a few cars down the street, away from the doorman, his fists pushed deep into his jeans pockets, a white t-shirt and some Army boots completing him, like Dylan ten years before down in the village. At least that's what some woman, long-haired and dreamy, had told him at the mid-town library as he poured over telephone books and maps of Manhattan. It had been luck, seeing Kate's picture in the arts section of the
New York Times
. He'd been living in Coney Island, on Mermaid Avenue, not far from Woody Guthrie's childhood home, selling hot dogs to fat bored ladies and their children, when he'd happened upon the article about the forthcoming Kiyoshi Awazu retrospective in â75. The curator, her name was now Kate Strauss, talked about the importance of Awazu's contributions to urban design. He studied the picture of her in front of MOMA, the black-and-white jacquard print of her wrap dress, the softness around her waist where it did not sink inward as sharply as it had once, the fullness of her checks, the crosshatching at the top of them near her eyes, like pie crust, the wisps of silver that nested like spiderwebs in her dark, straight hair.
The same woman who appeared at the entrance to the apartment building, an attaché in one hand, purse in the other, and stepped toward the idling car.
“Kate,” he said, and the doorman, who could have been a 240-pound fullback for the New York Jets, stepped in front of him.
“Do you have an appointment to see Mrs. Strauss?” He lifted the two trunks of his arms like a crossing guard, and the seams in the armpits of his doorman's coat grew wide-eyed under the strain.
“Kate Crane, I need to talk to you.” He bobbed his head over the doorman's shoulder. “Don't you remember me? It's Calvin Johnson.”
He did not remember what happened exactly nextâher attaché falling on the ground, followed by her purse, the doorman's weight atop him, his boots scraping against the pavement.
“Eddie, it's okay.”
From where he lay on his back, he could see her arm, her bangles cutting against her wrist, as she tugged at the doorman's shoulder. Her hand suddenly dove over the doorman and grabbed at Johnson's neck, pulling at the silver chain and medal from where it lay hidden in the cotton of his shirt. She gazed at the medal of Saint Christopher for a second, her brother's, before she started crying. The hand disappeared, and he heard the scrape of her heels against the pavement as she stood up.
“Ma'am, is this man bothering you?” The doorman sat on his haunches as Johnson squirmed, even at six feet, so small under him.
“No, Eddieâit's okay.” She dug in her purse for some tissue for her eyes until Eddie offered his handkerchief. “I know him.”
Now Johnson was standing, just as quickly as he had been pinned to the sidewalk, the doorman dusting him off like an item in a menagerie.
“Why are youâ¦soâ¦?” Her lips parted, but no words emerged. Her eyebrows furrowed, as if that knit them into being. “You lookâ¦like a bum.”
She nodded toward the car, at the opened door and the driver standing by it. “Get in.”
On the way to the museum, she ran her hands along his face, touched his lips, fingered the bent ear lobes that angled back toward his head. It had been almost thirty years since he'd seen her eyes, heard her voice, now slightly worn.
“You sure you're not Calvin's son?” She lit a cigarette. “Is this some sort of joke?”
“I swear on my soulâyou left me in Ohio, but I never forgot you. I saw you in the newspaper. I've been in New York for years looking for you, after promising myself I'd only stay a week or two. Before that, I was in Montana.”
“Did you tap some sort of fountain of youth out there?” She tried to knock her ashes in the ashtray but the little cakes of gray tumbled over onto the carpeted floor. “I think I need to call my therapist. Jesus. He needs to adjust my dosage.”
“Noâlook, I didn't tell you everything that happened to me in the war, and I probably should have. But even I didn't know, when I saw you, what the truth of it was. But I want to tell you now. That is, if you even want to see me, I didn't mean to frighten you. Hey, they got the right guy for that job at the door there.”
“Sure, sure,” she repeated, her words not for him. A battle somewhere deep in her thoughts occurred as he watched her eyes flit back and forth. He took her hand, small and clammy, and squeezed it. He could feel her heartbeat leap from her skin into the dried callous of his palm. No other words filled the space between them until the car pulled up to 53rd Street. She began to climb from the seat, but turned to him.
“Stay here.” She grabbed his wrist. “I'll be right back.”
They walked through the upper west side of Central Park, near her apartment. A chill crawling off the Hudson wove through the paths and danced with the litter on the sidewalk. The sky swirled uneasily with clouds, a deep sea of blue behind them. The city was a soft parade of sound that seemed to accentuate their silence rather than hide it.
“So what paper did we work on together at school?” She played with the strap on her purse.
“Beowulf,” he answered. “Do you remember my grade?”
“I'm sorry.” She shook her head.
“C-plus.”
“Why did you go to Montana?”
“To find Stanley Polensky.” He took a cigarette from the pack she extended. “A soldier I served with. It's a long story, though. I got the letters you sent from New York. Not until after I came back, though.”
He had imagined the small walk-up off Times Square that they would have rented back then, had he followed her to New York, a place where they brewed coffee and fried eggs for breakfast and had a rye after work before heading over to the galleries at night for parties, more cocktails with her friends. Something he'd probably never feel comfortable with, and yet she would challenge him to do it, to prove his love for her, and he would.
“It was just yesterday I saw you,” he explained, clasping and unclasping his hands. “It's as if it's only been a few yearsâ¦you went to New York for school. For me, it is. It really is.”
“But it's been a whole lifetime, almost,” she answered, glancing at him as they walked. “At least for me.”
“What did you think, when I didn't write you back?”
“I don't know,” she sighed, adjusted her sunglasses with her thumb and forefinger. “That you thought I was incredibly difficult and silly and that you found yourself a nice, agreeable woman to marry. My parents always said I was too independent for my own good. But life goes on.”
“For some people,” he answered. “So what happened? When your life went on?”
The shadows grew long over the park as he digested, with revulsion and satiation, each morsel of her life apart from him, the stories of art world superstars and trips to Europe, her husband Harry, a surgeon, the private schools in Connecticut for her boys and the “little shack” in the Hamptons. It was a book in which he played no part, and however compelling, he could not own it, nor could he be sure a sequel would be written.
It was getting late. They'd walked over the bridge over the 79th Street transverse up to the 85th transverse and around the reservoir and back down to the Met. He stopped walking, and she trailed ahead a few steps before noticing, before he curled his hand around her arm and pulled her gently to him.
“I never got over you,” he said, his hands reaching for his neck. He held the unclasped medal of St. Christopher, her brother's, before her. “I think you should take Stephen's medal back. I've finally found my way safely.”
“I don'tâ¦I don't understand.” She gripped the medal in her palm. He watched the chain undulate between her fingers like a pendulum, a dousing rod. “It's just not possible that you're here, and you're the same. And, even in the smallest realm of possibility that somehow this is real, you are real, why would you just show up here, all these years later, and expect to claim me?”
She opened her mouth, sucking in the air between them, perhaps so that she could scream, to exert the force of her being, to sonically disperse him, the hallucination, the doppelganger hustler before her. But before she could make a sound, he pressed his lips on hers.
In the main gallery, he waited for her, studying the paintings, the drips and streaks, and it was a lot different than when he was in high school, when they studied Michelangelo and Rembrandt. Even art had moved on without him.
“Do you see anything you like?” Her voice behind him, velvet with age, and he turned with such an urge to kiss her but stared into her eyes, the brown pools of them, acknowledged the laugh lines by her lids. She took him in as well, his worn clothes, the fruity cologne he had borrowed from another boarder at the house in Coney Island. She clasped his arm above his left elbow. “I'm going to show you what I like.”
They came to a painting with lots of dark boxes shaped into a grid. Gray-ghost hieroglyphic swirls and numbers were painted in the grids. A letterbox or graveyard of them.
“Lee Krasner,” Kate said simply. “This woman will get her due. I will see to it. First female retrospective at MOMA. She was not just Pollack's wifeânot by a long shot.”
“What do you like about this painting?”
“They are the secrets of life.” She moved her finger in the air overtop the symbols. “Whose meanings are private and unique to each of us and yet entirely unknown. And our greatest rewards come in brief episodes of coherence, sometimes only just one. The rest of the time, one is flailing, drowning, eyes burning with saltwater.”
He closed his eyes and concentrated on the weight and warmth of her hands on his arm, the sound of her voice swimming through the air to his ears as she explained the rise of early 20th-century cubism and abstract expressionism to modern and pop art and fluxus. She had spent her life in these quiet halls, in equally quiet places in her head loving the majesty of ideals. This was her life, her voice said, the discovery of Lee Krasner, of Frida Kahlo, Willem de Kooning. He would remember all of it because he could not forget the rush of her voice, her breaths, as she spoke about color wheels and brush strokes and canons and the American identity in modern art. The excited lilt of her voice made it sound a little higher, and she was Kate again, the girl in his class at Bowling Green, laughing over a milkshake at the drug store.
“I don't love many thingsâmy sons, my parents, my brother Stephen. I loved my husband, at some point in time. I love art,” she said as they stood in front of a Robert Motherwell painting. He put his arms around her from behind and cradled his head into her neck.
“I want you to love me,” he murmured into her neck. He felt her back stiffen and arch, her eyes scanning the gallery, before falling against him. “Just a brief episode of coherenceâ¦will be okay.”
Kate hailed a cab and ordered the cab driver to drive them to a hotel on 31st not far from Chinatown. The smell of garlic and peanuts wafted over the sour burps of manholes as he guided her up the drab red carpet and into the lobby. In the room, they touched thingsâhim the lightswitch plate, her the cheap wood of the dresser. Then, slowly, they came together in the middle, their bodies pressed against each other like praying hands. And then their lips connected them in a space that neither of them could see, but they swam in its calm darkness together.