Frances squealed and doubled over.
“If you tell a soul, Frances, I swearâ”
“If? If? I can't think of a soul I
won't
tell!”
She went away laughing. Elisabeth felt as if her blush would never dissipate. Every time Will asked what was so funny, she burst into laughter anew.
They honeymooned in a cabin at a little lodge outside Plainwell. She was nervous and felt conspicuous when they checked in, assuming the proprietor and everyone he knew were aware of their business. But she found Will so considerate and gentle that she knew she would cherish living with him forever.
Upon their return, Elisabeth was puzzled when Will drove not to his big old home in the fourth ward, but to a beautiful estate in the first, not far from where she grew up.
“What's this?” she asked.
“Your wedding present.”
He had to be joking. They parked in front of sprawling, palatial estates that backed up to the Rocky River and were owned by bankers, doctors, and industrial moguls. In fact, immediately to the south was the well-known Porter home, which featured “Lover's Bridge,” a rustic footbridge that led to an island in the river.
“Which one would you like?” Will said.
Elisabeth's eyes were glued to the one before her. “This would suit me just fine,” she said.
“That's a relief. It's yours.”
She laughed. “And have you arranged a tour? I'd love to see it if we have time. We must get home soon though, mustn't we?”
But Will was out of the car and coming around to her side. As she stepped out she noticed keys in his hand. “Will. What is this?”
He took her arm and led her up the icy front steps and onto an expansive Victorian porch. The roofline was all angles and gingerbread. Elisabeth was falling in love with the place, still unsure what to make of it and not wanting to get her hopes up. It was impossible they could afford something so extravagant and more than they would need until they had half a dozen children.
Will unlocked the door. The house was bare, but the fireplace in the living room blazed. Someone had been put up to that. She could only hope it was a realty agent who knew better than Will that this was beyond his reach.
The interior was even more impressive than the exterior, everything freshly painted, scrubbed, and waxed. Elisabeth enjoyed the beauty, imagining what she would put where. Will was maddeningly silent, grinning, andâshe fearedâwasting their time. He had proved to be a bright man, a fast riser within Fairbanks-Morse, the youngest manager in their history, and much more handsomely paid than she ever dreamed he would be. But perhaps he was still naïve. Maybe because he had never lived in this ward he was under the impression that a person could take out a mortgage on a place like this and help make the payments by taking in boarders.
By the time they reached the kitchen Elisabeth had had her fill of the excursion and was through dreaming. “We really should go, Will.”
“We really should stay,” he said.
“No, really.”
“Just one more room,” he said.
She sighed and followed him to a glassed-in sunroom in the back. She looked past the tarpaulin-covered piles that filled half the room, apparently belongings that had yet to be moved. Elisabeth was struck by the wide lawn that led to the river and the tree-lined horizon beyond. The sun would set over those trees and create an enchanting vista. “It's gorgeous,” she said. “All right? Can we go home?”
“We're home, Elspeth. Look here.”
He pulled the tarpaulin off the piles and she saw it was his things and hers from the other house. “We need to talk,” she said. “This is ridiculous.”
Will found two chairs that looked shabby in their new surroundings, and set them next to the window, facing each other. Elisabeth reluctantly sat across from him, and he took her hands in his. “Will, I don't need this. I don't want this. We're sensible, middle-class people.”
“You were raised in this neighborhood,” he said.
“Not on this street I wasn't. This is above me. I wouldn't feel comfortable here, knowing the hole you had to put yourself in to get it. We'll look silly, rattling around in hereâ”
“Until we start filling it.”
“You can't take in boarders in this neighborhood.”
“I meant our own family.”
“Will, we'd live under the mortgage for years and we'd never be able to live up to the expectations of theâ”
He let go one of her hands and put a finger to her lips. “If I can't persuade you,” he said, “I'll put it back on the market tomorrow. But hear me out. I have been saving every spare penny since I was a child. For years that meant just a few cents a week, but then it became dollars. When my father died we had some tough years, but the boarding house was cheap and quickly paid for, and you know I did most of the work myself. I sold the house and the business. If we went back there, we'd have to pay rent.
“I've had my eye on a place like this since I was twelve years old. I didn't say anything because I didn't want to disappoint you if I never achieved it. My life's dream was to go into our marriage with only a small mortgage. I make a good salary, and our only debt is a mortgage that will pay off the balance in ten years, about the same amount we would have paid for rent or for a smaller home in another ward.”
“Which would have suited me perfectly.”
“That's one of the things I love so much about you, Elspeth. But even without you working, we can easily make the payments, cover other expenses, and even save. I've worked toward this my whole life, but I'm not married to it. I'm married to you, and all I want is to make you happy. Tell me what would make you happy, and I'll do it without looking back.”
“You'd sell this place and we could set up housekeeping in a normal house?”
“If that made you happy.”
“But I want
you
to be happy.”
He smiled and shook his head. “I'm happy if you're happy.”
“That gets us nowhere, Will. Tell me what you want.”
“You know what I want. I want to give you this.”
“That would make you happy.”
“That would thrill me.”
She studied him, loving him all the more. “Then I accept.”
“Really?”
“Absolutely.”
“And all your objections?”
“I'll get over them. I might feel self-conscious for a while, but who wouldn't love this place and be grateful to God for a husband so kind?”
Will slumped in his chair. “I was afraid you were going to refuse.”
“When have I ever refused you, darling?”
He smiled. “There was that night on the way back from camp.”
She laughed. “Obnoxious as you were, who knew you were right? I'll never refuse you again.”
Elisabeth settled in more quickly than she could have imagined as the only matriarch on the street without professional help. She decorated rooms, arranged furniture, and set about preparing the home to entertain. She reminded Will often that she could only feel comfortable in such opulence if she shared it as a gift from God. Her Sunday school classes, the choir, the missionary society, their friends, Will's coworkers, just about anybody and everybody was welcome to parties, dinners, or even to stay overnight. Visiting speakers at church and other dignitaries learned to call the place their home away from home. To the consternation of some of the snootier neighbors, the Bishop home became a catalyst to bring a new class of people into the neighborhood.
Elisabeth's days were full and rich, and for the first time since she had made her lifetime commitment to Christ, she felt God was smiling upon her. She knew she didn't deserve it, that she hadn't earned it. But she believed God would honor obedience and dedication. All right, perhaps the sacrifice part was in the past, but hadn't she hadâas Pastor Hill's wife once lamentedâtoo much at too young an age anyway? Maybe she had already had her allotment of turmoil for one lifetime. She occasionally felt the guilt of living in such comfort, but neither was she possessive or worshipful of it. The more she was able to give, the happier she was.
Elisabeth rose early enough every day to send Will off with a hearty breakfast. Every other day he walked all the way to the factory, so he was in the best shape of his life. She, on the other hand, busy as she was, was eating well too and found herself picking up the occasional pound. No one else, not even Will, noticed. But she did.
When Will was gone she spent an hour in the sunroom reading her Bible and praying. Then she sat at the piano, brushing up to accompany the singing at churchâand improving her memory of every verse of every song in the hymnbook. It was an unusual ability and one that never ceased to amaze Will. During congregational singing, she never looked at the hymnal and never missed a word. Soon she even played from memory. Hymn lyrics had become nearly as dear to her as her Bible, and she loved meditating on them.
Elisabeth was busy at church and in the community, and near the end of their first year in the new house, few would have believed that she was yet to turn twenty-one. Elisabeth was an established woman about town, married to a most successful and prosperous young husband only a few months older than she.
On her twenty-first birthday Will took her out for dinner and gave her a beautiful necklace. “I have something for you too,” she said.
“A present for me on
your
birthday?” he said.
She nodded. “Just a bit of news I hope you will like. Sometime around the end of July I should be able to refer to you as Daddy.”
She loved his dumbstruck look. “You mean it?” he said, a little too loudly.
Elisabeth put a finger to his lips. “That's not the kind of a thing I'd tease about.”
She suffered a difficult pregnancy and a nearly unbearable summer of heat. On July 25 she gave birth to a son they namedânot merely with Will's permission, but with his insistenceâBenjamin Phillip Bishop. He was a sickly, colicky baby who kept them up all hours, causing their first angry words and heated argument, yet they loved him with all that was in them.
Benjy, as Elisabeth called him, nearly wore her out, and by the time he was two she confessed to her physician that she wasn't sure she was ready for another child. Her beautiful home had been reorganized to accommodate an energetic, curious, extremely strong-willed and messy toddler. She spent most of her day keeping track of him and trying to discipline him.
Will proved a good and attentive father. Elisabeth, though, because of her lack of time to take care of herself, felt unattractive. Pregnant with their second child by late 1923, Elisabeth suddenly felt older than her years and worried about maintaining the idyllic marriage she and Will had begun. But he was wonderful about getting home at the same time every night and spelling her so she could have a break and get some rest.
May 15, 1924, Elisabeth Vera was born, and the Bishops called her Betty from the beginning. Just about the time Benjy had shaken all the physical ailments from his infancy and had become a stubborn and tireless three-and-a-half year old, Betty was diagnosed with chronic asthma that the doctor predicted would plague her all her life.
Elisabeth was distraught but determined to provide for all of her children's needs, whatever they might be. As exhausting as these first two were, Will still looked forward to a house full. In her more rational moments, after a good night's sleep or when the babies were napping, she realized that Will was right. He acknowledged that she had the tougher job, but this too would pass, and they envisioned a big happy family of children who would come to Christ and serve God. That, she and Will agreed, was their highest calling.
Late that fall Elisabeth asked Frances Childs to come and watch the kids while she went to the doctor yet again. While she held her suspicions until she knew for sure, she hoped Will would be more excited than she was about yet another pregnancy. She could not tell him of her growing despair. She knew she would get over it and love the child.
O
n the way home from the doctor's office, Elisabeth prayed for the grace to accept yet another child and the emotional freedom to share Will's likely excitement.
She could not deny God's obvious blessing in her choice of a marriage partner: Will seemed always to rise to the occasion, being patient and kind with her even when she was testy. It was difficult even to fault him over the division of duties. She handled the household and he worked full-time, and after several years of marriage and two children, he was still quick to help and even to anticipate when she needed it.
Elisabeth had in her mind a vision of the perfect mother, and she feared she had never matched it. In fact, she was more sympathetic every day to the temperament of Aunt Agatha. Elisabeth wondered if she had been as challenging a baby or toddler as her two were. If she had been, it was no wonder Aunt Agatha turned her out the first chance she got.
With that realization came a wave of gratitude. Why had she never thought of it before? As she walked up the front walkâeager to know how Frances had made out with the children and also conjuring a way to break the new baby news to Willâshe stopped briefly and surveyed her beautiful home in a new light. She had always been thankful for it, but she had seen it as something Will had done for her. Yes, he was the wonderful husband God had provided, but now for the first time she understood that this place, this house, was God's recompense for the loss of her childhood home.
The fiasco with Aunt Agatha had been Elisabeth's fault. She had spoken recklessly and then felt obligated to stand by her word. She had been walked on and allowed the wishes of her dear father to be overruled. And yet because in the end she had acted honorably and not in her own interest, God had blessed her. Elisabeth didn't know what a theologian would say about that logic, but she believed it nonetheless.
Frances seemed relieved that Elisabeth was home, though she was ahead of schedule. “The children sleeping?” Elisabeth said.
“They are now,” Frances said flatly. “But they've been down only ten minutes.”
Elisabeth was alarmed at her friend's tone. “Everything all right, Fran?”
Frances was busily collecting her things. “Frankly, no. I'm afraid I'm going to have to ask that you find someone else next time.”
“What is it? Trouble?”
“Just the usual. I'm scared to death I'm not going to get the steamer right for the little one, her breathing is so labored. And I cannot concentrate on her when Benjy is up and around. He doesn't listen, doesn't obey. He has such a mind of his own, and, Elisabeth, I know it's only a stage, but I cannot handle him. I don't know how you do it.”
“He's a handful for me too.”
“Sometimes I think it's a godsend that Art and I have so far been unable toâoh, Elisabeth, forgive me. I'm not implying it would have been better if you hadn't been ableâwell, bless you. In an emergency, call me. But otherwise ⦔
Elisabeth walked Frances to the door. “I understand.”
“And you won't hold it against me?”
“Of course not.”
“You had a phone call, by the way.”
“Oh?”
“Mrs. Phillips. It had to have been Ben's mother, don't you think?”
Elisabeth racked her brain. “That's the only Phillips I know.”
“She's quite eager to talk with you. She asked me to tell you to expect her.”
Elisabeth was at a loss. “In person?”
“I told her I couldn't say whether you were prepared to entertain a guest, but she was not dissuaded.”
“I wonder how she got my number.”
“She said she called the drugstore and they gave her your married name. I hope they weren't out of line.”
“Not at all.”
Elisabeth expected Will at six. Betty was up wheezing by four and Benjy shortly made his noisy appearance. How could she possibly see Mrs. Phillips, and what was so important? Elisabeth had never followed through on her promise at Ben's memorial service to keep in touch, but neither had the Phillipses.
With dinner on the stove, Betty in her arms, and Benjy testing the back door lock, Elisabeth saw a late-model motor car pull up out front. Mr. Phillips came around to open his wife's door but then returned and waited behind the wheel.
“My goodness, you've married well, haven't you?” Mrs. Phillips said as Elisabeth welcomed her in.
“Not so well as it might appear,” Elisabeth said, “but we're happy, and we do love our house.”
“I'm sorry to barge in, dear. In fact, when we learned you had married, my husband urged me to leave you alone. But you deserve to know. I would not have wanted you to find out and wonder why the news had not come from us.”
“News?”
Mrs. Phillips pulled from her purse a letter from the War Department. “Let me hold the baby while you read it. She's not contagious, is she?”
Elisabeth smoothed the sheet before her and read, “Dear Mr. and Mrs. Phillips: A critically ill unidentified man, long assumed a derelict, has languished for years in a British clinic. Thought to be in his thirties, he was pulled half-eaten and barely alive from the English Channel during the war. Because he was rescued so far from action, bore no clothing, and carried no identification, the prospect of his being a serviceman was ruled out. Due to severe amnesia, he has only recently been able to communicate, and British authorities now believe he may be American military. We're asking next of kin to some victims of the Great War to provide any clues that might help us determine if he is one of ours. If he is, you may rest assured that we will do all within our power to bring him home and get him the best care possible.”
Elisabeth could not speak. She traded the letter for the baby.
“We're on our way overseas,” Mrs. Phillips said.
“It's him?” Elisabeth said, her eyes stinging and her head light.
She nodded. “We informed them of the unusual formation of three small moles on his forearm that look like a tiny footprint. They told us that was one of his few unaffected areas above the waist. They will confirm with dental records, but we have no doubt.”
“IâIâI don't know what to say.” Elisabeth felt as if she were dreaming.
“That you're glad to hear he's alive would be a start,” Mrs. Phillips said, brusquely handing back the baby.
“Of course! I'm just, justâ”
“Shocked, I'm sure. And you're married. And a mother.”
Elisabeth wanted to defend herself, to ask Mrs. Phillips if she had expected her to wait for Ben's return. Was this possible? How could it be? Who could have known? What would she have done if she'd known earlier, knowing God was steering her toward Will anyway? How would Mrs. Phillips have endured
that
crisis?
Dumbfounded and knowing she sounded so, Elisabeth said, “Well, thank you for telling me.”
“Shall I keep you posted, or would you rather I had not informed you at all?”
“No, of course, Will and I will be eager to hear if he's all right.”
Mrs. Phillips smoothed her skirt and leaned to look out the window at the car. “We already know he's not all right.”
“I know, I mean, yes, tell us when he gets home and when he might receive people.”
“You want to see him then?”
“I, uhâcertainly. Yes, of course.”
To Elisabeth's horror, Will pulled in the drive, slowing nearly to a stop when passing the Phillipses' car. With his suit jacket draped over his arm he shook Mr. Phillips's hand as the man stepped out. She could only imagine the conversation.
“We'll let you know, then, if you're sure,” Mrs. Phillips said as she left. Elisabeth could think of no proper response.
Benjy called for his mother. Betty cried in frustration just trying to breathe. Something was boiling over in the kitchen. Will came in studying the lay of the land. He gave Benjy a cracker and soothed the baby as he followed Elisabeth to the stove.
“Elspeth, I'mâI'm speechless.”
“Will,” she said, “I can't even eat now.” And suddenly she was crying, worried what Will would think of her reaction, yet having no control over it.
“Go up and lie down,” he said. “I'll feed the kids and we can talk.”
Elisabeth lay rocking in her bed, hearing Will inexplicably patient with the kids while he did her work and his, got the kids to bed, and even did the dishes. He joined her in bed two hours later.
“I didn't know what to say to his mother,” Elisabeth said. “And I don't know what to say to you.”
“I'm as stunned as you are, Elspeth. I'm glad he's alive. I hope he recovers and becomes the man he was meant to be. I don't know any other way to respond. Did his mother expect that you would be waiting for him?”
Elisabeth shrugged.
“Does she want you to leave me and give him a reason to get better?”
“Don't, Will.”
“How old is he by now?”
“Five years older than we are.”
“Twenty-nine or so then. A lot of life ahead. He can still go to seminary, become a pastor, whatever he wants.”
Elisabeth turned her back to Will and curled up. “He might have been better off dead. Who knows what he looks like, how much of his body he can use? How much of his mind is left? Can he think? Study? Speak?”
Will turned out the light and draped his arm over her. “Did you introduce his mother to Ben's namesake?”
“It never crossed my mind. Did you mention Benjy to them?”
“I didn't think of it either. I was just tooâ”
Betty wailed. Elisabeth sighed and began to get up. “Let me,” Will said.
Elisabeth was too tired even to thank him. She covered her ears and breathed a prayer of thanks for her husband. As he moved past the door and headed downstairs with the baby, Elisabeth suddenly sat up. “Will?” she called out. “Something else I forgot. I'm due again.”
He returned and sat beside her on the bed, Betty whimpering in his arms. “When?”
“Late May,” she mumbled. “Maybe early June.”
“I won't ask if you're as excited as I am.”
“Thank you,” she said, drifting off.
Over the next several months, Will and Elisabeth received letters and newspaper clippings about the return to Grand Rapids of Ben Phillips. “His motor skills and speech have improved remarkably,” his mother wrote. “He has asked about you but does not want you to see him until he is out of the hospital. I have not told him of your situation for fear of a setback. He is expected to be able to come home in the fall.”
Elisabeth wrote back with her best wishes and the news that it would be unlikely she could get away until sometime early in 1926, given that she would soon be the mother of three. Soon the letters from Grand Rapids stopped. “Whenever you want,” Will told her, “you should plan to go see him.”
“I'll have to tell him.”
“The truth never hurt anyone.”
“I couldn't tell him the whole truth.”
“That you would not likely have married him anyway? He doesn't need to know that. But he can't blame you for getting on with your life.”
Bruce James Bishop was born Monday, June 1, 1925, named after Robert Bruceâa favorite historical character of Elisabeth'sâand, of course, after her father. Exhausted and guilty about not sharing Will's enthusiasm over another baby, still she was taken with Bruce from his first squall. A healthy, beautiful boy, he had olive skin, large dark eyes, and a full head of hair. The first time she cradled him to her breast he seemed to look deep into her eyes. She experienced a feeling similar to that strange day when she felt she had been granted a glimpse of her future with Will.
It was as if she could see Bruce as a compliant, obedient, bright child. She discounted it as wishful thinking, but the image would not leave her. Every time she held the newborn, she ascribed to him wonderful character traits like patience, honesty, and kindness. She had a feeling he would be curious and fun-loving. She prayed he would be a man after God's own heart.
Elisabeth was deeply grateful he was physically perfect. She felt sorry for Betty and the malady that would dog her her whole life. She also enjoyed that the new baby seemed more of a cuddler than the other two, never pulling away but rather seeming calmed by nuzzling Elisabeth, the closer the better.
Her premonitions proved accurate. Bruce made parenting a pleasure. As the older two became more difficult, Elisabeth looked forward to interacting with her youngest. He loved to be held; he cooed and tried to talk to her from the first, smiled earlier, crawled earlier, even seemed to understand the word no.
Will told Elisabeth he noticed that she had more energy and was quickly back to her old self. “We should think about another child,” he said.
“I don't know,” she said. “We shouldn't press our luck.”
In the fall of 1926 a letter arrived from Ben Phillips addressed to Mrs. Will Bishop. So he knew.
“Dear Elisabeth,” it read, “I trust you and Will are doing well and prospering in the Lord. I hear wonderful things about you and him and your family.
“Put to rest any fear you may have about my reaction to your marriage. Clearly God was in this, and while I don't understand my loss of so many years, I continue to rest in him. I will finally be going to seminary this fall with only a slight limp and scars visible only in the neck area. I may never know how I survived, but I am grateful for a second chance and feel much like Lazarus must have felt. My goal is still to preach, and I feel gratitude beyond measure that God has restored my memory and my mental faculties (such as they are!).
“My warmest greetings to Will. (You're a lucky man, friend.) I would love to see you both when it's convenient and you feel it appropriate. It might be awkward for us all, but my wish is that we might be friends and fellowship together as brothers and sister in Christ.”