The Transformation of the World (211 page)

Read The Transformation of the World Online

Authors: Jrgen Osterhammel Patrick Camiller

BOOK: The Transformation of the World
7.1Mb size Format: txt, pdf, ePub

  24
. Yapp,
Strategies
, pp. 419–60; M. C. Meyer and Sherman,
Mexican History
, pp. 385–401. On colonial wars, see
chapter 9
, below.

  25
. Labanca,
Oltremare
, pp. 108–22.

  26
. Wesseling,
Divide and Rule
is the standard narrative account. For more recent approaches, see Pétré–Grenouilleau,
From Slave Trade to Empire
.

  27
. Even the best of them all: Gildea,
Barricades
, pp. 326ff., and Sperber,
Europe 1850-1914
.

  28
. This is especially marked in J.-C. Caron and Vernus,
L'Europe au XIX
e
siècle
.

  29
. Koebner and Schmidt,
Imperialism
, p. 50.

  30
. An important theme in Winkler,
Long Road West
, broached already in vol. 1, p. 5.

  31
. Otto Dann,
Zur Theorie
, p. 69. Such a definition was still lacking from the “basic concepts” in Dann,
Nation
, pp. 11–21.

  32
. Voigt,
Geschichte Australiens
, p. 114; M. King,
Penguin History of New Zealand
, pp. 266f.

  33
. The literature on nationalism is no longer manageable. For Europe, the main focus of research, recent works include: v. Hirschhausen and Leonhard,
Nationalismen
, esp. the editors' introduction (pp. 11–45); Leerssen,
National Thought
; Baycroft and Hewitson,
What is a Nation?
.

  34
. H. Schulze,
States, Nations, and Nationalism
.

  35
. W. Reinhard,
Staatsgewalt
, p. 443.

  36
. On the “modernity” of nation building and the epochal change around 1800, see the argument summarizing the discontinuity thesis in Langewiesche,
Nation
, pp. 14–34.

  37
. For an attempt to grasp this ideal-typically as an opposition between perennialism (the Romantic idea of the nation as a primal entity) and modernism (the nation as a construct), see Smith,
Nationalism and Modernism
, pp. 22f.

  38
. See Guibernau,
Nationalisms
, p. 48. Although I have many points in common with Connor (
Ethnonationalism
, 1994), I differ from him in this stress on internal “nation building” and, more generally, on objective, nonascriptive factors.

  39
. W. Reinhard,
Staatsgewalt
, p. 443.

  40
. See the original map in Buzan and Little,
International Systems
, p. 261.

  41
. Schölch,
Egypt for the Egyptians!
; J. R. Cole,
Colonialism
; Marr,
Vietnamese Anticolonialism
, pp. 166f.

  42
. E. Weber,
Peasants into Frenchmen
.

  43
. Schieder proposes a similar but slightly different typology in
Nationalism
, pp. 110f. These should not be confused with typologies of nation
building
: see Hroch,
Europa der Nationen
, pp. 41–45.

  44
. Breuilly,
Nationalism
, chs. 4–7.

  45
. The concept of the cycle of revolution was first introduced by the Leipzig historian Manfred Kossok. See
chapter 10
, below.

  46
. For an initial orientation, see Wood,
American Revolution
, pp. 17–30; Rodríguez,
Independence of Spanish America
, pp. 19–35; and, in a broader comparative framework, Elliott,
Empires
.

  47
. Dubois,
Avengers
. See also
chapter 10
, below.

  48
. The classic account is J. Lynch,
Spanish American Revolutions
, a masterpiece of narrative history.

  49
. Seton-Watson,
Nations and States
, p. 114.

  50
. Bitsch,
Histoire de la Belgique
, pp. 79–86; Rich,
Great Power Diplomacy
, pp. 59–61.

  51
. Jelavich,
Balkans
, vol. 1, pp. 196f.

  52
. Sundhaussen,
Geschichte Serbiens
, p. 130.

  53
. Jelavich and Jelavich,
Establishment
, p. 195.

  54
. Bernecker,
Geschichte Haitis
, p. 106.

  55
. Clogg,
Greece
, p. 73. See also
chapter 17
, below.

  56
. Bitsch,
Histoire de la Belgique
, pp. 119ff.

  57
. On the concept of the “polycephalic federation,” see Rokkan,
State Formation
, pp. 111, 220.

  58
. Blom and Lamberts,
Low Countries
, p. 404; J. Fisch,
Europa
, p. 171.

  59
. Another approach that does not use the concept of hegemony is Ronald Speirs and John Breuilly, “The Concept of National Unification,” in idem,
Germany's Two Unifications
, pp. 1–25.

  60
. On the two different styles of constitutional-authoritarian rule see Rusconi,
Cavour e Bismarck
, esp. 169ff.

  61
. Summary discussions for Italy: Beales and Biagini,
Risorgimento
; Banti,
Il Risorgimento italiano
; a synopsis of recent research is Banti and Ginsborg,
Il Risorgimento
. Of the numerous studies of Germany, a particularly good one is Lenger,
Industrielle Revolution
, pp. 315–81.

  62
. Lenger,
Industrielle Revolution
, p. 348.

  63
. Blackbourn,
History of Germany
,, p. 184.

  64
. Nipperdey,
Deutsche Geschichte 1866–1918
, vol. 2, p. 85.

  65
. Francesco Leoni, “Il brigantaccio postunitario,” in Viglione,
La Rivoluzione Italiana
, pp. 365–85.

  66
. N. G. Owen et al.,
Emergence
, p. 115.

  67
. Kirby,
Baltic World
, pp. 185–89.

  68
. Bumsted,
History
, pp. 132–42.

  69
. Extracts are published in Keith,
Selected Speeches
, vol. 1, pp. 113–72.

  70
. Mansergh,
Commonwealth Experience
, vol. 1, pp. 34–46.

  71
. See
chapters 7
and
17
.

  72
. See the exemplary analysis in Voigt,
Geschichte Australiens
, esp. pp. 170–84.

  73
. The dramatic story of the resistance is recounted in Ravina,
Last Samurai
, esp. chs. 5–6.

  74
. M. B. Jansen,
Modern Japan
, pp. 343–47.

  75
. I have found most convincing the analysis in Potter,
Impending Crisis
.

  76
. H. Jones,
Union in Peril
; cf. the speculations on the consequences a possible Confederate victory in R. W. Fogel,
Without Consent or Contract
, pp. 411–17.

  77
. See Dülffer et al.,
Vermiedene Kriege
, pp. 513–25.

  78
. Carr,
Spain
, pp. 347ff.; Balfour,
End of the Spanish Empire
, pp. 44–46; A. Roberts,
Salisbury
, p. 692.

  79
. Engerman and Neves,
Bricks
, p. 479.

  80
. Clarence-Smith,
Third Portuguese Empire
.

  81
. There are few general books covering the history of empires in the nineteenth century in their entirety. For overseas empires see Wesseling,
European Colonial Empires
; and for the later part of our period: Butlin,
Geographies of Empire
; also two excellent French textbooks: Surun,
Les sociétés coloniales
; Barjot and Frémeaux,
Les sociétés coloniales
. A pioneering attempt to consider continental and overseas empires within one framework is v. Hirschhausen and Leonhard,
Comparing Empires
.

  82
. R. Oliver and Atmore,
Africa since 1800
, p. 118.

  83
. C. Marx,
Geschichte Afrikas
, p. 70.

  84
. Ricklefs,
Modern Indonesia
, pp. 144–60.

  85
. C. J. Baker and Phongpaichit,
Thailand
, p. 105.

  86
. See the more detailed argument in Osterhammel,
Geschichtswissenschaft
, pp. 322–41.

  87
. The following draws on suggestions in classics of nationalism theory, such as the work of Benedict Anderson and Ernest Gellner, and Calhoun,
Nationalism
, pp. 4f. It also expands upon the argument in Osterhammel,
Expansion
.

  88
. On borders see Münkler,
Empires
, pp. 5ff.; also Osterhammel,
Geschichtswissenschaft
pp. 210–13, and
chapter 3
, above.

  89
. Charles Tilly, “How Empires End,” in Barkey and von Hagen,
After Empire
, p. 7.

  90
. M. W. Doyle,
Empires
, p. 36.

  91
. Langewiesche,
Nation
, p. 23.

  92
. Thom,
Republics
.

  93
. Langewiesche,
Nation
, p. 23.

  94
. Integration is an aspect not often discussed in the literature on empire. But see the empirically rich study Magee and Thompson:
Empire and Globalisation
.

  95
. Dunn,
Africa
, pp. 29, 33.

  96
. A new survey, which places great emphasis on the role of private firms, is Winseck and Pike,
Communication and Empire
.

  97
. This has often been noted before—most recently in Motyl,
Revolutions
, pp. 120–22. However, the same may be found in nation-states such as Spain and even France.

  98
. This structural definition builds on and modifies suggestions in Motyl,
Imperial Ends
, pp. 4, 15–27, and M. W. Doyle,
Empires
, pp. 19, 36, 45, 81. Cf. the excellent little book: S. Howe,
Empire
, esp. pp. 13–22.

  99
. In 1900 railroad mileage was of the same order of magnitude in these three countries. See Woodruff,
Impact of Western Man
, p. 253, Tab. VI/1.

100
. See Offer,
First World War
.

101
. See Osterhammel,
Colonialism
, pp. 10–18; cf. von Trotha,
Kolonialismus
.

102
. Kirby,
Baltic World
, pp. 52, 79f; Brower,
Turkestan
, pp. 26ff.

103
. See Cain,
Hobson
.

104
. Still invaluable is Mommsen,
Theories of Imperialism
. On the “classical” theories up to 1919, see Semmel,
Liberal Ideal
; and for a good survey of recent historical interpretations, Porter,
European Imperialism
, chs. 1–5.

105
. Schumpeter's classic essay on imperialisms (in the plural) is translated in his
Economics and Sociology
, pp. 141–219, esp. 190–213. The central concept here is “export monopolism.”

106
. See W. Reinhard,
Expansion
; idem,
Colonialism
; Adas,
Islamic and European Expansion
.

107
. Bayly,
First Age
. See also
chapter 2
, above.

108
. Wesseling,
Divide and Rule
, pp. 119ff.

109
. J. R.Ward,
Industrial Revolution
, p. 62.

110
. Many detailed examples are given in Brötel,
Frankreich im Fernen Osten
.

111
. Abernethy,
Global Dominance
, p. 101.

112
. J. Black,
War and the World
, p. 152.

113
. Headrick,
Tools
, pp. 20f., 43–54.

114
. Ibid., p. 117.

115
. On the following, a good synthesis is Okey,
Habsburg Monarchy
.

116
. For a brief sketch of the Habsburg position in Europe, see P. M. Kennedy,
Rise and Fall
, pp. 215–19.

117
. Bérenger,
History of the Habsburg Empire
, p. 134.

118
. On the disastrous sequel, see Bridge,
Habsburg Monarchy
, pp. 288ff.

119
. There is a tendency in the recent literature to distinguish between a pre-1867 “empire” and a looser post-1867 “monarchy.” See, e.g., Ingrao,
Habsburg Monarchy
; and Okey,
Habsburg Monarchy
.

120
. Cf. the evaluation in Hoensch,
Modern Hungary
, pp. 20ff.

121
. See the sophisticated discussion of nationalism in Okey,
Habsburg Monarchy
, pp. 283–309.

122
. Bérenger,
History of the Habsburg Empire
, p. 214.

123
. İnalcık and Quataert,
Ottoman Empire
, vol. 2, p. 782; Kappeler,
Russian Empire
, pp. 285f.

124
. Cf. D. Lieven,
Empire
, pp. 184f.

125
. Bawden,
Mongolia
, pp. 187ff.

126
. For a brief sketch of the Napoleonic Empire, see Boudon,
Histoire du consulat et de l'Empire
, pp. 283–303, see also Dwyer and Forrest,
Napoleon and His Empire
.

127
. There is a brilliant portrait of this new ruling class in Woloch,
Napoleon and His Collaborators
, esp. pp. 156f.

128
. Broers,
Europe
, esp. pp. 125–38, 202–30.

129
. See the map in ibid., p. 181.

130
. Quoted from Jourdan,
L'Empire de Napoléon
, p. 120.

Other books

All the Pretty Faces by Rita Herron
The Dark Giants by Cerberus Jones
Where the Shadow Falls by Gillian Galbraith
Forever in Blue by Ann Brashares
Lacrimosa by Christine Fonseca
The Lopsided Christmas Cake by Wanda E. Brunstetter
Can't Get Enough by Connie Briscoe