The Perfect Game (31 page)

I sat in my car, turned the ignition, and powered on my wireless headset. As I drove away, I dialed Dean’s number. 

“Hey, bro, it’s early.” Dean’s voice was raspy. Apparently I’d woken him up again.

“Shit. I always forget the time difference. Sorry.” 

“No big deal. What’s up?” He yawned into the receiver.

“Chrystle lost the baby yesterday,” I said as my emotions whooshed out from me.

“Oh God, really? I’m so sorry.” I heard him shifting around in his bed. “Are you okay?”

“I will be.”

“So what now?” he asked, the same way he always did when we were kids.

“What do you mean?”

“I mean, you’ll get a divorce, right? You’re not going to stay with her now that there’s no baby?” He practically shouted in the phone, causing me to pull mine away from my ear a little.

“I can’t leave her right now, Dean. She’s devastated. She can’t stop crying.”

“So what? She’s a bitch. I’ll fly out today and help you pack.” His voice was serious.

“Even I’m not
that
heartless,” I commented with a snicker.

“Does Cassie know?” I heard his question and my mind drifted as the trees in the neighborhood rushed past my window.

“No.”

“Are you going to tell her?”

“Not right now,” I admitted.

“Why not? What is going on with you? Leave Chrystle and come make things right with Cassie!” 

“Not yet.”

“What are you waiting for?” He sucked in a gulp of air. “You’re not in love with Chrystle, are you?”

My hands gripped the steering wheel, my knuckles turning white with the force. “Are you fucking crazy? I don’t even know how to love anyone other than Cassie.”

“Just making sure.”

“I’m gonna go. I just wanted to tell you. Can you tell Gran and Gramps, please, and tell Gran I’ll call her soon. Don’t tell Cassie. She shouldn’t hear it from you,” I demanded. 

“Fine. But you better tell her soon.”

I arrived at the clubhouse gym to find three of my teammates already working out. Coach sat in his office, the phone in one hand and a cup of coffee in the other. I smiled when he placed down his coffee and reached for a donut, shoving part of it in his mouth while he tilted the phone back behind his shoulder. His eyes darted out the window and met mine before his head nodded in time with his moving mouth. He put the phone down, stood up, and wagged his finger. “Carter.”

Anxiety shot through me as I walked into Coach’s office, my stomach dropping.

“I just got off the phone with the head of the organization. You got the call, kid. They’re moving you up for the playoffs. Pack your stuff, grab that wife of yours, and get ready to leave tonight. You start playing with the team tomorrow.”

My feet wouldn’t move and my ass felt like it was super-glued to the chair I was sitting in. “What?” I asked like an idiot and he laughed.

“Get outta here, Carter. Your flight leaves at ten tonight. We’ll messenger the tickets to your house. Congratulations, kid, you’re a hell of a pitcher.”

“Thank you, Coach. Thank you so much.” I stood, my hand shaking as I reached for his. 

I throttled the gas, a million thoughts racing through my head, the most prominent one being how badly I wanted to share this moment with Cass. After everything we’d been through, she was still the first person who came to mind when I had news to share. It made me fucking sick to think I wouldn’t be moving her to
Arizona
with me. When I dreamed of the future, this had always been part of it. Getting to The Show was the foremost thing on my mind. But Cass at my side went hand in hand with that vision. 

When I got home, I searched through the house. “Chrys? Chrystle?” I shouted.

“In here.” Her voice drifted in from the kitchen.

I walked into the kitchen and caught her eye. “Start packing. We leave for
Arizona
tonight.” I smiled.

“What? Really?” Her voice radiated with excitement as she threw her tiny arms around me.

Since she was no longer carrying my child, I didn’t move to hug her back. 

I
’
m an asshole.

“A messenger will drop off the tickets and a car will pick us up at eight thirty.”

“What do we do with all our stuff? Just leave it?”

“We’ll come back here when the season ends and pack everything up. But for now, just bring the necessities. I’m not sure how long we’ll be there.”

“This is so exciting! I’m married to a big leaguer.” Her voice rang out in song as she reached for her cell. “I’m going to call my mama.”

“Alright. I’m gonna hop in the shower,” I said as she hummed to herself.

I ran upstairs and turned the shower on, closing the bathroom door behind me as I  wished for a moment of solitude. Wished for a moment that Cass was here. Wished I hadn’t fucked things up. Realizing I’d left my cell phone in my gym bag downstairs, I opened the door to ask Chrystle to get it for me. “Chrys?” I scanned the bedroom, but she wasn’t there.

I wrapped a towel around my waist and headed downstairs when I overheard Chrystle say, “Oh please, Tressa, I’ve got him wrapped around my finger. I’ll have him so guilt-ridden by the time the night is through, he’ll never leave.”

I paused on the stairs, listening with intent as she continued. “I know, right? No, he’s in the shower. Tressa! He doesn’t suspect a thing. And plus, I’ll make him sleep with me until I actually do get pregnant…for real this time.” 

My jaw worked as I saw red and my ears started to burn. “He has no idea I made the whole thing up. How could he? What does a guy know about being pregnant? Nothing.” 

She laughed and my temper flared. I stormed down the rest of the stairs and into the kitchen, my eyes burning a hole right through her. “Hang up the phone,” I demanded as her face twisted with surprise. “Hang up the goddammed phone. NOW!” I lunged for the device in her hand, but she pulled it away.

“Tressa, I have to go. I’ll call you later. ’Bye.”

“Tell me you didn’t, Chrystle. Tell me you didn’t fucking lie to me about being pregnant.” I vibrated with emotion, my hands balling in and out of fists, and she moved away from me. 

She didn’t answer. Instead, she stared at me with her stupid face, and I wished for a brief second that it was socially acceptable to punch a chick. “Who else knows?” She didn’t move. “WHO…ELSE…KNOWS?” I shouted through my rage. 

“J…j…ust Tressa and Vanessa,” she stuttered.

“You’re lying!” 

“I’m not lying, Jack. I swear. They’re the only ones I told.” Her voice shook with her admission.

I glared at her, my adrenaline pumping like wildfire through my already heated veins. “Why would you do that to me? You ruined my fucking life! You made me lose the only person I’ve ever loved for a
lie
?!!
Why, Chrystle? TELL ME WHY?” I screamed from the other side of the granite island in the kitchen, pounding my fist against the top.

“Because!” she shouted back.

“Because why?”

“Because I just wanted a major league baseball player for a husband! Okay? I wanted to marry a professional athlete. I wanted a rich and famous husband,” she screamed.

“And it didn’t matter that you ruined my life, as long as you got what you wanted?” 

“Oh, save it. I didn’t ruin your life, Jack. It’s not like I killed your career or anything.” She rolled her eyes with a huff, any guilt she felt dissipating.

“Get your stuff and get the fuck out. I don’t care where you go, but you can’t stay here.” I pointed toward the front door.

“But you leave for
Arizona
tonight. At least let me stay while you’re gone.” Her whiny voice sent irritation through me like the sound of nails on a chalkboard.

“No. If you step foot in this house while I’m away, I’ll have you arrested for breaking and entering, right after I file the restraining order against you and annul this sham of a marriage for false pretenses and lying.” 

“Whatever, Jack. Good luck getting Cassie back after all this. No one will ever
really
love you. Your own mom didn’t even stick around.” She hurled the insult and I took it like a ninety-mile-an-hour fastball to the gut.

“I changed my mind. Get out of my house now. I’ll set your things on fire and mail you the ashes.” I grabbed her by the arm, forcefully removing her from the premises before engaging the dead bolt on the door behind her.

“Jaaaaaaaaaaaaaack!!!!” she screamed as she pounded her fists against the door. For a bitty thing, she could sure make a lot of noise.

“You’re dead to me
,”
I shouted through the door before turning around and heading upstairs to pack.

TWENTY

CASSIE

We need to talk
.

I stared at the text message from Jack for nearly twenty minutes before putting the phone down on my dresser and walking out of my room. 

“Melis?” I asked, poking my head through her doorway. 

She was sprawled out across her bed reading. “Yeeessssss?” she responded, dropping her electronic reader to her side.

“Jack just sent me a text.”

She adjusted her body to an upright position before crossing her legs Indian style. “Say what? What’d he say? Did you text him back?”

“It just said we need to talk. What do we need to talk about? And why now? Do you think he knows I’m leaving?” My eyes darted around the room, pausing at the various photos of us on the walls.

“It’s possible. I’m sure Dean told him. But why would he need to talk to you about that?” she asked, patting the spot next to her for me to sit down.

“I have no idea.
”

“Are you gonna text him back?” 

“
Should I
?
”

“Hell yeah, you should. You should be like, ‘What do we need to talk about? I’m all talked out from spilling the entire contents of my heart to you the night before your wedding. I think we’re done talking,’” she finished with a sassy head gyration and my jaw dropped.

“I’m not saying that!” I leaned back into her mountain of fluffy pillows.

“I know. I’m just kidding. Just be super casual and ask him what’s up. Give me your phone, I’ll do it for you.” She reached for me and I fell backward onto the other side of the bed, typing quickly.

What
’
s up?

“There. Sent.” I pretended like my insides weren’t doing somersaults.

“Now we’ll just wait for his—” Melissa’s voice was drowned out by the sound of Jack’s ringtone. I’d forgotten to change it. I shot her a horrified look before she whispered, “Answer it! Just answer it.” 

“Why are you whispering?” 

“I don’t know! Answer it!” she screamed.

“Hello?” I answered, scooting my body from her mattress.

“Hey, Kitten.” His familiar voice sent chills racing up and down my spine.

“Hi.” I didn’t protest at the nickname. I was too busy being caught up in the sound of his voice. I never realized how much I’d missed it until it was beaming into my eardrums, the comfortable familiarity forcing nervous energy to ping throughout my insides. 

“I have to tell you some stuff,” he started to say and my legs immediately gave out, the words a reminder of the heartache I’d experienced not that long ago.

“What do you possibly have to tell me now, Jack?” I snapped at him, hoping to mask the pain I still carried, as Melissa gave me a thumbs-up of support. 

“Chrystle lost the baby.” His voice relayed the unfathomable information and I fell to the floor, my back sliding against the wall in Melissa’s room. 

“What?” My breath hitched and a lone tear rolled down my cheek.

“I mean, she didn’t lose the baby. Well, that’s what she told me, but she was really never pregnant. She lied.” He paused to take a breath, then let out a sigh. “About everything.”

“Oh my God, Jack, I’m so sorry. That’s…insane. How’d you find out?” 

“I overheard her on the phone
telling her best friend how stupid and gullible I was. And that she’d try to get pregnant for real.” His voice lowered.

“That little bitch.” The words escaped my lips as my mind drifted back to the night in the parking lot.

“Cass, I left her. I’m annulling the marriage and I got called up tonight. I leave for
Arizona
in an hour.” His tone changed and I recognized the joy in his voice.

“Jack.” I smiled, my eyes meeting Melissa’s. “That’s incredible! Congratulations.”

“Thank you. But, Cassie?” He paused. “I’m really sorry. I should have listened to you. I
never should have married her.”

“You didn’t know she was lying, Jack. And you were just trying to do the right thing…no matter how misguided. Your heart was in the right place. I was just devastated that it wasn’t with me.”