What conclusions can we draw? To invite the gods ruins our relationship with them but sets history in motion. A life in which the gods are not invited isn’t worth living. It will be quieter, but there won’t be any stories. And you could suppose that these dangerous invitations were in fact contrived by the gods themselves, because the gods get bored with men who have no stories.
The gods didn’t realize, nor did men, that that wedding feast in Thebes was the closest they would ever get to each other.
The next morning, the Olympians had left the palace. Cadmus and Harmony woke up in the bed Aphrodite had made for them. Now they were just a king and queen.
They had four daughters: Autonoë, Ino, Agave, and Semele. Cadmus’s hair had turned white and woolly on his bony head when one day, years later, he stopped in front of his daughter Semele’s tomb immediately outside the palace. It was an area of rubble with thin plumes of smoke rising from the place where Semele’s bed had been when Zeus came to make love to her. Vine shoots twisted around the crumbling stones. In that scene of devastation and luxuriance, Cadmus saw the image of his life. The plume of smoke was the sign Zeus’s thunderbolt had left, the thunderbolt Zeus had recovered from Typhon’s cave thanks exclusively to Cadmus. But Cadmus couldn’t tell anyone about that. That story of long ago was sealed up inside him. It would hardly have seemed proper that Zeus had once been saved from defeat by the merest Phoenician traveler. And it would have been even less proper to have spoken of the sinews stolen from Zeus’s body. No one would ever know anything about it. Cadmus went on looking at Semele’s tomb. The broken columns were covered by a thin layer of ash. Who could guess what part of Semele’s tender body had been transformed into that gray dust—Semele, the youngest, the most beautiful of his daughters, envied from birth by the others, although they too were very beautiful. Just as Europa had disappeared across the water, so Semele had vanished in the flames. Zeus, always Zeus, the encircling one. But that was another story that couldn’t be told. Cadmus’s other daughters, who hated their sister passionately, said she had coupled shamelessly with a stranger and then begun to tell lies about Zeus having come to her bed. Semele’s sisters were happy she had been reduced to a handful of ashes. And Cadmus couldn’t even mourn her, or adore her as mother of a new and ancient god, the god who announced his presence in the vine shoots twisting among the broken stones and who was, in the end, his grandson: Dionysus.
Cadmus went on staring at Semele’s tomb. The tempest
of calamities wasn’t over yet. When he had married the young Harmony, the opposite extremes of the world had come together in visible accord for one last time. Immediately afterward they had separated, torn apart. Semele was reduced to ashes; all her sisters, at some point of their lives, were either cut to pieces or cut someone else to pieces. Nobody ever inflicted or endured laceration as much as Harmony’s daughters. Actaeon, Autonoë’s son, was torn to pieces by Artemis’s dogs. Learchus, lno’s son, was run through by the spit of her father, Athamas. And time held still other lacerations in store. Cadmus was no longer king of Thebes. He had given up his throne to his grandson Pentheus, Agave’s child. And this grandson of his, who looked on him as a more or less good-for-nothing old man, had chosen to quarrel with Dionysus, the new god, of whom he knew nothing and understood less. Cadmus was obliged to play the part of the rather undignified old man who lifts his thin legs in a dance with the thyrsus. Pentheus watched him with scorn. Pentheus thought he was the city. He refused to remember how Thebes had been nothing more than a hillside of wild grass before Cadmus sunk his plow into the earth. One old man leaning on another, Cadmus and Tiresias set off for the mountains where the delirious Maenads lived. Lost among them, unrecognizable amid those sleeping or ecstatic bodies, were the three princesses: Autonoë, Ino, Agave. Step by wary step, Cadmus and Tiresias climbed on into the woods. They knew that one does not quarrel with a god.
Cadmus was back in Thebes in time to pick up the shreds of Pentheus’s body, torn to pieces on the mountains by his mother’s own hands. He called his old wife, Harmony, and told her to get ready to leave, one last time. He had been a wanderer when she met him, and as wanderers they would end their days. Shortly afterward, Dionysus appeared in Thebes. He took possession of the city and expelled Agave, Cadmus, and Harmony. After Pentheus’s atrocious death,
they were all contaminated. Helped by his servants, Cadmus loaded a few sacks on a big cart. Harmony already had the reins in her hands. Dionysus pointed the way. They must head for the western boundaries of the earth, the mists of Illyria.
On their wedding day, young and radiant, Cadmus and Harmony had arrived standing on a chariot drawn by a lion and a boar. Now, thrown out of their own home, these two old exiles climbed on a cart pulled by a pair of simple oxen and loaded with memories. When the cart rolled off, Cadmus and Harmony sat down side by side, and the Thebans saw the couple’s backs knot together in the scales of a single snake. Cadmus and Harmony rode away, twined snakes below, heads held high. Thus we may still see them today on the stone that marks their tomb, “by the edge of the black gorges of the Illyrian river.”
As he drove his cart westward, knotted to his spouse, like some stubborn emigrant still seeking a new city long after it is too late, Cadmus thought about the past. What was left of it? A few bundles of things on a cart, and behind them a city Dionysus had shaken with an earthquake. Cadmus had saved Zeus, but this hadn’t saved him from life’s precariousness. He had set out to find his sister Europa and had won the young Harmony. A traveler had told him that Europa had become queen of Crete. Harmony was at his side, an old snake. He felt as he had when he climbed off his ship in Samothrace: a man without gifts, because everything he had was on the cart. But Cadmus’s gift was impalpable.
Another king from Egypt, Danaus with his fifty bloodthirsty daughters, had brought Greece the gift of water. Cadmus had brought Greece “gifts of the mind”: vowels and consonants yoked together in tiny signs, “etched model of a silence that speaks”—the alphabet. With the alphabet, the Greeks would teach themselves to experience the gods in the silence of the mind, and no longer in the full and normal presence, as Cadmus himself had the day of his marriage.
He thought of his routed kingdom: of daughters and grandchildren torn to pieces, tearing others to pieces, ulcerated in boiling water, run through with spits, drowned in the sea. And Thebes was a heap of rubble. But no one could erase those small letters, those fly’s feet that Cadmus the Phoenician had scattered across Greece, where the winds had brought him in his quest for Europa carried off by a bull that rose from the sea.
This page | | Homeric Hymn to Demeter , 5 |
This page | | Ibid., 10–11. |
This page | | Lycophron, Alexandra , 1293. |
This page | | Ibid., 1297. |
This page | | Herodotus, Historiae , I, 4, 2. |
This page | | Ibid., I, 4, 3. |
This page | | G. Moreau, Pasiphaé , in L’assembleur de rêves , Fontfroide: Fata Morgana, 1984, p. 69. |
This page | | Diodorus Siculus, Bibliotheca historica , V, 77, 3. |
This page | | Plutarch, Life of Theseus , 19, 6. |
This page | | Virgil, Aeneid , VI, 397. |
This page | | Ovid, Fasti , III, 498. |
This page | | Chaeremon, The Centaur , 71 F 11, in Tragicorum Graecorum Fragmenta ( TrGF ),. vol. 1, ed. B. Snell. |
This page | | Plutarch, Life of Theseus , 20, 8–9. |
This page | | Euripides, Hippolytus , 339. |
This page | | Iliad , XIV, 296. |
This page | | Callimachus, Aetia , II, fr. 48 (Pfeiffer). |
This page | | Iliad , XIV, 349. |
This page | | Nonnus, Dionysiaca , XLVIII, 372. |
This page | | Ibid., XV, 409. |
This page | | Ibid., X, 339. |
This page | | F. Solmsen, Eratosthenes ’ Erigone: A Reconstruction , in “Transactions of the American Philological Association,” 78, 1947, p. 262. |
This page | | Hyginus, Astronomica , II, 4, 2. |
This page | | Ovid, Metamorphoses , VI, 125. |
This page | | Eratosthenes, Erigone , fr. 22, in I. U. Powell, Collectanea Alexandrina . |
This page | | R. Merkelbach, Die Erigone des Eratosthenes , in “Miscellanea di studi Alessandrini in memoria di A. Rostagni,” Turin, 1963, p. 472. |
This page | | Rig Veda , VII, 87, 5. |
This page | | Nonnus, Dionysiaca , XLVII, 135. |
This page | | Ibid., XLVII, 190, 249. |
This page | | Diodorus Siculus, Bibliotheca historica , II, 65, 2. |
This page | | Plutarch, Isis and Osiris , 364 d. |
This page | | Nonnus, Dionysiaca , XVI, 229, 252. |
This page | | Ibid., XVII, 184; XXXVI, 469. |
This page | | Clement of Alexandria, Hortatory Address to the Greeks , II, 39, 3. |
This page | | Ibid. |
This page | | Nicola Damasceno, H 90 F 38, in F. Jacoby, Die Fragmente der griechischen Historiker ( FGrH ), II, A, p. 345. |
This page | | Hyginus, Fabulae , CCII, 1. |
This page | | Catalogue of Women , fr. 60 (Merkelbach-West). |
This page | | Hesiod, fr. 298 (Merkelbach-West). |
This page | | Isyllus, Stones of Epidaurus , in I. U. Powell, Collectanea Alexandrina , p. 134, v. 47. |
This page | | Odyssey , XI, 581. |
This page | | Pausanias, Description of Greece , X, 4, 3. |
This page | | Ibid., X, 4, 1. |
This page | | Munich, Museum antiker Kleinkunst, 2309 (in Corpus Vasorum Antiquorum , Munich, col. IV, bearbeitet von R. Lullies, plate 161). |
This page | | Pindar, Pythian Odes , III, 15. |
This page | | Ibid., III, 20. |
This page | | Ibid., III, 21–23. |
This page | | Apollonius Rhodius, Argonautica , IV, 612–614. |
This page | | Plutarch, Life of Theseus , 6, 9. |
This page | | Ibid., 6, 8. |
This page | | Ibid., 6, 4. |
This page | | Isocrates, Eulogy to Helen , 23. |
This page | | Pausanias, Description of Greece , I, 39, 3. |
This page | | J. J. Bachofen, Das Mutterrecht , in Gesammelte Werke , Basel: Schwabe, vol. II, 1, 1948, p. 271. |
This page | | Diodorus Siculus, Bibliotheca historica , IV, 28, 4. |
This page | | Plutarch, Life of Theseus , 30, 5. |
This page | | Ibid., 29, 3. |
This page | | Tzetzes, Scholium to Aristophanes’ Pluto , 627 b, 1–4, in Scholia in Aristophanem , pars IV, ed. L. M. Positano, Groningen: Bonma, 1957. |
This page | | Plutarch, Life of Theseus , 35, 7. |
This page | | Aeschylus, Supplices , 9. |
This page | | Pindar, Pythian Odes , IX, 114. |
This page | | Strabo, Geography , VII, 6, 8. |
This page | | Aeschylus, Choephori , 631. |
This page | | Aeschylus, Danaids , fr. 44, in TrGF , vol. 3, ed. S. Radt. |
This page | | Aeschylus, Supplices , 291. |
This page | | J. J. Bachofen, Das Mutterrecht , vol. II, 1, pp. 288–89. |
This page | | Aeschylus, Myrmidones , fr. 136, in TrGF , vol. 3, ed. S. Radt. |
This page | | Pseudo-Lucian, Loves , 48. |
This page | | Callimachus, Hymns , II, 49. |
This page | | Plutarch, De genio Socratis , 591 b. |
This page | | Euripides, Alcestis , 147. |
This page | | Plutarch, On Love , 768 e. |
This page | | Plato, Symposium , 179 c. |
This page | | Ibid., 179 d. |
This page | | Herodotus, Historiae , VII, 129, 1. |
This page | | Hesychius, Lexicon, A 1156. |
This page | | Plutarch, On Love , F61 e. |
This page | | Aeschylus, Supplices , 214. |
This page | | Euripides, Alcestis , 147. |
This page | | Plato, Symposium , 182 a. |
This page | | Ibid., 182 d. |
This page | | Ibid., 183 b. |
This page | | Theocritus, Idylls , XII, 13. |
This page | | Plato, Symposium , 184 e. |
This page | | Ibid. |
This page | | Ibid. |
This page | | Anacreon, fr. 125 (Gentili). |
This page | | Pseudo-Lucian, Loves , 42. |
This page | | Ibid., 39. |
This page | | Achilles Tatius, The Adventures of Leucippe and Cleitophon , II, 38, 3–4. |
This page | | Aeschines, Against Timarchus , 185. |
This page | | Pseudo-Lucian, Loves , 41. |
This page | | Plutarch, Amatorius , 750 c. |
This page | | Pseudo-Lucian, Loves , 4. |
This page | | Ibid., 5. |
This page | | Ibid., 12. |
This page | | Ibid., 16. |
This page | | Ibid., 17. |
This page | | Theocritus, Idylls , XVI, 108–9. |
This page | | Simonides, in Anthologia Palatina , VII, 25, 3. |
This page | | Plutarch, Amatorius , 751 d. |
This page | | Strabo, Geography , X, 4, 21. |
This page | | Plutarch, Amatorius , 751 c. |
This page | | Aristophanes, Clouds , 978. |
This page | | Xenophon, Symposium , VIII, 21. |
This page | | Plutarch, Amatorius , 751 e. |
This page | | Plato, Symposium , 180 b. |
This page | | Herodotus, Historiae , II, 53, 1. |
This page | | Ibid., II, 53, 2. |
This page | | Hesiod, Theogonia , 885. |
This page | | Iliad , I, 184, 323, 346. |
This page | | Ibid., I, 143, 310, 369. |
This page | | Ibid., I, 298. |
This page | | Ibid., I, 304. |
This page | | Ibid., I, 13. |
This page | | Ibid., I, 23, 111, 377. |
This page | | Ibid., I, 447. |
This page | | Thucydides, Historiae , I, 11, 1. |
This page | | M. Parry, The Making of Homeric Verse , Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1971, p. 97. |
This page | | Apollonius Rhodius, Argonautica , IV, 794–95. |
This page | | Ibid., IV, 799. |
This page | | Ibid., IV, 796. |
This page | | Aeschylus, Prometheus Bound , 768. |
This page | | Pindar, Isthmian Odes , VIII, 36. |
This page | | Apollonius Rhodius, Argonautica , IV, 804. |
This page | | Iliad , I, 395. |
This page | | Aeschylus, Prometheus Bound , 762. |
This page | | Ibid., 768. |
This page | | Iliad , III, 164. |