Authors: Heidi Julavits
Today I swam out to sea with a stranger. Since my usual swimming partner had left town, I'd put the word outâSwimmer Too Scared to Swim Alone Needs Swim Partner. I am scared to swim alone not because I might drown but because I might be attacked by a shark. Mine is an unwarranted phobia (shared by basically every person in my generation, i.e., those of us who grew up with
Jaws
); companionship is an illogical cure. To date, there have been no shark attacks in our harbor. Should a shark, against all statistics, appear, a friend (unless he or she is swimming with a machine gun) will be unable to save me from it. But I feel safe in knowingâbefore I am pulled underwater to my death by an animal, I can share a final
what the fuck?
moment with a sympathetic human.
This is the only protection I require.
A friend invited me to swim off her property with her sister, a woman who sees ghosts. The sister and I swam to a motorboat, then to a buoy, then to a lobster boat. We talked about the real estate coincidence that binds us. My husband and I looked at her mother's house to buy, but instead we bought ours. Her mother looked at our house to buy, but instead she bought hers. I told the woman who was sensitive to ghosts that the reason we hadn't bought her mother's house was because it hadâand I hoped I
wasn't insulting her by saying thisâbad energy. Even my mother, not a woman who's ever anxious about energy save the kind that can, via the cord on your coffeemaker, maybe burn your house down, agreed with me. “I think I'd kill myself if I lived in this house,” my mother said when the real estate agent was out of earshot.
The woman with whom I was swimming, however, said she hadn't experienced any bad vibes in that house, which was strange given she was so sensitive to spiritual entities. She told me about the ghost she'd seen when she was a child, a man in an overcoat walking up the stairs in her house who was “definitely malicious.” She'd seen other ghosts as well. As we rounded the lobster boat we talked about the lodge that was for sale right in front of us. Twenty-one bedrooms for under a million dollars. Why was it such a steal? Maybe it was haunted? We fantasized about tearing down the haunted parts, like amputating a cancerous limb. Would this work? It didn't always work with actual cancer. It hadn't worked with the bamboo in our backyard. Our soil was poisoned by mutant cells. No matter if we killed the plants, their undead genetic material lurked underground and reappeared in strange places, like halfway up the outside wall of our barn.
We emerged from the sea and I thanked her for swimming with me and for distracting me with talk of ghosts. “Better than talking about sharks!” I said. I'd (mostly) stopped worrying about sharks this summer, which was such a massive accomplishment that I considered listing it on my CV. “Ugh!” the sister said. “Please don't mention that!” She told me that sharks were moving northward because the water had become so warm. There'd been a shark sighting not too far from where we'd been swimming, just beyond the protective barrier of the islands.
“What kind of shark?” I asked.
“The bad kind,” she said. Then she told me who'd supposedly seen this shark, and I relaxed a little. The shark-spotter is a famed alarmist. Once she'd told us that our elm tree was sickâthe little tendrils sprouting from the trunk were, according to her, signs of its imminent expirationâand that it would cost $5,000 to remove it, and that we had to do so immediately, because the next big wind would blow it over and it would crush our house. In a panic, we called a tree expert. The tree expert laughed at us. “Those tendrils mean it's healthy,” he said. The alarmist also whipped us into a panic froth about firewoodâ“You'll never get dry firewood at this time of year; the only firewood you can buy is green, and if you burn it in your stove the creosote will clog your chimney and cause a fire”âand about drinking alcohol while pregnantâ“Even one sip of one drink will diminish your child's intelligence and abilities.” I pointed out that her mother, as she'd bragged at one point, drank a martini every night while pregnant with her.
“Exactly,”
she said. “Who knows what I might have been? I might have been an Olympian.”
So the fact that the alarmist had reported the bad kind of shark sighting meant that (a) she'd mistaken a porpoise for a shark, or (b) she had seen a shark but had no idea what kind of shark it was, and likely, given she was right about practically nothing, this shark was not a bad shark.
Still, I worried about this supposed shark sighting for the rest of the day. I loved swimming so much! Part of what I loved about swimming was that I was no longer scared while doing it, so every minute I was in the ocean was another pat on my back. Way to go! You are no longer
such a huge scaredy-cat! I teach for the same reason. I used to be as scared of public speaking as I was of sharks. Every time I teach I get an endorphin high off the fact that I did not have a panic attack. I teach and swim in order to measure my improvement as a human. I am no longer terrified of quite so many things.
I considered how to stanch this renewed shark fear before it grew so large that I could no longer swim. I considered Googling
great white shark spottings recent maine
. Even if one shark had been spotted, or two, this could reassure me that the shark situation was not unusual; i.e., this new sighting was not proof of an imminent invasion I might wisely seek to evade by keeping to the land.
Also, it's not like there had
never
been great white spottings off the coast of Maine. When I was a kid I used to visit a seal who lived in Rockport Harbor. I have his biographyâ
A Seal Called Andre
, piquantly described in the jacket copy as “the true story of a unique human/animal relationship”âin which there are a number of pictures, including one of a young girl in 1960s hounds-tooth pedal pushers beside a dead great white. The caption reads, “Beauty and the beast: Carol poses uneasily with the monstrous great white shark that devoured Basil.” Basil was the other seal with which the author of the book, Harry Goodridge, had a unique human/animal relationship. Harry made friends with lots of harbor seals; his semi-related hobby was harpooning great whites in order to prove the marine biologists, all of whom insisted great whites seldom swam farther north than Cape Cod, wrong. Maine was considered by these biologists no more than the “casual range” of the great white, to which Harry riposted, “I'd harpooned a dozen or more in Penobscot Bay in the course of several summers and had sighted
many more. It struck me that the presence of that many man-eaters constituted more than a âcasual' population.” Harry's point being that I
should
have been scared of sharks when I was a kid. His point probably also being that I should still be scared. However, no one to my knowledge has ever been attacked by a great white shark in Maine, and since Harry saw great whites in the 1960s, meaning they'd lived in these water for
decades
, these were clearly some lazy-ass sharks. I was less scared to know that there were sharks than that there weren't. The evil was among us, but it was fine, it was all fine. We were not awaiting some future species clash, the initial trials of which might involve me.
And yet I still felt tempted to Google the sharks. Maybe a human
had
been attacked by a shark in Maine recently. I was not very up on the news. I barely knew who the Republican presidential candidate was. Maybe there were so many sharks now that the biologists had revised their casual range projections. I began to feel like my friend who suspected her husband of having an affair, and who had the power to satisfy her curiosity if she just dared to read his e-mail. I just had to Google
great white shark spottings recent maine
. But what good would our sleuthing do either of us? She probably wouldn't leave her husband. I probably wouldn't stop swimming. Why bother knowing? I saw no point.
Today I heard a terrible noise. I was in my office and I was talking to a student. She'd written a story about a
semi-neurotic woman trying to buy salmon at a fish shop. We were both, this student and I, cognizant of the fact that we are somewhat like this character. We are subtextual, and sub-subtextual, and sub-sub-subtextual readers of the world.
Suddenly, in the middle of our conversation, we heard the terrible noise. From somewhere on the quad, where there is always a landscape maintenance crew performing destructive acts of beautification, a vibration jostled the air. Not just the air, the buildings. The sound it produced was of a very low frequency, and nearly inaudible. It registered in my molars.
I covered my ears until it stopped.
“Wow,” I said.
“Wow,” she said.
“That was crazy,” I said.
“Yeah,” she agreed.
“What
was
that?” I said.
“What?” she said.
“That noise,” I said.
“What noise?” she said.
“Didn't you hear that noise?” I said.
“No,” she said.
“You really didn't hear that noise?” I said.
She hadn't. We continued talking about her short story, but now I was distracted. How had she failed to hear that noise? At a different point in my life, I might have congratulated myself for hearing what she did not hear. I was so sensitive I might qualify for extrasensory perception status. I detected what no one else detected. But I am no longer at that point. Now when I see or hear something that no one else sees or hears, I worry that a part of me is failing. I am not extra-anything, I am less-something.
I am reminded of my less-somethingness when I cannot find pleasurable a book or TV show that everyone else finds pleasurable, even brilliant. Am I the only person who can't perceive the genius of this book or that TV show? I used to believe my failure was proof of a refined intellect; that I refused to see genius where lesser people, with lower genius standards, found gobs of genius. But now my failure to find the genius makes me worry that I'm missing something, not receiving something. What do all of these people understand that I don't?
Regardless: the noise. The student suggested that maybe I had something wrong with my inner ear. This seemed plausible. I have children who yell and who cause me to yell. Who knew what frequency contusions the invisible chambers of my ear had suffered.
I made an appointment with an ear doctor. Just the act of making the appointment reassured me: something was failing, but that something could be fixed. I should have seen a doctor when I could not understand how anyone found that multi-prize-winning novel remotely good. My inner ear, it must have been my inner ear.
Then I told my husband about the terrible noise, and how I'd made an appointment with the doctor to discover why I'd heard it and my student had not.
“Interesting,” he said. “So there really was a noise?”
“What do you mean?” I said.
“The noise you heard actually existed?”
“Yes,” I said. “It actually existed.”
“You didn't just hear it in your head?” he said.
What noise don't you hear in your head? I wanted to ask. But his question freaked me out. I heard a noise, but had there been a
noise
? How many people have to hear a noise before it becomes a
noise
?
I promised him: there was a
noise
. It existed. I really did hear it, and my student really did not.