The First Time is the Sweetest (23 page)

He moaned, “Sabrina, don’t move, don’t move, God—” He trembled, his arms and thighs rock hard as she ran her hands along his skin, trying to get him to thrust. She looked up and saw Jimmy staring at her. He reached around Gabriel and slid his fingers down to play with her sex and she tried not to arch up, but couldn’t help it, wanting so badly to feel Gabriel sliding in and out of her. Jimmy moved his hand away too soon, and Gabriel dropped down to his elbows to frame her face with his hands. “Sabrina,” he breathed. His eyes closed and a look of intense concentration came over his face. She heard Jimmy grunt softly, and then both men gasped. She could see Jimmy behind Gabriel, feel the other man’s hands urging both of them to hold steady.

“Okay?” Jimmy ground out. Gabriel just nodded. Impossibly, his cock swelled even larger.

“What’s he doing?” Sabrina whispered, touching Gabriel’s face.

He opened his eyes. “He’s fucking me with his fingers, oh God, it feels so good—” Gabriel groaned. Sabrina held as still as she could, feeling him trembling over her. “He’s got three fingers in me now.” He panted.

Jimmy moaned then, and she felt him rub against Gabriel. “Sabrina, you have no idea, he feels so hot,” he muttered. “I don’t want to hurt you, Gabriel,” he continued. Sabrina felt herself get even wetter as she watched both men shaking above her, trying to control themselves.

Gabriel just shook his head. “Doesn’t hurt, just, God, just fuck me already, please,” he begged, breathing heavily, and Sabrina felt his hips jerking slightly as he struggled not to thrust. She moaned and shivered and raked her hands up his arms to grab at Jimmy’s face. Jimmy shifted his weight, and she knew he’d begun to push inside Gabriel. She felt Gabriel’s thighs tightening against hers.

“Okay?” Jimmy asked hoarsely. Gabriel nodded and she felt Jimmy push in a little bit more. To her amazement, each tiny shove moved Gabriel further inside her. She groaned, nearly climaxing because every thrust knocked against her clit. Little by little Gabriel’s face eased as Jimmy carefully worked his way in. She felt Jimmy through Gabriel, both of them pressing into her, all that masculine power contained. Finally, Gabriel groaned and shook, and Jimmy rested his head on the other man’s shoulder.

“Jesus, you feel good, Gabriel,” Jimmy said. He was all the way in. Gabriel looked like he was about to die, his face flushed and his eyes so hot on hers it was a miracle they didn’t go up in flames. She wasn’t sure if he was hurt or if it just felt good, but his cock was hard as iron inside her. She whined for him to start moving, and he smiled for a split second before closing his eyes.

“Are you okay?” Sabrina whispered as Jimmy began to rock, tiny thrusts, and Gabriel’s hand stroked briefly down her breast.

Gabriel nodded, his nostrils flaring. “You have no idea, Sabrina, you both feel so good. Fuck, Jimmy, don’t stop,” he said, voice cracking. His face was tight with arousal, and Sabrina felt him sigh with relief as Jimmy began to move in earnest. Gabriel pulled out, and she clutched at him frantically, but then he fucked into her as Jimmy slowly shoved back inside. She shivered as the two men found a rhythm together, closing her eyes to savor the pleasure. They made love like this for minutes or hours, Jimmy kissing the back of Gabriel’s neck and sometimes stroking her with his hands, Gabriel alternately kissing and shuddering into her hair. Every move Jimmy made was given to Sabrina in turn by Gabriel. Soon they grew incoherent, Gabriel in the center, his cock hitting her clit with every stroke. She hovered at the edge of orgasm almost before she knew what was happening.

“Gabriel, Gabriel, oh God I’m going to come, please, I love you, love you both,” she cried. Then her body arched despite the weight of both men, and she heaved her hips up at them, thrusting herself onto Gabriel as he held rock still. Suddenly, he groaned, and she felt him come, cock pulsing inside as Jimmy fucked into him erratically, forcing the other man to rock through the pleasure. The added friction made her cry out, and Jimmy stopped and moaned, low and deep. His arms shook as he tried to hold himself up, but he lost the battle and collapsed onto Gabriel, who managed to hold him without crushing Sabrina for a long, silent minute. Then he gently eased himself out to lie down, Jimmy behind him, trembling as Jimmy hugged them both close. No one moved for a very long time.

* * * *

Sabrina was grateful they’d started a fire before the photography session. Even though it was summer, it was cool in the cabin so the warmth was welcome. She dozed for a while, then woke as the sunlight moved off the rug and high onto the wall. She cuddled between Gabriel and Jimmy, both men’s arms thrown across her stomach, their thighs trapping hers. She savored their heat, replaying the memory of how they’d made love together over and over, remembering how Gabriel felt inside her, his eyes dark with arousal and love. She remembered how Jimmy moved inside both of them. She shivered, flushing with renewed arousal. Gabriel lifted his head, cocking his eyebrow, then smiled as he realized the direction her thoughts had taken. She blushed.

“Hey, look who’s awake,” he said.

She felt Jimmy’s grin against her shoulder. “And look who’s blushing.”

“Shouldn’t I be the one to blush?” Gabriel added. Sabrina snickered and dropped her eyes shyly. She remembered how he felt when she had her fingers inside him and blushed again. Jimmy laughed, keeping his eyes closed and his arms around her. Gabriel smiled and held her more tightly. He didn’t seem at all embarrassed, and she was stammering to herself in her own thoughts!

“Were you, um—” she broke off. Gabriel lifted his head and looked at Sabrina inquiringly.

“Was I what?” he asked, stroking her face gently with one hand.

“Weren’t you worried? Not every guy wakes up one day and thinks,
Yeah, let’s go for it
.”

Gabriel smiled and shook his head. “A little, but I’ve always known I was bi and wondered what it would feel like. So the idea of making love like that wasn’t strange for me. I knew Jimmy loved me, just as you do, just as much as I love you,” he continued as Sabrina stared at him in surprise. She knew how she felt but wasn’t sure the two men were as committed. Then she remembered Jimmy crying out during his climax. She looked at Gabriel’s smiling face, his deep blue eyes. Jimmy hugged her tightly from behind. Sabrina smiled, drawing Gabriel close and caressing Jimmy’s arm at the same time.

“I do love you,” she said, wonderingly.

“Yeah,” Jimmy agreed, his reply muffled by her hair. Delight raced through her as Jimmy hugged her even tighter, and she turned to kiss him.

“I love you too, Jimmy.” Two pairs of very attractive eyes twinkled as she smiled. “So, you really weren’t nervous?” she asked Gabriel again.

He shook his head. “Maybe a little, but it just wasn’t that big of a leap for me. And, well, Jimmy sure as hell knows what he’s doing.” Gabriel laughed as he kissed her. Sabrina felt heat crawl through her body all over again.

Jimmy smiled at Gabriel over her shoulder. “Gabriel, you make it easy, man. You’re fucking gorgeous.” Sabrina blushed at his frank words. Then he yawned and sat up, leaning over to kiss the other man.
I am so lucky,
she thought.

“Should we go to bed?” Jimmy asked when he finally pulled away. Sabrina nodded, and Gabriel stretched. Jimmy eyed his nude body greedily. He was gorgeous, all sleek muscle and contained power. After he stood up, Gabriel reached down and hauled Sabrina up, too, laughing as she squeaked in protest. Jimmy grinned and arched his arms over his head, showing off his well-defined abdomen to great effect. Gabriel and Sabrina stared.
The way we’re going, we’re never going to get upstairs!
she thought, chuckling as she pulled herself together. She gathered her clothes and stalked up the steps, not bothering to dress. When she slid into bed, the cool sheets made her shiver. She hoped it wouldn’t take them long to join her, wishing for the men’s body heat to warm her up. Jimmy veered off into the bathroom, and Sabrina heard the water running as he cleaned himself up. She yawned again.

“Tired?” Gabriel asked, sitting on the edge of the bed. She nodded as Jimmy sauntered into the bedroom. Gabriel stroked her face, then got up for his turn in the bathroom. Jimmy lay down next to her, and Sabrina sighed, enjoying the warmth as he idly ran his hands over her torso.

“You okay?” he asked. She nodded. “You’ve kinda jumped into the deep end here with us, you know.” His hands landed on her breast and tweaked her nipple. She gasped, and he leaned over and licked at her skin, his tongue rasping over the sensitive tip.

“Yeah, but I trust you,” Sabrina said once she could draw a steady breath.

“You know I would never hurt you.” Sabrina looked at Jimmy’s face, relishing the love that was so evident when he looked at her and Gabriel.

“I know.” Sabrina gasped as he sucked her nipple back into his mouth.

“I never expected this, to have Gabriel show up and for the three of us to fall in love this way,” he continued, still lapping at her. Sabrina grabbed his hair with both hands and arched into his mouth.

“I know. Who could expect it? It’s not something I ever even imagined.” Jimmy was moving down her body now, nudging her legs apart. She opened for him gladly, and he lay down on his side, smiling against her inner thigh.

Sabrina continued. “I mean, at the beginning of summer, I was on a horrible date. When you kissed me that first time, I had no idea we would soon be making love together. I had no idea that we’d meet Gabriel.” She shook her head in bemusement, then gasped as Jimmy walked his finger up higher, petting the sensitive skin around her opening.

“I was shocked when I saw you for the first time this summer,” Jimmy admitted, still stroking. Sabrina stretched her arms over her head, enjoying his caress. “I mean, I loved you before, loved your sense of humor and the way you always smiled and hugged me, but we were kids. And then when I saw you come downstairs to say hi, I almost had a heart attack. You wore that white halter top and a skirt, and you looked so delectable. All the blood rushed out of my head and down to my cock.” She laughed and squirmed as Jimmy continued to talk, sliding a finger inside at the same time.

“I thought your dad was going to see my hard-on.”

“Really?” Sabrina gasped as he pumped his finger in and out, deliberately avoiding her clit, to her consternation. She wiggled, trying to get him to move his finger up.

Jimmy chuckled. “Yeah. You were beautiful. I didn’t know how I was going to control myself. Then you stumbled into me while we were making dinner that night, and I was so fucking hot for you I couldn’t handle it anymore. I was afraid I was going to scare you to death.”

His finger paused, and he bent down for a quick lick, making Sabrina buck up into him as she tried to focus on what he was saying. “God, Jimmy, you were so gorgeous, I didn’t know what to do. And I had no idea that you would want me. I was such a nerd before.”

“Sabrina, I wanted you from the moment I set eyes on you,” Jimmy rasped, gripping her thighs tightly. “After we started fooling around, tickling each other, and my hands slipped into your halter, God, I almost came in my pants!” Jimmy chuckled, rubbing his stubble on her inner thigh. “That’s why I turned around so abruptly. I didn’t want you to know.”

Sabrina shook her head, wondering what would have happened if he’d made a move on her back then. She’d just started thinking about her attraction for him. Would she have freaked? She didn’t think so. She gasped as Jimmy nipped her skin and slid his fingers back in.

“You starting without me?” Gabriel asked as he walked into the bedroom, running a dry towel through his damp hair. The two of them sprawled on the bed, Sabrina’s thighs loosely nestled on either side of Jimmy. Sabrina looked up at Gabriel standing near the door, a second towel slung around his waist, barely covering his cock, which was obviously growing interested in what was happening on the bed.

Sabrina shivered as Jimmy’s fingers stroked through her wetness, dipping just inside, teasing. “Nope,” he said, “just getting her ready for round two.” He kissed her thigh, eyes gleaming with heat, then dipped his head down and sucked her clit into his mouth. Gabriel inhaled sharply and dropped the towel as Sabrina moaned; then he walked over and kissed her. She whimpered when Gabriel pulled back and he winked, then dipped his head down and licked the head of Jimmy’s cock without warning, wetting it before taking it into his mouth. Jimmy moaned around her clit and sucked harder, driving her crazy. She watched Gabriel suck Jimmy, his cheeks working as he swirled his tongue over the head as Jimmy did the same to her. She didn’t expect this after having made love an hour or so ago, but already her skin was on fire.

“God, Jimmy, I need…” Sabrina gasped, but couldn’t continue as he brought her close to orgasm again and again, never letting her fall over the edge. She grabbed his hair, twisting her body on the sheets, trying to keep his tongue against her, but he pulled back. Sabrina opened her eyes.

Jimmy kneeled, head thrown back as Gabriel sucked him down and fingered his hole at the same time. Then Gabriel slipped his finger inside Jimmy, and the other man bucked into his mouth, grabbing at Gabriel’s hair. With a laugh, Gabriel pulled back until his lips rested just on the crown of Jimmy’s cock, his finger still moving in and out as Jimmy groaned and writhed. Sabrina watched, mesmerized.

Gabriel smiled and then looked at her, Jimmy’s cock resting against his lips. “Jimmy,” he began, then moaned as Jimmy fucked himself down on Gabriel’s finger, legs spread decadently wide, eyes closed. Sabrina swallowed, her mouth going completely dry. “Jimmy, I want to fuck you.” Sabrina felt a surge of wet seep from her core. “I’ve never done it before, never fucked a man,” Gabriel whispered, then eased another finger into Jimmy. Sabrina moaned, her hands snaking down to touch herself. Gabriel watched her, eyes hot, then licked at Jimmy’s erection.