The First Time is the Sweetest (17 page)

“Wow,” Jimmy finally said. Sabrina smiled, squirming a little as her body throbbed. Gabriel looked at her, and the heat in his eyes burned across her skin. Without speaking, they stretched across Jimmy to kiss. Sabrina had no idea what she was feeling. Instead of embarrassment, she just wanted to get closer, touch them more. Was this love? Tears stung her eyes, and she felt Jimmy’s breath on her cheek as she sucked Gabriel’s full lower lip into her mouth, licking gently. She moaned when he slipped his tongue inside, so aroused now with love or lust she didn’t know where to put her hands, how to hold still. Dimly, she felt Jimmy turn her body, lifting her onto his lap as Gabriel backed away just enough to pull off his shirt. Sabrina stared. She wanted to roll herself all over him. His lean chest was lightly sprinkled with dark hair and she shuddered, imagining what it would feel like to scrape her breasts against him. She slid her hands around his pectorals, brushing over his nipples.

Gabriel shivered, and Jimmy chuckled. “Looks like you’re still raring to go,” Jimmy murmured to the other man as he stroked his hand down Sabrina’s back under her tank top. Then, unexpectedly, Jimmy pulled her halter up and over her head, exposing her breasts. Gabriel’s eyes darkened even more, and he leaned in, brushing his fingers lightly over her nipples. She trembled, and Jimmy pulled her back further, exposing her even more as he nestled her against his chest.

“Yeah, I think I could definitely keep going,” Gabriel murmured, cupping her breasts, flicking the tips with his thumbs as she squirmed. She slid her hands over his shoulders, and he leaned close and kissed her lightly as Jimmy moved his hands over her waist and down to the top of her sweatpants.

“Sabrina, do you want to keep going?” Jimmy asked quietly, playing with the soft elastic. Gabriel’s dark hair clung to his face, and Sabrina caught Jimmy looking at Gabriel as he kissed down her neck, mussing his hair further. She shivered and Gabriel cuddled her closer. She enjoyed the way her body fit against his chest. “Sabrina?” Jimmy asked again, but she ignored him, too aroused to think. She threw her head back. “Dude, hang on.”

Sabrina felt Gabriel nod as he pulled back to look intently into her face. Sabrina blushed. She wanted so badly to make love to him. And to Jimmy. She felt like she’d been waiting forever after all these weeks of dancing around. She nodded and cleared her throat, trying to speak.

“Yeah, I do,” she said, swallowing thickly. She was nervous and aroused and excited and suddenly so deeply in love she couldn’t imagine this night ending any other way.

“Are you sure, Sabrina?” Gabriel asked, taking hold of her hands and rubbing his thumb over her palms. Jimmy nodded behind her as his body warmed her skin. Heat moved through her in a wave while she tried to consider his question.

“The first time is a big decision,” Jimmy said. “I don’t—
we
don’t want to force you into anything you’re not ready for. There’s plenty of ways we can make you feel good without the final act.”

Sabrina shook her head. Did they care about her? They must, or they wouldn’t be stopping and asking her if she was sure. Most guys would just assume she would want to, not take the time in the middle to talk to her about it first. She inhaled, suddenly sure. She could smell both of them on her, and she loved that they cared enough to pull back and wait. The certainty that she was doing the right thing, choosing these two men, felt good.

“I want to feel you inside me,” Sabrina breathed finally, staring right into Gabriel’s eyes. His breath caught and Sabrina felt herself blush at the way he looked at her, desire and affection both apparent on his face. She squirmed around on Jimmy’s lap until she could see his face. “And I want to feel you inside me, too, Jimmy,” she said. Jimmy looked at her, quiet and thoughtful, then nodded and kissed her lips gently. She almost wept at the tender look in his eyes. She shivered with pleasure.

“Let’s go upstairs, then, to your bed.” Gabriel pulled Sabrina to her feet. She blushed, realizing that she had no shirt on, but then Jimmy rose behind her, not bothering to dress. He seemed completely comfortable in his skin as the three of them moved to the stairs, and she felt her shyness disappear. At the top of the steps, Jimmy picked her up, and she squeaked in surprise, struggling instinctively.

“Jimmy!” she exclaimed, but he just laughed as he walked down the hall and tossed her on the bed. Gabriel turned on the low light she kept on her nightstand and she giggled. She didn’t expect sex to be so much fun. The two men were laughing with her and she loved it.

They climbed onto the bed on either side of her, Jimmy lounging back against the headboard, still nude, while Gabriel tugged on her sweatpants until he pulled them off.
It’s a good thing I have a large bed
, she thought, watching Gabriel stand up and slowly push down his jeans and boxers in one smooth motion. Now all three of them were naked, and she was feeling a little shy again. But Jimmy reached over to kiss her while Gabriel ran his palms up her waist to cup her breasts. Sabrina forgot all about modesty as the two men set about pleasuring her together.

“Mmm, Sabrina, you smell so good,” Gabriel murmured as he leaned closer, kissing the side of her breast, then trailing his tongue up to her nipple.

She couldn’t speak, moaning into Jimmy’s mouth instead. His tongue stroked hers, pulling back to lick at her lips, then sliding inside again. He rolled onto his side, and she felt his right hand move down her body to tease the curls at the apex of her thighs. She opened her legs willingly; by now she felt like she’d been dipped in fire. She could smell her own arousal as Jimmy’s clever fingers moved down to stroke gently at her opening. When Gabriel moaned against her breast, pressing his cock into her hip, Jimmy released her mouth to kiss down her shoulder while his fingers stroked, up and down, spreading her wetness across her labia. Sabrina opened her eyes just as Gabriel moved up to kiss her, and Jimmy bent his head to her breast. She groaned and shook, overwhelmed.

“Easy now, sweetheart,” Jimmy whispered just before he sucked her right nipple into his mouth.

Gabriel’s free hand played with her other nipple while Jimmy’s right hand slid into her. Sabrina bucked, trying to get more of him inside, completely lost in the sensations the two men were creating. Jimmy slipped two fingers in, then stopped as Gabriel pulled back. She opened her eyes and looked down at herself, seeing Jimmy’s head at her breast and Gabriel’s free hand moving down. She panted, then moaned again as Gabriel reached her clit and rubbed it softly while Jimmy’s fingers continued their stroking inside. She didn’t know what to do with her hands and they ended up clutching both men, one in Jimmy’s hair, the other around Gabriel’s neck. She opened her thighs even wider and saw Gabriel suck in a breath as he moved further down the bed to see. He ran his hand up the sensitive skin of her inner legs, trembling as he inhaled and closed his eyes.

“Oh God,” he whispered, and she saw that his cock was so hard the tip touched his stomach, painting a sweet, wet line against his skin. “I want to taste you, Sabrina.”

She shivered and felt the slightly callused skin of his fingers tighten on her skin. Without waiting for an answer, he moved his hands down further, rubbing his thumbs against her wetness and settling between her thighs. She felt Jimmy breathing against her breast and turned to see him looking at Gabriel as the other man leaned in and licked her swollen bud. She thrashed at the lovely, insane pleasure of it and both men moved to hold her down. Fierce sparks shot through her body. Then Gabriel sucked her into his mouth and tongued gently while Jimmy eased yet another finger inside. She felt full and crazy and incoherent, and she wanted more. She wanted more of them both. Dimly, she felt Gabriel moan against her center as Jimmy lowered his head to nibble at her breast again. Every place they touched felt electric.

“Oh, oh, please, I need—” Sabrina gasped, thrashing. The two men looked at each other for a moment, then grinned.

“What do you need?” Jimmy questioned against her breast, smiling, eyes hot, the brown almost completely swallowed by the black of his pupils. She stared at him, at the way his tousled hair gleamed in the low light, so close to climax she couldn’t speak. “Do you want Gabriel to slide his gorgeous cock inside you?” he whispered, arousing her even more, his voice growling and low. She nodded frantically just as Gabriel looked up, blue eyes gleaming.

“I would love to fuck you, Sabrina.” He deliberately lowered his head to lick her from bottom to top, not seeming to care that he also licked Jimmy’s hand at the same time. She shuddered. “Sabrina, please, let me. I want to fill you up, fuck you so good…” Gabriel murmured against her thigh. She nodded and prayed he’d hurry up as she closed her eyes.

“What about condoms?” Gabriel asked, looking at Jimmy, who frowned. He shifted, easing his fingers away from her so he could hunt some down when Sabrina cleared her throat.

“I’m on the pill,” she said, her voice weak.

Gabriel smiled. “Oh.”

Jimmy sat back down and Sabrina felt the bed shift as Gabriel settled himself on his knees between her legs. Then her eyes flew open when she felt the hot, thick heat of Gabriel’s cock against her opening. She looked down to see him holding himself with one hand, rolling the tip around her pussy, coating himself in her wetness. His muscles flexed, and she gasped every time he bumped her clit. He slid himself against her over and over as she writhed.

“Please,” Sabrina croaked, wanting to feel him inside. Jimmy chuckled and bent over, sucking and biting her nipple again, shooting sparks through her. She ran her hands through his soft hair, absently tugging harder when he flicked his tongue against the erect peak.

“You’d better do as she says, Gabriel,” Jimmy said, pulling back and moving closer to the bottom of the bed. Sabrina watched both men watch her as Gabriel slowly eased his cock inside. He was huge and hot, and she throbbed at the stretch. It burned a little. She didn’t think he was going to fit but he stopped, letting her adjust to the sensation.

“This might hurt a little bit, sweetheart.” He eased inside slowly, rocking deeper and deeper until she couldn’t tell if the ache was pain or pleasure. When he finally stopped she realized that he was fully seated in her body. “Are you all right?” he asked quietly, breathing heavily and trembling. Jimmy stroked his hands up and down her waist to her breasts and back down again as she nodded and experimentally moved her hips against Gabriel. He shuddered and slowly slid almost all the way out until she felt the tip of him just inside her entrance. Then, without warning, he shoved back inside all at once, and she whimpered at how good it felt. She thrashed against Gabriel. The feeling of fullness was so huge she almost couldn’t stand it, and then Jimmy leaned over and kissed Gabriel, wet and deep. She watched him suck on Gabriel’s full lower lip and almost came just from that while Gabriel’s cock moved inside her. When Jimmy pulled back, he leaned over and she shivered as Gabriel froze.
What is he doing?
she thought, confused. Then Jimmy leaned down and sucked her clit inside his mouth with Gabriel still inside.

“Oh Jesus,” she vaguely heard Gabriel mutter right before he pulled out and pushed back in again. Sabrina realized he could feel Jimmy’s mouth on his cock every time he moved. Knowing that Jimmy was pleasuring them both at the same time drove her crazy; then something inside her snapped, and a wave of pleasure snaked through her. She arched her back and shuddered against both of them, thrashing uncontrollably. It went on and on and Gabriel groaned, making several short, sharp thrusts. Sabrina’s toes curled, and her hands gripped Gabriel’s hair as Jimmy’s clever tongue flicked against her. Gabriel pushed himself so far inside, his cock tapped against her womb. When he stopped and moaned, she nearly passed out from the sensation, feeling his orgasm pulse hotly inside her body. After a long minute, he pulled out and she felt the bed shift as Jimmy sat back on his heels. She tried to remember how to breathe.

“Sabrina, can I?” Jimmy asked, and she opened her eyes to see that Gabriel had collapsed beside her, looking fucked out and dazed. Jimmy was now between her thighs. He held his erection firmly at the base, and she nodded, admiring his cock, a little longer than Gabriel’s but slightly thinner. Without further ado, he leaned over to kiss her and slide himself inside. She still felt the aftershocks of her climax with Gabriel when Jimmy began moving. She couldn’t believe he fit inside so easily. She wasn’t even sore. He felt so sweet and hot and lovely she moaned, unable to help herself. It was incredible, being with Jimmy, finally after all these years. They locked eyes as he slid in and out again, and then Gabriel rolled over and snuggled his face into Sabrina’s neck as Jimmy fucked her, and she loved it. She loved knowing that both men cared for her and wanted her to feel good. She loved feeling Jimmy’s cock inside her while Gabriel licked at her neck and sighed against her skin. She loved the way Jimmy rolled his hips with every thrust, pushing against her clit. And then, to her astonishment, she felt arousal flash through her again, spiraling hotter and hotter every time Jimmy’s cock pushed inside, his body rutting against hers. Without warning, another climax rushed through her and Sabrina bucked up, keening and writhing as he thrust and froze, his cock pulsing as he spilled his pleasure. He’d shoved inside her so hard that Gabriel caught onto her shoulders with one hand and cradled her head with the other to keep her from hitting the headboard. Then Jimmy collapsed, snuggling into her neck as Gabriel gently kissed her lips, holding them both close. They shivered in the aftermath of the most incredible pleasure she’d ever experienced.