The Dare (3 page)

aty could not believe what she was allowing to happen to her. Two men at once!
Both
pleasing
her
. And she was going to let them. She threw the last of her hang-ups out the door. She was here, she was going to enjoy every single moment like there was no tomorrow. Because there would be no tomorrow. Not like this.
If
she could face Evan. And God help her if she ran into the stranger again. But she wasn’t going to worry about that now.

Now the only thing she was going to worry about was how much she was going to enjoy giving Evan a blow job, while this green-eyed stud fucked her senseless.

And wasn’t Evan going to be pleasantly surprised. He loved it when she went down on him more than intercourse. He was thick. He had a gorgeous wide head, and he knew how to use it, but this stranger’s cock was what porno movies were made from and she was so sopping wet with anticipation for it she could hardly stand it.

Her lovers moved in perfect sync. When Evan pushed his finger into her, Green Eyes withdrew his thick finger from her pussy, but at the same time he held on to her clit with his blistering lips, sometimes grazing that sensitive nub with his teeth. It drove her crazy. Then when Evan pulled out, Green Eyes slid deeply into her, and suckled her clit as he flicked it with his tongue. Dear God but it was like nothing she had ever experienced before.

Green Eyes made small contented sounds as if he were enjoying a feast. Maybe he was. Evan always said her pussy was the most delicious item on the menu, and in all the women he had gone down on, he never enjoyed one the way he did hers. She was tight, and for as much as she was being naughty right now, she’d had only four lovers in her thirty-year life, including Evan and this stranger. Perhaps she’d have to rethink her reasons for being so chaste.

The momentum of their fingers pushed her closer to the hovering orgasm, and just as it uncoiled within her, the stranger latched onto her clitoris and sucked it hard, curving his long thick finger into her G spot. Evan’s teeth sunk into her neck right where it met her shoulder, and he quickly thrust his finger in and out of her, machine-gun rapid. It was all too much and not enough. She screamed, not caring if the entire police department arrived on scene. The intensity of the orgasm wrecked her from the inside out, and before she could come down from it, Evan pulled her away from Green Eyes’ hot mouth and hand and carried her to the bed.

“Keep the heels on, and get on all fours,” Evan commanded. Her body quaked with the aftermath of her orgasm, nowhere close to recovering. She couldn’t believe he’d done that! He knew this was her first!

“Evan,” she gasped. “A minute—”

He grabbed a condom from the dresser top and tossed it to Green Eyes, who looked like he was ready to throttle Evan. “Put that on and get behind her.”

“I’m clean,” Green Eyes growled, then turned to Katy, and softly but firmly asked, “Is that what you want, sweetheart? Me behind you?”

Her pussy clenched so tightly at the intimate way he spoke to her and the thought of him inside of her, she creamed herself. “Yes,” she hoarsely whispered. “Please.”

Evan wasted no time as he positioned Katy so that she was facing him as he stood in front of her, his anxious cock wagging in front of her face. She reached out to take it into her mouth, but he grabbed her chin gently and shook his head. He opened the nearby bathroom door that had a full length mirror attached to it and angled it so that they could watch themselves. Katy shivered anxiously as she caught Green Eyes’ smoldering gaze in the mirror. He looked impatient to get inside her. Her pussy clamped and unclamped, the juice of her arousal moistening the inside of her thighs. God, she never dreamed she could feel this way.

“I want to watch your face when he enters you and I want you to see it, too,” Evan said.

“Yes,” she breathed. “I want to see everything.”

“Easy does it, sweetheart,” Green Eyes crooned as he slid his big hands along the curve of her ass cheeks before grasping the cradle of her hips from behind. And despite her eagerness for him, and his for her, he was gentle as he guided that massive cock slowly into her weeping pussy.

Katy let out a long expansive moan as he filled her. The sublimity of sensation beyond her imagination. It was—it was—there were no words to describe the sensuality of the sensation of feeling him slowly fill her, as she watched his face tighten with desire, the blaze of green fire in his eyes, and the way her blue eyes shone and her lips parted in breathless abandon. If she could encapsulate the vision of just the two of them at that moment and time, she would never have need of a man again, because the picture they painted was carnal knowledge at its most basic.

“Beautiful,” he said as he hit the core of her.

“Eyes open, Katy, watch yourself,” Evan commanded. It was all she could do not to close her eyes and enjoy the glorious rapture of that thick rod sliding slowly into her.

“You look so fucking hot right now,” Evan hoarsely whispered. When her eyes turned up to his, he had his cock in his hands, slowly stroking himself. “So fucking hot.” He guided the blunt head to her waiting lips.

“Fuck me with your mouth, Katy, like he’s fucking your pussy with his cock, and don’t take your eyes off yourself as you do it.”

Wet and needy, her pussy fisted the cock inside of her as she creamed. Green Eyes moaned, grasping her hips tightly. “Sweetheart, you are so damn tight and wet, let me set the pace or I’m going to explode.”

“You wait until I say you can come,” Evan growled at Green Eyes.

Green Eyes’ fingers tightened on her hips signaling his anger. But she didn’t want him to come yet, not when she knew she was going to come again herself, and this time, she was going to ride it all of the way out and enjoy it for what it was, because knowing her track record, it could very well be her last.

Slowly, Katy sucked Evan’s swollen cock into her mouth. Watching him watch her and watching the stranger taking her from behind made her pussy spasm in all sorts of ways. It was indescribably delicious and she wondered if she would be ruined forever for one-on-one sex. This was so damned decadent. She had come so easily at the stranger’s mouth, something that never happened, and she knew she was going to come again by his cock. Another first.

Evan sank his fingers into her wild mass of tangles, and slowly began to thrust deeper into her mouth. She took all of it. One thing she had never been shy about was her affection for Evan’s cock. Maybe it was because it was so responsive to her. She loved touching it, licking it, manipulating it to granite, and Evan had always appreciated her efforts. Still, it was hard to concentrate on him while her pussy was being so properly fucked. And Green Eyes could fuck.

He was as worked up as she. His fingers dug into the cradle of her hips, causing Katy to whimper in pleasure. She loved being dominated by these two men, and loved that Evan was calling the shots because never in a million years could she admit that what she was doing right now was something she never had the courage to fantasize about.

“Pay attention to my cock, Katy, suck harder, take me deeper.”

Immediately she obeyed. Balancing on one hand she cupped his smooth balls, and sucked him all of the way to the back of her throat. His sharp hiss of breath made her smile even with such a mouthful. He held her head firmly between his two hands, keeping her on point.

Her skin shimmered, slick with sweat. The sound of Green Eyes’ hips slamming into her ass as his heavy balls swung up and slapped her swollen clit, coupled with Evan’s cock thrusting in and out of her mouth, had her on the verge of total meltdown. Saliva dripped down Evan’s shaft, the sound of his grunts and his slick thrusts a total turn-on.

She whimpered as her body tensed with the impending climax. It was so hard to leash, it thrashed and thrust within her, demanding release. She whimpered again, feeling it slipping out of her control.

“Come, Katy,” Evan commanded. “Come now!”

At his command, her body shattered.
Oh, God.
She grabbed on to his cock, sucking him down her throat as her pussy fisted the other cock slamming in and out of her. In that perfect storm of erotic overload, she came in a wild, crazy, out of control orgasm that shook her from Evan slamming her mouth to Green Eyes ramming her pussy. It was epically perfect, and she knew that after this moment, she would never be the same.

As her body came apart at the seams, the stranger behind her dug his fingers painfully into her hips, jettisoning her orgasm into the stratosphere. He cried out in primal satisfaction, his hips bombarding her pussy. Caught up in the wild storm of their simultaneous orgasms, Katy closed her eyes for one brief perfect moment as she absorbed the frenzied sensations crashing wildly between her body and the one buried deeply inside her.

When she opened her eyes, and her gaze clashed with Evan’s hot gaze in the mirror, her pussy clamped harder around the orgasming cock inside of her, his furious yet predatory gaze adding mileage to her orgasm.

“You’re killing me, sweetheart,” Green Eyes groaned, clasping her hips against his, holding her immobile as the last vestige of his orgasm rolled through them both. She didn’t want it to end.

Evan cursed, abruptly pulled out of her mouth, and as he did, he grabbed Katy beneath the armpits and yanked her off the cock imbedded inside her. He flipped her over on to her back, grabbed her knees and spun her around. He yanked her toward his cock, then grabbing her hips he pulled her toward him as he moved into her, impaling himself deep inside of her.

“What are you doing!” she gasped.

He thrust into her. “Fucking you the way you should be fucked.” Her liquid muscles grasped him, holding onto him, milking him from the orgasm she was still experiencing.

He looked up and past her to Green Eyes. “Your party’s over, get out of here.”

“You’re a sick fuck,” the stranger said as he pulled the wet condom off and flung it on the floor. Before he made a move for his clothes or for the door, he caught Katy’s eyes in the mirror. “Do you want me to leave?”

No, she wanted him to stay. But—Closing her eyes she turned away from him and said, “Yes.”

“You got it.” She could only open her eyes after the door slammed shut, signaling his exit. Katy didn’t want to know what evil adjectives he was using to describe her at the moment. She would never see him again, and she was very okay with that because she doubted she would be able to face him.

asping for breath as her body continued to spasm with the remnants from her orgasm with Green Eyes, Katy tried to sort her emotions. It had been amazing. “You liked that big cock?” Evan furiously demanded.

“Yes,” she admitted.

He thrust into her. “Do you like
this
cock?”

“Yesss,” she hissed. Her body, still on overdrive, trembled violently as another orgasm began to unfurl. Sensing it, Evan withdrew completely. “No!” her hips chased his as the rest of her body undulated with need. “Evan! Please,” she begged, reaching up to grab him.

“You don’t come for me when you’re still creaming for him, Katy.”

“I’m not!”

Evan lowered his head to hover just above hers. “You don’t get to come until I say you can come, Katy.” His body shook with desire but he withheld himself from her. “Lie back and don’t move.”

She immediately complied. Lord help her but she wanted another orgasm.
Ten more!
Her body twitched as she fought to force it into submission. Her breathing was accelerated, her breasts rising and falling quickly in tune with her shallow breaths.

“Spread your legs.”

Before he finished the command they were parted. Katy bit her bottom lip as she felt warm wetness drip between her sensitive folds.

“Your pussy is weeping, Katy. Weeping for
my
cock. Isn’t it?”

“Yes,” she whispered.

“If you’re a good girl, you might get it.”

“I’ll do—”

“Quiet! I didn’t tell you to speak.” He moved off the bed to stand beside her, and as he looked down at her, he slowly stroked his cock. “If you’re a good girl, I’ll let you have it, but if you’re bad…” He smiled wickedly and suddenly she wanted to know what the punishment would be.

Evan had large hands. Nicely formed fingers and neat nails. With each stroke his bicep bunched and released. She liked a man with nice arms. Her gaze dropped to what his hand was playing with, pre-cum glistening on the fleshy head.

She swallowed hard. She was not a patient woman. He bent over her and captured a nipple between his teeth. She hissed in a sharp breath, as she forced herself to keep from rising to him. His hand brushed her thigh, the tip of his heavy cock nudging her.

He tugged at the nipple, causing all sorts of wild shivers to course through her. “You like the pain, Katy?” he breathed. His hot breath against her wanting flesh flamed her desire.

“No,” she denied. Only to herself would she dare admit, that she liked the pain that came from being dominated. She liked that aspect of her kink to be taken out of her hands, almost as if it wasn’t really her decision to be dominated. In reality, though, she allowed it. The realization should have shocked her, but it only made her hotter for the man above her, whom she trusted not to hurt her. That revelation surprised her.

She and Evan were fuck buddies for the most part. Yes, they occasionally went out to dinner or to a movie but it was always a precursor to sex. He was a good lover. She had opened up more for him than any other man. Though she didn’t orgasm, she enjoyed sex with him. He was funny, passionate, and unselfish. But their intimacy began and ended in bed.

It struck her at that moment that she wanted more from him. Had wanted more for a while now but hadn’t been willing to risk the relationship they did have. Knowing she wanted more made her feel vulnerable and that scared her. For now, between her long hours in the lab and his lack of interest in going to the next level, it was easier just being fuck buddies. No one got hurt. Besides, if Evan had true feelings for her he would not have been so quick to watch another man fuck her. And that was the saddest thing of all.

She shivered as her mind and body recalled the tremendous orgasms that had ensued with Green Eyes. Oh, but what a gift Evan had given her. The tension her thoughts created eased from her only to be replaced by a different tension. She and Evan needed to talk—after he fucked her proper.

“Where did you go?” he softly demanded.

Katy opened her eyes not realizing she had closed them and looked up into two heated hazel eyes. A sly smile stole across her lips. “That’s for me to know and you find out.”

His eyes flared and his cock flexed against her thigh. “It will be my pleasure to fuck it out of you.”

“I would expect nothing less.”

He grabbed her hands pushing them over her head. “Grab the headboard and don’t let go until I tell you.”

The urge to defy him was overrun by the excitement of him having control of her body. Trembling violently, she felt the slow drip of cream between her thighs. She moaned as she arched, twisting her hips toward his eager cock.

“No, no, my dear,” he softly said as he nipped a hard nipple, and pressed her hips back into the sheets. “You don’t get any of that until you tell me what was going on in that pretty little head of yours.”

“I—I was thinking how much I liked two cocks in me at the same time.”

“Yeah?” he said, as he straddled her and pushed her thighs apart with his knee.

“Yeah,” she gasped. “Please, Evan,” she begged. “Don’t torture me.”

“How can I not when you’re talking about liking another man’s cock inside of you?”

“But you—”

He nudged her slick lips with his cock head and nipped at her shoulder. “I didn’t think you would do it.”

Her nipples puckered and her breasts grew heavier as she relived the moment Green Eyes slid her glasses from her face and then unhurriedly unclasped the hair clip allowing her hair to spill down her back, a sensuous precursor to carnal paradise. “I was shocked when you dared me, I thought—”

His lips slid along her collarbone, eliciting a moan. His fingers trailed down her belly to rest on her damp mound. When he cupped her, she fought the urge to raise her hips to encourage him to go further. He slid his middle finger across her clitoris, her juices making it swirl easily. “Oh—”

“Oh, indeed,” he said, lapping a nipple. His tongue swirled around the hardened peak as his fingertip traced a slow figure eight around her clit.

“Evan,” she breathed.

“Don’t move,” he commanded. “Not one muscle until I say you can.”

His lips trailed languidly from her breasts down her belly to her navel as his feather soft fingertips played with her clit and pussy lips. His tongue was wet, and strong, lapping her skin as if he were a dog licking a bone. Sensation riveted her, and if she could have, she would have sunk her fingers into his hair and pressed his lips more firmly into her, demanding he—ahhh, his tongue swirled around her hot nub, catching it, holding it, letting it go before quickly retaking it. His finger slid deeper against her seam, opening her, back and forth, so slow she was going to die of anticipation.

She fought her body’s need to writhe and pitch. Unendurable tension swelled within her. Her jaw hung slack as she gulped for air, and her fingers grasped the headboard so tightly they ached.

When she squeezed her eyes shut, two piercing green eyes taunted her. The orgasm built with a fevered pitch. She forced the image out of her head. She was with Evan.

“Open your eyes, Katy. Look in the mirror and see how sweet and pink and creamy you are.”

She did as commanded and nearly came at the sight.

“Tell me why you took my dare?”

“Because I was angry you even asked it!” she cried.
And because I could have Green Eyes.
As his finger slid deeply into her, she gasped. “Oh, sweet Jesus, Evan, please—”

“You could have said no.” He suckled her nether lips and slid in a second finger.

Her body quaked. She could have. But she didn’t. “I thought you didn’t—caaarre … I mean—” She licked her dry lips. “We’re just fuck buddies.”

He stopped all movement and caught her hooded gaze in the mirror. “Is that all you think you are to me?”

She swallowed hard and forced back the urge to undulate. “Aren’t I?’

A smile stole across his handsome lips. He kissed her clitoris, then nipped at it, causing her hips to flinch. It felt so damn good when he did that. Just the right amount of pain. Not enough to hurt, just enough to—ahhh, he grazed his teeth along her stiff little peak.

“I love fucking you, Katrina Winslow.” He slipped his fingers from her and she almost cried. His hands cupped her breasts, bringing them together, and he sucked each nipple, then kissed his way up her neck to her lips. He dug his fingers into her hair, cupping her head in his palms. “You are so responsive tonight. So eager. Yet still so shy.” He yanked her hands lose, freeing her, and as he did, he hovered above her. “It took another man in our bed to unleash the wanton in you, Katy.” He slid into her, filling her inch by inch to capacity. Her body hugged him as one would a long lost lover. He felt so good.

“But I’m man enough to accept that because I love fucking you.” He slowly thrust. “I love that you trust me with your body.” His lips lowered to hers, his tongue gently parting her lips. His kiss was gentle, but built quickly in tune to the cadence of his hips. “How could you ever think you were just a fuck buddy to me?”

She’d held so much of herself locked away from him because she hadn’t thought he would care, or like his predecessors, he would abandon her. “I’m sorry, Evan, I had no idea.”

He moved slowly but deeply in and out of her body. It felt so good. If she didn’t know better, she’d say she was drugged. He swept her away to a place she never imagined she would go with him.

His kiss deepened, and the urgency in his body quickened. Tearing his lips from hers, he clasped her face between his hands. “Come, Katy, come now.”

And for the first time with Evan inside her, she did.

“God, yes,” he hissed. “Finally.”

“Evan,” she gasped, clinging to his shoulders as he followed her in an orgasm of his own.

“Katy,” he cried triumphantly, capturing her lips again, grasping her tightly to him as their bodies strained in the timeless throes of passion.