The Complete Essays (214 page)

Read The Complete Essays Online

Authors: Michel de Montaigne

Tags: #Essays, #Philosophy, #Literary Collections, #History & Surveys, #General

BOOK: The Complete Essays
3.78Mb size Format: txt, pdf, ePub

57
. ’88: over our
invention and our arts…

58
. ’88: so
monstrous
a constitution…

59
. Commonplace deriving from Pliny, VII. Erasmus exploited it (Adage,
Dulce bellum inexpertis
); Rabelais satirized it (
Tiers Livre
, TLF, VIII).

60
. Lucretius, V. 223; cf. Lambin, 389.

61
. ’88: this world:
our feebleness at birth is found, more or less, at the birth of the other creatures
. Our skin…

62
. Plutarch, tr. Amyot,
Lives
, Lycurgus, XIII.

63
. Lucretius, V, 1032.

64
. Ibid., II, 1157.

65
. Plutarch, tr. Amyot,
Quels animaux
?, 512 CD.

66
. Commonplace; for Herodotus, II, 2, Phrygian is Man’s natural language. Principal sources: Aristotle,
Hist. animal.
, IV, ix; Varchi,
L’Hercolano
(citing Dante,
Purgatorio
, XXXVI, 34) and L. Joubert,
Erreurs populaires au faict de la médecine
, 1578,
ad fin.
, (Lucretius, V. 1077, cited directly, and according to Lactantius,
Div. institut.
, III). Same scepticism, Rabelais,
Tiers Livre
, XIX. If some animals can laugh, then laughter is not the ‘property’ of Man.

67
. Already cited by Montaigne in I, 36 (‘On the custom of wearing clothing’); inscribed in Montaigne’s library and attributed to ‘Eccl. IX’.

68
. Lucretius, V, 874; 921 (Lambin, pp. 430–4).

69
. ’95: similar faculties,
and from richer effects, richer faculties
. Consequently we should admit that the animals employ the same method
or some better one
and the same reasoning… (
Imagination
in Montaigne can include
thought
. Sebond, LXIII, champions a contention rejected here by Montaigne: it is not convincing to unaided human reason.)

70
. Plutarch,
Quels animaux?
, 513 G;
Comment on pourra discerner le flatteur d’avec l’ami
, 41A; Herodotus, IV, 71–2; Petronius,
Satyricon
; and Tibullus, I, ix, 21, cited by Justus Lipsius,
Saturnalia
, II, 5.

71
. Diogenes Laertius,
Lives
, Diogenes. The following pages are largely based on Plutarch,
Quels animaux?
and
Que les brutes usent de la raison
, with additions from Pliny, X, 43, and Plutarch’s
Life of Sylla
, etc. Cf. n. 94, below.

72
. Juvenal,
Satires
, XIV, 74; 81.

73
. Persius,
Choliambics
, which often appear as a preface or postscript to the
Satires
.

74
. Or rather, Flavius Arrianus, tr. Vuitart,
Les faicts d’Alexandre
, 1581, XIV.

75
. Juvenal, XII, 107.

76
. Lopez de Gomara, tr. Fumée,
Hist. générale des Indes
, 1584, II, 9. Cf. G. Bouchet,
Sérées
, I, 7.

77
. ’88: places.
We live, both they and ourselves, under the same roof and breathe the same air. There is, save for more or less, a perpetual similarity between us.
I once saw…

78
. Cf. I, 31, ‘On the Cannibals’
(ad fin.
); Martial,
Epigrams
, IV, xxix, 6.

79
. ’88: own,
for in our own children it is certain that until they are nearly grown up, we can find nothing to go on but their physical form
.

80
. Lucretius, IV, 1261 f.; 1266 f. (cited with approval by Tiraquellus,
De Legibus Connubialibus
who is similarly disapproving of women’s provocatory movements: see his Law XV,
in toto
).

81
. Horace,
Satire
I, 2, 69. In the final pages of the
Essays
sex
is
considered a ‘necessity’ for the vast majority of humankind.

82
. Oppianus was translated into Latin by both Adrian Turnebus and Jean Bodin, scholars admired by Montaigne.

83
. Ovid,
Metam.
, X, 325.

84
. Juvenal,
Satires
, XV, 160.

85
. Virgil,
Georgics
, IV, 67. For the Ancients, Queen bees were Kings.

86
. Lucretius, II, 325 (Lambin, p. 127).

87
. Horace,
Epistle
I, 2, 6.

88
. Verses attributed to Augustus, in Martial,
Epigrams
, XI, 20. The patroness may be Margaret of France, the future wife of Henry of Navarre.

89
. Virgil,
Aeneid
, VII, 718 f., IV, 404; here cited with Seneca in mind (Preface to
Quaestiones Naturales
).

90
. Plutarch,
Lives
, Sertorius (but it was not Pompey); Virgil,
Georgics
, IV, 86.

91
. S. Goulard,
Histoire du Portugal
, 1581 (1587), VIII, 19, 244v°.

92
. Aulus Gellius,
Attic Nights
, V, 15, etc. This tale of ‘Androdus’ and the lion is related in Ravisius Textor’s
Officina
, which is a probable source of some of Montaigne’s animal lore throughout the ‘Apology’.

93
. Virgil,
Aeneid
, XI, 89.

94
. The long series of borrowings from Plutarch on animals ends here (cf. n. 71, above). The paragraphs which follow are indebted to Sebond, chapters 217 and 293.

95
. Lucretius IV, 988 f, 992 f, 999 f. (Lambin, p. 345).

96
. Propertius, II, 18, 26.

97
. Lopez de Gomara, II: XX, 73; LXXXIV, 170 f.; IV: III, 276; Pliny,
Hist. Nat
. VI, xiii; Gasparo Balbi,
Viaggio dell’Indie Orientali
, 1590, 76; Pliny,
Hist. Nat
. VI, xiii.

98
. Cf. Cicero,
De nat. deorum
, I. x. 24.

99
. Seneca,
Ep. moral.
124, 22 (reading
multis for mutis
).

100
. Ovid,
Metam.
, I, 84; it was often (as by Sebond) taken very seriously (cf. J. Du Bellay,
Regrets
, TLF, Sonnet 53, notes), but it does not commend itself to unaided, or unilluminated, human reason.

101
. Cicero,
De nat. deorum
, II, liv, 133 ff. (A long praise of the Immortals’ care in shaping Man. It is indebted to Plato’s
Timaeus.
)

102
. Ennius,
apud
Cicero, ibid., I, xxxv, 97.

103
. ’88: vital,
noble organs
closest to ours is,
according to the doctors
, the pig…

104
. ’88: beauty.
And since Man did not have the wherewithal to present himself naked to the sight of the world, he was right to hide himself behind the coats of others:
wool, feathers, hide or silk,
and other borrowed commodities…

105
. Ovid,
Remedia amoris
, 429.

106
. Lucretius, IV, 1182 (Lambin, p. 359 f.).

107
. Plutarch, tr. Amyot, Des
conceptions communes contre les Stoiques
, 577 AB; cf. Erasmus,
In Praise of Folly
, XXXV and XI.
    ’88: to the
mask
of…

108
. Cf. p. 573.
    ’88: daft.
All our perfection, then, consists in being men
. We do not…

109
. Socrates: Xenophon,
Memorabilia
, I, iv. 12; Cicero,
De nat. deorum
, III, xxvii, 69.

110
. Epicureans, especially, accused Aristotle of disloyalty and of a misspent youth.

111
. Horace,
Epodes
, VIII, 17; Juvenal, XIV, 156.

112
. ’88: for:
‘Among… dignity’
, this sentence reads:
Learning is even less necessary in the service of life than glory and such other qualities
.

113
. ’88: only
obedience
can…

114
. References to the Fall, Genesis, III, and to Homer
apud
Cicero,
De fin.
, V, xviii, 49. Cf. Plutarch (tr. Amyot),
Contre Colotes
, 597 FG, for the remark attributed to Epicurus.

115
. ’88: he knows something. That is why
simplicity and ignorance are
so strongly advocated by our religion as
elements properly conducive to subjection
, belief and obedience. All the philosophers… (Colossians 2:8. Cf. Augustine,
City of God
, VIII, ix, a key text for Christian folly, the praise of which is soon to be taken up by Montaigne.)

116
. Horace,
Epistles
, I, i. 106; John Stobaeus,
Apophthegmata
, Sermo 21.

117
. Plutarch,
Contre les Stoïques
, 578 G.

118
. Plutarch,
Que les bestes brutes usent de raison
, 270 F.

119
. Cicero:
Tusc. disput.
, V, xxxvi.

120
. Lucretius, V, 8; Montaigne discusses his madness in II, 2, ‘On drunkenness’: ‘That great poet Lucretius vainly philosophizes and braces himself: there he was, driven out of his senses by a love potion.’

121
. Cicero,
Acad.: Lucullus
, II, xxiii, 73;
De finibus
, II, xiii, 40: ‘As Aristotle says: Man is born for thought and action: he is, as it were, a mortal god.’

122
. Plutarch,
Contre les Stoïques
, 583 E; cited with Seneca in La Primaudaye,
Académie françoyse
, 1581, p. 5; Cicero,
De nat. deorum
, III, xxxvi, 87; Seneca,
Epist. moral.
, LIII, 11–12.

123
. ’88: footman.
It is all wind and words
. But supposing…

124
. Cicero,
Tusc. disput.
, II, xiii;
De fin.
, V, xxxi, 94.

125
. ’88: natural talent.
Knowledge sharpens our feelings for ills rather than lightening them
. What…

126
. S. Goulard,
Hist. du Portugal
, II, xv, 46v°.

127
. Aristotle,
Problems
, 30–I. (For Tasso’s madness, see
Montaigne and Melancholy
, p. 371ff.)

128
. Livy, XXX, xxi; La Boëtie (ed. Bonnefon, 1892, p. 234); Ennius,
apud
Cicero,
De fin.
, II, xiii, 41.

129
. Cicero,
Tusc. disput.
, III, vi, 12; III, xv, 33;
De fin.
, II, xxxii, 105 (citing, in translation, Euripides’
Andromeda
); I. xvii, 57; II, xxxii, 104 – and contexts. The Italian verse is otherwise unknown.

130
. Epicurus (in Cicero,
De fin.
, II, iii, 7 and in Lucretius, III, 1043–4); Seneca (the dramatist)
Oedipus
, III, 17.

131
. Horace,
Epist
. I, v, 14.

132
. ’88:
vain
fantasies. (What follows is virtually all from Erasmus’ adage,
In nihil sapiendo jucundissima vita
(including references to Horace,
Epist.
, II, ii, 138; Sophocles,
Ajax
, 554; Ecclesiastes I:18). Also, Erasmus,
In Praise of Folly
, XXXVII.)

133
. ’88 onwards:
All
Philosophy
agrees…
(The remedies of Philosophy are not of course those of revealed religion (which supersedes them when there is a clash). But Christianity welcomes Philosophy. For the usual view, see Melanchthon,
On the First Book of the Ethics of Aristotle
, ‘On the distinction between Philosophy and the Christian Religion’,
Opera
, 1541, IV, 127.)

Other books

Souls of Fire by Vanessa Black
Angel Among Us by Katy Munger
Love Obsessed by Veronica Short
Snowbrother by S.M. Stirling
The Queen Mother by William Shawcross
The Lycan and His Witch by Anastasia Maltezos
Walk On The Wild Side by Jami Alden