The Columbia History of British Poetry (68 page)

Read The Columbia History of British Poetry Online

Authors: Carl Woodring,James Shapiro

Tags: #test

BOOK: The Columbia History of British Poetry
7.12Mb size Format: txt, pdf, ePub
 
Page 291
The remarkable achievement of Pope's later career was to write poems which fused the positive energies of the old epic, the anger of satire, and the skepticism and subjectivity we expect in the writing of a "knowing and judicious age." The Roman poet Horace had emphasized his own disinclination for the epic and for the martial doings central to it. And certainly Pope's imitations of Horace, the important work of his later career, give us an excellent rendition of Horace's civilian voice. But Pope's Horatian poems are also his most original, personal, and agitated writing; in their own versions of high civility, Pope imitates but also measures his distance from Horace and, in a manner one could not have predicted, goes on to create a link between the heroic and the sociable in the career of the writer of satire.
In his most accomplished poems, Pope will cause us to imagine some version of himself undergoing some significant development in the very act of writing the poem at hand. Like Dryden, he focuses on public affairs, but in his engagement with them, it is his tendency to foreground the poet's person. What connection there is between the "real" Pope and his imagined, often theatrical, versions of himself is, of course, an important question, but not different from what we might ask about any autobiographer. It would not, however, be irresponsible to assert that Pope's ideal versions of himself make better use of craftiness, deviousness, and anger than did their fleshly counterpart, who, as Johnson quipped, could not drink tea without stratagem. Physically misshapen, usually in pain, almost never without a professional quarrel, devious in his literary dealings even with his friends, this "actual" Pope displayed himself in his poems as a being whose anger was a gift of the gods, whose writings were heroic acts, and whose passion itself could be a mode of civility. Although his poems, like all satire, are public writings deeply implicated in contemporary events, they are also major documents in the history of self-portrayal, not to say self-fashioning.
Pope aims his later satire at the modern, commercial society coming into being after the collapse of the Stuart monarchy. His targets might have been Dryden's: the Hanoverian kings invited to the throne by a Whig parliament; the financial machinery invented by a society intent on growing rich and powerfula national bank, a national debt, stock and bond markets; the standing army financed by these instruments; the political style governing such a societydeal making, influence, bribery; and the larger consequences, as Pope saw them, of this political and commercial energy: a culture in shreds, a cheapened literary
 
Page 292
marketplace in which obscure beings hacked out a living by turning out "products" pleasing to a debased and newly rich readership, or by writing propaganda in support of an illiterate king and a corrupt ministry.
These writers and publishers, readers and politicians, scientists and hobbyists, are magnified in Pope's most exuberant and intense satire into the agents of cultural and moral collapse; they are the fabled "dunces"the zanies who creep up from the enormous documenting apparatus below the text of
The Dunciad
to swarm and cavort within it as they join in the crazy carnival that Pope, with some solemnity and much hilarity, envisions as the end of the classical-Christian culture he took to be the foundation of his own imaginative and moral life. Taken together, the targets of Pope's satire constitute a caricature version of a modern societyenergetic, vulgar, incoherent, and rich. And Pope's positives amount to an opposing caricaturea vision of a monarchical and aristocratic society, magically incorporating the organic order of a feudal paternalism, the sophisticated skepticism of the Enlightenment, the civic virtue of classical republicanism, and the material pleasures made available by capitalism.
Pope's satire is deeply implicated in the actual history of his own time, but Pope's reader should be aware that the world he shows us, like the image of his own being, is a powerfully imagined one, seen through anger, distorted, intense, and very exuberant. It constitutes the first great criticism we have of our modern culture, even as it participates fully in it. These comments apply particularly to Pope's later poems, which are related to the early ones as by a revisiting and a revision.
In the youthful
Windsor Forest
and
Essay on Criticism
, Pope fashions an almost entirely positive vision of the integration of imaginative mind, political virtue, and social pleasure. In
Windsor Forest
the imperial energies of Queen Anne's Tory England, represented as eager with health and restrained by virtue, are the objects of an astonishingly precocious but stylistically old-fashioned display of talent: in the poem's ornate and conventional mythologies wood nymphs give their names to England's honored geography, tutelary spirits rise from their riverbeds, grasp emblematic urns, utter positive prophecies.
Pope's
Essay on Criticism
, ostensibly a treatise on literary theory published when Pope was not yet twenty-three, is actually an elegant celebration of literary culture, a positive vision of imaginative mind generously integrated with social being, of the individual talent growing into
 
Page 293
its tradition, of reader joined with text, of critic with poet, of artistry with nature, of part with whole, of society with cosmos. Articulated in the modern idiom of the Enlightenment, these ideas link Pope's poem to some central notions of the humanist Renaissance.
And these are the ideas that are tested even as they guide the impassioned satiric poems of Pope's later career. Between them and the early writings was the decade and more that he devoted to his translations from Homer. From these translations Pope grew rich, in part because the same literary marketplace he lashes in
The Dunciad
and elsewhere was composed of publishers and readers eager for his work. It may be that his project to deliver Homer in a manner pleasing to a modern age helped to form the wonderful blend of the heroic and the civil that we hear in the voice of the Horatian poems to come.
More certain is it that the voice of those imitations of Horace is a grand and original artifact, made in Pope's supple manipulation of the couplet to accommodate an astonishing range of tonalities, and in his crafting, from its discrete and epigrammatic mechanism, of whole verse paragraphs coherent as larger units of sound, thought, and feeling. In managing the transitions from verse paragraph to verse paragraph, Pope develops the line of feeling, the emotional curve that unifies his "epistle" or "satire." Certainly one way to read his later poetry is to ask how the sounds of speech at the poem's end developed from those it began withto ask this question with the sense that its answer is one of the poem's meanings.
And finally, Pope's art in his later poems reveals his capacity to naturalize the conventional mythology and generic apparatus he inherits from Homer and Virgil. He does not reject this rhetoric, but he submerges it, all in order to bring it to the surface again in versions appropriate to the epistle, the verse essay, the satirethe literary kinds constituting authentic matter for Pope's urbane readers. But in making the old rhetoric of genre and myth familiar in modern terms, Pope does not lessen his demands upon his imagination, he intensifies them.
In the fantasy "bits" of the first of his two moral essays on the use of riches, as an instance, a visionary hilarity is produced precisely by Pope's witty superimposition of the dress and manners and financial instruments of his modern moment upon the ways of older and simpler times. Here, for example, is how the art of bribery has been improved by the invention of the money markets:
 
Page 294
Blest paper-credit! last and best supply!
That lends Corruption lighter wings to fly!
. . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
A single leaf shall waft an Army o'er,
Or ship off Senates to a distant Shore;
A leaf, like Sibyl's, scatter to and fro
Our fates and fortunes, as the winds shall blow. . . .
A witty collision of old myths and modern ways produces this grand and jocular fantasy attributing magical power of enormous and corrupting consequence to the stealthiness and abundance of paper money. Bills of credit are the sibyl's leaves of capitalism, and if their end result is disaster, Pope's exuberant fantasizing nevertheless reveals his understanding of the imaginative intensity that capitalism answers to, as, in a moment of great poetic interest, he colors its financial instruments with the charm of old fables even as he tells a tale of modern ruin. Such imaginative play is a sign of the entirely positive use Pope makes of his "belatedness."
These naturalizing tendencies are most interestingly apparent in
Moral Essay 4
also known as the
Epistle to Burlington
. Here, without any of the shepherds and nymphs and singing contests and mythological narrative that marked the earlier
Pastorals
and
Windsor Forest
, the essential work of pastoral and georgic is incorporated within the conversational manner of a letter. In that manner Pope articulates an ideal vision of pleasure reconciled with work, of nature commanding (as in pastoral) reconciled with nature commanded (as in georgic), all accomplished in the imagined projects of a busy and virtuous nation. I have shown in
Nature and Society
that as the conventions and mechanisms of pastoral and georgic are here submerged and then brought forth in versions suitable to conversation, they are the more strongly realized as shaping myth.
Notice in these lines how the reference to a "laughing Ceres" envisions as an historical, not a magical, process the conversion of the inauthentic ostentation of bad ownership into the projects of pleasured profit.
Another age shall see the golden Ear
Imbrown the Slope, and nod on the Parterre,
Deep Harvests bury all his pride has plann'd,
And laughing Ceres re-assume the land.

Other books

Big Bad Easy by Whistler, Ursula
The Shadow Project by Herbie Brennan
Fractured Darkness by Viola Grace
2SpiceRack_bundle by Karen Stivali and Karen Booth and Lily Harlem
Fang Me by Parker Blue
Valhalla by Newton Thornburg
Darjeeling by Jeff Koehler