The Columbia History of British Poetry (25 page)

Read The Columbia History of British Poetry Online

Authors: Carl Woodring,James Shapiro

Tags: #test

BOOK: The Columbia History of British Poetry
3.48Mb size Format: txt, pdf, ePub
 
Page 106
member of the Elect, could be led into the most flagrant hypocrisy. The poem's opening sums up a central aspect of Scottish Calvinism as Burns heard it preached around him:
O Thou that in the Heavens does dwell,
Wha, as it pleases best thysel,
Sends ane to Heaven an' ten to Hell
        A' for thy glory,
And no for onie guid or ll
        They've done before Thee.
I bless and praise thy matchless might,
When thousands thou has left in night,
That I am here before thy sight,
        For gifts an' grace
A burning and a shining light
        To a' this place.
Satire of a less biting kind is found in "The Holy Fair," a description of the great outdoor communion service then common in the west of Scotland, at which preaching, drinking, and lovemaking went on simultaneously, and the claims of the spirit and of the flesh asserted themselves in ironic contiguity. Yet another kind of satire is found in the "Address to the Deil," where the Devil of folklorea mischievous, Puck-like figurereplaces the evil tempter of the preachers and is reduced almost to a figure of fun.
A totally different kind of poetry is represented by the grave, slow-moving, lovingly etched picture of a farm laborer's family at home in "The Cotter's Saturday Night." In this poem, however, moments of sentimentality and even of posturing occur. These remind us of what might be called Burns's cultural vulnerability: he was susceptible to the cult of feeling typified by Henry Mackenzie's novel
The Man of Feeling
, and could on occasion assume the role of sentimental observer of the human scene. A peasant who had been made free of the world of polite literature, a Scot who was all too aware of the anglicizing forces among the arbiters of taste in Edinburgh, a fierce critic of social inequality with a deep sense of humanity, a remarkable capacity for friendship, and a passionate involvement in sexual lovethis complex character walked a tightrope between the genteel world of the Scottish Enlightenment and the rough realities of peasant life. When in 1786 Burns decided to publish a book of his poems, he deliberately posed,
 
Page 107
in his preface, as an uneducated peasant whose inspiration came solely from heaven. He was very well educated, but he shrewdly judged that the "literati" of Edinburgh would be more favorably disposed toward an unlettered farmer poet, a "phenomenon." He was right. His poems were enthusiastically received both by simple country people and by the sophisticated critics of the Scottish Enlightenment. In a review of the poems by Henry Mackenzie, Burns was called a "Heaven-taught ploughman," and he was beckoned to Edinburgh as an example of the genius of the natural man. He was glad to accept that rolefor a time and up to a point. Sometimes when he was condescended to and patronized by people of wealth and position whose intellects he knew to be inferior to his own, he let the pose drop, and he was then accused of arrogance.
All this is reflected in Burns's poetry, which moves between conventional sentimental verse in Augustan English and lively Scots, with varying mixtures. One might say that the complexities of Scottish culture in his daywith educated people still speaking Scots but writing in standard Englishforced a degree of role taking on Burns. At any rate, he was adept at it. He could play the role of the complete anarchist"a fig for those by law protected"as in his "Cantata"
Love and Liberty
(generally known as
The Jolly Beggars
). He could write songs against the Union of 1707, belligerent patriotic pieces like "Scots Wha Hae," he could play the sentimental Jacobite lamenting the lost Stuarts, and he could also sound the note of loyal British patriotism. After being lionized in Edinburgh, Burns felt unsettled and restless, and although he returned to farming, he was not successful. He succeeded finally in obtaining a position as an excise officer, which he held to the end of his life in spite of getting into trouble politically over his sympathy with the French Revolution.
Besides his satires, verse letters, animal poems, and poetry of popular celebration, Burns wrote one superb narrative poem,
Tam o' Shanter
, based on an Ayrshire folk story. In octosyllabic couplets with cunningly varied diction, from vivid colloquial Scots to formal English, the poem alters the speed of its narrative as it moves from description of a cozy pub interior to the storm outside, then to the dance of the witches, then to the frenzied pursuit of Tam when he is discovered watching them. A masterpiece of carefully patterned voices, the poem ends with a mock moral, and this ironically pretentious moralizing note sounds intermittently throughout.
 
Page 108
To many, however, Burns's greatest achievement was his songs. The eighteenth century in Scotland was a great age of collecting and imitating ballad and folk song. The two collectors and publishers who asked for Burns's assistance unleashed in him a passionate activity of song writing and song collecting that lasted until his death. These pieces are in Scots tipped with English, or in English tipped with Scots, and show a remarkable gift for fitting new words to existing tunes. Burns took the crumbling and half-forgotten fragments of his country's folk songs and restored them, sometimes by complete rewriting, sometimes by supplying new verses to an old chorus, sometimes by filling out a mere suggestion he found in some half-remembered line or barely surviving refrain. He undertook to find wordsold or refurbished or newto all the existing Scottish airs that he thought worth preserving, whether they existed in his time as song tunes or as dance tunes. He traveled around Scotland picking up local traditions and local work songs. Many songs he never claimed as his own but presented as old songs he had discovered. "A Red, Red Rose" and "Auld Lang Syne," for example, are among those he never claimed as his: they clearly use traditional elements but also show his own craftsmanship at work. Burns could put his love songs into the mouth of either sex: some of the most popular are from the girl's point of view (e.g., "O Whistle and I'll Come to Ye, my Lad" and "O Wha my Babie Clouts Will Buy"). Burns could link love, sex, and parenthood in a way no other poet has done, rejoicing in all three. He could celebrate friendship as well as love, drink as well as sex, work as well as play, anger and indignation as well as happiness. In his best songs he speaks for life as it is actually lived, relishing the realized moment of experience. He has songs of posed sentimentality, too, but even these can break out into something true and haunting, as in his farewell song to Agnes McLehose, the "Clarinda'' to Burns's "Syl-vander" in a hothouse love affair that ended in disaster. The farewell poem he wrote for her, "Ae fond kiss and then we sever," is one of the world's great songs of parting. Burns the man is full of paradoxes and his poetry is full of contradictions. His whole career as a man and as a poet was a remarkable balancing act amid conflicting demands and loyalties. Burns was the last great poet to use Scots before the renaissance of Scottish poetry begun by Hugh MacDiarmid in the present century. There is something elegiac about his achievement, a sense sustained in the way his memory is cherished and celebrated.
 
Page 109
Further Reading
Bawcutt, Priscilla, and Felicity Riddy, eds.
Selected Poems of Henryson and Dunbar
. Edinburgh: Scottish Academic Press, 1992.
Daiches, David.
The Paradox of Scottish Culture
. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1964.
Daiches, David.
Robert Burns
. Rev. ed. London: Deutsch, 1966.
Jack, R. D. S.
Alexander Montgomerie
. Edinburgh: Scottish Academic Press, 1985.
Kinsley, James, ed.
Scottish Poetry. A Critical Survey
. London: Cassell, 1955.
Scottish Academic Press.
Longer Scottish Poems
. Vol. 1 (13751650), edited by Priscilla Bawcutt and Felicity Riddy; vol. 2 (16501830), edited by Thomas Crawford, David Hewitt, and Alexander Law. Edinburgh, 1987.
Shire, Helena M.
Song, Dance and Poetry at the Court of Scotland under King James VI
. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1969.

Other books

Before I Break by Portia Moore
The Hidden City by David Eddings
The Twilight Prisoner by Katherine Marsh
Ramage's Prize by Dudley Pope
Echoes of Us by Teegan Loy
Hotel Ruby by Suzanne Young