Authors: Toni Sala
The deaths of the last two dogs, Lluna and Frare, hurt more than the deaths of all four grandparents put together. It
wasn't a question of quantity, but rather of quality. Maybe it's that one suffering has nothing to do with another: pain, when it's so great, just blends together, no matter what the source. Or that was what she liked to think. Was that why she studied veterinary science? To learn to care more about a person's death than an animal's? To prepare herself for Jaume's death? Did her inconsolable grief over Frare's death have anything to do with him being an animal and not a person? People are much more limited, people have that mechanical part, that rational, abstract, imposed part: reason. It's like poison because it pushes life into a corner, adulterates it, separates it from itself. That was how she was managing, right now, to experience her boyfriend's death so happily, so cerebrally; thanks to that she could fool herself with denial that denied on another level, because each level, each superimposed level of awareness, distanced her from the truth of death. Every personâher mother sobbing beside her, wondering if she should keep on sobbing, whether sobbing was really helping her daughter or in fact the oppositeâwas the separation of a person, death in life; every person would always be incomplete because they couldn't ever reach themselves, at least in this life they couldn't ever catch up to themselves, and it was a question she often asked herself while she was studying for exams or writing a term paper, immersed in the classifications of breeds and species and chemical formulas, a question that she still hadn't found the right way to phrase but was something like: could she ever catch up to the animals that she would cure? Just like when she jammed that needle into the boxer, wasn't she like a god to those animals and, as a god, a defective being, beneath her creation, which she was forced
to set freeâto believe inâand, therefore, to lose for herself, just like parents lost their children because they remain beneath them, as all creators remain beneath their creations?
She saw it with the experience she was starting to have of the enormous death that wasâthat over time would becomeâthe death of her beloved, of her future, of someone like her, on her level, of that which she had started to pursue and that was perhaps her herself, Iona herself. Animals, on the other hand, in their purity, live more deeply, closer to the heart of the universe, closer to the heart of life, without the painful, banal distractions people have; they have a pure experience of hate and love, of sex and motherhood, of family and food, of sickness and, above all, death. If only she could have learned more from the death of her three dogs! Animals were ahead of people, in a world without animals man would never understand himself, he wouldn't know how to behave or how to accept his situation. Dogs' loyalty and love for the humans they live with give rise to greater loyalty and love in their owners. First the dog and then the person. She had also seen it with the two horses at Can Bou, one for each sister.
From animals, man learned to settle. What could he possibly figure out for himself, stuck in his lie? Lies can't even exist on their own. Man had to imitate animals in order to be someone and survive. There are no tragedies in nature; there is no expectation of pain. There is a single, authentic pain. Just one, and it is real.
Every death told her: you are dead and that's why you must live. You have to live because you're dead. If you weren't dead, it wouldn't make sense for you to live. But you are dead, and
therefore you have to live life and not live death. If you were alive, you'd have to live death. That's why you're dead: live life. But Iona still remained in denial, waiting for the arrival of authentic death.
“You go with your sister tonight and I'll take my brother, okay?”
“Why don't you lend him your car and we'll take mine?”
“Because his is in the shop, he crashed it last night. He drove it into a ravine. He drives like a psycho, and I don't trust him with my things, you know how he is, all he ever thinks about is girls. Look what he did to his car, and you want me to lend him mine, one he's never driven before, so he can kill himself? You want him to drive my car off a cliff? What am I gonna drive then? Yours?”
Poor Xavi. They should have lent it to him. He wouldn't have done worse than his brother.
The morning after that conversation, her mother was weeping in Iona's room, waiting for her daughter to get dressed. It had been more than ten years since Iona had been naked in front of her mother, but she didn't ask her to leave and just swallowed her embarrassment. She was thinking about how provisional denial is; the wave of reality was heading toward her, underground. Soon, the only thing she'd be able to do would be to flee. Until one day she'd wake up and find that it had all been fake. But that might take some time. Her life from now on had to be parenthetical, until the wave of reality flooded the dream of Jaume's death and it turned out that he was alive.
“What should I wear?”
“Wear whatever you were planning to. You don't have to go anywhere. Llúcia asked me not to take you there. They won't open the viewing room until this afternoon.”
She pulled off her shirt and presented her body to her mother as if returning a recyclable. The last person who saw her naked was Jaume.
Would her mother have taken off her clothes in front of her? Iona's mother couldn't think that much. She was too sad, she was sobbing, crying; she was surprised by her daughter's impassivity, but Iona couldn't cry with her, she had to think, she had to feed her brain because leaving it alone would be like leaving a hungry baby alone with a plate of poison.
She saw a drop of blood on the sheets. She felt wetness on her inner thigh. Her period had come early to eliminate any doubt. Her body didn't want to deny it. Animals accepted, they went straight to sadness, like her mother. She remembered how sad the dogs had been, their eyes damp and their ears lowered, when Grandpa Enric died, when the other dogs died. The knots were coming loose, the blood dripped down, there was nothing you could do, you didn't even feel it coming. It was the protest, the wave of reality. As a person she could deny it, as an animal she couldn't.
That intensity ate away at her. The blood had written on the sheet:
HE LEAVES NO ORPHANS
. Her mother stopped mid-sob and hugged the pillow. “Thank God.” Her daughter, menstruating, naked, twenty-one years old, her reproductive system at its peak . . . In college they were studying mammal morphology, animal reproduction and obstetrics, she would find herself one day acting as a midwife to dogs and cats. If everything went as it should, she would help birth
foals, calves, and piglets, she would interfere in the privacy of entering life, and then she would intervene in the exit, sometimes of the same animal, because it wasn't unusual for a veterinarian to find herself having to put down an animal she had helped to bring into the world. She would inseminate and she would sterilize. Come here, boy; that's it, now, go on ahead.
But her period had come early, and that would help her in her denial. She wouldn't have to make the decision of whether to have the child or not. Because, with Jaume dead, would she have more reasons to have it, or less? A dead father gave more reasons than a living father to continue the pregnancy. A dead father couldn't talk, so everything had to continue its course. But how could she have done thatâhave his childâto Jaume? And to which Jaume, if continuing the pregnancy would mean accepting his death? That was also a crack in the denial: who would want a child after revealing life's uncertainty and absurdity with his own death? Really, who would want that world for his child? Would Xavi and Jaume's parents have had children if they'd known they would end up driving into a tree at twenty and twenty-two years old?
Or at thirty? Or forty? At fifty? Sixty, seventy, eighty? How many would you like, ma'am? Well, if I can't live a hundred years, there's no point. Well, I'll settle for twenty-five. What luck, not to have to think about that. No, thirty or so's enough for me, because I know we're part of a chain and are here to perpetuate the species . . . And what if you don't have kids? What if you can't or you die too soon, like Jaume? Here we can only guarantee you a link to the dead, ma'am.
And what if it wasn't her period? What if it was an early miscarriage? A miscarriage before fertilization, a period coming early to impede a birth, nature rushing to expel the part that came from him, the part he had wasted, and replace it as fast as possible, to give someone else a chance, a better role model for Iona's child. Nature wasn't rushing. Nature was immediate.
Jaume hadn't even been buried, and he'd already lost all his rights. Nature went against itself by bringing you into the world, but when it came back for you it regained its place on the throne. She had gotten naked in front of her mother and, at some point, she would do it in front of another boy. She would let another boy undress her, even if just to reclaim her own body, while she waited for Jaume, so she could give it back to him. Deathâthat death that wasn'tâsimplified things. All her doubts about Jaume, all the ambiguities constructed in the four or five years they'd been dating, all the inaccuracies, were gone with his death, as if down the drain. Everything that was unresolved, everything that still had to be discussed.
She covered her thigh with her panties and quickly grabbed some clean ones. She pulled up the top sheet, crumpled it, placed it over the stain, and left the room. She went into the bathroom, washed, and put in a tampon. When she came back to the bedroom, her mother had laid out her clothes on the mattress. She had stripped the sheets off the bed; they were in a pile on the floor. Beside her mother was Mireia, her younger sister.
“I have to get dressed,” said Iona.
Her breasts were still showing, her breasts which were
Jaume's and his children's, because they'd wanted to have children. They had talked about it, picked names, names that were now lethal . . . Her forsaken breasts were now, once again, her's. Not even that. They were shrinking. They were regressing to a barren girl's. My god. Her pubis shaved the way Jaume liked it. How could her mother welcome the part of him that her daughter embodied?
She wanted to tell her sister that everything was okay; as the older one she had to take the lead and guide her little sister, but she couldn't. She hugged her to console her. Her sister was crying for her, but Iona had to bear the denial of Jaume's death alone, and she felt it scattering, she couldn't hold on to the denial; it was slipping through her fingers; it was bringing her other deaths to life, four grandparents, three dogs, so vivid that if the well had been open, she would have asked Mireia to accompany her to see the woman at the bottom, swimming in her clothes, peaceful, trusting, waiting for them to throw her a rope. That woman was Jaume's death. It wasn't going to be easy to settle into living in a false reality. She resisted at the border of fantasy, entering that country had too high a priceâinsanityâbut holding out on the border. . . it wasn't just that her own body was denying the denial. The denial expanded inside her, a new pregnancy that drove out Jaume's, and countered reality, resituated it, corrected it to underscore the incongruities. Who talked about menstruation? She searched for the cherry tree from the window. It was too sunny for a winter day. No, nothing about menstruation. The cherry tree that festered. The dogs' blood traveled up through its roots, swelling the cherries, dripping off the leaves, trickling down the branches and trunk to the
ground and there, in the day's white and intense light, like a frozen flash of lightning, it seemed like the shadow of the fruit tree but wasn't; it was a red shadow, a puddle, the ground was wet. The other cherry tree was also bleeding, and the peach trees had matured so suddenly that the peaches hadn't had time to fall; they had rotted on the branches, and their bone-colored pits hung among the leaves. Late January and that sun. It couldn't be. The pomegranates and figs, filled with seeds, erupted; the apple tree lost its leaves, and its branches curved, loaded down with red apples. The garden covered the tubers' rapes, the pregnant watermelons burst, across the sky came a flock of seagulls from the dump in Solius.
The two sisters and their parents didn't have lunch; they watched television without speaking all afternoon and evening. Then their father said he was going out for a walk through the fields and left. The funeral was the next afternoon. The silence of Can Bou covered the other silences. The televisions' volumes were low, fewer people walked down the streets of town, kids didn't cry. The air had frozen over the plain. Even the weekenders from Barcelona, driving through the fields of Vidreres in search of the freeway, slowed their pace.
“I'm very tired,” said Mireia, as the evening drew to a close. “I just want to go to sleep.”
“Wait a minute, until your father gets back, and then go on to bed,” said her mother. “You don't have to come to the wake.”
“I don't think I'll go to the burial either,” said Mireia.
Iona felt she should say something, as if she were in charge of protocol and invitations, as if she had the right to
excuse her sister from attending. What was the point of her little sister being there? But Jaume and Xavi were dead, and it seemed that, in turn, the two sisters should have to go to the funeral, like an offering to the God who had taken the two brothers and not them. Iona would go as if it were nothing; she would fly over the funeral just as she was flying over this first evening with Jaume dead. The more immediate realitiesâthe furniture in the house, the smells, the wordsâhad intensified, as if to help her hide from what was going on.
“Maybe it's better if you don't come, Mireia,” said Iona. “It won't do you any good, not you and not them.”
“I'm really sorry, I'm so tired, emotionally. I just don't have the heart, and it's better I say it now. I don't want to worry all night about having to tell you tomorrow. But it seems rude not to go. Wouldn't they have wanted the whole town to see them off? Wouldn't they have come to our funeral, if it had been us?”