Authors: Laurie Gwen Shapiro
“What's a good date?” Dr. Zuckerman asks.
Owen looks at my faceâhe knows I was thrilled to be asked, but even so I hemmed and hawed for a day before coming back with a definitive yes to his proposal. “We'll get back to you on that, Dad.”
“Where are you taking your honeymoon?” Summer asks quietly.
I feel bad saying Paris because I know Alan and Summer took their honeymoon in Cape May. That may be New Jersey's prettiest seaside town, full of charming Victorian houses, but it sure as hell isn't Paris. That's why I feel bad about discussing my honeymoon, isn't it? Pity for a sister-in-law who married my poor brother? It can't be because I'll be taking a celebratory jaunt abroad without Kit. Would I have survived this awful year without Owen and his incredible patience and humor? The year AK, After Kit, as I think of it, started out sour but when Owen and I finally acknowledged our growing connection, I enjoyed my days. It took three months for us to sleep together, but then, we were rarely apart. I was thrilled the day he asked me to move in to his quite roomy place in the Gramercy Park area. Owen and I have tons in common, if not the status of our bank accounts. He loves that I can proofread for him, and I love that he is always ready with a book recommendation.
My future father-in-law pats his belly. “How did we all forget the toast! A Chanukah toast to marital bliss!”
Â
“You're getting married in a synagogue?” Dot says. Knitting needles click from somewhere very close to her phone. “I never thought I'd see the day.”
Eric is next with his congratulations. As he speaks, the clicking noise is farther way, and then it's back to the first level of volume. “Hold, on, darling,” Eric says. “Dot wants you again.”
I brace for the worst as I wait for her to speak. What could she say to bruise me now? Gene once said it best. Dot can't help herself. If given enough time on the phone, she hits you with the very thing that will hurt the most, even if she never has a clue that she is so automatically insensitive.
“So your mother is a locked box on the matter, but honey, you tell me. What happened to Kit?”
I grit my teeth before I answer. “Fell by the wayside.”
“I have to say, he was a lovely man.”
“For a Christian?”
There is a shocked pause at my insouciance. “I never spoke out against that relationship, did I?”
“No, but tell me Dot, if things had worked out, would you have approved?”
“Cookie, do you really care what your silly old aunt thinks? And there are loopholes as far as the rabbinate is concernedâ”
“Loopholes?”
“For children. The child of a Jewish woman is always Jewish.”
I let a few seconds go by, and try to mask my curiously intense reaction as humorous. “Now you remind me of this?”
“I had no idea you had any interest in a Jewish home.”
“I'm not sure what I want, Aunt Dot.”
She pauses. Breathes loud. “Enough nonsense, Shari. You're getting married to a scholar.
Mazel Tov.
”
Â
I stand in my childhood bedroom, really a storage closet with a bed that was given to me. There was and is, as the expression goes, not even enough room to swing a cat. But I never minded, I loved my itsy-bitsy closet room and the privacy it offered me. If I closed the door I could hardly hear my brothers fighting.
I look up at the time on the swinging cattail hallway clock that has always been there. Mom is on a date. With my father-in-law to be. Except they're not calling it a date. They are shopping, as neighbors. Rolling individual carts down the gourmet oil aisle in the supermarket.
She wants me to take my best shot at the guest list so we can go over it together when she gets back.
Since I've visited Mom last, she's converted my room back to its original use of storage space. My bed is gone, but on the new shelving is my pillow sham with its fairy hovering over a girl asleep in a bed of flowers. I really would like to take that back with me to Manhattan. I put it on the floor so I won't forget it.
I remove a box off the highest shelf, and immediately spot some of her three children's camp Peanuts postalettes preserved in a see-through sandwich bag. The rubber band snaps with age as I try to wiggle one out.
Before Dad died we got to go for two sessions a year, but afterward only one session of three weeks. My
mother forewarned us not to complain, as she and Dad never went to camp at all.
“Awesome time!”
were Gene's two sole words on his Snoopy postalette.
“Camp sucks,”
Alan wrote after three paragraphs summarizing his dislikes and resentment at being forced to go.
“Please come get me now!”
“I learned how to float in the creek,”
Mommy's good girl scrawled, sealing her news with a Lucy sticker.
Mom has piled up more remnants of our childhood on the lower shelf. There are our favorite board games including Basket, a lever-action game with “working” mini nets, baskets and backboards that popped up to shoot the basketball that we always felt looked more like a Ping Pong ball. The corners of the Basket box are taped together for strength. The old price sticker of eight dollars is still on Billionaire: The Game of Global EnterpriseâI can almost remember the rules: you could try your luck at investments like diamonds or electronics, something like that. Whatever industry Gene chose he always creamed us in profits. There is Alan's favorite, Stay Alive! He loves moving those slides. A new configuration of recesses would appear every time a slide moved, and if you were unlucky, one of your five marbles would disappear into them. Alan always had the last ball left, and even back then I suspected Gene let him win at his game because Alan loved it so.
And yes, she's saved my favorite, every little girl's favorite, Candyland. The game box is dirtied with water stains. I smile as I unfold the board. I select a red gingerbread man to move around the rainbow path. I race
my man through Peppermint Stick Forest to the candy castle. I laugh out loud. Whenever Alan tried to trounce me at my favorite game, Gene slipped me the “big advance” ladder cards from the pick deck.
A tongue depressor from my toy nurse's kit is on the floor. I pick it up and marvel; it must have been stuck in the side of the Candyland box for thirty-odd years. I was ridiculously sad the day I wrote off that piece of wood, and secretly never felt it was the same with a long adult-sized tongue depressor replacement from the drug store.
Countless other small family sorrows will never be fixed. As hard as Jack pitched his mother those magic beans, Gene begged Mom to buy circus tickets so he could see the Ringling elephant doing the headstand like in the TV commercial, and when Uncle Sam finally took us Gene bellowed at Alan for eating most of the big box of Sno-Caps and we missed the headstand. Oh, and what about the time I lost the seven-layer chocolate cake Dad handed to me from the bakery to holdâfive Diamonds couldn't figure out where I could have left it if not on a car rooftop.
I fight the lump in my throat that you get from digging around in your past.
There's change in the kitchen. I forgot that Gene gave Mom money to spruce up her kitchen with a cheery yellow paint job, new white cabinets and a dishwasher. But there's familiarity, too, a comforting box of Wheatina on top of the fridge. I quickly run water in the kettle and put it on a burner. With no one to set my limits, I slather the serving with heaping tablespoons of butter and sugar.
I finish it quickly as if someone might catch me out. I wash my dishâGod help us kids if we didn't wash our dish after a snack. A box is under the table, marked Shari in thick black letters. There's a fusty scent of old paper as I excavate my issues of
Petticoat
and a pile of my favorite childhood books that further helped set my identity.
The Secret Garden.
I stare at my wobbly name I scripted on a
Cat in the Hat
bookplate inside the cover.
Shari R. Diamond.
I put it down and stare at the ceiling. Yes, who on earth would not be happy to land a man like Owen? I'll finally override my wiring if I just let myself. The onward rush of time always works.
Â
My mother opens the door with that quaint look that accompanies any woman's new crush.
“You like him,” I say immediately.
“Does it show?”
“It does.”
She flinches. “I haven't felt anything like that since, well, I met your father. I honestly don't know how to proceed. I don't want to step on yourâ”
“Mom, you have the spark. Proceed.”
Without my blessing, Cathy proceeded with Kevin, but she had her comeuppanceâas it turned out she couldn't stomach him either. But at least she knows now that she has crossed all of her
t
's in her search for a Great Jewish Man. The short-lived relationship was uncomfortable for us roommates, even if all of it unfurled away from our apartment. Kevin still refuses to see me
as a friend, or even to finally talk things out without the intensity of the day he caught me out. Am I vain if I suspect he dated Cathy as a way of hurting me without seeing me?
“How did you do on your wedding invite list?” Mom says from the couch just before she pulls off her high-heeled supermarket date shoes. She rests her feet on a twenty-year-old ottoman, arms in a stretch, toes stretched, too, the longest line my mother can be.
V
elma motions for me to go into Dr. Cox's office.
“I had a brainstorm,” I say preemptively as I enter the room.
“Let's hear it.”
“I'm officially quitting the dissertation.”
Anger flushes his face: “That's your brainstorm?”
“I want to write a memoir,” I say meekly. I continue talking even though my dissertation supervisor is glaring at me. “So I didn't find a Volapükist in New York State. But I have had adventures. For better or for worse.”
I await his answer. Finally, Dr. Cox is ready to speak.
“I needed time to find my true calling. I had two tries at my own dissertation, did I ever tell you that? We're going to see this Ph.D. through.”
I don't argue with him.
Dr. Cox stands and offers me a pity hug I don't really
want. Maybe I should bring up my engagement so he doesn't feel so badly for me. My financial worries are over, that's for sure. I guess that's what you call marrying well.
“I'm actually excited about this,” I bravely pipe up.
“I have tenure, sweetheart. I can get you any extension. I can put in a word for more funding. Don't give up.”
“I'm done, Dr. Cox. No more dissertation.”
I hug him.
There's no going back.
“O
wen, where are we going?” I say the day after we've landed in London. My fiancé's been driving for almost an hour now since we refueled our gas tank and stomachs at a petrol station that also sold stale ham and butter sandwiches.
“What do you mean?”
“If you want to get to Dover in time for your research appointment, you might want to turn back around. You took a wrong turn.”
“No, I haven't,” Owen says automatically.
“Owen, seriously, turn around.” Since the trip to the pet cemetery, I've become a master of the road map. “We're
going
the
wrong
way.”
“Not when I have a surprise for you.”
“So then where exactly are we going?” I say, confused. There's been little tenderness between us lately.
Without even a glance at me, Owen answers. “Rolvenden, three miles southwest of Tenterden on the A28 on the Kent and Sussex border.”
“Why there?”
“For my research.”
“And this will thrill me how?”
“The old home we're going to is supposed to be magnificent.”
“Then we'll continue on to Dover?”
I expect a firm yes. The last chapter of Owen's almost-finished book will focus on Dover, the site of so many important joint American and British war stories. He went there a month ago and he needs a follow-up visit. It was his idea to combine leisure travel and research, to shift the focus away from the very embarrassing lack of progress with our wedding plans. Instead, my driving companion mumbles incoherently.
A glance at his face tells me all I need to know. Jesus. I'm not fighting back. I'm mentally exhausted from the plane trip yesterday afternoonâalthough at least I'm not paranoid this time. I'm also exhausted from my engagement. Owen's sister Wendy is practically my enemy now since she spent hours finding the perfect band (after Owen said our specifications were retro hip, jazzy and under two thousand for the night) and on our end we've gotten nowhere. Yes,
mea culpa
âI've made a muddle of the big event, avoiding setting a date just like a woman fed up with housework who refuses to face any more pesky stains on washday.
What sort of defense do I have? Maybe we should just
go ahead and pull the plug. I know that's what Owen has secretly been thinking, too.
Since I've delayed setting the date again for the third time after the Christmas greet-and-meet, Owen has stopped making any form of sexual advance toward me, and prickles when I touch him in any place that might lead to more physical contact.
Last night after we checked into a bargain hotel he found on Orbitz, I stood over his armchair and optimistically touched his shoulders. We were thousands of miles away from his dad with the daily wedding instructions, and my dead thesis. He looked up from his crossword puzzle, forced a smile. When I went to kiss him he said, cruelly, “Did you know how long Jonah was in the whale?”
Okay, this isn't a honeymoon, but it is our first big trip overseas since we tried to hunt down Kit almost a year prior. With a lovely blue sky above us, I'm feeling pro-active again; I suggestively put my hand on his thigh. Owen quickly removes it with an “I need to concentrate.”
“What's the name of the house?” I say sharply a few minutes later.
“I told you,” he says, just as coldly. “A surprise.”
We've been through six couples' therapy sessions already, but why the hell
should
I get married if this kind of passive-aggressiveness is what I'm up against? If he really loves me, he should be willing to wait until all of my regret over Kit is gone.
Finally, there is a grand estate up ahead of us on the road.
“Do you know someone here?” I say when we park.
My voice has softened to neutral but Owen is still particularly unresponsive.
Eventually I spot a sign that will have to do the explaining for me. Great Maytham Hall.
A groundskeeper pokes his head in Owen's right-side driver window. “You're too early. It's only open Wednesday and Thursday afternoons May to September.”
It's an April Monday.
Owen gets out of the car, motions the guard aside and whispers something. The guard nods his head. Even though I am despising Owen right now, I'm itching to know what this is all about. We step inside a gate, and walk on acres of land with flowering trees. A surprisingly large number of seniors are roaming the large grounds.
Owen's first words since we parked: “I forgot. He said they've converted Great Maytham into a senior's residence.”
I stand firm on a mossy corner of grass. “Who said? Okay, Oâwhy am I here?”
For the first time in hours, he makes direct eye contact. “Let's go inside the house and find out.”
“Why are you being so crazy? Why can't you answer me?”
“You know what? I've changed my mind. Let's look inside later. Let's have a walk around the place.”
Owen starts walking toward the formal green lawns.
I'm exceedingly pissed off now. I follow a few feet away and raise my voice. “These grounds are pretty, but tell me what's happening here.”
“It is time for your surprise,” my fiancé says signifi
cantly. He leads me by the hand to a brick wall. His long look is as devastating as the one Kit gave me before he stormed off, at turns pitying and hateful.
I'm inwardly shrinking, but outwardly calm.
“What is it?”
Owen hands me a brochure and thenâBoom! “I'm leaving you now.”
“What was that?”
“Shari, you don't really want to be married to me. Deep feelings of affection are not enough. I think that goes both ways.”
I'm speechless. Between Kit's disappearance and my father's untimely departure, I've had quite enough with the dramatic abandonment.
“Read the brochure,” he continues in a toneless voice. “We'll talk later. You'll have to figure out when and where.”
“Where?
What?
”
He is gone. I'm too shocked to run after him. I stand silently, his strange words echoing in my head.
And then I read:
Great Maytham Hall, which inspired Frances Hodgson Burnett's
The Secret Garden
is open Wednesday and Thursday afternoons in May. According to Ann Thwaite, biographer of Frances Hodgson Burnett,
The Secret Garden
is a book of the new century.
Burnett lived at Maytham Hall from 1898â1907, and wrote many loved books here, including
The Secret Garden.
This beloved classic, inspired by the old walled garden at Maytham, suggested children should be self-re
liant and have faith in themselves, in that they should listen not to their elders and betters, but to their own hearts and consciences.
What else can I do except listen to him? I angrily walk through a wooden door. Inside is a garden so close to the description of Mary and Colin's garden that I have to think,
Whose memory is this? A reader's or a filmgoer's?
There, under an abundance of greenery, is a man in a gazebo reading a copy of, of course,
The Secret Garden.
I brave the chopping block. I touch a shoulder.
Christopher T. Brown sizes up my wet eyes as he holds a hand out.
“I didn't know you were here until a second ago,” I push out.
“He didn't tell you?”
“No.”
“Bloody hell! That wasn't the plan! You were supposed to be here of your own volition.”
But I'm here. And you're here.
I immediately start to weep.
I try to talk. “I wish we could wipe away that day we foughtâ”
Kit holds my hand to comfort me. “You know you're not completely to blame. I was going to get around to the whole story on my own schedule. Bloody English. We're such fools sometimes.”
“I met your grandfather,” I finally manage.
He stares. There's a long break before he answers again. The birds wait it out, too. “I was going to tell you about my family advantage over you just before we got there.”
I let him continue at his own pace.
“Shariâmy grandfather beat my mother when she was young. That's why I was so secretive about everything. I hate him, but his father is my great-grandfather, and he was by all accounts a remarkable man, a true enthusiast for the power of language.”
“He told me he was awful to her. I have to knowâdid he rape her?”
“Boy you New Yorkers, you don't mince words.”
“It's my very unpleasant theory.”
He breathes out. “Now I know he didn't. My mother wouldn't say a word more other than he hurt her. I had to know, too. I became a Volapük academic just to find that out, and eventually I told Robert who I was. By then we were âpals' you see, and he bared his soul.”
“Did Helen know about the real reason for your academic research?”
“Unfortunately, yes. That's why her betrayal of me cut so deep. I have another story for you. Helen was my wife, you know.”
“I met her, Kit. I know that, too.”
He's so taken aback that he actually chortles. “What is it that Woody Allen's mom says in
Annie Hall
when she's horrified?”
I laugh, too. “âDrive a stake through my heart.'”
“That's it,” he nods.
“You don't have to tell me anything else.”
“I want to. You can tell me about the meeting later. First I want to sayâmy reserveâ” He struggles for the right words. “My reserve is not by choiceâmy mother escaped Robert when she was seventeen. My grand
mother sided with her husband. Mum met my father in London. She was beautiful, you know? There was that crazy obsession for language in my family, and she spoke well for a farmer's girl. She simply rewrote her past and married money. My father died when I was fifteen. We weren't as close as you and your dad, but I did miss him.”
“I'm so sorry about what I said.” I burst out crying again. “The way I accused youâ”
This time he lets me cry. “Yes. You practically had foam on your mouth. Drugged, apparently. Or so Owen told me.”
“Owen,” I say distraughtly, remembering the rest of this mess.
“I tried to warn you. Owen is a complicated fellow. He is an angel or a son of a bitch, according to who he interacts with. He's been withâ” Kit stops. “I shouldn't say thisâ”
“After what we've been through, you might as well say it all.”
“He's been with Helen for a month.”
“
What?
No way. He had a business trip here last month, to Dover, for his book.”
“To London, I'm afraid.”
It's my turn for stunned silence.
“As soon as he realized what he wanted, he carried on your search to find me. He wormed into favor with me. I guess he's not all terrible, mind you. He didn't want you to have another crack-up.”
“Is that what he called it?” I say contemptuously.
“He said he knew you would be okay if he found me. He said you were still in love with me.”
“Well, I guess he was right.” I have to keep talking or I'll fall to pieces again. “Who came up with the plan to meet me here?”
“Dot.”
My jaw drops for the second time in three minutes.
“We've been in touch by e-mail for a bit. She e-mailed me after you announced your engagement plans. Apparently you didn't sound so convincing. “She's led the charge to get us back together. She wanted to be careful about your mother and Owen's father though. Your mother is very much in love, you knowâ”
“That I do know.”
“So I think you'll be seeing Owen whether or not you want to. After Dot e-mailed, Nigel was the one who really talked sense into me. Funny how brothers can do that. I was moping andâ” Kit pauses, slips the Zippo out of his pocket, and readies his rolling papers.
“I'd like to meet your family,” I say, repeating Kit's words to me from so many months ago.
“And my mother wants to meet you, if you are coming home with me.”
“What did she think of Helen?”
He weighs the question. “She thought she was pretty. And that was good enough for me.”
“Helen is not pretty. You were right. She's gorgeous.”
“She's got nothing on you. No one has those big brown laser eyes you haveâ”
I kiss him. I kiss his head. I kiss his cheek. I kiss his wrist. “Are you real? I missed you so much.”
“So who's the loon now? You've got a loving family, and it appears I'm the one who should be ashamed of my bloodlineâ”
“We're both crazy then. I'm loving my family now, and I know I'll love yours.”
He squeezes my hand. “Mum is going to drag every bloody photo of me out. I'm forewarning you, when I was eleven in my addicted-to-custard stage I got really, really fat.”
Maybe Kit's previous confession about his grandfather and mother was too taxing. He starts to bawl. An Englishman is crying. An Englishman is crying for
me.
I let him cry as I hold his hand. Five minutes of silence does my soul well. I may well get the knack of the stiff upper lip.
“I had a look about the place earlier,” Kit finally says in a recovered voice. He points: “There's the old door Burnett found, but it's bricked up. And this is the gazebo she used to write her books.”
I pat the wood.
“In this seat?”
My cell phone rings, my rich-person's phone Dr. Zuckerman has prepaid for the year, a really great engagement present. Owen has the same kick-ass plan with all the bells and whistles, unlimited international and national plan, photo capacity and texting.
“I'll get it later,” I say to Kit.
“You should answer it. It's probably Owen checking to see if you're staying.”
He's probably right. I flip open the phone.
“Hey, Miss S,” Gary Marino's voice says.