“What's the matter? What do you want?” Some reflex, or perhaps some whisper from my ancestors, helped to keep my mortal terror out of my voice. I sounded angry, and I immediately realized that this was, for the moment, anyway, the only tone I could take. “Get that light out of my eyes! What the hell do you want?”
“We want you to put up your hands,” said a drawling voice, “and then we'll put out the light.”
I put up my hands. There they were, of course, in blue, two of them, of course, white, of course. One stood by the car, while the other came up to me, and frisked me. Cops love frisking black boys, they want to find out if what they've heard is true.
“All right. You're coming down to the station with us.”
People become frightened in very different waysâthe ways in which they become frightened may sometimes determine how long they live. Here I was, in the country, and on a country road, alone, facing two armed white men who had legal sanction to kill me; and if killing me should prove to be an error, it would not matter very much, it would not, for them, be a serious error. It would not cost them their badges or their pensions, for the only people who would care about my death could certainly never reach them. I knew this. It was more vivid to me than the policeman's hands, his breath, his holster. I knew that I was frightened, and I knew how frightened I was. But I remembered, vaguely, reading somewhere that animals can smell fear, and that when they do, they leap and they devour. I was determined that
these
animals should not smell
my
fear, and this determination deflected, so to speak, my terror from them to myself: my life was in my hands. I had not yet guessed why they had come for me, and I did not know what was going to happen. But I was going to scheme as long as I had breath, and outwit them if I could.
So I did not whimper,
What for? I ain't done nothing,
but asked, as deliberately as I could, and as mockingly as I could, “What is it that you imagine me to have done?”
I was gambling on their reflexes. They were accustomed to black boys whimpering, or, on the other hand, defiant, and it was easy, in either case, for them to know exactly what to doâto amuse themselves with the whimper or the defiance, and beat the shit out of the boy, and sometimes to beat the boy to death. I had to walk a tightrope between groveling and shouting, and had to hope that a faintly mocking amusement would be sufficiently unexpected to confound their reflexes and immobilize their impulses, at least until I got to the station, where I would have to begin to calculate again. Central to my calculations was the terror of finding myself begging for mercy: I hoped I would be able to see that moment coming, and nullify that moment by causing it to come too late.
There I was, in the car, handcuffed, in the back. We moved along the road, fast; it was, I carefully noted, the road to town. So, I dared, “May I ask youâagainâwhat it is you're arresting me for?”
Neither of them said anything, from which I concluded that they either did not know what to say, or were undecided as to what tone to take. I thought, They came to my house, so even
they
must know that I'm a stranger in this town, and am working with people sufficiently celebrated to get them into trouble. But then I thought, If they were really worried about that, then they wouldn't have come at all. I thought, Saul and Lola and Rags don't really care much about me; I can't depend on them. The two or three movie stars who had been drifting in and out of our ken all summer didn't know me from any other shoeshine boyâthough I was determined, if I had to, to use their names as a threat. Barbara and Jerry cared, but where were they? And Madeleine cared.
Madeleine.
She gets to the theater at eight-thirty, but maybe they'll let me call her house, and then I thought,
Madeleine.
Then I remembered the elderly man and his wife. Solid citizens, they had done their duty and called the police. It was unbelievably funny. If I had not been handcuffed, I think I might have laughed.
But it was not a laughing matter. We arrived at the station, which looked ominous indeed, and ostentatiously crossed the sidewalk, while people stared at us, and nudged other people, and came up behind us, and began gathering, staring, on the steps. We walked into the station.
A colored boy. They arrested a colored boy.
I became faint, and hot and cold with terror. It was in vain that I told myself, Leo, this isn't the South. I knew better than to place any hope in the accidents of North American geography. This was America, America, America, and those people out there, my countrymen, had been tearing me limb from limb, like dogs, for centuries. I would not be the first. In the bloody event, I would not be the last. I thought, I wonder if Madeleine has charged me with rape? But, no, I thought, don't you have to be caught in the act? Then I thought, No. They just need Miss Ann's word.
But I knew if I allowed myself to think this way, I would lose my nerve completely. The man was behind the desk, and I forced myself to look him in the eye; and I forced myself, nearly fainting, to attack: “Why have I been arrested?”
He looked at me with a curiously impersonal loathing. He was fat, red-faced, Irish, a true believer, a regular fellow. “It's just routine, boy. We'll satisfy your curiosity when we get around to it.”
“I'm sorry. But I think the law compels you to tell me
what the charges are against me. You have no right to hold me without charges.”
His face got redder, and he seemed to swell, and his eyes got darker. We stared at each otherâif I had allowed myself to drop my eyes, I would have fallen to the floor.
“Are you trying to tell me my business, boy?”
“I'm only telling you what my rights are, as a citizen of this country.”
He and his buddies laughed. I realized that I had made a tactical error. “What's the matter with you, boy? You some kind of nut? Are you a Red?”
I said nothing, only looked at him. Again, he darkened and swelled. He did not know how frightened I was. He was, Allah be praised, far too dense for that: but he knew that I hated him, and would have been happy to see him dead. And this baffled him and angered himâwhich increased my dangerâfor
he,
after all, did not hate
me.
I was not real enough for that. I was not as real for him as he, unspeakably, was for me. But I could not drop my eyes. I told myself that there was nothing I could do, now, to minimize the danger. All that I could do was control my fear.
I was not booked, I was not fingerprinted. I was taken into another room, and left alone there for awhileâto meditate, I supposed, on my sins, or else to count over my blues. I knew that this probably meant that they were not yet certain to what extent they were to be allowed to vent themselves on me. I took this as a good sign, though I also knew that this might merely mean that I was being saved for their more accomplished sadists. I knew that it was best not to think, not to undermine myself with visions of what was before me. For the moment, there was nothing I
could do. There was no way to tell what would happen, who would enter, when the door opened again. And, not altogether consciously, I began to evolve a trick which was to help me, later, in the theater: Leo, I said, you can't know what's going to happen, and, until it happens, you can't know what to do. You're going to be surprisedâso
be
surprised. That's the only way you'll be ready.
But when the door openedâso much for the most impeccable theories!âI was
not
surprised. Two plainclothesmen stood there, with the elderly man and his wife. I stood up, and we looked at each other. How can I explain this? I still thought that they were funny.
“Is that the boy?” one of the detectives asked.
“Yes,” said the man; and “That's him,” said his wife. They stood as though they were in a jungle, protected by their hunters, but poised to scream and run at the leap of the jungle cat.
“This gentleman,” said one of the plainclothesmen, “says he saw you coming out of an apartment a little while ago, where you had no business to be.” He raised his eyebrows at me.
Well, they might beat me up when the couple left the room, but they weren't going to beat me while the couple were still in it; and I didn't care, abruptly. I was tired of this vicious comedy, and ashamed of myself for playing any role whatever in it; something turned in me, in an instant, cold and hardâit might have been the abject posture of the old man and his wife.
I said, “The gentleman is a nervous old lady. He doesn't know whether I have any business in the apartment or not.” I felt myself beginning to be angry, and I forced myself to take a breath. “The apartment is rented by Miss Madeleine Overstreet. She is an actress, and she
is working here in The Green Barn Theater, and I am an actor, and we are friends.” I was damned if I was going to cop a plea, and say that I was working for Madeleine, and I was cleaning up her joint. Fuck the mother-fuckers. “I believe the gentleman will tell you that when he saw me, I was locking the door of the apartment and had the keys in my hand. The gentleman will certainly tell you that, if his eyesight is not failing, and if he is in the habit of telling the truth. Which,” I could not resist adding, though I knew it to be foolish, “on both counts, I doubt.”
“Do you have the keys on you now?” the plainclothesman asked.
“I refuse to answer any questions until I have been allowed to make a phone call, which is my right by law, or unless my lawyer is present.”
Well, it was funny, all right. I saw what they sawâa funky, little black boy, talking about his lawyer. And I didn't give a shit. All you can do is beat my ass. I knew they were too dumb and too scared to know whether I was bluffing or not. So, fuck you, miserable white mother-fuckers.
Fuck
you. I stared at the detective who was asking the questions, and I charged my eyes to say, Baby, if my prick was a broomstick, I'd sure make your tonsils know that you had an ass-hole. Believe me. Oh, yes. Now, come on, you fagot, and beat my ass.
ButâI had frightened them. They did not know what to make of it. I don't mean at all to suggest that they believed me. They didn't believe me. They thought that I was mad. But they had not intended to tangle with a lunatic: they had merely been ordered to pick up a black boy.
Well, here I was: black, certainly, and not much more than a boy. And there they were. Now, I was dangerous
to them. They did not know what might happenâif I were not a lunatic, then my story might be true. And if my story were trueâwell, then, yes, they might be in trouble, and they might lose their pensions. If I could happen, then anything could happen. I could see this in their eyes.
“What's your name?”
“I have told you that I will not answer any more questions until I am allowed to make a phone call, or until I am advised by my lawyer. You have not booked me, you have not charged meâit is
you
who are acting against the law!”
One of them moved toward me then, but the other one checked him. Thank God, the couple were still in the room. Or thank my ancestors.
“You say you're an actor?” one of them asked, in a friendly, conciliatory tone.
I sat down on my bench, and folded my arms.
“Young man,” said the elderly gentlemanâat another moment, I might have been sorry for himâ“I just thoughtâI didn't mean to cause you any troubleâ”
“You haven't,” I said, “caused
me
any trouble at all. But I can make a whole lot of trouble for
you.
”
The plainclothesmen and I looked at each otherâfor what seemed a long time. Then, they all left the room. And I was alone again, a long time, while my anger subsided and my fear returned.
Someone now entered whom I had not seen before, bluff, hearty, red-faced, who called me by my name and slapped me on the back. “So, you're an actor! Why didn't you tell us that in the first place, Leo? You can't blame us for a little misunderstanding. Mistakes
will
happen, won't they?”
I stared at him, and I said nothing. I really did not know what to say.
“I used to have a brother in show business.” He choked a little on his monstrous cigar; he sat down next to me. I decided he was probably from Texas. “Of course, that was a long time ago, before you were born.” He chuckled, wrapped in the veils of memory. “Yes, he used to do a routine with the great George M. Cohan himselfânow,
there
was a trouper! And a
prince.
A prince among men, Leo, I assure you.”
I was very young then. I watched him with an amazement which steadily filled with loathing. I really could not move.
“But it's a rough life, show business. Very rough. I know you realize that, Leo, you look like a very intelligent boy.” He chuckled again, and nudged me. “But it's got its good side, too, eh, Leoâjust between us men? The best broads. I bet the girls love you, don't they, Leo?” He leaned confidentially toward me, and winked. “You know, there's a saying, Big man, little tool, little man,
all
tool! Ha-ha-ha!” He pinched my shoulder, and it hurt. “Oh, you don't want to say it, but I can see it in your eyes. You've been around a little, young as you areâhow old are you, Leo?” He looked at me. I looked at him. I said nothing. There was a choked, ugly pause. “All right. Let me guess. It's hard to tell with your people. Let's see. Seventeen? Twenty-two?”
He was very, very good at his job, and I think that I probably would have made some sign if I had been able to move my head. I simply stared at him, hypnotized, dumb; and now really frightened, more terribly, more profoundly, than I had been before.
When he realized that I was not going to answer, he
said, “Leo, like I said before, mistakes
will
happen. All of us are human, and we all make mistakes. That's why we invented erasers.” He was watching me closely behind the veil of cigar smoke; but he was bluff and hearty and he continued to smile. “I hate to say it, Leo, but you know as well as I do that people in show business, they tend to be, well, kind of laxâlax in their
morals.
That's the reason my brother finally just
had
to get out. He couldn't stand the life.” He looked at me with great sympathy. “I'm not saying this for you, you look like a fine, upstanding boy. I bet your mother's proud of you. Where does your mother live, Leo?”