Authors: Ivan Doig
Armbrister may have charged me with being venturesome in the matter of miners' fillers enlivening the editorial page, but as editor he showed a bold streak himself. Those of us in the newsroom learned to sit back like pewholders about to hear thunder from the pulpit whenever he would hold up crossed fingers and announce, “Lords and ladies, I have a hunch.” From his years of servitude at the
Daily Post
, always referred to on our premises as the
Silly Boast,
he knew Butte inside and out, and so constantly tinkered with our journalistic offerings to entice readers away from our despised rival. One time the hunch, inspiration, mad notion purloined from somewhere might be a gossipy new feature called “Around the Lodges”âthe city had fraternal organizations of every stripe and inclinationâand the next, “The Homemaker's Helper,” solicitously aimed at weary miners' housewives trying to keep a family fed and fit on the pay their husbands brought from the Hill. “Cranking up the hurdy-gurdy,” he called such audience-pleasers.
Thus it was that I was manning my typewriter, firing editorial ammunition in the direction of the top floor of the Hennessy Building as usual, when the editor sauntered over, actually looking pleased about something.
“Guess what, Morgie, we're coming up in the world. We're going to start running the weekend stock exchange roundup.” His harsh laugh. “We've got a source for it, let's say.” He flourished the galley of companies and numbers set in practically flyspeck type. “I have a hunch it'll draw us readers with some actual bankrolls to their name,” he said with relish. “Horse Thief Row types and such.”
“Devoutly to be wished, I'm sure. May I?” I held up the galley, the better to scan it. “Anaconda, up three, too bad. Chicago, Burlington and Quincy Railroad, down one, so on and so on,” I skipped through. “Hmm, hmm, hmm, here it is.” My thumb at the particular listing, I showed Armbrister. “Nelots, unchanged.”
“Never heard of the company, but so what?”
“Envision that backwards, as the
Post
is counting on us not to.”
His face drooped. “âStolen.'” He grabbed back the galley as if it might singe him. “Those tricky bastards. They almost made me fall for it.”
“Nosce inimicum tuum,”
I counseled,
“Know thy enemy,” and went back to my typewriter to cannonade that foe some more.
â¢Â   â¢Â   â¢
Almost like a boxing match, that day held another round of parrying and punching. The presses had run, ours and the competition's, like twin but opposing engines in the daily race for readers, and the rival versions of news and opinion had been dispatched to the streets, to be hawked on every corner by newsboys as usual. Most of the staff had left for the day, except as ever the few nightside reporters and rewrite men, and I was putting on my coat and trying to settle down Armbrister as he shook his head over the latest piece of “Voices from the Hill” overset. From the ranks of the Irish, it ran:
My sweetheart's a mule in the mine,
I drive her with only one line.
On the ore car I sit,
While tobacco I spit,
All over my sweetheart's behind.
“For crying out loud, Morgie, do we have to put this in the paper?”
“Of course we must. Quin sent it in, can't you guess?” Armbrister looked even more pained. “Jacob, it actually serves the purpose quite well. In one regard, it is the very essence of Ireland, is it not?”
“This malarkey? How so?”
“It's a limerick.”
The office door banging open ended that, as into the newsroom came Rab and Russian Famine, the one furious and the other downcast. “Hoodlums, that's what they are,” Rab said through her teeth as she stormed over to Armbrister and me, “absolute hoodlums. Jared is in Helena or I'd have him find them and, andâ” Dire enough punishment failed her. “Just look what they did to poor Famine.”
He had a bloody lip. Worse, tear tracks down his cheeks. Worse yet, his newspaper bag slung over one shoulder was torn and empty. “Got run off my corner,” the words practically twitched out of the upset boy. “Couple of the Posties slugged me and threw my papers in the gutter. Same thing happened to Abe and Frankie.”
And no doubt countless other
Thunder
newsboys, Armbrister and I understood with a glance at each other. “Isn't this swell,” he uttered in a Job-like tone. “It leaves us with cigar stores and Blind Heinie's newsstand and not a hell of a lot else to get the word out.” He threw his hands up. “Take me now, Jesus! Without newsies, we might as well be whistling down a gopher hole.”
As the editor's lament raged on, Rab and I watched Famine test his split lip with his tongue.
After a little, I murmured to her, “Rab? I wonderâ”
“Mr. Morgan,” she purred in my ear, “are you thinking the same thing I am?”
â¢Â   â¢Â   â¢
The detention school amounted to a slightly prettified reformatory, the high brick wall surrounding it garnished with a few flower boxes, growing nothing but icicles this time of year. According to one of Rab's remarks, the soot-gray many-gabled residence on a shoulder of the Hill above Dublin Gulch had been a nunneryâa short journey for pious girls from the mine families, now a holding pen for troublous sons from those same shanties. As I topped the last street rise and left behind the world of downtown, the day was a rare one of winter clarity, the snow-held Rockies beyond the city limits dazzling in full sunshine, while the thirty or so mining operations in full swing along the Hill stood out in every detail of black steel headframe towers and bin cars loaded with peacock shades of copper ore and squat redbrick hoist houses throbbing and thrumming with cable work, the entire spectacle as if a gigantic factory had been thrown open for inspection.
The Richest Hill on Earth never ceased to thrill and chill me at the same time, with its powerful manufacturing of wealth and the squalid leavings of that, dump heaps like Sahara dunes and gaping bottomless pits called glory holes. And three times a day, the human equation came into stunning view as shifts changed and miners in their legions poured forth to and from neighborhoods gullied into the surroundings of machinery and dumps and pits. I am not subterranean by nature. Only once had I dared to go down in one of these mines, the forbidding Muckaroo on the crest of the Hill not far beyond the detention school, and it took every drop of courage in me to trek through a labyrinth of narrow, unforgiving tunnels. Yet beneath the ground I stood on, beneath all of Butte, around the clock three thousand men per shift drilled and blasted and shoveled in the most dangerous of circumstances to produce the metal that would wire the world for electricity. The old twofold question: What price progress, what cost if not?
With those thoughts in the back of my head, I rang at the iron front gate of what Russian Famine had aptly enough called the hoosegow school. But looking every inch the spirited schoolmistress rather than a jailer, Rab met me with a rush, lowering her voice conspiratorially as she hastened me into the building. “So far, we're in luck, Mr. Morgan. I've sweet-talked the superintendent into it. If the boys can get steady jobs that don't interfere with school, they can be let out for that period of time.”
“A perfect fit. You haven't lost your wiles since you practiced them in my schoolroom, Rab.”
“Such things as I learned from you,” she acknowledged that trace of mischief with the right kind of grin, then turned seriously to the matter at hand. “I chose the seventh grade for this. The eighth are one step short of desperadoes.”
I smiled. “That hasn't changed either.”
“Although I suppose I should warn you about even these.” She paused with her hand on the knob of the classroom door. “If you remember Eddie Turley”âmy poorest and most ill-fated student, son of a bullying fur trapper, in that Marias Coulee schoolroomâ“I have loads of him for you.” I assured her I was not expecting little gentlemen in velveteen.
Still, walking into that room was a step into bandit territory. Row on row, street toughs who looked hardened beyond their twelve and thirteen yearsâRab had warned me they'd earned detention terms for fighting in class, petty theft, or chronic truancy, although some were simply from disrupted families that could no longer care for themâthe lot of them were coldly eyeing me and my suit and vest. It was all I could do not to stare back. The youthful faces were sketch maps of Ireland, Italy, Cornwall, Wales, Finland, Serbia; early drafts of the mining countenances drawn from distant corners of the world by word of a hill made of copper. In the person of their immigrant fathers and mothers, Butte's hard-won contribution to the American saga still went on, its next chapter these young lives ticketed, like those, to the mines.
“Mouths closed and eyes and ears open, everyone.” Rab swished to the front of the classroom, brisk as a lion tamer. “Today we have with us someone schooled in so many fields of learning it would tire you out to hear them. Except to say I will make anyone who misbehaves regret it to the end of time, I'll let Mr. Morris Morgan tell you himself why he has come. Mr. Morgan, they're all yours,” she demurely invited me up to the desk and blackboard, her eyes saying,
Have at them
.
That introduction did not impress the captive audience as much as might have been hoped. At desk after desk, young roughnecks slouched as if they had heard their fill from figures of authority, as they no doubt had. A fortunate exception, up front amid the obvious hellions, was a smaller, redheaded boy with the face of a Botticelli angel, watching as if he couldn't get enough of me. It wrung a person's heart to think of such a one cast out into the world; why someone had not put him in a pocket and taken him home, I couldn't fathom. Meanwhile at the far back sat Russian Famine, prudently away from sharp elbows and random clouts, looking restless but curious. Well, two such were better than none. I cleared my throat and set to work on the rest.
“Your instructor, Mrs. Evans”âoff to one side Rab tried to look matronly, not at all successfullyâ“has invited me to offer this select group a chance for each of you to go into business for yourself.”
“Huh, us? That's a good one,” a long-shanked tough in the second row jeered. “Who do you want us to knock the blocks off of?”
I forced a chuckle. “I didn't say that, did I. What Mrs. Evans and I have in mind is for you to become individual merchants. With the freedom of the city, at hours that won't interrupt your, ah, education, in which to sell your merchandise.”
“Sellin' what?” another sarcastic voice demanded. “Noodles to giraffes?”
“Nah, canary birds, cheap, cheap,” yet another member of the unholy chorus was heard from. Retribution in her eye, Rab started for the nearest offender until I held up a hand to stop her. “The merchandise,” I went on as if uninterrupted, “is the entirely honorable sort produced at the place where I myself work.”
“Yeah? Where's that, then?”
“At a bastion of the Fourth Estate. At Butte's citadel of fair enterprise,” I couldn't help getting a bit carried away. “At the pinnacle of journalistic endeavor, the
Thunder
.”
In an instant the room rang with wild hoots. “You mean that rag down by Venus Alley? . . . Newsies! Beat that! He wants us to be newsies! . . . That don't sound like no way to get rich.”
There was only one thing to do. Sighing, I took off my suit coat and rolled up my sleeves as if for a fight. Stepping closer to the blinking rank in the first row of desks, I singled out a chunky youth who had been one of the loudest hooters. Gazing at him so relentlessly his Adam's apple bobbed, I demanded to know: “What day of the week is this?”
“T'ursday, natcherly.”
“What if I told you it had another name?”
“Uh, like what?”
I whirled to the blackboard and wrote in big letters THOR. “Thor's day. In the time of some of your great-great-great-grandfathers, that was the pronunciation.”
“Yeah, so?” some skeptic called out. “Who's this ape Thor?”
I glanced around for some kind of implement. The window crank would have to do. Seizing it by the handle, I leaped onto the teacher's desk and brandished the blunt instrument overhead so threateningly that the entire front row reared back in their seats with a sucked breath.
“
THE GOD OF THUNDER!
”
I roared. “That's who.”
While I had the class's undivided attention, I stayed atop the desk and regaled them with the mighty reputation of Thor and his mountain-crushing hammer in the bloodiest of Viking myths. Rab had her hand over her mouth, eyes sparkling, and Russian Famine squirmed in excitement as I led the lesson around to thunder's inception from lightning. “What we hear as that hammer blow of sound is the air being disturbed by the bolt of electricity. And so,” I concluded, still looking down at the pale sea of faces, “thunder comes of a troubled atmosphere. I hardly need to tell any of you that describes quite a lot of life here in Butte as well, hmm?”
While that hung in the air, I hopped down from the desk. “That's why the newspaper is rightly called the
Thunder
, and why I think I've come to the right place for its best possible newsboys.”
“Yeah, but,” the silence was broken by a high-pitched voice from the end of another row, “my brudda tried that wit' the
Post.
He always ended up wit' a pile of papers nobody'd buy.”
“I promise that will not happen with the
Thunder
, which lives up to its word in fairness for the workers. We will buy back any of your unsold newspapers at half the street price,” I improvised, with mental apologies to Jared and Armbrister, who would have to figure out the further economics of that. “You're guaranteed that much of a wage, while you're making profits from all the papers you sell.”