Second Star (19 page)

Suddenly, a deafening shout on a megaphone: “The harbor is closed. I repeat, no boats will be launching from the harbor today.”

He tries to explain that conditions are so bad and visibility so limited that the Coast Guard has shut down the beaches for miles around, but it’s nearly impossible to hear him as the crowd erupts into a series of shouts. I’m jostled about as the surfers raise their arms and their enormous boards in protest. No one will be surfing Witch Tree today after all.

The crowd disperses fast as everyone scrambles to make their way to the next wave.

“Wait!” I say, shouting my brothers’ names. But my voice is carried off by the wind.

I hear someone say they’re heading up the coast to Maverick’s, someone else say they’re gonna head down to Killers, a wave in Mexico; the swell is sure to generate heavy waves down south in a couple days, too. And it’s easier to get around the Coast Guard down there.

“Wait!” I shout again, chasing the surfers into the parking lot.

I feel the heat of Jas’s hand slipping into mine. “Come on,” he says, nodding in the direction of his truck. “Let’s head back to the motel.”

I shake my head. “Where do we go next?” I ask desperately, but I let him lead me to the car. How could such a large crowd disappear so quickly? I look frantically at the few surfers who are left, trying to pick out a familiar face.

And then I see one. Not a face I’ve been looking for, but the last face I expected to see.

“Pete,” I say softly. Somehow, over the wind and the waves, he hears me. My belly twists inside of me; I drop Jas’s hand and stop walking. Jas pauses and turns, sees just who I’m staring at.

I rub my hands against each other as though I’m trying to keep warm, but the truth is, I’m trying to rub Jas’s touch away. Why don’t I want Pete to see me holding Jas’s hand? The last time I saw him, I told him I didn’t ever want to see him again. So why do I care whether he knows that I’m with Jas—
am
I with Jas?

Belle appears from behind Pete, scowling first at me and then at Jas. She doesn’t seem surprised to see us here. Pete, on the other hand, looks completely floored. I feel myself blushing hotly.

“What are you doing?” Pete shouts. His words are directed at me, but he’s looking at Jas.

“I’m looking for John and Michael,” I shout back, but my voice sounds thin, reedy, weak. Pete crosses the parking lot until he’s so close I could reach out and touch him. Belle follows, along with a few faces I recognize, including Hughie and Matt.

“I’m looking for my brothers,” I repeat. Even though it’s the truth, it feels like a lie.

Pete takes a step closer—not to me, but to Jas.

“Don’t use her to get back at me,” he says icily.

The wind picks up, sweeping sand into my eyes, blinding me. “What?” I shout.

I hear Jas’s voice saying, “I’m not—” but then Pete cuts him off.

“Not that I should be surprised,” he says. “It’s just your style. And you never could get over it that Belle chose me.”

I try to open my eyes, but my body won’t cooperate. The sand is making tears leak from beneath my eyelids.

“Once she sobered up, though, the choice was obvious. Tell me, Jas, did you have to drug Wendy to get her, too?”

I shake my head. In my mind’s eye, I can see Jas’s face last night when he leaned in to kiss me. The long muscles in his torso when he lifted his shirt over his head. The arch of his back when he reached for the light switch, plunging the room into darkness. His hands on my skin; his face next to mine.

“Pete,” I say, forcing my eyes open. His face is blurry in front of me, an impressionist painting. “What are you talking about?”

“Didn’t he tell you, Wendy? Belle used to be Jas’s
favorite
duster.” He says the word
favorite
like it’s something dirty. “Until she wised up and left him. I gave her a place to stay after he bled her dry. And he never forgave me for it.”

“I don’t understand,” I say.

“Oh my god, Wendy, isn’t it obvious?” Belle shouts. “I was with Jas until Pete rescued me, got me sober, taught me to surf. And now Jas is using you to get back at Pete.” She turns from me to Jas. “An eye for an eye, right, sweetheart?”

Finally, Jas speaks. “It’s not like that, Wendy,” he says softly. “Not at all.”

Pete is standing so close to him that he can’t even turn to face me.

“Really?” Pete says. “Tell me how it is, then. When will it be enough? Do you have to mess with everyone I care about?”

I take a step back, away from them both. Nothing that they’re saying makes any sense, and yet everything they’re saying is perfectly clear. My tears have washed the sand from my eyes and I’m able to see clearly when Pete lifts his fist and brings it crashing down on Jas’s face, right above the bruise that’s already there. I hear Jas shout in pain and watch him try to shove Pete away; he doesn’t throw a single punch, just holds his hands up to defend himself. He’s inches taller than Pete, but he looks utterly defenseless.

I turn from the fight and break into a run until there’s too much fog between us for me to see any trace of them at all.

30

I run onto a path at the edge of the parking lot, up onto the rocks that overlook the ocean. On prettier days, this is probably a place where parents take their kids to play, where young couples bring their dogs for a hike, maybe where first dates go for a romantic view of the water. But there’s nothing romantic about the ocean today, about the waves crashing angrily against the rocks. The spray is high enough to reach me, soaking my ponytail, drenching my skin. I shiver.

I’d almost forgotten that
this
is the reason everyone else came here—for these waves. The waves brought Pete and Belle here. They didn’t come here looking for me, or for John and Michael; they came to surf. Maybe that’s all Jas wanted to do, too. Maybe I was just a pleasant enough companion to take along for the ride. Or maybe he was using me to get back at Pete for taking Belle from him, just like Pete said.

But then why did he suggest going to the bar yesterday? Why did he put himself in danger just to ask about my brothers? I sit down, even though the rocks are sharp and cold beneath me, and rest my head in my hands.

Even if I head up to Maverick’s or down to Killers, continuing my search for my brothers alone, I’ll still be chasing just a rumor, a whisper, a hope. I haven’t found clues, just dead ends. A hopeless detective on an endless scavenger hunt.

The heat of someone’s body beside me makes me look up.

Pete.

“Hey,” he says, sitting down next to me.

“I’m surprised you’re willing to sit next to me,” I say. “You know, after I joined forces with your arch nemesis and all.”

Pete laughs at my choice of words, as though he and Jas are two superheroes battling it out for world domination.

“It’s my fault you’re with him, Wendy. If I’d just been honest with you from the start—”

“Why weren’t you?” I interrupt. “Really. I’m not angry anymore.”

“You’re not?”

I shake my head. I’m too tired to be angry. “I just want to understand it.”

“I told you,” Pete says. “I wanted more time with you.” He looks so earnest, so sweet, like a little kid who’s begging his mother for another slice of cake, another piece of candy, more time at the playground, just a few more minutes on the beach.

“You thought that if I knew you couldn’t help me find my brothers, I’d immediately lose all interest in you?” I ask.

If only he knew. The truth is, I was drawn to him from the very first time I saw him on the beach, though it seems like a million years ago now. When I followed him into Kensington the next day, it was because I was looking for my brothers, sure, but I also followed him just because I wanted to. Because I wanted to find out where he was headed.

“No,” he answers. “But I felt awful once I know they were your brothers and they were missing. And I felt responsible. I knew if you knew I’d kicked them out, you’d never forgive me.”

He doesn’t look at me when he says it, but at the rough sea. I follow his gaze. What does it feel like to be ready and willing to take on an ocean like this only to be told that you’re not allowed to leave dry land? All those surfers at the harbor today—what will they do with all that pent-up energy now that the Coast Guard has shut the beach down? How strange to think of the ocean as something that can be closed for business, locked up and gated and guarded. Is there really any place to put all that energy when your chance has been taken away from you, all because the thing you want is simply too dangerous to attempt?

Returning my gaze to Pete, I shrug. “Isn’t that what you’re supposed to do with addicts? Kick them out? Tough love or something?” I guess that’s what my parents were trying to do when they tried to ship me to Montana.

My poor parents. They must be worried sick. I picture them at home in the glass house, walking around silently, wondering what they did so wrong, how they failed so spectacularly as parents that all three of their children felt the need to flee. And Nana; my dog probably misses me most of all. Suddenly, I miss her so much my stomach hurts: My parents, too. They were just trying to help me.

Pete shakes his head. “I didn’t kick them out for their own good, Wendy.” He pauses, taking a deep breath. “I kicked them out for
my
own good. For Belle’s. For Hughie’s. I kicked them out because I hate Jas and I didn’t want anyone in my house who was involved with him.”

Pete looks at me now, his hazel eyes fiery even in the mist.

“I should have let them stay. I should have
begged
them to stay. I should have helped them get sober, the same way I did for Belle.”

“You helped Belle because you love her,” I say.

“But I should have helped her because it was the
right
thing to do. I should have helped your brothers because it was the right thing to do.”

His voice is thick with guilt. He stops talking suddenly. An enormous wave crashes against the rocks, sending up spray and soaking us, but neither of us moves.

“I really thought that I’d find them here,” I say finally. “That’s why I came, you know. And now, who knows where they’re headed?” I’m surprised that I’m able to get the words out around the lump in my throat. When the tears finally overflow from beneath my eyelids, Pete stands and pulls me into his arms.

“Wendy,” he says, and my name sounds different somehow. Important. In Pete’s arms, I feel safe and warm. Like nothing bad can happen to me, not as long as I let him hold me.

“I know you miss your brothers,” he says. “And I’m so, so sorry for the part I played. I’m sorry that I made them leave, and I’m sorry for lying to you.”

I nod, my cheek damp against his shirt. He must be freezing, here in the wind and the damp in nothing but a T-shirt and board shorts, but somehow, being in his arms still makes me feel warm.

“I know that you’ll see them again, Wendy, one way or another. They’re out there.” He gestures to the ocean. “They’re surfing somewhere. I know that.”

I nod. Could Pete be right? Maybe John and Michael are destined to spend their lives searching for their next great ride, just like Pete, and maybe just like Jas, too. Maybe I should try to learn to live with that. I
need
to learn to live with it if I’m going to have any kind of life of my own.

“Wendy,” Pete says gently, “do you think you can be happy, even with them gone?”

“I don’t know,” I answer honestly.

“I do,” Pete says firmly. “You were happy in Kensington. With me. Weren’t you?”

I close my eyes. I remember taking a wave while the boys cheered me on from the beach, standing in front of a bonfire to keep warm, sitting on the cliffs with Pete holding me the way he is now. I was never just there to search for my brothers; I spent my days and nights in that house on the cliffs and on the beach below falling for Pete. I never felt so free, never felt so alive. Jas said living in Kensington agreed with me, and he wasn’t wrong. Maybe Pete knew that all along.

“Yes,” I say finally. “I was happy there.”

“Then come back with me,” Pete says quickly. “Come home.”

My eyes still closed, I see myself walking into Jas’s house; the heat and the rhythm of his party, the warmth of the carpet on his floor. I see his blue eyes spotting me from across the room, beckoning me closer. I feel the heat of his body against mine, smell the warm scent of his skin. I don’t belong in that drug-saturated house with Jas; and I don’t think I belong in the abandoned house with Pete, Belle, and the boys, either.

But Pete is right. It’s time for me to go home.

“I can’t,” I say softly, disentangling myself from his hold. The wind rushes off the water, blowing my clothes flat against my body until it feels like I could take flight. “I’m sorry.”

I turn away from his hazel eyes and his warm arms, begin walking back down to the road. Somehow, I’m going to make my way back to Newport, to the glass house on the hill, to my parents and my dog, to the life I left behind. The life that’s waiting for me. But as I walk away, I hear Pete’s voice carrying over the wind.

“Belle and the boys and I are going to stick around here for a few days,” he says. “So, if you change your mind, Wendy, I’ll be waiting.”

31

My duffel bag feels heavy when I lift it off the second bed in the motel room. It’s hard to believe that I was so happy here in Jas’s arms just a few hours ago. The guy at reception told me that there’s a bus stop about a mile down the road where I can catch a ride down the coast for only forty dollars. When that bus leaves, I intend to be on it. Once I’m closer to home, I’ll call Fiona. Call my parents. I’ll go to therapy if they want me to, I’ll go to rehab. I’ll do whatever they say I have to in order to be back home, to get my life back on track, to go to Stanford like I’ve been planning to do my whole life. I am
done
chasing phantoms.

“Don’t leave,” says a deep voice behind me, and I spin around, startled. I didn’t hear Jas come in. Or has he been here the whole time?

“I’m going home,” I say, shaking my head and walking toward the door. Jas blocks my way. “Please don’t,” I say softly. “I just want to go.”