Pauline Kael (71 page)
Authors: Brian Kellow
163
“I already know what happened”:
Author interview with Howard Suber, July 28, 2010.
“I already know what happened”:
Author interview with Howard Suber, July 28, 2010.
163
“had been advertised as a one-man show”:
Kael, “Onward and Upward,”
The New Yorker
(February 20/27, 1971).
“had been advertised as a one-man show”:
Kael, “Onward and Upward,”
The New Yorker
(February 20/27, 1971).
164
“has lived all his life in a cloud of failure”:
Ibid.
“has lived all his life in a cloud of failure”:
Ibid.
164
“98% hustling and 2% moviemaking”:
DVD,
Citizen Kane
, Turner Home Entertainment, 2001.
“98% hustling and 2% moviemaking”:
DVD,
Citizen Kane
, Turner Home Entertainment, 2001.
164
“a first-rate account and I am a better man for having read it”:
Letter from Nunnally Johnson to Pauline Kael, March 5, 1971.
“a first-rate account and I am a better man for having read it”:
Letter from Nunnally Johnson to Pauline Kael, March 5, 1971.
164
“the references to Mank’s drinking”:
Ibid.
“the references to Mank’s drinking”:
Ibid.
164
“There have always been the Welles idolators”:
Author interview with Tom Mankiewicz, December 16, 2008.
“There have always been the Welles idolators”:
Author interview with Tom Mankiewicz, December 16, 2008.
164
“a highly intelligent and entertaining study”:
The New York Times
, October 31, 1971.
“a highly intelligent and entertaining study”:
The New York Times
, October 31, 1971.
164
“superficial and without one quotable line”:
Ibid.
“superficial and without one quotable line”:
Ibid.
164
“he was the one who did in fact put it all together”:
Ibid.
“he was the one who did in fact put it all together”:
Ibid.
165
“loaded with error and faulty supposition presented as fact”:
Esquire
(June 1972).
“loaded with error and faulty supposition presented as fact”:
Esquire
(June 1972).
165
“were to collaborate in writing the prefatory material to the published screenplay”:
Ibid.
“were to collaborate in writing the prefatory material to the published screenplay”:
Ibid.
165
“full credit for whatever use she made of it”:
Ibid.
“full credit for whatever use she made of it”:
Ibid.
165
“That is 100 percent, whole-cloth lying”:
Esquire
(June 1972).
“That is 100 percent, whole-cloth lying”:
Esquire
(June 1972).
165
“vivified the material”:
Ibid.
“vivified the material”:
Ibid.
165
“twaddle”:
Ibid.
“twaddle”:
Ibid.
166
“The revisions made by Welles”:
Ibid.
“The revisions made by Welles”:
Ibid.
167
“How am I going to answer this?”:
Author interview with Peter Bogdanovich, September 26, 2009.
“How am I going to answer this?”:
Author interview with Peter Bogdanovich, September 26, 2009.
167
“Don’t answer”:
Ibid.
CHAPTER FOURTEEN“Don’t answer”:
Ibid.
168
“I don’t really care much about the story in a film”:
Commentary by Robert Altman, DVD,
McCabe & Mrs. Miller
, Warner Bros., 2002.
“I don’t really care much about the story in a film”:
Commentary by Robert Altman, DVD,
McCabe & Mrs. Miller
, Warner Bros., 2002.
169
“saddened and disgusted”:
Rona Barrett broadcast, Channel 5, June 2, 1971.
“saddened and disgusted”:
Rona Barrett broadcast, Channel 5, June 2, 1971.
169
“rated R, presumably for rotten”:
Ibid.
“rated R, presumably for rotten”:
Ibid.
169
“got up and walked out”:
Ibid.
“got up and walked out”:
Ibid.
169
“
McCabe & Mrs. Miller
is a beautiful pipe dream of a movie”:
Pauline Kael, “The Current Cinema,”
The New Yorker
(July 3, 1971).
“
McCabe & Mrs. Miller
is a beautiful pipe dream of a movie”:
Pauline Kael, “The Current Cinema,”
The New Yorker
(July 3, 1971).
169
“so indirect in method”:
Ibid.
“so indirect in method”:
Ibid.
169
“the theatrical convention that movies have generally clung to”:
Ibid.
“the theatrical convention that movies have generally clung to”:
Ibid.
169
“Will a large enough American public accept”:
Ibid.
“Will a large enough American public accept”:
Ibid.
170
“Seeing
Sunday Bloody Sunday
”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(October 2, 1971).
“Seeing
Sunday Bloody Sunday
”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(October 2, 1971).
170
“MRS. GRENVILLE: Darling, you keep throwing in your hand”:
Penelope Gilliatt,
Sunday Bloody Sunday
:
The Original Screenplay of the John Schlesinger Film
(New York: Dodd, Mead, 1971), 89.
“MRS. GRENVILLE: Darling, you keep throwing in your hand”:
Penelope Gilliatt,
Sunday Bloody Sunday
:
The Original Screenplay of the John Schlesinger Film
(New York: Dodd, Mead, 1971), 89.
171
“Peter Finch’s Dr. Daniel Hirsh”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(October 2, 1971).
“Peter Finch’s Dr. Daniel Hirsh”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(October 2, 1971).
171
“the characters here all are coping”:
Ibid.
“the characters here all are coping”:
Ibid.
171
“instantly recognizable as a classic”:
Ibid.
“instantly recognizable as a classic”:
Ibid.
171
“lost his stridency”:
Ibid.
“lost his stridency”:
Ibid.
171
“what few people who write for the screen think to do”:
Ibid.
“what few people who write for the screen think to do”:
Ibid.
171
“mistake the film for the filmmaker”:
Author interview with William Friedkin, May 10, 2008.
“mistake the film for the filmmaker”:
Author interview with William Friedkin, May 10, 2008.
172
“bland, barren, gray look”:
The Village Voice
, February 24, 1972.
“bland, barren, gray look”:
The Village Voice
, February 24, 1972.
172
“It’s a dismal town”:
Ibid.
“It’s a dismal town”:
Ibid.
172
“I have visions of Pauline Kael in the year 2001”:
Ibid., October 14, 1971.
“I have visions of Pauline Kael in the year 2001”:
Ibid., October 14, 1971.
172
“turn into a bludgeon to beat other filmmakers with”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(October 9, 1971).
“turn into a bludgeon to beat other filmmakers with”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(October 9, 1971).
172
“worked-up, raunchy melodrama”:
Ibid.
“worked-up, raunchy melodrama”:
Ibid.
172
“exploitative of human passions and miseries”:
Ibid.
“exploitative of human passions and miseries”:
Ibid.
172
“a lovingly exact history of American small-town life”:
Ibid.
“a lovingly exact history of American small-town life”:
Ibid.
172
“perhaps what TV soap opera would be if it were more honest”:
Ibid.
“perhaps what TV soap opera would be if it were more honest”:
Ibid.
173
“For several decades”:
Ibid.
“For several decades”:
Ibid.
173
“still feeling that they represented something preferable ”:
Ibid.
“still feeling that they represented something preferable ”:
Ibid.
173
“part of the truth of American experience”:
Ibid.
“part of the truth of American experience”:
Ibid.
173
“Pauline misses the point”:
Author interview with Peter Bogdanovich, September 26, 2009.
“Pauline misses the point”:
Author interview with Peter Bogdanovich, September 26, 2009.
173
“It would have taken
Winchester’73
”:
Larry McMurtry,
The Last Picture Show
(New York: Dial Press, 1966), 204.
“It would have taken
Winchester’73
”:
Larry McMurtry,
The Last Picture Show
(New York: Dial Press, 1966), 204.
173
“If Bogdanovich replaces Hopper”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(October 9, 1971).
“If Bogdanovich replaces Hopper”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(October 9, 1971).
174
“I told him that Pauline had said it was a picture that even Richard Nixon would like”:
Author interview with Peter Bogdanovich, September 26, 2009.
“I told him that Pauline had said it was a picture that even Richard Nixon would like”:
Author interview with Peter Bogdanovich, September 26, 2009.
174
“I don’t know if that’s a compliment or not”:
Ibid.
“I don’t know if that’s a compliment or not”:
Ibid.
174
“I thought Pauline was deaf to feminism”:
Author interview with Karen Durbin, January 12, 2010.
“I thought Pauline was deaf to feminism”:
Author interview with Karen Durbin, January 12, 2010.
175
“the best high of all”:
Joan Didion and John Gregory Dunne, screenplay of
Panic in Needle Park,
1971.
“the best high of all”:
Joan Didion and John Gregory Dunne, screenplay of
Panic in Needle Park,
1971.
175
“everyone seems to be dressed for a mad ball”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(October 30, 1971).
“everyone seems to be dressed for a mad ball”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(October 30, 1971).
175
“It is literally true”:
Ibid.
“It is literally true”:
Ibid.
175
“often irrational and horrifying brutal”:
Ibid.
“often irrational and horrifying brutal”:
Ibid.
175
“extraordinarily well made”:
Ibid.
“extraordinarily well made”:
Ibid.
175
“what we once feared mass entertainment might become”:
Ibid.
“what we once feared mass entertainment might become”:
Ibid.
176
“primarily an American Jewish contribution”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(November 13, 1971).
“primarily an American Jewish contribution”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(November 13, 1971).
176
“probably the only successful attempt ”:
Ibid.
“probably the only successful attempt ”:
Ibid.
176
“the Jews as an oppressed people”:
Ibid.
“the Jews as an oppressed people”:
Ibid.
176
“self-hatred and self-infatuation”:
Ibid.
“self-hatred and self-infatuation”:
Ibid.
176
“Younger members of the audience—particularly if they are Jewish”:
Ibid.
“Younger members of the audience—particularly if they are Jewish”:
Ibid.
176
“Thank you for your in
depth
critique”:
Letter from Norman Jewison to Pauline Kael, March 15, 1972.
“Thank you for your in
depth
critique”:
Letter from Norman Jewison to Pauline Kael, March 15, 1972.
177
“man in his natural state”:
The New York Times
, January 4, 1972.
“man in his natural state”:
The New York Times
, January 4, 1972.
177
“directed toward cuteness at every opportunity”:
Life
(February 4, 1972).
“directed toward cuteness at every opportunity”:
Life
(February 4, 1972).
177
“a viciously rigged game”:
Ibid.
“a viciously rigged game”:
Ibid.
177
“If such a catastrophe has indeed occurred”:
The Village Voice
, December 20, 1971.
“If such a catastrophe has indeed occurred”:
The Village Voice
, December 20, 1971.
177
“a victory in which we share”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(January 1, 1971).
“a victory in which we share”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(January 1, 1971).
177
“symptomatic of a new attitude in movies”:
Ibid.
“symptomatic of a new attitude in movies”:
Ibid.
177
“corrupt”:
Ibid.
“corrupt”:
Ibid.
178
“At the movies”:
Ibid.
“At the movies”:
Ibid.
178
“right-wing fantasy”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(January 15, 1972).
“right-wing fantasy”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(January 15, 1972).
179
“falling to the water in an instant extended to eternity”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(January 29, 1972).
“falling to the water in an instant extended to eternity”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(January 29, 1972).
179
“take the façade of movie violence”:
The New York Times
, February 26, 1995.
“take the façade of movie violence”:
The New York Times
, February 26, 1995.
179
“got so wound up in the aesthetics of violence”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(March 21, 1970).
“got so wound up in the aesthetics of violence”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(March 21, 1970).
179
“profoundly depressing”:
Letter from Sam Peckinpah to Pauline Kael, May 22, 1970.
“profoundly depressing”:
Letter from Sam Peckinpah to Pauline Kael, May 22, 1970.
180
“You can’t make violence real to audiences today”:
Kevin J. Hayes,
Sam Peckinpah Interviews
(Jackson: University of Mississippi Press, 2008), 102.
“You can’t make violence real to audiences today”:
Kevin J. Hayes,
Sam Peckinpah Interviews
(Jackson: University of Mississippi Press, 2008), 102.
180
“The vision of
Straw Dogs
is narrow and puny”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(January 28, 1972).
“The vision of
Straw Dogs
is narrow and puny”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(January 28, 1972).
180
“intuitions as a director are infinitely superior to his thinking”:
Ibid.
“intuitions as a director are infinitely superior to his thinking”:
Ibid.
180
“stale anti-intellectualism”:
Ibid.
“stale anti-intellectualism”:
Ibid.
180
“one of the few truly erotic sequences in film”:
Ibid.
“one of the few truly erotic sequences in film”:
Ibid.
180
“the punches that subdue the wife”:
Ibid.
“the punches that subdue the wife”:
Ibid.
180
“The rape has heat to it”:
Ibid.
“The rape has heat to it”:
Ibid.
180
“The thesis that man is irretrievably bad and corrupt is the essence of fascism”:
The New York Times
, January 2, 1972.
“The thesis that man is irretrievably bad and corrupt is the essence of fascism”:
The New York Times
, January 2, 1972.
180
“What I am saying, I fear”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(January 29, 1972).
“What I am saying, I fear”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(January 29, 1972).
180
“Fascist, God how I hate that word”:
Letter from Sam Peckinpah to Pauline Kael, February 21, 1973.
“Fascist, God how I hate that word”:
Letter from Sam Peckinpah to Pauline Kael, February 21, 1973.
181
“Doesn’t Kael know
anything
about sex?”:
Hayes, 100.
“Doesn’t Kael know
anything
about sex?”:
Hayes, 100.
181
“
Cabaret
is a great movie musical”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(February 19, 1972).
“
Cabaret
is a great movie musical”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(February 19, 1972).
181
“distinctive, acrid flavor—a taste of death on the tongue”:
Ibid.
“distinctive, acrid flavor—a taste of death on the tongue”:
Ibid.
182
“The grotesque amorality in
Cabaret
is frightening”:
Ibid.
“The grotesque amorality in
Cabaret
is frightening”:
Ibid.
182
“you can create a new organic whole”:
Ibid.
“you can create a new organic whole”:
Ibid.
182
“the best popular movies come out of a merger of commerce and art”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(March 18, 1972).
“the best popular movies come out of a merger of commerce and art”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(March 18, 1972).
182
“tenaciously intelligent”:
Ibid.
“tenaciously intelligent”:
Ibid.
182
“mellowed in recent years”:
Ibid.
“mellowed in recent years”:
Ibid.
183
“those old men who carry never-ending grudges”:
Ibid.
“those old men who carry never-ending grudges”:
Ibid.
183
“Organized crime is not a rejection of Americanism”:
Ibid.
“Organized crime is not a rejection of Americanism”:
Ibid.
183
“one of the most intricately balanced moral dilemmas imaginable”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(March 25, 1972).
“one of the most intricately balanced moral dilemmas imaginable”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(March 25, 1972).
183
“Inexplicably”:
Ibid.
CHAPTER FIFTEEN“Inexplicably”:
Ibid.
186
“improbable one”:
Author interview with Erhard Dortmund, February 9, 2009.
“improbable one”:
Author interview with Erhard Dortmund, February 9, 2009.
186
“She would throw a little dart in”:
Author interview with James Wolcott, August 3, 2010.
“She would throw a little dart in”:
Author interview with James Wolcott, August 3, 2010.
187
“Sometimes I would just sit there silent as a stone”:
Author interview with James Morgenstern, May 8, 2009.
“Sometimes I would just sit there silent as a stone”:
Author interview with James Morgenstern, May 8, 2009.
187
“She thought that the editorial department should be doing more”:
Author interview with Hoyt Spelman, January 15, 2009.
“She thought that the editorial department should be doing more”:
Author interview with Hoyt Spelman, January 15, 2009.
187
“fossil”:
Author interview with Joseph Morgenstern, May 8, 2009.
“fossil”:
Author interview with Joseph Morgenstern, May 8, 2009.
188
“Pauline was one of the women”:
Author interview with Karen Durbin, January 12, 2010.
“Pauline was one of the women”:
Author interview with Karen Durbin, January 12, 2010.
188
“that a Negro family can be as dreary as a white family”:
“Trash, Art and the Movies”:
Harper’s
(February 1969).
“that a Negro family can be as dreary as a white family”:
“Trash, Art and the Movies”:
Harper’s
(February 1969).
188
“never pushes a moment too hard”:
Pauline Kael, “The Current Cinema,”
The New Yorker
(September 30, 1972).
“never pushes a moment too hard”:
Pauline Kael, “The Current Cinema,”
The New Yorker
(September 30, 1972).
188
“the singular good fortune”:
Ibid.
“the singular good fortune”:
Ibid.
188
“to strive for classical plainness”:
The New York Times
, September 25, 1972.
“to strive for classical plainness”:
The New York Times
, September 25, 1972.
188
“no resemblance whatsoever to reality as I observed it”:
The New York Times
, November 12, 1972.
“no resemblance whatsoever to reality as I observed it”:
The New York Times
, November 12, 1972.
188
“Are they available only for fantasies”:
Life
(October 20, 1972).
“Are they available only for fantasies”:
Life
(October 20, 1972).
189
“heavy and glazed”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(November 4, 1972).
“heavy and glazed”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(November 4, 1972).
189
“Factually it’s a fraud, but emotionally it delivers”:
Ibid.
“Factually it’s a fraud, but emotionally it delivers”:
Ibid.
189
“Pop music provides immediate emotional gratifications”:
Ibid.
“Pop music provides immediate emotional gratifications”:
Ibid.
189
“want Billie Holiday’s hard, melancholic sound”:
Ibid.
“want Billie Holiday’s hard, melancholic sound”:
Ibid.
190
“Everything outside this place is bullshit”:
Bernardo Bertolucci and Franco Arcalli, screenplay of
Last Tango in Paris
, 1972
.
“Everything outside this place is bullshit”:
Bernardo Bertolucci and Franco Arcalli, screenplay of
Last Tango in Paris
, 1972
.
191
“our marriage was nothing more than a foxhole for you”:
Ibid.
“our marriage was nothing more than a foxhole for you”:
Ibid.
191
“Listen, you dumb dodo”:
Ibid.
“Listen, you dumb dodo”:
Ibid.
191
“drenched”:
Author interview with George Malko, April 15, 2009.
“drenched”:
Author interview with George Malko, April 15, 2009.
191
“Bernardo Bertolucci’s
Last Tango in Paris
”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(October 28, 1972).
“Bernardo Bertolucci’s
Last Tango in Paris
”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(October 28, 1972).
192
“having a seizure onstage”:
Ibid.
“having a seizure onstage”:
Ibid.
192
“a study of the aggression in masculine sexuality”:
Ibid.
“a study of the aggression in masculine sexuality”:
Ibid.
192
“Americans seem to have lost the capacity for being scandalized”:
Ibid.
“Americans seem to have lost the capacity for being scandalized”:
Ibid.
192
“might have been easier on some”:
Ibid.
“might have been easier on some”:
Ibid.
192
“this is a movie people will be arguing about”:
Ibid.
“this is a movie people will be arguing about”:
Ibid.
192
“I’ve tried to describe”:
Ibid.
“I’ve tried to describe”:
Ibid.
193
“Bertolucci and Brando have altered the face of an art form”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(October 28, 1972).
“Bertolucci and Brando have altered the face of an art form”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(October 28, 1972).
193
“I remember we came out of the movie”:
Author interview with Charles Simmons, June 29, 2009.
“I remember we came out of the movie”:
Author interview with Charles Simmons, June 29, 2009.
193
“I saw
Last Tango
, not with her”:
Ibid.
“I saw
Last Tango
, not with her”:
Ibid.
193
“stylistically wasteful and excessive”:
The Village Voice
, February 1, 1973.
“stylistically wasteful and excessive”:
The Village Voice
, February 1, 1973.
193
“its best scenes are isolated from each other”:
Ibid.
“its best scenes are isolated from each other”:
Ibid.
194
“Under ordinary circumstances”:
Ibid.
“Under ordinary circumstances”:
Ibid.
194
“That . . . was her last tango with Sarris”:
Author interview with Hoyt Spelman, January 15, 2009.
“That . . . was her last tango with Sarris”:
Author interview with Hoyt Spelman, January 15, 2009.
194
“the ultimate princess fantasy”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(November 11, 1972).
“the ultimate princess fantasy”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(November 11, 1972).
194
“too sensitive for this world”:
Ibid.
“too sensitive for this world”:
Ibid.
194
“ridiculously swank”:
Ibid.
“ridiculously swank”:
Ibid.
194
“a writer’s performance”:
Ibid.
“a writer’s performance”:
Ibid.
195
“wanted Frank Perry to direct”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(November 11, 1972).
“wanted Frank Perry to direct”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(November 11, 1972).
Other books
Detour by Martin M. Goldsmith
Render Unto Caesar by Gillian Bradshaw
Handful of Heaven by Jillian Hart
Toby's Room by Pat Barker
The Deserters: A Hidden History of World War II by Charles Glass
The Pillow Fight by Nicholas Monsarrat
Transcendence by Christopher McKitterick
Agatha Webb by Anna Katharine Green
The Deep by Helen Dunmore
Action (Hollywood Nights (Book 7)) by North, Cara
