Nothing but Trouble (11 page)

“Why do you always have to go looking for trouble?”

Now that wasn’t fair. He, in fact, was the one who’d started all this. “I’m not looking for trouble. I’m just trying to be the friend I should have been . . . would like to be.”

No, if she were honest, there was more to it. Like proving that Trudi’s husband wasn’t a murderer and that she wasn’t an abysmal judge of character by putting Davy in Trudi’s care. Or that she wasn’t a giant failure as an aunt for getting him kicked out of Fellows.

Well, there wasn’t much hope of changing that. “Besides, is there trouble?” She said it sweetly, batting her eyelashes.

His face was stone. “Trudi seems to think that Ernie Hoffman was killed by his son, Tucker.”

“Really? I wonder how she got that idea.”

Boone shook his head like he wasn’t buying her bluff.

“Okay, okay, so I
might
have suggested something to that effect this afternoon when I dropped by Peppermint Fence to pick up Davy. But, Boone, the poor woman had been on the telephone for most of the day, trying to scrape up 10 percent of
the
one-hundred-thousand-dollar minimum bond
 
—hello, what kind of judge sets that?
 
—for murder. Now Jack’s stuck there at least for the entire weekend, if not longer.”

“He’s a flight risk. We placed him at the scene around the time of death. He had means
 
—a guy who’s a physical therapist could certainly break a man’s neck. And he had motive
 
—Ernie took his money. We traced a wire transfer from Jack’s account to Ernie’s the day of the murder that Jack finally admitted knowing about. Which was why he attacked Ernie at the country club. At best, Ernie lost Jack’s money. At worst, he stole it.”

“I don’t think old Mr. H. was a thief. And I can’t believe Jack is a killer.”

“Why? Because you feel sorry for him?” Boone took off his glasses and shoved them into his pocket. “I’m not the bad guy here.”

“Turning over a new leaf?”

“Sometimes, PJ
 
—”

“What, can’t take the truth?”

Boone’s eyes flashed. “You might not know the entire story; did you ever think of that?”

“I know enough. And unless the bank gives Trudi a second mortgage, Jack’s in for a long stay at Kellogg Sing Sing. I hope you’re proud of yourself.”

“You act as if I’m a vigilante posse. For pete’s sake, PJ, I’m a cop. We arrest people.”

“That seems to be what you Buckams do best.”

Boone gave a quick intake of breath. PJ looked away, running her hands up her arms, now blistered with a chill.

“The thing is, we haven’t had a murder in Kellogg since I was in seventh grade.”

PJ glanced at his cold expression.

“Until you came to town.”

“You don’t think I’m responsi
 
—”

“I think you’re sticking your nose in where you shouldn’t.” He leaned close and PJ tried to dismiss the fact that summer air clung to him like sweet cologne. “Guess what, PJ
 
—I actually went to school to become a cop, and I just might know what I’m doing.”

He slid a step closer to her, and PJ felt the doorframe needle up her spine. His look softened as he scanned her face. She’d forgotten how handsome he . . . was . . . no, she
hadn’t
forgotten, not at all. He still started a smile with a slow curve on one side and had dark lashes that framed those pale blue eyes. PJ drew in a long breath and realized that was a mistake.

“We found our killer. You should be cheering.”

“Boone, I just think you should look at Tucker Hoffman. And did you ever get ahold of Carol Billings?” Her voice, however, ended with a tremor that belied her frustration. “I gave the list of Jack’s appointments and his journal to Trudi, but
 
—”

Oops. She might have given too much away there. She wanted to slap her forehead, but that would really convict her.

Boone narrowed his eyes slightly, then looked at her lips. “Carol Billings is out of town and has been for two weeks. And, yes, I checked Tucker’s alibi. He was teaching summer school all day.”

Not all day. After all, he’d had time to stop by and fight with his father. PJ’s voice dropped to a whisper. “Don’t you think it’s weird that Carol would make an appointment during the time she’s out of town?”

“She claims she never made the appointment. She was at a
funeral when Jack says he went to her house.” Boone touched her face gently with two fingers. “What are you doing back here, anyway?” His voice held the tone that had chased her for a decade, the one that found her in that naive place between asleep and awake. “You shouldn’t be here. Not now. Don’t you know that when you’re around I can’t think straight?”

Oh.

When he leaned close, PJ lifted her face, caught in the sweet danger of being in the hot circle of his embrace, churning up unfinished business.

“Aunt PJ!”

Boone jerked away as if he’d been slapped.

“Davy!” She ducked under Boone’s arm, her heart nearly cutting off her air, and almost ran to her four-year-old savior. She turned Davy toward the kitchen to wipe the chocolate from his face.

“PJ, listen to me.” Boone came up behind her. She caught warning in his voice, even if it still held a tremor of desire. “Just let me do my job. If Jack is innocent, justice will be served.”

PJ whirled hard, the emotions in her throat swift and fresh. “Oh yeah, I know all about justice. Like the fact that the man I thought I . . . the man I almost . . . well, the guy who told me that he loved me let the entire town think I burned down the country club, and he didn’t say a word to defend me
 
—”

“That’s not exactly how
 
—”

“Why didn’t you tell them the truth, Boone?” Her voice cracked. “That you were the one who was smoking, not me? That I was waiting for you, like you asked me to while you went and bragged to your football buddies about me and about what we were going to do.”

“I wasn’t bragging
 
—”

“I don’t want to know what you were doing. But you should have stood up for me, told them it wasn’t my fault.”

“I had my scholarship
 
—”

“You lied to save your own skin.”

He flinched. Oh, how she wanted to slap him. And perhaps in a different life, a different time, she would have. Only she wasn’t that person anymore. Or was trying not to be.

She schooled her voice, glancing at Davy. “I hope you did well at the university. I never did make it to college.”

“That wasn’t my fault
 
—”

“Do you seriously think I could have gone to the same school
 
—seen you on campus every day? You were my whole life, Boone. I didn’t even apply at any other colleges. And then it was too late.”

“You were my life too. You and football. Only you were gone, and I broke my ankle in preseason practice. I never got to play. Ever. I lost my scholarship and joined the army.”

That snapped the wind out of her sails. Just long enough for Boone to gather his feet under him.

“You don’t know the mess you left behind.”

“
I
left behind
 
—”

“Me, Peej. You left me. I wasn’t ready to lose you.” His voice sounded as if he’d torn it from someplace inside. “Do you have any idea what life was like after you left town? You weren’t the only one whose life derailed that night. And I had
more
to prove than you
 
—I still do.”

He took a step toward her, but she held up her hand. “Don’t
 
—”

His face quivered, emotion flashing across it, but he kept
his voice tight. “I felt sick. I even drove down to your aunt’s place in South Dakota once I got the address from your sister, but you’d already left.”

“I couldn’t stay there.”

“But you didn’t come back to me either. Sheesh, PJ, I thought . . . yeah, okay, I loved you. And I thought you loved me back. What about this?” He yanked up his shirtsleeve, and the name
PJ
on his shoulder, small and defined, matched the
Boone
on hers. PJ felt the urge to put her hand over it, hide it, or even trace it back into her heart. But she couldn’t move. Because everything she’d hoped for
 
—too much, probably
 
—shone right there in his eyes, crisp and brilliant.

He let his shirtsleeve fall. “That meant something to me
 
—everything to me. I was ready to marry you.” He shook his head, turning away from her.

She saw herself going up to him, touching his back, calming the fury she saw between his tense shoulder blades.

But she couldn’t go back there, not without tripping over all the baggage she’d dragged behind her
 
—and after ten years, she needed a virtual trailer. Most of all, she wasn’t the girl he’d chased to South Dakota. And she needed a man who believed in her now.

“I didn’t know you did that.”

“What, loved you?” His voice hovered just above a whisper.

“Came to South Dakota.”

He let a beat pass. “I went to California too. Connie told me you were living on the beach there, and I took one summer . . . and tried to find you.”

He turned, his blue eyes in hers.

“No, you didn’t.”

“Yes, PJ, I did. But you were gone. Again.” A muscle pulled in his jaw. “You have no idea how sorry I am. How many nights I tossed away, wishing I could take back that night, wishing you could hear me call, see me looking for you. The best day of my life was when I pulled into the country club on Sunday and saw you standing there, as if you’d never left.” He took a step closer to her, and she didn’t stop him. “I want you back.”

PJ closed her eyes, the words rushing over her like an ocean wave. The floor tilted under her.

“But you and I have nothing to do with Jack. Stay away from my investigation.” His breath touched her face.

She opened her eyes. “He’s innocent, Boone.” But her voice lacked muscle.

“Everything I’ve uncovered points to Jack.”

“But
 
—”

“Hey, I’m a cop. You can trust me.”

Oh, how she longed to trust him
 
—especially now, with his heart wide open for her to see his regrets. But something inside tightened down, her scars hardening to close over the tender flesh of her own heart.

He must have seen the doubt in her eyes. “Okay, maybe I should rephrase. What if I say, if you don’t trust me, I’ll make sure you get more than a suspended sentence this time?”

She tried for a nasty look, but he reached out and ran his hand behind her neck, and it felt so warm and familiar and safe . . .

“Boone, stop,” PJ whispered, but it came out against the soft smile curling his lips as he leaned close. Too close. And
of course, her heartbeat slammed against the thumb caressing her neck to betray her. “Jack is innocent; I know it.”

He gave her a one-eyed wince. “Peej
 
—”

“What if I can prove it?”

“I don’t want you to prove it.” His lips moved against her neck, a shiver of dormant feelings brushing through her. “Don’t you get that part?”

She sighed, put her hands on his chest, and pushed with everything she had inside her, which at the moment, seemed feeble. In fact, she couldn’t be sure if she didn’t just hang on.

He took a half step back. “All right. I’ll dig a little. If you promise to behave. And if Jack Wilkes is innocent . . . I’ll . . .” He took her face in his wide, warm hands. “I’ll . . . take out an ad and tell Kellogg that you didn’t set fire to the country club.”

Oh no, he’d made her laugh. In the back of her brain she knew he was just trying to charm her . . . but his eyes were on fire as he drew her to him, angled his head . . .

“What on earth is going on in here?”

This time PJ was the one who jumped. Her mother stood at the front door, her hazel eyes cold as she stared at Boone.

What was her mother doing here? PJ needed some sort of early warning system if her mother was going to suddenly start popping into her life.

Boone took one look at Elizabeth Sugar and let go of PJ as if she might be made of fire. Amazing how fast a nearly thirty-year-old man could morph into a teenager with a look of sheepishness. “Mrs. Sugar
 
—”

“Get out, Boone. Now.”

PJ opened her mouth to defend Boone, but her mother’s
tone touched something inside her. It sounded just a little like . . . panic.

Boone clenched his jaw tight as he strode out without a word.

Elizabeth’s icy look nearly sent PJ racing out behind him. “I can’t believe you let him in the house after . . . after . . . Haven’t you learned anything?”

“Calm down, Mom. He was just filling me in on Mr. Hoffman’s murder. They have Trudi’s husband in custody, but I know he’s innocent.”

“And you’re the town crier?”

“What brings you by?” PJ gave her a little hug, still feeling Boone’s hands in her hair.

“I don’t like that Boone coming around here. He’s just going to get you in trouble again.”

PJ stared at her mother as she unwrapped her head scarf, pulled off her driving gloves. Get
her
in trouble? And here she’d always figured her mother believed Boone’s side of the story. “I know. So, what’s up?”

“I brought another box by that I thought you could go through.”

PJ peered past her to the driveway. The Mercedes backseat looked piled high with the file boxes from her closet. “I would have come by tomorrow.”

“I’m sure you would have,” her mom said, not sounding sure at all. She brushed past PJ, into the house. “David? Come give Grandma a hug.”

Davy ran to her from the far side of the kitchen, still chocolated.

“So nice that you’re remaking friends in town,” Elizabeth
said, glancing at PJ. “Although . . . are you sure you want to run around with Trudi again?”

She made it sound like Trudi was stationed on the nearest street corner. “She’s married with two kids. And Trudi is about the only friend I have in town.”

“What about Kristi Farr? She liked you.”

“No, she liked Boone.” In fact, ten years clear of Boone’s whirlpool of power, she wondered who had been groupies and who had been true friends.