Read Making It: Radical Home Ec for a Post-Consumer World Online
Authors: Kelly Coyne,Erik Knutzen
MAKING YOUR OWN SOAP RECIPES
You can experiment with any oil or fat to make your own custom soaps. Jojoba oil, avocado oil, and wheat germ oil, to name a few, make luxurious moisturizing bars. However, soap making isn’t easy to improvise. There’s some pretty advanced chemistry behind it. Different oils give different characteristics to soap, and each oil requires different amounts of lye to saponify properly. For this same reason, you should never simply double or halve a soap recipe. Miscalculations can result in soap that is too harsh or in soap that never sets up. Fortunately, there are all sorts of free online soap calculators. Just search “soap calculator” or “lye calculator.” Enter the kinds of oil you want to use, and the amounts you want to use, and the calculator will generate the amount of lye and water necessary for the recipe.
Homemade Liquid Soap
Genuine liquid soap, the thick, rich sort, requires long cooking over very low heat in a large slow cooker. It also requires potassium hydroxide instead of sodium hydroxide, and potassium hydroxide cannot be found in stores but must be special ordered from chemical or soaping supply companies. It is true that you can extract potassium hydroxide from wood ash, as seen in Project 43, Making Soap the Hard Way, but it is difficult to adapt a standardized liquid soap recipe to the vagaries of homemade lye. For these reasons, we’ve not tackled liquid soap ourselves yet, so are not including a recipe for it in this book. If you want to try making liquid soap, most soapmaking manuals will include at least one recipe.
If you’re hankering after the tidiness of pumped hand soap, it’s easy to make watered-down liquid castile soap (like Dr. Bronner’s) work for that purpose—you just need to use a foaming pump. They can be bought new or easily reused. See, these newfangled foam pumps require the soap inside to be highly diluted in order to function properly. They’re ideal for the purpose. Just fill one with diluted liquid castile soap or even throw some chips of bar soap in the container and fill the rest of it up with water. The soap chips will dissolve into a dilute solution ideal for making foam. Of course, you can use diluted soap in nonfoaming pumps too, it’s just a little runny.
43>
Making Soap the Hard Way
What if you couldn’t get nice vegetable oils to make soap? What if you had no access to sodium hydroxide? We like to mull over hypothetical apocalyptic scenarios like this, because it leads to interesting discoveries.
As you learned in the last project, soap is made with fat and lye. These days, vegetable oils are inexpensive and widely available, but if that weren’t the case, the oils would be hard to make at home because of the sheer volume of plant matter necessary to extract oil in quantity. It is far easier to collect fat from animal sources. Homemade soap was once made entirely with animal fat, either tallow from cows and deer or lard from pigs. Better soap was made with high-grade fats, but workable soap could be made with scraps and cooking fats saved from the kitchen. Lye was made by filtering water through wood ashes. Ashes from the stove and fireplace were put aside for this purpose. Wood ash lye (potassium hydroxide) does not make hard soap. It makes a sort of soap paste, which years ago was kept in crocks and scooped up for washing.
Having made this soap, we’d say that we’re mighty grateful for blenders, olive oil, and sodium hydroxide in a jar. But we also like knowing that we
can
make soap from absolute scratch, if we have to.
Making truly homemade soap is a three-part process:
Part 1: Making Lye
PREPARATION:
1 hour
WAITING:
24 hours
Folks used to save all their ashes in a wooden barrel with a drain built into the bottom or in a trough-shaped ash hopper. The lye barrel or hopper was left open to the rain, and the rainwater leached through the ashes and became lye, which dripped out into a small receptacle bucket. The weak lye in that bucket was collected for general household cleaning. Clothes were washed in lye water, too, as opposed to soap and water, in a process called bucking. To make soap, people needed to make a stronger lye solution. To do this, they either passed the weak lye through ash again and again, or they boiled it down until the solution became strong enough to float an egg. Egg floating sounds bizarre, but it is a primitive test to determine, in chemistry terms, the relative density or specific gravity of the solution.
While you could make your own leaching barrel by packing a 5-gallon plastic bucket with ashes, we’re going to share a faster method with you.
YOU’LL NEED
*
Note on ash:
Ash for lye making must always be the white, feathery ash that comes from a hot fire. Charcoal will interfere with the lye’s effectiveness, so use a colander to sift out black charcoal chunks. The best wood ash lye is made with burnt hardwood (oak, hickory, maple, etc.) or fruitwood (apple, cherry, etc.). Don’t use softwood, like pine, because it is too resinous. The ash of dried seaweed, bracken fern, and even palm fronds can be used as well.
PUTTING IT TOGETHER
SOAK THE ASH
Scoop the 16 cups of ash into the pillowcase and knot the top. Put the pillowcase in the bucket and pour the 2 gallons of boiling water over it. You don’t have to add the water all at once—you can add it in kettle-size increments as you heat it. Put the bucket somewhere safe, out of the way of children and pets. Let it sit overnight. Anytime you think of it, put on a pair of kitchen gloves and slosh the pillowcase up and down a few times, like a tea bag. Be careful not to splash your skin as you do this.
The next day, don gloves and goggles and raise the pillowcase out of the water. Let the first rush of water drain out, then contrive some way to suspend the pillowcase over the bucket to finish draining. You want to collect every last drop of that ashy goodness, so leave the ashes suspended until they stop dripping entirely—several hours or overnight.
TEST THE LYE
When it’s all drained, you’ll probably have a gallon of lye, and this lye will probably need to be cooked down to reach soap-making strength. Test it two ways.
First, we recommend you do a preliminary test with our Cabbage Patch pH Indicator, just to make sure you’re on the right track. The lye should turn the indicator yellow or green, meaning it’s highly alkaline. If the reaction is blue to blue green, that’s not a good sign. Those colors indicate a lower pH, meaning the solution is not alkaline enough to make good lye. Be sure you are using ash from the right kind of wood and that you haven’t mixed lots of charcoal in with it. It’s unlikely that this low-pH lye will ever be strong enough to make soap, even after it’s boiled down. We’ve been there and done that. It might be best to try again with a new batch of ash.
SAFETY NOTE
At this point, the solution is not caustic enough to burn your skin outright. It’s milder than the sodium hydroxide solution you mix up for regular soap. Still, it will dry your skin severely, and you definitely don’t want to get it in your eyes, so be sure to wear gloves and goggles. Later, when the solution is reduced to full strength, be extra careful.
If the liquid tests yellow or green, move on to the egg test. If the lye solution is dense enough to float an egg, this means it’s strong enough to make soap. Start with a fresh, raw egg. (It must be fresh, because rotten eggs float in water. If you’re not sure how old your egg is, put it in a bowl of water. It should sink to the bottom.) Then lower the egg into the lye water—wear gloves when doing this. If it sinks to the bottom, the lye is too weak and must be cooked to reduce the water content. If the egg floats high enough that a little circle of shell the size of a nickel or quarter breaks the surface of the water, then it’s just about perfect. Some people will also accept the lye if the egg floats just below the surface but does not quite break it. If the egg floats high on the water, the lye is too strong and must be watered down with rainwater until the egg floats correctly.
Set the egg aside for subsequent rounds of testing. Don’t eat this egg! It is a sacrifice to the cause.
REDUCE THE LYE
Most likely, the egg will sink at this stage and you’ll have to cook down the lye. We’ve found the quantity of lye usually needs to be reduced by half. Pour the lye into a large stainless steel or enamel pot and heat it to a steady simmer. Take note of the water level early on so you can gauge how much water has cooked off. At any point, transfer a couple of cups of lye into a bowl and let it cool (so it doesn’t cook the egg) and test again. Test, cook, and retest until the egg floats. You’ll find it takes surprisingly large amounts of water and ash to make small quantities of soap-worthy lye. This project will probably yield 1 or 2 quarts.
If you notice ash sediment in the finished lye, strain it through a finely woven piece of cloth, like a dishtowel or a coffee filter. Store the lye in a lidded glass jar until ready to use.
Part 2: Rendering Fat
PREPARATION:
2 hours
Both tallow and lard are used in soap making. Lard is pure pork fat. Tallow comes from the fat of any grazing animal, like cows, sheep, or deer. Of the two fats, lard makes the better soap, because of its cleaning abilities and its gentleness on skin, but both types of fat are used for soap, alone or in combination with other fats and oils. Lard is also a high-quality cooking fat, which is enjoying a renaissance after years of undeserved scorn. You might want to render lard just to have it on hand in the kitchen. Tallow can be used to make candles as well as soap.
YOU’LL NEED
PUTTING IT TOGETHER
The best days to render fat are mild days when you can open all the windows in your kitchen, because this is a stinky process. If you have a range fan over your stove, turn it on when you start cooking.
Chop the fat into 1- to 2-inch chunks to facilitate melting. If you can grind it, things will go much faster. As you cut the fat, trim away as much meat and tissue as practicable. The rest will be separated out later. The processes of melting lard and tallow are a little different, so the directions branch off here.
SOURCES OF ANIMAL FAT