Samuel Pecke turned up during Lucy's first day at the printshop, almost spitting with indignation. His complaint wasn't, as Lucy had expected, that his junior partner had set up in competition: it was that his junior partner had cut him out of a profitable new enterprise. Lucy listened to Pecke respectfully, agreed that he'd been ill-used, and told him, quite truthfully, that she didn't know where Mabbot was. Mabbot had, in fact, made very sure that that would be the case: he'd appeared early that morning to give her the sheet of news to print, but told her that he would be âout' for the rest of the day.
Pecke's visit was on a Friday, the start of a new period of newsgathering. The following Thursday, after their first issue came out, a scrawny man in a good coat turned up, his meagre face blotchy with rage. âWhere's White?' he demanded, glaring around the printworks.
Lucy hurried forward, wiping her hands. âI manage the works for Mr White,' she admitted nervously.
The stranger looked her up and down with contempt. âWho are you? Where's White?'
âI'm Lucy Wentnor, sir. I have charge here while Mr White is at his other shop. It's on Thames' Street ifâ'
âOh, of course! At the other shop! Did White hire you?'
Lucy winced. âMr Mabbot did, sir.'
The other let out a shriek. âGilbert Mabbot! God give me patience! Gilbert Mabbot the Licensor! I have been
abused
!'
âSir, if you wish to speak to Mr Mabbot, he isn't here, and I know not where he is.'
The stranger whipped a copy of the new
Intelligencer
out of his coat. âDid you print
this
for Mr Mabbot?'
Lucy swallowed. âAye, sir, we did.'
âThe whoreson rogue! The lousy cozening rascal! God
damn
him! I'll have the law on him! Where is he?'
âSir, I know not, but if you would leave a noteâ'
âHe'll take
note
of me, I swear it! You lying whore, where is he?'
âSir, I know not! He came this morning with the paper of news, and then went!'
âYou inky strumpet! This is
my
title! I built it up from nothing to what it is today! You surely knew it was
my
title!'
âSir, I'm but a hireling! Leave a note or a message for Mr Mabbot, and I'll see that he gets it!'
The stranger glared. âYou tell him this: he's a false knave, and I'll have the law on him!' He stormed out.
âThat was Mr Dillingham,' one of the assistants said, awed.
âI guessed as much,' said Lucy sourly.
Dillingham found himself new printers, registered again with the Stationers and resolutely published his newsbook the following Thursday, just as he had before. For the next three weeks two completely different versions of
The Moderate Intelligencer
did battle on the streets of London. Mabbot toyed with the notion of cancelling Dillingham's new licence, but he had no excuse to do so, and he was afraid of what the action might cost him if the matter came to court. Both
Intelligencers
carried the imprimatur of Gilbert Mabbot.
Dillingham, however, didn't take the matter to an ordinary court of law: instead, he appealed to the House of Lords, who were officially responsible for overseeing the Licensor. The Lords had resented the Army's interference in appointing Mabbot and were quick to take advantage of the complaint against him. They ordered him at once to yield the title
The Moderate Intelligencer
back to the man who'd founded it.
Lucy was alarmed. Obviously, Dillingham
deserved
to keep the title he'd built up from nothing, but by this time she was thoroughly enjoying the work she was doing for Mabbot. It was both easier and more difficult than managing Tew's clandestine press: easier because everything could be done openly; more difficult because there was more to do. Not only were there three staff instead of one assistant, there were also the âmercury-women', the hawkers who sold the newsbook on the street. This was a group of poor women who collected copies of the
Intelligencer
when it came out on Thursday morning, and kept everything they earned above the printer's price: keeping track of who had taken how many copies, and how much money was due back, was difficult. On top of this, there was
advertising
. She was already accustomed to setting the little notices in the
Diurnall
: so-and-so would provide lessons in dancing or music; Dr such-and-such announced the availability of his infallible cure for the pox; Mr Blank offered a reward for the return of his stolen horse. Now she also had to check over the text and collect the newsbook's sixpence for the service. All of this involved a lot of accounting and figuring, and she often found herself taking the account books home to pore over them by candlelight. She liked the challenge, though, and loved the sensation of being in the centre of things, with the news flowing out from under her ink-stained fingertips. She did not want to go back to simple typesetting at John Bourne's.
Mabbot arranged another dinner at The Cock to discuss what to do. When Lucy arrived, she found that Wildman had also been invited again. She had just sat down beside him when Robert White came in.
âAh, Robert!' said Mabbot easily. âGood day! This is John Wildman, a lawyer friend of mine; John, this is Robert White, my printer.'
White gave Wildman a hard look. âYou're the Leveller law-man?'
Wildman sighed resignedly. âAye.'
He was beginning to attain a minor notoriety, if only among those who followed the news closely. He had drafted
The Case of the Army Truly Stated
for a group of radical Agitators: this document strongly protested the failure to act upon all the Declarations and Engagements made the previous summer, and called for the dissolution of Parliament and fresh elections. âAll power is originally and essentially in the whole body of the people of this nation,' it declared, âand their free choice or consent by their representers is the only original and foundation of just government.' The notion was considered by many to be dangerous and extreme: it not only did away with the need for King and Lords but also ignored all distinction between rich and poor.
The whole body of the people
, it said â not just the few who currently had the vote.
White regarded Wildman uneasily.
âJohn's a wise man,' Mabbot reassured him. âAnd no enemy to property â indeed, he's as quick to acquire it as any man I know!'
Reassured, White sat down beside Mabbot. âA man's doing well if he can acquire property in these times! What do you deal in, sir?'
Wildman gave a sour smile. âI've purchased some land that was confiscated from malignants.'
âAh!' White was now impressed. âI know half-a-dozen that have
tried
to buy such and failed.'
âIt helps to know law,' said Mabbot, âand to have kinsmen in Parliament. But we're here to speak of my newsbook, not John's business!'
âYou mean
Dillingham's
newsbook,' replied Wildman.
Mabbot made a face. âI thought the law would grind slow!'
âJustice has been done speedily for once,' said Wildman, amused. âGilbert, give it up! You can't have been earning much the last weeks anyway, not splitting the readership with Dillingham.'
Mabbot, dissatisfied, appealed to White. âRobert, what
were
our sales this past week?'
White jutted his lip, as though he were thinking hard; Lucy was quite certain that he hadn't been following the newsbook closely enough to know. She took out her notebook. âThree hundred and eighty copies,' she said. âAfter costs we had a loss of three shillings and eightpence.'
Mabbot raised his eyebrows appreciatively. âThat's less than I feared.'
âThe mercury-women that hawk it say people now ask which
Intelligencer
it is, sir.' She met Mabbot's eyes hopefully. âI think some prefer the new
Intelligencer
to the old.'
âStill, it is a loss,' said Mabbot unhappily. âI'd
hoped
to earn money by this venture.' He looked at Wildman. âIs there no hope of keeping the title?'
Wildman shook his head. âYou must make your choice, my friend. Publish a newsbook that's truly your own or go back to the
Diurnall
.'
Mabbot frowned.
âSir,' said Lucy hesitantly, âyou wanted your own newsbook in part because you tired of Mr Pecke's caution, did you not? Perhaps you should be bolder in what you write.' She glanced at Wildman and said, âThe Royalist mercuries sell well because many long for the king's return. Perhaps something might be done on
our
side, too. Everywhere we hear Levellers reviled, or else passed over in silence, and yet there are many of us and we are all great readers of the news.'
Wildman gave her a startled look. âThat is a very fair point, Mistress! I, certainly, would be glad to read a newsbook that spoke well of us!'
Mabbot frowned some more. âPerhaps . . . and yet there are a great many people who think ill of you now â aye, I know how falsely you're slandered! But John, if my newsbook closed because readers shun it, how would that help anyone?'
âMistress Wentnor's point was that it
wouldn't
close,' said Wildman. âThat there are enough of us to make it profitable.'
Mabbot tapped the table. âI should think on this. Robert â you're happy with Mistress Wentnor's management?'
White had been staring at Lucy with some astonishment; he started. âWhat â oh, aye. The wench is hard-working and knows her trade.'
âThen we'll carry on for at least a few more weeks. I can afford patience if the loss is no worse than four shillings a week. Though it seems, alas, that I must find a new title.
The Moderate Intelligencer!
' He sighed. âI
liked
that. Here, can anyone think of a title that sounds as if it's but a continuation? That way we might keep some of our readers.'
â
The Army's Intelligencer
?' suggested Wildman.
Mabbot made a face and shook his head. â
That
would hardly please the Lords! They are angry enough with the Army as it is.'
â
The City Intelligencer
?' offered White.
âNay!
That
sounds as though it means to speak of Common Council and its affairs, which is foul ground!'
â
The Moderate
?' said Lucy.
â
The Moderate
,' repeated Mabbot, tasting the name. âAye. That will do.'
Eleven
The Moderate
first came out the following week. It was four pages shorter than
The Moderate Intelligencer
and was published on Tuesday, rather than Thursday; this was to take advantage of the people who liked to send a newsbook to their country cousins on the post-coaches which left London on Tuesday morning. For its first few weeks it continued much like its parent, cautiously neutral. Events, though, made neutrality increasingly difficult to sustain. Mabbot's Leveller sympathies were expressed cautiously, at first; when sales actually
improved
as a result,
The Moderate
became enthusiastically radical.
The king declared his preference for the Army's
Heads of the Proposals
over the strict Presbyterian terms being offered him by Parliament, then refused to negotiate with the Army. He saw the Scots commissioners regularly, however, for long private discussions. The threatening rumbles north of the border which had been sounding all summer were growing much louder. The Scots had made a Covenant with the Parliament of England: would England's Army break it? Charles was Scotland's king as well as England's: how could the southern kingdom presume to settle with him as though the northern one had no rights in the matter? The summer of struggle had settled nothing, the threat of another war was growing again, and still the country was paralysed.
John Wildman's
The Case of the Army
, with its insistence on the sovereignty of the people, was formally presented to Lord General Fairfax and the Council of the Army. Cromwell, however, was still desperate to come to an agreement with the king. He used all his influence to ensure that
The Case of the Army
was rejected, and made a speech in Parliament dissociating himself from it and praising monarchy.
And thus Cromwell's dear Democraticks being left all in the suds, [
Mercurius Pragmaticus
reported cheerfully] his face is now more toward an Aristocracie than Zion, which has raised a deadly feud betwixt him and the Agitators, who looke upon him as fallen from grace; especially since he has used all his wit and power in the Army to suppresse them, now that he has served his ends upon them.
âWhat's a Democratick?' Lucy asked Wildman. They were at The Whalebone, where Lucy had gone after work in the hope of meeting friends.
âOne that believes in the sovereignty of the people,' Wildman told her. He looked very weary â unshaven, hollow-eyed and dishevelled, not at all his usual immaculate self. âFrom the Greek
demos
, the people, and
kratia
, power.'
âOh!' said Lucy. âI thought it meant something bad.'
That drew a tired smile. âMany think it does. They say that if the common people get power into their hands, they will turn first upon the rich and then upon one another, and all will descend into anarchy and bloody ruin. And yet the Grecians, when they were at their most flourishing, settled upon democracy as the best and noblest form of government.'
Lucy considered that. âSo common people
have
ruled, in the past?'
âAye, they have!' Wildman roused himself and added fiercely, âAnd will again, by God's grace!'