Ivan’s War (63 page)

Read Ivan’s War Online

Authors: Catherine Merridale

BOOK: Ivan’s War
13.49Mb size Format: txt, pdf, ePub

One witness to it all was Nikolai Belov. ‘I wanted to write to you so much on the first of May,’ he wrote to Lidiya on 3 May, ‘but the way it’s worked out is that we’ve been in battle the whole time, and what’s more they’ve been really hard and drawn-out battles, the kind where you don’t have time to talk, let alone to think about writing.’ Four of her letters had arrived on 1 May, but he had been in the thick of the shelling in the Tiergarten, and when it was over he was too tired to open them. Then came the city’s capitulation, a lull in the thunder of guns, and finally, a chance to rest. ‘I haven’t slept like I did just now for a long time – I was like a corpse,’ he wrote. But he knew the war was coming to an end. ‘I don’t know if there’ll be another lot of fighting like we’ve just seen, but I doubt it. It’s all finished in Berlin.’ When Weidling signed the capitulation papers, Belov had been asleep.

The lieutenant had not witnessed the end of Operation Bagration. He had been wounded just weeks after writing the last entry in his diary, in the late summer of 1944. His reward had been the first home leave of his entire war, a second honeymoon with Lidiya. It was of home that he was thinking as he wrote on 3 May. A fellow officer had invited him to celebrate the first of May – belatedly – in his ‘baronial’ quarters in Berlin, ‘where, as they say, you probably can relax a bit’, but the thought of luxury repelled the weary officer at that moment. ‘To hell with all this stuff,’ Belov declared. ‘I’d rather be in a hut somewhere – anywhere, as long as it’s in Russia, so that I could relax and forget the whole nightmare of this war, including the bloodstained German race.’ The luxuries reproached his conscience, too, for he had not had time to send a parcel home, although he longed to help his family. He was exhausted and sick of the war, but his letter also contained a germ of real hope.

The point was that Lidiya was expecting their baby, a child conceived during his leave. He called the pregnant woman ‘fatty’, affectionately telling her to eat well and get lots of rest. More seriously, he also contemplated the things his unborn children would think later on, when they asked what their father had done in the war. He had no reason to reproach himself, and the thought made him proud. They would, he thought, ‘not be ashamed, because we fulfilled our duty to the end’. But all that was still in the future. In those first days of May the war was not quite over, and nor was the stress, the sense of endless combat, in his brain. ‘No doubt you are celebrating,’ he
wrote. ‘I can imagine how delighted our whole nation must be, but for us, soldiers, it’s difficult to grasp the true extent of our victory, our aim has been to take a city or to win a battle, and we’re used to weighing the effect of a given battle, and we’ll only start thinking about the victory when we have heard the last shot.’

He knew that there would not be long to wait. ‘Perhaps,’ he concluded, ‘the war will have ended before you even get this letter.’ Five days later, Zhukov accepted Germany’s unconditional surrender. The ceremony was as dignified, as final, as wartime conditions could make it. The cameras of the world’s press flashed as Keitel, the German head of state, took off his glove to sign the act of capitulation just after midnight on 9 May. When the German delegation had left the hall, the Soviet and Allied delegations collapsed with relief, the wine and vodka appeared on the green baize tables, and Zhukov himself danced to the applause of his generals.
128
Outside, the men greeted their victory with salvoes of heavy gunfire, rifle shots, and yet more drink. But Belov never heard the last shot of his war, nor did he ever see the daughter who was born a month later. He was sent west, to Burg on the Elbe, on 4 May. The next day, 5 May, he was killed there.
129

 

More than 360,000 soldiers of the Red Army and of its Polish comrades perished in the campaigns for Berlin, perhaps a tenth of them in the battles around the capital itself.
130
Those men and women were the ghosts at the feast on 9 May. But for a few hours, most soldiers remembered life, not death. ‘We heard the joyful news on the radio at three o’clock this morning,’ Taranichev wrote home to his wife. ‘Anyone who was already asleep was woken up, and we organized a gathering straight away: we fired volleys out of every kind of gun till morning, which means that right up till dawn the town was under such heavy fire that it looked as if a real battle was going on. My dears, you cannot imagine what joy there is among our officers and men because of the war’s ending; it’s true that you suffered very greatly back home behind the lines, and that our rearguard together with the valiant Red Army defeated the fascist beast, but all the same for us at the front it was hardest of all, and you’ve got to understand us,
frontoviki
!’
131
Ageev spoke for many when he declared that ‘there has never been such happiness and pride in history as the Soviet people are experiencing today’.
132
At Samoilov’s base, the soldiers had been celebrating since the fall of Berlin on 2 May. On 7 May, they heard a rumour that the war was finally over, and some began to fire into the air. They fired again on 8 May, this time because the BBC had
announced Germany’s capitulation, but it was not until Keitel surrendered to Zhukov himself that they got really drunk.
133

Elsewhere the men had not waited that long. On 5 May, a soldier in the NKVD’s border guards happened to find a canister of wood alcohol in the courtyard of one of SMERSh’s Berlin stations. He drained an experimental portion into a teapot and shared it with two other troops in the security service. The single pot was not enough, and so they filled a three-litre container and shared that out, fetching yet more when the cook turned up and invited himself to the party. That night, another seven men joined in – or helped themselves, because the original drinkers had passed out by this stage, happily forgetting that the war was not yet won. They did not live to see the victory. The first three men died on the second day. The rest would die before Keitel had signed the final papers.
134
Such cases were repeated all along the front. Wood alcohol was frequently to blame, but so were antifreeze, white spirit, and even too much looted schnapps.
135
At least the victims never knew the disappointments of the peace.

The next day, 10 May, Berlin would feel deserted, silent. The streets were empty, and the public squares, where the Wehrmacht had felled trees in preparation for its own artillery, felt blank, bereft even of songbirds. Most soldiers were sleeping off their hangovers. But not everyone had remained in the German capital to greet the end of European war. Ermolenko was among the thousands of men already heading east. His company received the news of victory as their train approached the Ural mountains.
136
He did not know the details of his mission yet, but he was heading for Manchuria. The European war was over, but the Soviets would now join in the struggle to defeat Japan.

It was the first straw in the wind, the first hint that Germany’s defeat would not mean the end of military service for Red Army troops. They had fulfilled their duty, as Belov had said, not flinching even to the last, but now the first of many disappointments loomed. It would not be a few weeks but some months, and even years, before most men would see their wives and families again. As for their hopes, the dreams that they had nurtured through long evenings of talk and writing, it would be a longer wait still. As Kopelev had understood as he watched the flames rising above Neidenburg, it was not clear what these people were now equipped to do. It would never be clear how they would deal with peace. The only thing that they could count on as they watched the spring unfold around the ruins of Berlin was the ruthless power of the state for which so many had died. They had saved it. Now they would learn the measure of its gratitude. 

Notes – 9 Despoil the Corpse
 

1
Chuikov,
Reich
, p. 18.

2
RGASPI-M, 33/1/261, 9 and 24.

3
RGASPI-M, 33/1/1409-19, 6.

4
RGASPI-M, 33/1/261, 29.

5
Intercepted field post, Bundesarchiv, RH2-2688, 51 (January 1945).

6
I am grateful to Professor W. Brus, himself a witness to Russia’s war at the time, for this insight into Ehrenburg’s wartime standing.

7
Christopher Duffy,
Red Storm on the Reich
(London, 1991), p. 274.

8
Cited in Werth, p. 965.

9
See Beevor,
Berlin
, p. 34.

10
Bundesarchiv, RH2-2467, 82.

11
Khronika chuvstv
(Vladimir, 1991), pp. 175–6.

12
Pis’ma s fronta i na front
, p. 93. Letter dated 26 February 1945.

13
Bundesarchiv, RH2-2467, 86.

14
Werth, p. 944.

15
RGASPI-M, 33/1/261, 27.

16
Kopelev, p. 14.

17
Ibid
., p. 13.

18
Julius Hay, cited in Norman Naimark,
The Russians in Germany: A History of the Soviet
Zone of Occupation
, 1945–49 (Cambridge, MA, 1995), p. 70.

19
See Naimark,
loc. cit
., and also RH2-2686, 37.

20
See Glantz and House, p. 235.

21
Bundesarchiv, RH2-2338, 45-01.

22
Bundesarchiv, RH2-2686, 33.

23
Kopelev, p. 36.

24
Bundesarchiv, RH2-2467, 9.

25
Ibid
.

26
Stalin,
O velikoi otechestvennoi voine
, p. 100 (23 February 1945). This formula echoed a time-honoured earlier phrase about capitalism, used in the harsh years of class war (collectivization). Then, the catchword was that the class enemy would resist with greatest desperation as the victory of the proletariat approached.

27
Ermolenko, p. 105.

28
RGASPI-M, 33/1/261, 35.

29
Ibid
., 38.

30
Bundesarchiv, RH2-2688, 13 (captured letter).

31
For a parallel story of captivating inhumanity, see the account of the slaughtered buffalo in Tim O’Brien,
The Things They Carried
, pp. 75–6.

32
Leonid Rabichev, ‘Voina vse spishet’,
Znamya
, 2005, no. 2, p. 163.

33
Ibid
, p. 163.

34
Ibid
, p. 159.

35
Ibid
, p. 165.

36
Kopelev, p. 37.

37
Bundesarchiv, RH2-2338, 44-10, 3.

38
Kopelev, p. 50.

39
Werth, p. 964.

40
Bundesarchiv, RH2-2688, 12.

41
Kopelev, p. 39.

42
Ibid
., pp. 46–53.

43
Naimark, p. 74.

44
This seems clear despite the bland statement by Werth (p. 964) that the rapes were just an outlet for the soldiers’ sexual frustration.

45
Bundesarchiv, RH2-2688, 13.

46
Overy, p. 260.

47
For discussions, see Susan Brownmiller,
Against Our Will: Men, Women and Rape
(London, 1975); Sylvana Tomaselli and
Roy Porter (Eds), Rape: An Historical and
Social Enquiry
(Oxford, 1986).

48
RGASPI-M, 33/1/1409-19, 6.

49
Rabichev, p. 164.

50
Set in a culture of almost total denial, Rabichev’s article and Kopelev’s book are, to date, among the only discussions of this question in Russian. The time for an honest assessment of the war is still far off, as the Victory Day celebrations in Moscow in 2005 testified.

51
Atina Grossman, ‘A Question of Silence: The Rape of German Women by Occupation Soldiers,’
October
, 72, spring 1995, p. 51.

52
Bundesarchiv, RH2-2688, 13.

53
Cited in Naimark, p. 112.

54
Anonymous (sic),
A Woman in Berlin
, trans. James Stern (London, 1955), pp. 93–4.

55
Temkin, p. 197.

56
Beevor,
Berlin
, p. 326.

57
A Woman in Berlin
, p. 64.

58
Temkin, p. 202.

59
Igor Kon and James Riordan,
Sex and Russian Society
(London, 1993), pp. 25–6.

60
For a more recent parallel, see Gilles Kepel’s comments about Algerian Islamists, those ‘impoverished young men’ whose crowded family conditions forced them into abstinence and who, in consequence, ‘condemned the pleasures of which they had been so wretchedly deprived’. Cited in Jason Burke,
Al Qaeda: The True Story of Radical Islam
(London, 2004), p. 133.

61
RGASPI-M, 33/1/261, 27.

62
N. Inozemtsev,
Tsena pobedy v toi samoi voine: frontovoi dnevnik N. Inozemtseva
(Moscow, 1995), p. 108.

63
GARF 7523/16/79, 56.

64
For an example of such propaganda, see
Pravda
, 13 July 1944, p. 3 (account of Olga Ivanovna Kotova and her ten children).

65
Pushkarev,
Po dorogam voiny
, p. 154.

66
Belov, p. 469.

67
RGASPI-M, 33/1/1414, 57.

68
RGASPI-M, 33/1/1405, 67.

69
Kopelev, p. 29.

70
GARF, 7523/16/79, 59, has another letter demanding that soldier fathers have control over their children.

71
Exotic German women’s clothes – ‘Gretchen knickers’ – would often scandalize the soldiers’ wives who received them as gifts from their husbands. See Beevor,
Berlin
, p. 407.

72
Cited in Naimark, p. 108.

73
RH2-2688, 51.

74
Ibid
., 52.

75
On this aspect of rape, see Ruth Harris, ‘The “Child of the Barbarian”: Race, Rape and Nationalism during the First World War,’
Past and Present
, 141 (November 1993), pp. 170–206.

76
A Woman in Berlin
, p. 219.

77
The most comprehensive figure, from Barbara Johr, is a total of two million in the whole of Germany. See Naimark, p. 133. See also Helker Sander, ‘Remembering/Forgetting’,
October
, 72, spring 1995, p. 21.

78
Atina Grossman, ‘Silence’, p. 46.

79
Venereal disease statistics are available in NKVD files and also in the records of hospitals near the front throughout and just after the war. Although it generally maintained a cool attitude towards the epidemic, the NKVD did occasionally note the pace of infection, as in RGVA 32925/1/516, 178.

80
A Woman in Berlin
, p. 17.

81
RGVA, 32925/1/526, 43. See also Naimark, p. 74.

82
Velikaya Otechestvennaya
, 2(3), p. 304 (order of 11 July 1944).

83
For example, the three cases of gang rape dating from April 1945 are cited in RGVA, 32925/1/527, 132. The guilty men in each case were turned over to SMERSh.

84
Rabichev, p. 164.

85
Kopelev, p. 51; Temkin, p. 201.

86
GARF, 7523/16/424, 85 and 98, for example.

87
See Douglas Botting,
In the Ruins of the Reich
, pp. 23–4.

88
Naimark, p. 10.

89
Botting, p. 99.

90
Snetkova, p. 47.

91
GARF, R7317⁄6⁄16, 81.

92
This confirmed the GKO’s resolution of 23 December 1944.
Velikaya Otechestvennaya
, 2(3), 344–5.

93
Temkin, p. 199.

94
Velikaya Otechestvennaya
, 2(3), 344.

95
Kopelev, pp. 39–40.

96
Beevor, p. 35.

97
RGASPI-M, 33/1/1405, 146.

98
Snetkova, p. 47.

99
See Beevor,
Berlin
, pp. 407–8.

100
RGASPI-M, 33/1/1405, 157.

101
Ibid
., 152.

102
Ibid
., 158.

103
GAOPIKO, 1/1/3754, 5–9.

104
RGASPI-M, 33/1/1454, 139.

105
TsAMO, 233/2354/1, 28.

106
A Woman in Berlin
, p. 60.

107
See photo, p. 280.

108
For an account from Poland, see RGVA, 32925/1/527, 86–7.

109
Ibid
., 108.

110
RGASPI-M, 33/1/1454, 125.

111
Beevor,
Berlin
, pp. 177–8. For a different perspective, see Glantz and House, p. 255.

112
The numbers given are two and a half million Red Army and Polish troops and roughly a million German defenders. Glantz and House, p. 261; Overy, p. 266.

113
Glantz and House, p. 260.

114
Pis’ma s fronta i na front
, p. 160.

115
Chuikov,
Reich
, p. 146.

116
Beevor,
Berlin
, p. 218.

117
Chuikov,
Reich
, p. 147.

118
Overy, p. 268.

119
Beevor,
Berlin
, p. 222.

120
Chuikov,
Reich
, p. 184.

Other books

The Breach by Lee, Patrick
Alpha in a Fur Coat by Sloane Meyers
Running the Rift by Naomi Benaron
Alex by Sawyer Bennett
U.G.L.Y by Rhoades, H. A.
Cheetah by Wendy Lewis
Tori Phillips by Midsummer's Knight