Authors: Delia Sherman
In another universeâ
Perhaps a mortal moment, after all.
therapeutic value of the alternate universe theory:
âa sophisticated illusion (?) to help us manage the pain of uncertainty/finalityâhelpful only if we believe we can choose the “better” universe (or does just the vision of, say, the squirrel still frolicking
somewhere
ease our pain?)
ânot a defense against the eventuality of death, unless we posit universes of impossibly old people (and squirrels and beagles)
but mortal anxiety anxiety about deathâthe “good” death, quiet in bed at ninety or one hundred, that one is “ready” for (at least some have said they are ready); that death does not inspire mortal anxietyâthe young death, the accidental death, the “wrong” death that comes before we are finished, before we even know who we are; and the impossibility of foreseeing and avoiding that death, of controlling the terms of our existenceâ
New title:
Mortal Anxiety and the Alternate Universe
by E. K. Smythe (would appeal to multiple markets: psychology, philosophy, science, science fiction; the cover needn't tell that E. K. is a womanâif that matters)
Mortal, or existential, anxiety destroyed Katherine's marriage of five years to “Steve.” He knew of her anxiety when he married her but neither thought that it would come between them and having a family. “Steve” dreamed of becoming a father. At first Katherine wanted children, too, despite her terror of taking on responsibility for their safety (if she couldn't trust herself with a dogâthen a child?). Then their friends “Bridget” and “Dennis” lost their infant son to the flu. Every year a few, very few children succumb unpredictably to influenza; theirs was one. Katherine had never seen such intense grief. She kept waiting for time to bring healing, but it didn't. “Bridget” sank into depression. “Dennis” sought distraction in an affair. They divorced. “Bridget” moved in with her parents and spent her spare time drinking.
A bottomless well of anxiety opened up in Katherine's heart. How would she ever survive such a horrendous loss? She knew that people did, that not everyone destroyed themselves or their marriages. Some families circled, like wagons, embracing each other until they could move on. But could she?
"Steve” mourned the loss of his friends' child, even tried to help them patch up their marriage. He spoke with Katherine of the risk of that awful pain, the risk of loving as a parent loves. Still, his longing to be a parent survived his contemplation of the risk. Katherine admired his bravery but could not find it in herself. “Steve” finally left. Now he has a new wife and a six-month-old son. He is happy. Katherine is glad he is happy. But when she contemplates having her own children she falls back into that terrible well of anxiety and only by promising herself childlessness forever can she pull herself out.
how can I with words open up that bottomless well?
perhaps I should keep it covered and let those who can maintain their illusions keep them or is it the well itself that offers a way into other universes?
My mother awaitsâhence I awaitâthe biopsy results. I go online to check prices to fly to California. Then I realize this is the ideal test situation. How many universes can I create, spin off, as I make my reservations? I select “search by price” for a Boston-LA flight and am rewarded with a plethora of possibilities. Overwhelmed, I should say. Which airline? Which day? Which flight? My life will turn out differently depending on the choiceâperhaps only a little differently, perhaps a lot. Perhaps end. But I cannot tell unless I peer into those other universes.
I select a date at random, choose another a week later, look for a flight leaving neither too early nor too late. I take it all the way up to “Click to buy ticket” and my hand freezes over the computer. This is it, a fulcrum moment, I can buy or not.
And even if I buy, I can go or not.
Which life, which universe do I choose? To buy this ticket, go on this flight? To buy this ticket, then choose later whether to go or not? To start over?
I hold my hand motionless, letting my thoughts pour into the moment and fill it, nudging me into this universe or that. Or at least opening a tiny window, a hatch, into other possible universes, so that I know what I am choosing.
The universes close up tight.
Tell me, God, tell me what to do.
God, as usual, is silent. Or not there.
segue to: “God and Mortal Anxiety"
âare there universes in which God is, and universes in which He/She is not? or universes with many Gods? or one God for many universes?
âreligious people have been found to be happier, less depressed, less anxious; check researchâis it the belief in God as such, or the existential certainty that accompanies such belief, that relieves anxiety?
âatheists are likewise certain; are they less anxious?
âagnostics, the uncertain, the know-nots: if uncertainty breeds anxiety, then anxiety must trail them like a hungry dog
Because Katherine teaches religion, her studentsâand othersâassume her to be a religious person. She is a religious person in the sense that the deep questions of life concern her greatly, and she seeks the subjective responses of religion and philosophy, not just the objective answers of science. But so far her studies have shed no light on the question of God. Despiteâor perhaps because ofâyears of religious study, Katherine finds herself a thoroughgoing agnostic. Faith in God and the prospect of heaven, being unreal to her, can neither comfort her nor calm her anxiety.
could it be belief in heaven, rather than spiritual certainty or belief in God, that relieves mortal anxiety?
âheaven: a kind of alternate universe accessible primarily through death, perhaps also through trance or visionâcarrying heavy moral weight (unlike most other alternate universes)
âpre-existent to this universe? i.e. not a result of bifurcations of it or of universes preceding; or perhaps a very early bifurcation but a universe accessible by death is not therapeutically useful when the interior aim is to
avoid
untimely death ways other than death to access alternate universes:
âinward: meditation, hypnosis, trance, aided by fasting, drugs, painâoutward: specialized technology (not yet known), travel at a particular speed or direction, key geographical points/gateways, transitional objects is
belief
in the alternate universe necessary to reach it (as perhaps to reach heaven)?
âthen the agnostic is doomed; neither science nor theology can save her
(unless in writing this book I find a wayâ)
Despite Katherine's anxieties, she persists in the belief that only total immersion in the vagaries of life will eventually bring security. She knows she thinks too much. To get out of her head, out of her anxieties, she goes to the supermarket. Instead of imagining the universes that may be splitting off as she chooses to take this road instead of that, this parking space instead of that, this shopping cart instead of that, she focuses on the tastes she plans to bring home: mango, pineapple, strawberries. Plain first, then with vanilla yogurt, then whipped with a little sugar and spice into an East Indian lassi.
Her mouth waters.
The man in front of her in the checkout line has a basket full of hamburger, a dozen packages. None have been put into a protective plastic bag, although these are provided in the meat section. When Katherine buys hamburger, she pulls a plastic bag over her hand like a glove, picks up the package of meat, then pulls the bag back up, never touching the original plastic wrap packaging. Who knows, a little juice might have dripped out, a little meat spilled, bacteria-filled, contaminated.
Katherine has never contracted food poisoning at home.
She watches the man load the hamburger onto the conveyor belt, notices the wet spot underneath when he shifts the packages to make room for more, a crumb of red that might have oozed out of the plastic-wrap. She looks at her mango and pineapple (there were no strawberries today). Alternate universes spin before her: Despite the hamburger, nothing happens, she washes everything thoroughly and stays well. Or she has a touch of food poisoning, recovers. Or she dies of a new modern virulent form of E. coli. Orâ
She excuses herself from the line, mumbling something about a forgotten item. But she forgot nothing. On the contrary, she remembers too much. She heads for another line, stops in her tracks. Who's to say the customer three or four places ahead of her, already in the parking lot, didn't leave the cashier's hands and the conveyor belt already contaminated?
She decides to go back to the produce department for plastic bags for her fruit. Then she spots a cashier spritzing her station with disinfectant, wiping everything down, switching on the light that says the lane is open. Katherine scurries over, stepping in front of a slow old man with a package of pork chops. She smiles apologetically; he nods and his eyes twinkle. She puts the mango and pineapple onto a conveyor belt, which still glistens with disinfectant. She will wash them before cutting them up, before closing her mouth around their incomparable sweetness. But she feels confident that even if the washing is not perfect, the fruit will not sicken her in this universe she has chosen/created.
If she gets sick, it will not be her fault. She has done what she can.
creating the secure universe: the aspiration of the mortally anxious their ritual objects: plastic bags, helmets, antibacterial sprays, locks, alarms, sensors, diagnostic tests, seatbelts, organic foods, insurance policies limits on creation of the “safe” universe:
âability to choose universes by taking precautions is limited to hazards which can be foreseen and preventedâfor unforeseen/unforeseeable events, the only chance to choose lies in catching that moment, the fulcrum momentâbut
how
to access other universes through that moment?
The phone rings. Katherine puts down the fork with mango still skewered upon it, reaches for the phone, pauses with her hand extended. She senses her mother at the other end of the line, tries to picture her face: relieved? devastated? worried but hopeful? This is it, the moment, she feels it, she
knows
it. How does she turn it aside? By never answering the phone? By answering in this moment rather than the next, by waiting another ring? By closing her eyes and taking some inward turn in her mind? By clicking her heels, turning left three times, saying “abracadabra"?
She sweats, she fights tears, but she cannot move her mind/self/reality into position to leap/fall/dissolve from this universe into another. She feels herself toppling into the well of anxiety, but rallies and lifts the phone. Hello.
Hello. Her mother's voice is strained. She wastes no time. “It” is malignant. She will have surgery right away. The doctor is hopeful. Butâ
Katherine watches the moment recede in her rearview mental mirror, feels herself sitting at the bifurcation of universesâthey split and split again into a great cauliflower-like fractal of possibilities, of realitiesâinnumerable universes exploding from the moment and mushrooming up and out (those organic metaphors again) in great clouds.
In which universe does her mother die soon, die later, respond to treatment, not respond, go into remission, experience a complete cure?
Katherine hangs onto the phone, the tips of her fingers whiten. She wishes she could reach out and grab onto the “good” universes, let them pull her along and her mother with her, into a place where squirrels still frolic and beagles play and, if she cannot avoid all pain, at least she can exercise some choice about which pain to experience and which to let go.
But the universes slip from her hands like so many silken cords. She clings to the one that remains, praying, with all that is within her, that this is the right one, the one where she belongs, and that the pain will not be more than sheâthan Iâcan bear.
I've never thought to call myself “interstitial” (until now), but I have always felt caught between sometimes conflicting identities: am I poet or scientist, country girl or academic, mystic or naturalist, Midwesterner or Yankee? To add to my bewilderment, I tend to feel greater affinity for the world in which I am not; back home in Indiana I feel like a New Englander, but in Maine I'm aware of my lingering Midwesternisms. So I'm always more or less out of placeâexcept when I am in nature, and when I write.
My writing grows from yet another experience of incongruityâthe sense of life as a constant juxtaposition of the bizarre and the taken-for-granted. My own experience leans to the bizarre, not because my life has been bizarre in any usual sense, but because I find existence essentially incredible. Perhaps the inability to take things (such as existence) for granted is one of the roots of anxietyâbut also of imagination.
As for “Alternate Anxieties,” I owe its existence to an unlucky squirrel, who died in the manner described. I was left to ponder the enormous consequences of seemingly trivial choices. Thus, a story.
Karen Jordan Allen
"There was a young Hebrew in the prison, a slave of the captain of the guard. We told him our dreams and he interpreted them."â
Genesis
41:12
"Why did you repay good with evil? This is the cup from which my lord drinks, and which he uses for divination."â
Genesis
44:5
killing an ox: Good. It means the removal of the dreamer's enemies.
writing on a palette: Good. It means the establishment of the dreamer's office.