Authors: C.W. Gortner
“He must be changing his clothes,” I said. I took up my neglected embroidery and set myself to work, anticipating his arrival. The mechanical clock on my mantel chimed each hour with excruciating slowness. By midnight, I realized he had no intention of seeing me tonight. It was the first time we hadn’t spent an evening together while in the same palace, and as my women snuffed out the candles and retired to their pallets I paced my bedchamber, my mind awhirl.
I began to imagine the worst, Besançon’s words tumbling over and over in my head. The choice he’d mentioned could only mean Philip would turn to France. He’d forge an alliance with Spain’s enemy to spite my parents and bend them to his will, causing me no end of trouble.
My hands bunched into fists. I had to put an end to this before it went any further. I would go to Philip. I would not have our love tainted anymore by Besançon’s wiles.
I slipped into a robe and low-heeled slippers. Doña Ana slept in a separate room, and as I tiptoed past my ladies in the antechamber I motioned to my ever-attentive Beatriz to stay put.
On fleet feet, I moved through the darkened palace, encountering only the occasional stray hound, dozing courtier in an alcove, and the night sentries.
At the door to his antechamber, I paused. In the small watching-room, the candles were doused, the fire ebbing. The page who usually slept here, ready to attend to whatever Philip might need in the middle of the night, was nowhere in sight.
I was relieved. Let Philip express his frustrations while I listened patiently, knowing there were no ready ears in the antechamber, recording every word. I had no doubt that I would win. The archbishop, for all his guile, was no match for a visibly pregnant and anxious wife.
His bedchamber door was ajar and I saw flickering candles within. I felt a rush of pity. He too was awake, probably unable to sleep, distressed as I was, uncertain as to—
I heard a burst of muffled laughter. I glanced over my shoulder. Was the page here after all, entertaining some guest in the corner? Another burst of laughter rang out, immediately followed by an unmistakable voice. “Be quiet, wench. You’ll wake the entire palace.”
I froze where I stood. The moment fractured about me. My hand poised over the door’s latch; without knowing what I was about to do, I pushed it open on its oiled hinges.
His bed sat directly before me, the silver and blue brocade curtains pulled back. I had a fleeting impression of rumpled white sheets before my gaze dropped to the floor. Clothing littered the trampled rushes. I stared at a woman’s overturned white satin shoe. All sound faded. I lifted my gaze, slowly, in mounting horrified disbelief, my entire body turned to ice.
The candelabra on the sideboard tossed his shadow onto the wainscoting, slashing light across bare skin. Fleshy thighs poked out at either side of his hips, lifted in midair, the red-nailed toes curling upward. I saw the supple muscles of his buttocks flexing, his spine tensing under his back as he increased his pace, plunging into the creature beneath him.
Sound rushed back to me in a sickening deluge. I heard groans, whimpers, the slapping of skin against skin, and a woman’s voice saying over and over,
“Oui, mon coeur, oui, oui, oui…”
Philip arched, released a husky groan I knew well, then shuddered and collapsed. The white thighs beneath his splendid body splayed onto the mattress. He rolled over, a hand at his brow, his mouth curved in a satiated smile. The woman, half-submerged within the pillows piled against the bed’s headboard, gave a laugh, her large, blue-veined breasts jiggling as she pushed tangled flaxen tresses from her face and sat upright.
Her eyes flew at me. She let out a small high-pitched gasp.
“Mon Dieu!”
Philip chuckled. “What now? Didn’t you get enough, you greedy slut?” and he looked about. I looked straight at him, at his still-hard and wet sex. Tears burned in the corners of my eyes.
“Oh my God,” I whispered, and I turned blindly back into the antechamber.
Behind me, there was commotion, Philip’s brusque order: “Get out!” Bare feet hit the floor. I pressed a fist to my mouth, fighting back a wail of pain and sorrow as I saw the woman creep past me, gown and undergarments and white shoes clutched against her.
I did not know who she was. I might have passed her a hundred times in the gallery or in the hall and never know she’d bedded my husband.
Then I heard Philip come up behind me. I whirled about. He’d tossed on a scarlet robe. “My infanta, I…” He looked chastened, like a boy caught misbehaving.
“How—how could you?” I heard myself say, the plaintive, distraught tone foreign to my ears. “How could you do this to me?”
“I didn’t mean to hurt you,” he muttered. He did not try to touch me, his hands awkward at his sides. I wondered if his fingers smelled of her. “It was a bit of sport. It means nothing.”
“Nothing?” I whispered. My tears broke free. “You call it nothing, when you betrayed me?”
“Betrayed you?” For a moment, he seemed bewildered. “What, because of her? I told you, she’s nothing. A pastime. I’ve had a dozen just like—” He stopped, his eyes widening.
“You’ve done this before?” I echoed, and a sob thickened my voice.
“No, no.” He made a sudden move, his hand coming up as if to soothe me. I flinched, recoiled. “I swear, not since our marriage,” he said hastily. “Please, Juana, I promise you.”
I wanted to believe him. The betrayal I felt was so unbearable, so unthinkable, I wanted only for it to go away, for his touch to make me forget the searing memory of him pumping his seed into another.
But I didn’t, because I knew I could never forget. Something precious and irreparable had broken inside me.
“I must go,” I said, and I started to the door, moving like a woman underwater.
He caught my arm, not hard, but enough to pull me back. “Where are you going?” he said, and I saw a flicker of impatience in his gaze.
“Away.” I pulled from his grip. “Anywhere but here.”
“What? This is ridiculous! All husbands do it, Juana. When their wife is with child, they seek comfort elsewhere. It hardly matters.”
I felt my heart turn over. He was a stranger. I had made a terrible mistake. I had married a man I did not know. An intense rage came over me. “Is that what Besançon told you,” I said through my teeth, “that it doesn’t matter? That you may do as you please because I’m with child? Well, it does matter! It matters to me! I am your wife. And I loved you!”
“I was angry,” he flung back. “God’s death, I was angry and hurt. Your mother insulted me. She denied me my right as your husband and chastised me as if I were a snot-nosed brat. I didn’t mean for you to find out. Had you stayed in your rooms, you’d never have known.”
“Yes,” I whispered, “you’re right. I would never have known. And you would never have told me.” I turned away again, to the door.
He said, “Juana, come back. Please, let us talk about this. You’re being unreasonable.”
I moved into the corridor. I paused, looking around as if I had never seen this place before. He stood silhouetted by the open doorway, the candlelight behind him. I could not see his face.
I broke into a desperate run. I didn’t know where I headed, only that once I reached my chambers, I must have looked a fright, my hair disheveled, my bare feet soiled from the passageways, my slippers discarded somewhere behind me.
Beatriz and my other women were awake, waiting. They gaped when they saw me.
“Start packing,” I cried. “We are leaving. Now.”
TEN
I
took my ladies back to Brussels. I would not confess to anyone, not even to my beloved Beatriz, even as my pain and humiliation and anger ate at me like a canker. I ordered the startled staff in Brussels to ready my rooms, and though they were only half-done cleansing the palace from our previous stay, without fresh rushes on the floors or laundered carpets, tapestries or linens, the stinking slop piles not yet carted away, I ensconced myself in my apartments and acted as if I had an entire court about me.
Not once in two full weeks did Philip’s name cross my lips.
At first, I made up wild plans to depart for Spain as soon as my child was born, return home to the Alhambra to raise him as a Spanish prince. I wept more tears than I care to recount when I thought of never seeing Philip again, but then like an injured person fingers their wound, I made myself recall that scene in his bedroom and feel again the terrible disbelief. I didn’t know if he had done it before or if he would do it again, but he had shattered my trust in him and as the days passed I began to wonder if everything we’d felt, everything we’d shared, the passion and laughter, the dancing and sleepless nights, had been an illusion.
I’d always known infidelity was an unfortunate but common part of marriage. My father adored my mother yet had had mistresses. My mother never raised protest, at least not publicly. In fact, when one mistress bore him a son, and another a daughter named Joanna, she had both children brought to court to be reared as befitted their rank. The mistresses were also found suitable husbands, once my father’s interest waned. But how had Queen Isabel felt when she first discovered this rupture in what she believed was the perfect union? Had she wept, railed at my father in private? Or had she displayed only equanimity, burying her pain deep within? If so, I knew I should do the same, if only because, like her, I had no other choice. Philip was my spouse; I had no say in how he chose to behave. I should consider myself fortunate he was young, comely, and that he cared for me. Other princesses contented themselves with far less.
And still, I couldn’t accept it. The fact that he’d bedded another woman hurt me less than the realization that he hadn’t cared to deny himself. He’d thought of his own satisfaction rather than our love, squandering it the moment a difficulty came our way. It felt careless, callous, the act of a vengeful boy, and I feared I might never find the resignation I needed to forgive him.
Then one afternoon, as I prepared to take my daily walk in the gardens, Beatriz rushed in. “Your Highness, the archduchess Margaret is here! She insists that you receive her.”
I went still. “Here? Why? I thought she…” My voice faded. The door opened and Philip’s sister swept in, clad head-to-toe in black, her hands outstretched.
“Ma chérie.”
She smothered me in her embrace, then drew back to regard me with a searching look. I saw at once, she knew. She had returned home from Spain and seen Philip. He’d told her of our estrangement and now she was here, to make amends. But why was she still in mourning?
I said quietly, “You wear black.”
“Yes.” Margaret lowered her eyes.
“But the six months of mourning for my brother are done.”
She whispered, “Oh, my dear, it’s as I feared. You don’t know. You haven’t been told.”
I met her eyes. The chamber started to keel. “Told what?” I heard myself say.
She did not speak. A tear slid down her cheek.
“Dear God,” I said, “what is it? Is it Philip? Has something happened to him?”
“No, my brother is well. He waits downstairs. He didn’t know if you would see him.”
I stiffened. “Philip is here?”
She took me by the arm. “I am not here for him. My dear, your sister Isabella…I am so sorry. She is dead.”
I heard her words in utter silence. Then I said, “No. That is impossible.”
“I know it must come as a shock,” said Margaret. “Her pregnancy went so well, almost perfect. No one expected the birth to be so hard on her. Your mother sent word, asking Philip to spare you the news until after your own child’s birth. But when I got to Lierre after that infernally long sea voyage and he told me what happened, I insisted we must come to you at once. I didn’t want you to be alone, in case you learned the dreadful news elsewhere.”
My breath evaporated from my lungs. I did not feel myself move as memories crashed over me. I saw Isabella in her widow’s garb, mourning her dead prince; her disapproval when Catalina and I escaped into the Alhambra’s gardens; and I remembered her words on the day I left Spain. She’d said we would never see each other again in this life. How had she known?
I buried my face in my hands. “God, it cannot be. Not again. Not my poor sister.”
Margaret moved to embrace me when a quiet voice said, “My infanta.”
I looked up. He stood in the doorway, his cap in hand. He looked pale, thin. “I have your mother’s letter,” he said. “I’m afraid it’s true. Isabella is gone.”
From my bedchamber door, Doña Ana let out an anguished wail. Beatriz guided my bereaved duenna away. Philip approached me. I met his eyes. “My sister’s child, is it…?”
“He is. A boy christened Miguel. But the birth nearly killed him too. Your mother has taken him to Granada in the hope his health will improve.”
“Granada. Yes, the air is pure there. Granada will heal him.”
I felt Philip take my hand. I was so cold. I wondered if I would ever feel warm again. He said softly, “Please, forgive me,” and the pain resurfaced, sharp as a blade.
I pulled back. “I can’t. Not now. Please, go. You’ve done your duty. Let me grieve in peace.”
His mouth tightened. “Juana, how long will you let this come between us?”
“I don’t know,” I whispered, and I walked into my bedchamber without a backward glance, closing the door on his frozen figure, Margaret helpless at his side.
I turned the key. Then I sat on the bed beside Doña Ana. Beatriz and Soraya flanked us like silent sentinels as I put my arms about my poor duenna and let myself weep.
I WENT INTO SECLUSION FOR THE OFFICIAL PERIOD OF MOURNING
for my sister; this time I did not deviate from the prescribed protocol. Directly afterward, I entered confinement for childbirth in early November of 1498. After surprisingly few hours of labor, I gave birth to a girl, who was later christened Eleanor. The midwives and physicians hastened to alleviate what they perceived as my disappointment with the declaration that my apparent facility for childbirth indicated I would in time bear a son. I nodded, hiding my covert pleasure. In bearing a daughter and not the prince he had craved, I’d thwarted Besançon’s ambitions.
Philip demonstrated only joy in the squealing infant. My official presentation to the applauding court after my churching and release from confinement concealed the stalemate that had developed between us. We shared the same palace, attended the hall to dine together, but after our public duties were done, I went alone to my rooms and bolted my door. Though he tried various times to implore me to reason, I would not listen to him. I was hurt and confused; I had never expected Philip to want another woman, much less bed her, and I didn’t know what to do next. I should have been the happiest woman in the world, with a new baby and a husband who, in the eyes of the world, was the perfect prince, but I had never felt more wretched or alone.
Following the New Year’s festivities of 1499, Margaret came to my apartments. Her father, the emperor, had betrothed her to the Duke of Savoy, an elderly lord with rich holdings, and she had been summoned to Vienna to meet her new bridegroom. I liked my sister-in-law. She was a lively, intelligent woman who’d survived my brother’s death and now faced another arranged marriage with equanimity; and upon hearing her news, I gave her a brittle smile.
“I’ll miss you,” I said.
She set hands on hips. “I’m leaving next week, though I hardly see how I can with matters as they are. Exactly how much longer do you intend to go on punishing yourself? My brother is despondent. He barely eats or sleeps. And neither do you, by the looks of it.”
“He betrayed me,” I retorted. “Why should he be despondent?”
She sighed. “
Ma chérie,
if every wife locked her door to her husband when she caught him with his hose down, there’d not be another legitimate child born in this world.”
I knew she spoke the truth. After much reflection and tears, I knew it was a wife’s lot, and yet I couldn’t resign myself. I didn’t want to be one of those women who turned the other cheek when her husband strayed. I didn’t want to become my mother.
“I’ve tried to forgive him,” I said haltingly. “God only knows how much.” I paused, meeting Margaret’s gaze. “Should I pretend it never happened? Is that what you advise?”
“No. He knows what he’s done.” She stepped to me. “But you love him, and he loves you. Believe me, pride makes for a very poor bedmate. At least, let him come to you. Give him the opportunity to atone for his mistake.”
“How can he atone? How can I know it won’t happen again?”
“You can’t.” She sighed. “My dear, you are still so young in matters of the heart. You do not understand that men are more imperfect than we are, for all their bluster that we are the weaker sex. Who knows why a man strays? But I know this much: he never meant to hurt you. He’s simply even more of a child than you, a boy forced to grow up too soon. And when boys feel rejected or betrayed, they lash out, often at those they love the most.”
“I did not betray him! I did not deny him the title he sought.”
“I know. All his life Philip has been taught that his overriding duty is to seek his aggrandizement as a prince and when a Habsburg is wronged he must take his vengeance.”
“I understand that. But he is a man now, and Besançon does him no favors. He relies too much on that man.” I resisted the urge to add that I knew Besançon had orchestrated this fissure in my marriage, that he had put Philip up to it, perhaps even selected the woman. That day we confronted each other, he had warned me. He as much as declared I should not aim above his power over Philip, and then he went and made sure I understood my limitations.
“That may be,” said Margaret. “But you are his wife, not Besançon’s. You must find it in yourself to forgive him, because you are the stronger one.” She took my hands in hers. “You’ve no idea how much I prayed that he would find a wife like you, to give him the happiness and care he so desperately needs. My brother lives in a hard world. To survive, he’s learned to close off his heart. But with time and patience, you can make him see the error in his ways.”
How could I resist such a plea? I couldn’t imagine the years stretching ahead devoid of the companionship, the love and unity I’d thought I had found. I was nineteen. I had my entire life to live. And I wanted to share it with the man I had wed.
“I will speak to him, if you want me to,” she added, and I nodded, hugging her close.
“I am sorry that I’ve only given you more burdens to carry,” I murmured.
“Ah,
chérie,
” she replied, “what is a sister-in-law for? Were it not for the burdens of others, my own might be too great.”
We kissed each other’s cheeks, and she left to pack for her trip to Austria.
Alone in my chamber, I let something dark and painful untangle in my heart. It unraveled slowly, barb by barb, and I at last allowed myself the forgiveness I had denied us both.