Friends With Full Benefits (Friends With… Benefits Series (Book 2)) (28 page)

"No problem. So tonight?"

"I can’t, but we could do something tomorrow."

"How about dinner? Maybe seven?" Jim asked.

"I'd love to. Do you know where Calhoun Hall is on Arch Street?"

"No, but I’ll find it."

"Alright. See you then."

"Bye."

Caroline hung up the phone and returned to bed. She watched as Jeff emerged from the bathroom with his penis hard once again. She gave him a playful grin. "What are you doing?"

"I was just thinking about you, and look..." He motioned with his eyes to his groin. "You want to do it again?"

As he approached, she looked him over from head to toe, feeling horny. Jeff grabbed a condom off the table as he asked, "Who was on the phone?"

"That guy from Penn I met in Atlantic City."

He seemed unfazed as he asked, "So, should I open this, or..."

"I don't know." She sighed.

"Come on, make up your mind. It wont be hard forever."

Her eyes returned to it as she took a moment to think. "This will be the last time
ever
. I'm serious." She watched with a naughty grin as he tore open the package and slipped the condom over his erection. She lay back in bed as he moved between her legs. She repeated, "The last time."

"Oh, I know. I think things with Lucy and me are really getting serious."

"You can't keep doing this to me."

As he slipped inside her, she looked at the ceiling, torn between guilt and pleasure.

The next day, Jim arrived outside Caroline's dorm, and they walked to a restaurant nearby. Once they were seated, she started rambling. "Look, I’ve been dating this guy. It’s nothing serious. I mean it was serious. We've been dating since like tenth grade, and I’m not sure if it’s really over or not." He smiled with relief, and she went on explaining, "Actually, he was in my room when you called. We, uh, thought it was over a couple of times, but every time it just... I just wanted to be completely honest."

"That’s fine. We don’t need to rush into anything. We had an incredible time in Atlantic City, but all that could have been due to the amazing suite, the $400 massages, and the bathtub the size of a small pool."

She chuckled. "Yeah, we could get out here in the real world and really not like each other at all."

He looked at her with a serious expression. "Yeah, I’m kind of bored already. I think I’m just going to go." He made a move to stand, and she looked shocked. Breaking into a broad smile, he sat back down. "Just kidding."

"You’re an ass," she joked.

They both sat back and reviewed the menu in complete silence before sharing a quick smile.

"What is it?" she asked.

"I don’t think it was the suite or the massage or the tub—I would have had fun with you in one of the regular rooms, too."

"You wouldn't have lured me into one of the regular rooms."

He grinned at her as the waiter approached.

After they ordered, she said, "So did you blow all your winnings?"

"Some."

"What’d you buy?"

"I have a confession, too... When I replied to your text, I was having lunch with this woman. Are we being totally honest here?"

"Sure, I just told you I had sex with a guy just after you called me yesterday. That’s pretty honest."

"No, you didn’t. You just said he was over." His jaw dropped.

"Oh, well I had sex with a guy just after you called me yesterday," she said casually and smiled.

"You slut."

"Don’t worry. We didn’t do anal or anything. With him, I'd charge extra for that."

"I’m not sure how I feel about this," he said half-jokingly.

"Yeah, I probably shouldn’t have. If it’s any consolation, I was on the fence about it. He was already naked in my bed. We had just done it before you called."

"Oh, well, then…" He rolled his eyes and grinned.

"And when I got off the phone with you, he was..." She leaned in close and whispered, "…hard again."

He widened his eyes. "You shouldn’t waste a good boner."

"My thoughts exactly." She smiled. "Wow, I’ve never been this honest before with a guy. This is... kinda refreshing. How did we get on this subject?"

"Honesty."

"Oh, yeah… honesty. So, you were going to tell me what you bought."

"I actually bought a $600 massage table and a few things to go with it."

"Are you starting a massage business?"

"No. I know it sounds crazy, but I bought it for the woman I met in Miami. She’s a friend of Jillian’s. We actually spent a lot of time together down there, and she had this empty room, and I wanted to do something nice for her, so..."

She gave him an odd look. "You've been spending a lot of your winnings on women you hardly know."

He nodded. "I just got this crazy idea, and I’ve never had so much money before. Let’s just say it was a spur-of-the-moment purchase."

"I’ll guess you guys were having sex." His eyes got big as he smiled. Considering his look, she added, "A lot of sex. Amazing sex?"

"Let’s just say I went down there technically a virgin and now..." They shared a weird look, and he said, "So far, you’ve told me you banged out a guy just under twelve hours ago. I’ve told you that I spent about a thousand dollars on a room makeover for a woman I’d known a week. Is this, like, the most bizarre first date ever?"

They looked at each other in silence, both holding back a laugh, until she said, "Maybe we should try to have a normal real first date."

"We should start fresh." He paused a moment. "What the hell do people talk about on first dates? Especially after they've already seen each other naked."

"Just pretend you never saw me naked."

He leaned in close, looked her in the eye and said slowly, "I can't… I really can't. I'll
never,
ever forget it."

After taking a deep breath, she shimmied in her seat and whispered, "I just completely got wet when you said that. That's never happened to me before with just, uh, words." She stared at him, blown away.

He gave her a mock-smug look. "I never know what to say to women, but that was pretty sexy, wasn’t it?"

She nodded, still captivated by his attention. "It was." Regaining her composure, she sat back and grinned. "Let's really try. No more dirty talk until we really get to know each other."

"Agreed."

She shrugged her shoulders, and they sat in silence for another few moments.

By the time the food arrived a few minutes later, they still hadn’t said much. After they each swallowed a bite, she smiled, and her face lit up. "Oh, so how’s your summer class?"

He told her all about it. They spoke about tennis and how she would like to learn to play. They talked about her mostly normal parents, his completely odd parents, movies, school, music, and just about everything else except sex. An hour later, after their waiter had asked for the fourth time if he could bring them anything else, Jim paid the check, and they headed back to campus.

Ten minutes later, they were making out fully clothed on the sofa in Caroline’s dorm. His hand made its way back to her ass, as hers ended up over his straining erection.

She pulled back from him, panting. "This doesn’t feel like we’re taking it slow."

"I know. It doesn’t."

They fidgeted, adjusting their clothing as they each struggled for composure. She said, "Are you planning on buying that woman in Miami any other furniture or anything?"

With a straight face he said, "I had my eye on this loveseat and matching chair." She looked at him, holding back a laugh. The joke was made, but he decided to milk it. "They’re a blue-and-white-striped pattern and would go really well with the general color palette in—"

"Okay," she interjected, and they both broke into laughter.

"And what about you? If Jeff comes over here and pops another boner, are you going to...?"

She looked at him, torn. "I don’t know… Seriously, I don’t. Why don’t we take it slow? We haven’t exactly begun this relationship in a traditional way, so why try to define it or—"

"You’re right. I’m really fine with..." He motioned between them with his hand. "I think this is really going to be good, though."

She looked at him with her fire reignited as they leaned in and kissed. It grew passionate again, and their hands roamed everywhere. She gently pushed him away. "I’ve never before had sex with two different guys in twenty-four hours, and I’m not starting now."

"Me either." He smiled as he leaned back in to kiss her.

Grinning, she turned her head. "I’m serious."

"I should probably go then."

She gave him a reluctant nod. He stood, and she walked him to the door.

In the hall, he turned to her, and they moved close. She smiled. "I think this really could be amazing."

"I think so."

They shared one last kiss. As he walked home, he limped just a bit for the first block or so.

After returning from an unspectacular-but-not-horrible first date, Victoria and Chase walked into her massage room. He wasn't the most engaging companion she'd ever been out with, but he was in the top five sexiest. She'd been
fantasizing
about putting her hands all over his body since the first day she saw him in the locker room.

As Chase looked around the room, he noticed the smooth rocks, grinned, and walked over to them.

"What the heck are these?"

"They're used for a warm-stone massage."

Chuckling, he picked up three of the rocks and began to juggle with them. He dropped one on the floor and nearly hit her with another. She gave him a stern look as she put her hand out for the remaining rock. He looked sheepishly at her and handed it over.

"Let’s give each other massages, and then if you’re a good boy, we can move on to other activities," she said with a sexy smile.

"Sounds like a plan."

"You should do me first."

"Oh, I will." He eyed her body up and down.

She slipped out of her clothes and lay down nude on the sheet with her head seated comfortably in the rest. He fumbled with a bottle of massage oil, squirted a little in his hands, and began to halfheartedly rub her shoulders. She closed her eyes and moaned slightly, since any type of massage—even a lousy one—still felt pretty amazing.

Suddenly, she no longer felt his hands on her. After a few moments, she felt his body pressing into the table near her head and heard him softly chuckle.

She kept her eyes closed as she asked, "What’s so funny?"

"Don’t you see it?"

"See what?"

She opened her eyes to the sight of his thick, erection maybe six inches from her nose. She had never seen one that big outside of a porn movie. Her mouth flew open. "Wow. Impressive, but put that away. He’ll get plenty of attention later."

"Seriously?"

"Yes, sex is not allowed in this room. It’s for relaxation only. The rest of the house is for screwing."

As she took one last look at the monster, she felt a little turned on. She sighed. He moved away from the table, and it disappeared from her view. She closed her eyes as he returned to massaging her.

After a few moments, she felt something hard pressing into her head. "What is that?" she asked.

"Nothing."

He pressed it harder against her.

"Really, what is that?"

She lifted her head, and he pushed his hips against the table. His erection brushed her nose, and its large head slid past her closed lips to her chin.

Popping off the table, she wiped her face and glared at him. "What the hell is wrong with you?"

"Just trying to have a little fun."

"I said there will be plenty of time for that later," she scolded.

He sighed. "This is kind of boring." Backing up, he gripped his penis at the base and moved sideways showing off his incredible length.

She gasped. "Wow. It
is
big."

"Biggest on the team."

"How would you know that?"

"We measure them," he said casually. "Over eleven inches. The closest guy was a measly nine."

Her eyes were drawn to it again as he moved to face her; the giant head seemed to be calling her name. She thought,
My God, he’s big!
Even Antonio would be turning toward the wall in the shower room if Chase were the competition.

She said, "Let’s finish the massages, and then we can—"