Read Falling Out of Time Online
Authors: David Grossman
ELDERLY MATH TEACHER:
You have become your death
so much that sometimes I must wonder
(Forgive me, have I crossed a line?
Best to be quiet? To ask? You know,
my son, I am a gentlemen, yet find myself unsure
how to address you … May I use the second person?),
but tell me, speak it clearly,
show no pity:
if they were to allow you—
they
,
there
—if you were given liberty
to choose—
would you come back?
Come back to this?
To me?
DUKE:
Or, as Rilke wrote of Eurydice,
are you, my child,
abundant with your own death,
which fills you
like a sweet and darkened fruit
?
While I,
a bothersome Orpheus,
try to pull you
over here
against your will?
ELDERLY MATH TEACHER:
Just one more, if I may?
(Whom else can I ask
but you, my teacher
in these mysteries?)
Tell me just what is the thing
in us, the living,
whereby we can become
completely dead
within an instant,
in the blink of our own death?
And give up everything,
be given up on,
as though a primal law
that always lurked inside us
suddenly appears and rises
like a shadow from the depths: around it
still the ruins mount,
and comfortably it settles in,
a haughty landlord long in charge,
its stony glare—which does not miss
a thing, yet sees nothing—
declares with just
a hint of triumph
in its smile—
“Death, my friends, is what is true!”
WALKERS:
When we meet … What will we tell them
when we meet? I, gentlemen
,
have already made up my mind:
I shall not tell him of his brother
,
born after his time. In her room
we changed all the pictures
.
We couldn’t bear it any longer
.
I ended up giving his dog
to a boy on the street
.
(silence)
WALKING MAN:
And after some time,
whatever I do, you
fossilize.
Then I must
carve you,
time and again,
out of the layers of stone
in which you are
cast. I must try very hard
to want it—
must carve myself for it, too,
must fight—
while my whole being
shouts: Let go, it’s best
this way. Let human nature
do as it will, you must
accept his fate, respect
his border—
But then I soon suspect
myself: perhaps deep down
I long for you
to fossilize?
To bleed no more.
To not be
so awake, so sharp,
white-hot and
everdead.
But no less painful
are the times when I succeed,
when my imagination
cleaves the hunk of stone until
it cracks, then crumbles,
falls around you,
and then suddenly
you are there:
naked,
breathtaking,
glowing in the palm of rock,
or merely standing,
limp
and incidental,
you look this way
and that, embarrassed, without knowing
that I watch you: present,
so present,
neither promising nor
disappointing, only
coolly beating with the pulse
of your calm being.
Just warm
enough.
And living.
Maddening.
WALKERS:
When we meet, if
we meet
,
what shall I tell him?
What shall I tell her?
Do you think they know?
Know what? That they
are dead
.
DUKE:
In August he died, and
when that month was over, I wondered:
How can I move
to September
while he remains
in August?
WALKERS:
Perhaps we’ll simply
face them, when we meet
,
without a word? Perhaps
he’ll say that now he understands
I only hit him
for his own good? I might sing her
the song I sang when she was
just a baby. I want to get there
soon, dear God. I’m afraid
he’ll be a stranger
to me. Rock-a-bye, baby
,
in the treetop, when the wind blows …
Just to be there
with her, just to be. I wish
I could take him
a bowl of tomato soup
.
WALKING MAN:
No, no … It can’t be, it can’t be—
WALKERS:
It can’t be, it can’t be—
WALKING MAN:
It can’t be that it happened to me, it can’t be that these words are true—
WALKERS:
It can’t be, it can’t be—
WOMAN IN NET:
That I saw them throwing my boy into a pit in the earth—
MIDWIFE:
That I heard—
thud-thud-thud
—the sound of a hoe digging in the soil—
WALKERS:
It cannot be that these words are true, they cannot be the truth—
WALKING MAN:
It simply cannot be.
MIDWIFE:
Burn! Burn the words! Burn this miserable talk!
WALKERS:
We look up, we know
just where to look, to the fire
,
the small fire
,
the constant flame
,
day and night it walks
with us, we’re used to it
.
I, my friends, call it:
the blaze.
Forget it, those are just small embers
,
not anymore, not anymore
,
look at the fire, inside
,
it’s alive, it’s like life—
Don’t move, wait, don’t anger it
,
it’s opening
,
peculiar, now
stretching out, slowly
slowly reaching hands, arms
,
my God, what is this
,
fingers—
WOMAN IN NET:
In the earth! The earth is where his little body rots!
WALKERS:
The air trembled loudly, the arms
of fire bristled, froze briefly in a glowing
,
burning crystal, then started once again
to spin, to flower in wild blossoms
,
then up above exploded
in a rush of molten fire, waxed
and roiled, above our heads
the fingers spread, lines of fire
flooded, slashed through
shadows, images, and suddenly
like whips they lashed, leaped, caught—
caught whom—the words—
the words? The miserable words
,
they devoured all the it-cannot-be
,
they swallowed all of it in fire, everything
went up inflames, we shouted
bitterly, a black-and-yellow flame
shot up from deep inside us, then
we fled—
kept still—
we screamed—
we froze, while she—
her flames of lionesses
,
dragons
,
snakes, we promised
silence
yet we screamed, we vomited
a brew of words, horrendous
words, it cannot be
,
it cannot be,
and she—
keeps thickly rising, bustling
,
rounds of fire chasing us, and
now inside us, eyes of red
and black, they open
,
tracking us, tongues
burning, let her come and burn
,
damn words, she blackened memories, and scenes
we have not dared to see for years, she ate them, gulped
,
a huge fire, swallowing and scorching, lapping
in our gut
,
we barked, we wailed
at the mad fire, take everything
,
take all of it, burn it to ashes
while we suffocate in the smoke
of words, the furnace—
Weary
,
empty, standing
,
tripping, faces
blackened as she dies
down finally
,
then silence
,
silence, tiny flames
abating, sated
,
shhhhh …
asleep
(pause)
What, what was that?
Was I dreaming? Sleeping?
Look at me! I’m breathing!
So light of limbs now suddenly, the body
floats on air … Tell me, madam, am I
dead? Alive?
Your face, my woman. Touch me
,
touch. How strange
,
it’s smooth, just like
it was
before—
Want—
I want—
I
want, we want
to wake up
,
to wake out
of it, to wake into the light, I want
to dip, to bathe my everything
in light—
You—
All of you—
Who cannot hear—who do
not answer—lying heavy
on our hearts—drawing
out our blood—sucking every drop
of life from us—collecting
tax—a coldness tax—
from every moment of our laughter—
light—forgetfulness—
distraction—you who whisper
back each word we say from here
And why?—Have you considered that?—Why did you
become dead?—How could you be
incautious?—You weren’t careful like we were—
Why did you go and pick up that disease?
And war
,
why did you go to war?—
And to the waves—
The razor—
And how is it that you
are dead, while we
managed to stay alive?—Have you ever wondered
what that means?—Perhaps it is not chance
that you are there while we are here?—
Might you have even done something that made you
be this w-w-way?—
You know what? We don’t even want to trouble ourselves
with these thoughts!—We don’t even want to
think of you!—We’ve thought of you
enough!—We’ve thought enough
of everything. Before it happened
I didn’t even know there were
so many thoughts!—Ahh, how many
years, dear God—how many tears—
So take—take—take your bundled bones—
and get out—get out of our lives—
Do you hear? Our lives!—
You
,
All of you there—
Die now!
WOMAN ATOP THE BELFRY:
Quiet
has come.
The distant town
slammed shut
at once.
As though
there, too,
they all stopped
breathing.
WALKING MAN:
But who am I?
COBBLER:
Who are you?
WALKING MAN:
I think I was looking for something here.
WOMAN ATOP THE BELFRY:
He left
and he came back,
he searched their faces
for all
that had been lost.
He ran
and circled
them,
and suddenly—
he fell.
WALKING MAN:
Who am I?
ELDERLY MATH TEACHER:
Pardon me, sir, do you happen to recall who I am?
COBBLER:
Ma’am, any chance you remember—
MIDWIFE:
There was a baby, and another baby, and another … Did they all come out of me?
WOMAN IN NET:
There was a house, there were clothes—
DUKE:
I played with horses, cavaliers—
TOWN CHRONICLER’S WIFE:
And you, sir, who are you?
TOWN CHRONICLER:
Me? I don’t … Excuse me, ma’am, I don’t know me.
WALKING MAN:
Who am I?
WOMAN ATOP THE BELFRY
(singing softly):
When I tell you yes,
you will embrace
the no,
embrace
the empty
space of him,
his hollow
fullness—
(pause)
There you are no longer
alone,
no longer
alone,
and you are not
just one there, and
never will be
only
one—
(silence)
WALKING MAN:
There
I touch him?
His inner self?
His gulf?