Click to Subscribe (19 page)

There is no way I’m screwing up Cat’s birthday
, too
, I tell myself as I work.
There. Is. No. Way.

It takes a few hours of cooking ma
stery before the cake is finally ready, but when it’s done, the cake is, let’s be honest here, fan-fucking-tastic. It’s large, at least the size of my face, and it’s smothered all over with dark chocolate icing. Above the icing is a layer of sour gummy worms, and on top of those, I make a mini Oreo pyramid.

But
the cake is not done yet. The best birthday gifts are also sentimental, so I head back up the stairs to my room. Pictures, I tell myself. I need pictures. Old pictures of Cat and I, of us smiling and having a good time, of Cat doing weird things and me taking photos of it. I’ll put them around the cake, on the plate, for her. When I reach my room I hear Dad muttering to himself in his own room across the way. For an instant, I strain to hear what he’s saying, but I can’t make out his words. I shake my head and shut my bedroom door.
It doesn’t matter
. I go back to looking for pictures of Cat.

It takes me a minute of throwing around clothes and old trinkets before I find a photo album of us. I smile a little as I pull it out and open it up.

I flip through page after page of photos, starting with when Cat and I were kids and we went to the bus stop for the first time, to when we were six and lost our first teeth and showed off our gap-toothed smiles to the camera, to when we went skiing together in sixth grade and quickly learned we were
not
born skiiers. I pull out a few more pictures here and there, of Cat and me sticking out our tongues to the camera, posing in front of
The
Icecreamery
as kids, and so on. Eventually, I make my way to the more recent pictures, smiling like an idiot all the way through. I feel something else, too, though; the beating of my heart. The buoyancy inside me. I look at the pictures of us, how close we were, how much we loved being around each other, and I start to feel… well…

I turn the page before I can finish the thought.
These pictures are of Cat and me showing off our dorky Harry Potter Halloween outfits, Cat and me looking like Sumo Wrestlers as we joke-fight each other on the boardwalk by the lake, Cat holding my hand and telling me I’m the biggest badass of a friend anyone could ever ask for.

I flip the page.
Next are pictures of us playing our epic games of whiffleball, which Cat always won, where we were laughing and smiling and not caring how stupid we looked. Another picture shows us on that trip to France we took with Mom last year, where we’re wearing fake mustaches and French painter hats, posing for the camera and grinning so hard. The next shows me and Cat doing our best fish impressions at the beach, our faces inches apart, our lips puckered like a fish’s. Then, I see one of Cat and me dressed up for our first Prom, our arms around each other, our faces so close and smiles so wide. By how happy we looked with each other, it seemed like we were going to Prom together, even though we went with different people.

I turn the page.
My heart tingles, rising slowly upward in my chest. All of a sudden, I can’t think straight. I’ve completely forgotten why I was even looking at these pictures in the first place, because now it’s just Cat and me and our memories. And as I look at those pictures of us laughing and smiling and being dorks and not caring because we have each other, my eyes start to mist—and I just know.

I know like you know if you failed a Math test, or you
did well in a job interview; I know because of that little instinct in the back of my mind screaming at me that “YES!! THIS IS THE RIGHT ANSWER!”

I know right then, as I stare at those pictures, that my quest for happiness, for
love
, was right in front of me the whole time.

I know that I, West Ryder, am in love with my best friend.

***

Before I
realize what I’m doing, I bolt out of my bedroom, abandoning the cake and the photos and my dad and everything else, fly down the stairs, out the front door, and sprint faster than I ever have before to Cat’s house. It isn’t a long run, but I wouldn’t have noticed if it were a thousand miles long because I can’t stop smiling. My whole head is filled with Cat Cat Cat and me me me, and how did I not notice, how could I have missed that I’m in love with my best friend this whole time?

It’s midnight, so I run in tune with the crickets
chirping in the distance, smiling as the wind ruffles my hair. A few minutes later I arrive at her front door, panting like crazy, my whole body so light I might as well as be flying, my heart skittering in my chest.

I’m in love with Cat. I’m in love with my best friend.

Oh my god. Oh my god oh my god oh my god. This is really happening, isn’t it? I’m really in love with her?

Cat opens the door a
minute after I ring the doorbell, yawning a little.

She frowns
when she lays eyes on me. “West? Everything okay? It’s late.”

I look at her. She’s dres
sed in her Harry Potter pajamas and a pair of pink socks, and she holds her hands at her waist. Her hair is a mess, but it looks so adorable and perfect in its own little way. Dark circles surround her eyelids, but her blue eyes shine so brightly it still looks like she can take on anything.

“Yeah,” I say, “everything’s fine. Sorry to wake you, it’s just…”
I step forward, not taking my eyes off her, her lips, the tiny traces of freckles that dot her nose. I’m not sure how to tell her. Tell her that I love her. That I know it for real now. That I want to be with her forever and ever.

But I know I have to.

“Why do you love me?” I say instead, taking a deep breath and watching her closely.

“What?”

“Why. Do. You. Love. Me?”

Cat sh
akes her head. “West, no, c’mon, we agreed to forget—”

“Cat,” I say. “Please just answer
me.” I grit my teeth. “Why do you love me?”

“You really want to know?”

“I do.”

She sighs. Turns. Look
s at me. Her eyes linger on mine for the longest time before she says anything, taking me in, studying me. She’s so beautiful, I realize, as the moonlight pours down on her. Perfect even though she just rolled out of bed—perfect
to me
.

I love her. I need her. We know each other inside and out, and she is my everything. She
has been my everything since the beginning.

“I love you, West Ryder,
” Cat finally says, “because you’re you. Because you’re smart and funny and weird and so goddamn charming”—she smiles distantly—“and you aren’t afraid to be
you
. I love you because we mesh, because you’re weird and I’m weird and we’re all weird together. When I’m around you I can’t stop smiling and yeah, that’s incredibly cheesy, but it is entirely true. I love you because I feel lonely when I’m not talking to you, not with you. I love you, West, because you are the one for me.”

She stops then, draws in another breath, and steps closer to me. It’s only a fraction of a movement, but it makes my heart skip a beat.

Her words seem to echo throughout the neighborhood.
I love you because you’re you.

“And you, West? Why are you asking this?”
She says it so carefully it’s like she’s testing a frozen pond to make sure it supports her weight.

I give a little half-smile. “Can’t a guy ask a question without ulterior motives?”

“Some guys, maybe. But you sure can’t. I know you too well for that.”

There’s a
long pause, and I can’t stop staring at her. I feel so invincible now, because I love her and I finally, finally know it. I don’t know how to tell it to her, to possibly put all she means to me into words. I can’t, though. Words can’t ever express how important Cat is to me, or how much I love her. “You know,” I say quietly, “how every winter that creek down the street would freeze? And you’d always race down to it and when it was solid enough to walk on, you’d get all agitated? Well, I remember asking you what was wrong, because we could play on the ice and wasn’t that a good thing? But you just shook your head like you knew something I didn’t, and you told me that was the problem.”

“It makes no sense, yeah,” she
says, looking at me uncertainly. “But I was eight.”

I step forward
again. I notice how her lips curl at my movement, how her eyes light up for the tiniest instant. “I know it makes no sense,” I whisper. “But you and the creek…. It’s the same as here. With me and you.”

“Huh?”

I don’t answer her this time. I squeeze my eyes shut, willing myself to tell her.

“What’s the matter, West?
” I open my eyes. Cat’s are locked on mine, and she looks a mix between worry and a growing sense of curiosity.

“The matter? This is the matter.
All
of this. I’m frickin’ in love with my best friend. I’m…” I take a deep breath and all of a sudden, it hits me. Just like that. “I’m in love with you, Cat,” I whisper. “And it’s like the creek because that’s the problem: that I’m in love with you.”

As soon as the words tumble out of my mouth, Cat’s face lights up, and I see her suppressing a smile.
She moves even closer to me now, her hips touching mine, and I feel her warmth against my body, her hands flickering, just slightly, back and forth and back and forth at her side. She’s so close I could give in to temptation right now and touch her, kiss her, get lost in her closeness and her love.

I hold back.

Barely.

Finally,
Cat opens her mouth to speak. I’m afraid she’s going to say something scolding, or disappointed, or whatever the hell they say on TV when a character tells another character he loves her, but instead Cat just smiles. “You are so weird,” she says simply.

My stomach tightens.
“Yes?”

S
he doesn’t respond. Instead, she reaches a hand out. I don’t move as she traces the side of my face, my cheek, my smile with her fingers. My whole body tingles at her touch, and I just look at her, breathing in, breathing out. I feel so tight, and every single muscle in my body freezes up the instant her skin connects with mine. In that instant, all I want is for her to keep going, to keep touching me, to hold me, just hold me, until the world melts away. “Tomorrow is my birthday,” she says.

“Yeah. I know.”

She stops tracing, but her finger does not leave my skin. I’m so aware of her touch, of her closeness to me. I smell her vanilla shampoo, hear each of her soft, satisfied breaths. “My seventeenth birthday.”

“I know…”

She glances up at me, her eyes now leveling with mine. They look so serious, like one touch will shatter them.

“Seventeen and in love,” she says so softly I swear she’s
talking to herself. She sighs, and I can’t move, can’t look away from Cat. She keeps standing there, not moving, and all I want is for her to kiss me, to hold me, to never let go. My body wants it so badly that it both terrifies and exhilarates me, that I realize both her warmth and her lips are what I’ve been waiting for this whole time. She’s my best friend and look where we are. Here. At midnight. Wanting each other.
Needing
each other.

But as I look into her eyes, as I remember a
ll the time we’ve held hands and laughed and smiled like it was nothing, like we didn’t care and didn’t
want
to care, it doesn’t even matter to me.

Because I love her.

“You know what would be a good birthday present?” she says finally, and presses her side to mine.

Now my smile really gr
ows, and I inch my side closer to hers, my mouth hovering an inch away from her lips. “I think I do,” I whisper.

“Then do it.
Kiss me.”

My throat catches at her words.
I mean, I knew what she was getting at, but it still paralyzes me to hear her say it. At first, I don’t know what to do, don’t know whether kissing her is worth it, but my body answers for me.

I lean in.
She’s right there in front of me, her eyes closed, her lips outstretched. Waiting. 

A
nd I start to do it—to kiss her. I really do. But I hesitate there, my lips so close to hers, and all of a sudden the fear takes over. I pull back, shaking my head and hating myself. “I love you, Cat,” I say softly, shifting my gaze to my feet, “and I realize now that I have all along. But I’m scared, scared of us. What if we do this and it doesn’t work out? What if it makes us split apart? What if I can never be normal with you again, talk to you, laugh with you?”

She grabs my hand and pulls me closer. My skin tingles at her touch, and it feels so good, so right, when her skin brushes against mine. “It’s supposed to be scary,” she whispers,
and I’m consciously aware of how close we are together. Our mouths hover there, a millimeter apart, and all I want is to man up and just fucking kiss her already. Her hand moves up and down my arm, and she smiles at me, a distant, sad smile. “And it’s supposed to hurt. It’s scary because it matters, West. I don’t know what’s going to happen to us myself, and the risk is just as terrifying to me. For all we know we’re about to get fucked and tomorrow this will all end. But I’m not going to live my life thinking about what could have been. I’m not going to stop loving you, either. So yeah, if this doesn’t work out, I will be crushed for the rest of my life. But I’m not going to say I didn’t go down without a fight. I’m not going to say I didn’t risk it. And the beauty of this risk, West Ryder,” she says, pressing her stomach to mine, “is that no matter what, it will work out, because I will have spent time loving you.” Then, she stops. Looks at me. My whole body trembles and I can’t help but laugh a little. I feel so overcome I’m also convinced I’m going to cry. Cat’s whole face seems to brighten at that, lips curling into a small smile, and I reach out and touch her face. Then, slowly, I run my finger up and down her cheek. I shudder, because it feels so good, and I realize how much I want to lean in and kiss her right then. She doesn’t move, though, just stays all tense and stares right into my eyes, smiling a little. I can feel the tension in her body, the slight tremble of her lips, and all I want is to keep on going.