Cin's Secret [Club Libertine 4] (Siren Publishing Ménage Everlasting) (7 page)

She’d wanted him to stay close to her afterward, keeping their bodies joined for a while, and was disappointed when he’d quickly pulled out and moved away from her, but she quickly realized that it was just so that his brother could take his place.

Liam barely paused. She could hear the condom wrapper and then he was on top of her, his cock pushing against her opening and seating himself deeply inside of her, unmoving. She felt Connor’s hands removing the restraints from her legs, and she automatically clamped them around Liam’s hips, urging him to move.

But he waited, leaning down to remove the nipple clamps. The blood rushed back into her nipples as he leaned down and suckled one and then the other. She screamed out her climax as a lightning bolt seemed to shoot from her nipples to her clit. Only then did he start moving, riding her hard and fast to his own completion.

* * * *

Lying between them, she dozed lightly. After Liam had come, Connor had removed the wrist cuffs and the blindfold, and then they had tucked her between them and gone to sleep, flat on their backs beside her.

She felt so safe and protected tucked between their big bodies, but she’d be a lot more relaxed if she didn’t have the plug still shoved up her butt. Carefully, she reached back, pulling slightly away from Connor. Maybe she could remove it without waking them.

Connor rolled onto his side and pulled her back against him. “Don’t even think about it. Once it comes out, one of our cocks goes in. And you are going to have to wait a bit for that. You’ve worn us both out.”

She must have finally fallen asleep because she awoke to Liam moving inside her. She looked up and could see Connor beside him, watching her get fucked by his brother. Her climax was building quickly, in part because of the sensual pleasure that being watched gave her. It surprised her. She’d never thought of herself as an exhibitionist before.

But suddenly Liam stopped moving. He held her tightly and rolled so she was on top of him. She tried to get some leverage so she could start moving. She was so close to coming. But he pulled her down against his chest and held her tight.

She saw Connor move and felt his hand on the butt plug. First he twisted it, and then he gently removed it from her ass. She heard the sound of the bottle of lube being opened and then he squirted some of the lube directly into her ass. She jumped at the cold feeling inside her. Both Connor and Liam chuckled before Connor squirted some more and worked it into her opening.

Then his cockhead pressed up against her and she felt the pressure as he pushed for entrance. The sensation of stretching was overwhelming as her body tried to accept him. At first there was just a pressure, but it kept building, and she started to tense up. It was hurting. She didn’t know she could take it if it took much longer for him to get his cock inside her.

Liam must have sensed her body tensing up and ran his hand over her shoulders, gentling her. “Relax your body, baby. And push back against his cock.”

She tried to obey, and then suddenly the head of Connor’s cock pushed through and lodged inside her body, her hole closing tightly on him. He groaned as he started moving inside her, slowly pushing deeper into her until he was seated all the way inside her.

She’d never felt so full or so turned on. The desire was like static electricity sparking all over her body. If they didn’t move soon, she felt like she’d expire from the need to come. She desperately tried to move against them, but they held her tightly between them.

Suddenly, tears started to fall from the depth of emotion she was feeling. She had to move. The pressure within her was overwhelming, but without some movement, something, she couldn’t come, and the desperate need to come was making her struggle against them.

“Please, please fuck me. I need to come. I’m begging you. Please let me come.”

With practice, or maybe just twin coordination, they started to move. One pulled out, and the other pushed in. Back and forth they pumped into her, harder and harder, faster and faster until she was bucking wildly between them, feeling like she was shattering into a million pieces. Connor came soon after, his hot cum shooting deep inside her. He pulled out, and Liam flipped her over onto her back again, pumping hard into her, pulling her legs up over his shoulders, and he came and came into the condom, finally collapsing onto her.

Connor again made a trip to the bathroom, coming back and cleaning her up before sliding in bed beside her.

The next time she woke up, it was morning. Connor was on top of her, kissing her awake.

“Morning, sleepyhead.”

She kissed him back, expecting him to slide his cock inside her, and was surprised when he flipped her over onto her hands and knees, her head pointing to the side of the bed. She didn’t have to wait long to find out what he had in mind as his slid into her from behind and Liam moved into view in front of her.

“Suck his cock, baby. You don’t get to come this morning until he does. And if you do, you’ll be punished.”

He immediately started moving quickly inside her pussy, which was still slightly swollen from the previous night’s activities. When she woke up, she’d been feeling so satisfied that she didn’t think she would come again for a week, but almost immediately, she could feel another climax rising in her.

Connor moved quickly, pumping in and out of her, pushing her toward orgasm as Liam pushed his cock into her mouth. She started working her mouth on him, licking and sucking, but she was no match for his self-control and his brother’s intensity. Soon, she was writhing as her climax hit her before she could get Liam to come. The men had amazing self-control. As soon as her climax slammed through her, they let themselves come. It was an incredible feeling of power to have both of them finding pleasure in her body at the same time, and she savored the feeling.

“That’s not fair. You deliberately set me up to fail,” she groused, really not that upset.

“Yes we did.”

“So what’s my punishment?”

“You’ll find out next time we play.”

“There may not be a next time. I told you that I couldn’t commit beyond a single night. In fact, I’m sure there won’t be. I’m probably leaving Seattle, right after my lunch with Lindy.”

“We thought if we made this night amazing, you wouldn’t be able to walk away from us. You didn’t say you’d be leaving town.” Connor’s voice was bleak. Cindy realized that she’d hurt him and his brother.

“I know. I’m sorry. Last night
was
amazing, and I’ll remember it the rest of my life. I wish I could explain, but it’s something private between me and Lindy. Last night I was being optimistic, thinking that there was a chance I could stay in Seattle and maybe we could have a relationship, but in the cold light of morning, I realize that I was just giving you false hope.”

“I don’t know what it is between the two of you, but it sounds like you are planning to run away. I didn’t think the woman who would take on two Doms was a coward, but I guess you are. You mislead us to get what you want, and then you run away. And it sounds like you are going to do a hit and run on your sister, too.” Connor sounded sad and disappointed, his shoulders slumping.

Liam reached out to her, but Cindy pulled away. It was hard to have dignity when she was naked, but she tried.

“You are right. I am running away. I always run. I’m a coward and a worse person than you can possibly know. You two are amazing men, and under different circumstances, I would love to stay and play with you forever, but we all have to pay a price for our actions, and the debt I owe is to Lindy. And the only way I can truly pay it is to leave town forever.”

She fled to the bathroom before they could see her cry.

She was in the shower, sobbing, when the door opened. Just for a minute, her heart soared. Maybe… But then the door closed quickly after her clothes and purse were thrust through the opening.

A few minutes later, she was walking down the stairs, but neither man could be seen. The front door was open, and she could see a cab waiting. She walked out the door without looking back.

* * * *

Connor and Liam were in the living room, not able to bear to watch her walk away. They left the front door open for her and waited, listening to her walking down the stairs and then close the door behind her as she walked out of their lives.

They watched from the window as she got into the cab, not once looking back at their house.

When the cab was out of sight, Liam sank down onto the couch, his face buried in his hands.

“God damn it. We only knew her a single night. Why do I feel like my heart has been ripped out?”

“She was the one, Liam. She was it. She should be ours.”

“Shut the fuck up, Connor. Stop talking about the
one
. I should never have listened to you. I believed you that there was a woman for us who would meet us and we would all magically know that we were meant to be together forever. I thought…” His voice trailed off.

“She was the one, Liam,” insisted Connor. “That was real. You felt it, too. Don’t try to tell me that it was all me or that you were going along with me. You felt it, too. I know you did.”

“So what. So fucking what? What if I did feel this pull you keep talking about. Clearly she didn’t and now I feel worse than I did before we met her. It’s like Santa brought me the best gift ever and I woke up the next morning to find a god damned lump of coal.” Liam was up off the couch now and pacing back and forth.

“So that’s it? You are just giving up on love and forever?”

“Connor. There is no love or forever. We just had one fantastic night of sex…”

“No.” Connor interrupted his brother. “No. Last night wasn’t just physical. There was an emotional connection. I felt it. And I know she felt it. I’m thinking that it scared her and that’s part of the reason why she ran.”

“You are crazy, you know that. You are certifiable. No one falls in love that quickly.”

“Our parents did.”

Liam stopped pacing. He ran his hand though his hair.

“Our parents eloped after knowing each other only twenty-four hours and they are still happily married,” continued Connor. “It can happen. You know it as well as I do.”

“But she doesn’t seem to know it,” countered Liam. “And what was she babbling about regarding her sister and having to leave town?”

“Whatever it is, we’ll figure it out, Liam. I don’t believe that softhearted Lindy would make her leave town, but if she did, we are planning on opening new clubs. We’ll just find out what city Cindy’s moving to and open one there.”

“You seem to have all the answers.”

“All I know is that I’m not giving up. And if you are, then I’m going after her on my own.”

Liam looked at Connor and grinned.

“Over my dead body. You said it yourself. She’s ours. I say we hunt her down, drag her back here and fuck her until she admits it.”

“Glad you are on board, bro, although I think your plan may need some work.”

An hour later, Cindy was in a restaurant sitting opposite her sister. Lindy looked amazing. She was glowing with happiness. Jake was obviously good for her. She’d been talking on the phone when Cindy arrived, but she quickly hung up and jumped up to hug her sister.

“So, where did you get off to last night? One minute you were there, and then you were gone. I called the apartment this morning, but Serena said you were out. But I know you aren’t a morning person.”

“I was with Connor and Liam last night. And this morning.”

Lindy beamed at her. “Oh, Cindy. They are great guys. I hope it works out.” And then her face got serious. “You aren’t toying with them, are you? You are my sister, and I love you, but you have a certain history…” She trailed off uncertainly.

“You have every right to wonder about me and about my motives. Growing up, I was the ‘perfect’ daughter. Sweet and dainty and looking like a Barbie doll. You have no idea just how jealous of you I was. I was eaten up by it.”

Lindy looked shocked.

“You were jealous of me?”

“Oh, yeah. You were everything I wasn’t. You were smart and athletic and people listened when you talked. I was the “pretty” one. But people acted like I didn’t have a brain in my head. If you went out without makeup, your hair thrown back, you were a natural beauty. If I did the same, people criticized me. I had to be perfect, look perfect for the folks to love me.”

“What are you talking about? I was jealous of you. You were so pretty and popular, and no one joked about you being too tall to land a man.”

“No, but they told me that the only way I could succeed in life was to land a man. It became my reason for being. I judged myself on male attention. If a man didn’t pay attention to me, I felt unworthy. When you brought Jason Chadwick home, I knew it was serious. I was so jealous of you. I went after him when you weren’t looking. I flirted, I flattered, and when he wouldn’t bite, I set him up so you would think that your boyfriend was sleeping with your sister.

“Lindy, I am so sorry. I was such a bitch to you. I went after every man who showed the slightest interest in you, but what I did with Jason was the worst. It was bad enough with Cam and Freddie. They were happy enough to jump into bed with me when I batted my eyes at them, but Jason was innocent. I set him up and made sure you found out. I was a horrible person, and as the years went by, it just ate at me. I knew I needed to apologize to you, make it up to you, but how do I say sorry for that? So I figured I had to show you how sorry I was, and to do that, I had to become a better person. And that’s why I left Seattle. To rediscover myself and come back triumphant and lord it over you again, this time as the kinder, more compassionate sister.