By His Rules (33 page)

your life.”

“No. But it’s a reminder of what I’ve known all

along. That I’m stupid and not very talented, and that I’m

embarrassing myself by trying to pretend otherwise.”

Keaton reached over and cupped Aiden’s jaw,

turning Aiden’s face toward him. With the four fingers of

his other hand, he delivered a quick slap to Aiden’s

cheek.

“Ow!” Aiden ducked away, one hand on his cheek.

“Don’t talk about yourself that way.”

The sting faded fast; Keaton had avoided the

shadowy bruise where Scott had struck him last night.

“The reason I haven’t brought up our future,”

Keaton said slowly, “is that I don’t know any more than

you do. I don’t know where we’ll end up. But I do know

I love you, and I’m willing to navigate situations as they

arise. I don’t think you going to school or me taking a

teaching post somewhere else automatically means we

can’t stay together.”

It sounded reasonable, put that way. Aiden folded

his arms on the table and buried his head in them. “You

must think I’m such an idiot.”

“No. I think your confusion makes a lot of sense. I

just wish you’d come to me so we could deal with it

together.”

“I guess it wouldn’t help to say I’m sorry?”

“It would help. But it won’t fix everything.”

Aiden nodded. He sat up, scrubbing his eyes. “I’m

sorry I ruined our relationship.” He pushed his chair

back. Keaton put a hand on his, keeping him in place.

“You keep saying that. But I fail to see how the

relationship is ‘ruined.’ You broke an important rule.

You broke it repeatedly, over a long period of time. In

doing so, you put yourself in danger. There are

consequences for disobedience, but it certainly doesn’t

mean the end of our relationship.”

Aiden swallowed. “But—what I did is so much

worse than anything I’ve done before.”

“It’s still a matter of a broken rule. Nothing more,

nothing less.”

“So… what, you’ll punish me? And then we’ll be

okay?”

“Does that sound fair to you?”

“It sounds too easy. Keaton, I basically cheated.”

“You didn’t sleep with Scott. You didn’t touch him

sexually or let him touch you. You stopped the

whipping before it got too far underway. As long as I get

a promise, in writing, copied out a few hundred times,

that you will
never
go anywhere with that man again—I’d

say we’re all right on that front.”

Aiden shook his head. “I wouldn’t feel all right.

How are you going to punish me? I mean, you spank me

when I bite my nails. How are you supposed to punish

me when I fucking ruin everything?”

Keaton shook his head. “You didn’t ‘ruin

everything.’ You put yourself in danger. It’s the same

principle—you do something that endangers your health

or your safety, you get spanked.”

“So you’re just going to spank me? Keaton, that’s

not good enough!”

“Why not?”

Aiden shifted, agitated, not sure how to make

Keaton understand. “It won’t hurt enough. I’ll still feel

guilty. Use something harder than your hand, at least.”

“What do you recommend?” Keaton asked.

“Your belt,” Aiden replied, even though the

thought sent a spike of fear through him. “You should

whip me. I deserve it.”

Keaton stood up. Aiden tensed, afraid Keaton

meant to take his suggestion here and now. Keaton stood

behind his chair. “Take your shirt off.”

Aiden swallowed and removed his T-shirt. He

shivered a little as Keaton’s hand brushed his shoulder,

tracing the swollen weal where Scott’s first stroke had

landed. Keaton moved his hand lower, dragging the heat

of his palm over the welt on the middle of Aiden’s back.

He pressed just hard enough that Aiden’s nerves

jumped, the lingering ache spreading from his flesh to

his brain. “Like this?” Keaton asked. “Is this how you

deserve to hurt?”

Aiden shuddered as Keaton touched the lowest cut,

the one that snaked down around his hip, disappearing

under the waistband of his pants. Aiden nodded. “Yes.”

“It doesn’t scare you? The thought of me whipping

you, leaving marks like this?”

“I deserve to be scared.”

“Is that how this works?” Keaton asked, touching

the bruised hollow at the base of Aiden’s spine, his

fingertips playing so lightly over the sore flesh that

Aiden arched into the dual sensation—pain and

pleasure. “I use discipline to scare you into behaving? I

use pain to keep you under my control?” He moved his

hand to a patch of unmarked flesh on Aiden’s back and

stroked.

“You should,” Aiden said bitterly.

“I won’t,” Keaton said simply. “Ever.”

Aiden put the pen down and flexed his hand. He

didn’t even want to think about what it would be like

writing lines later, with his butt sore and his hand

already tired from this writing assignment. Keaton had

asked him to make a list of events, reasons, and feelings

that had led to his decision to meet Scott at Obey last

night. His list was now three pages long and included

twenty-three items, and he’d tried to explicate each one

as thoroughly as possible.

His stomach grumbled contentedly. Keaton had

hovered over him while Aiden ate every last bite of what

had to be the World’s Most Balanced Lunch. He felt

good, comfortable, except for the cramp in his hand. He

frowned at the list. These all looked like excuses. He

didn’t understand how Keaton could forgive him. Maybe

he wouldn’t. Maybe he would pretend to, but this would

always be between them, eating away at their

relationship.

Aiden knew his guilt would linger long after

Keaton was done spanking him. A hand spanking wasn’t

going to make him feel he’d paid for his mistake. Which

fueled his worry that Keaton would always be too

gentle, too kind to convince Aiden to stop acting out.

He could tell Keaton that.

The idea was novel, frightening, and perfect.

He took the list and went to the living room, where

Keaton was reading on the couch. “I’m done,” he said.

Keaton closed his book. “How do you feel?”

“Okay. I wanted to talk to you about—I just wanted

to talk to you.”

Keaton patted the couch beside him. Aiden sat

down, a little stiff and uncertain, but Keaton put an arm

around him and drew him close, and they sat just as they

always had, Aiden’s head resting on Keaton’s shoulder,

Keaton’s hand rubbing circles on his back. “What’s on

your mind?”

“I’m worried this punishment won’t—won’t make

me feel like I’ve paid for what I did. And I’m worried

you won’t really forgive me, either. You might say you

do, and you might believe it, but what if you never can?”

Keaton’s fingertips trailed up and down his spine.

“That’s something we’ll deal with if it comes up. I’ll try

to be as open and honest with you as I expect you to be

with me. But Aiden, I’m not angry with you. That may be

hard for you to believe, but I’m not. I was angry last

night, and afraid. It upset me to learn that you’d been

dealing with your feelings alone. But that’s as much my

fault as it is yours.”

Aiden sat up. “Are you crazy?”

“You tried to talk to me last night.”

“I was being a total asshole. You were right; that

wasn’t the time or the place to talk about it.”

“But you needed to talk then. I shouldn’t have

brushed you off.”

“Don’t you dare. If you start blaming yourself, I

swear, I’m not going to stay in this room with you.”

“Part of the job of the dominant partner in a

discipline relationship is to pick up on signs that a sub

needs help but isn’t sure how to ask for it.”

“
I
didn’t even know how bad I was getting. How

the hell could you have known?” Aiden demanded.

“We both have responsibilities in this relationship.

I’m willing to forgive you if you’re willing to forgive

me.”

“There’s nothing to forgive,” Aiden said angrily.

“None of this is your fault at all.”

Keaton ruffled his hair. “I can’t take your guilt

away. It’s a natural consequence of your mistake and

may not disappear just because you were punished. But

I will help you through it.”

Aiden rubbed his cheek against Keaton’s shoulder.

“I know you’re worried about scaring me or whatever.

But I’m not delicate. I can take a lot.”

“I know that. But your job is to accept what I give

you.”

The words hit Aiden hard. It was as though he

understood—truly

understood—his

role

in

this

relationship for the first time. Keaton was in charge.

Keaton decided what punishments were appropriate.

Keaton exerted control, not through brutality, but

through doing things on his own terms, quietly confident

that he knew what Aiden needed. And he usually did—

better than Aiden knew himself.

“Yes, Sir,” he said softly, hoping Keaton wouldn’t

correct his use of “Sir.” He needed to say it.

Keaton seemed to understand. “Good boy,” he

said. He gave Aiden’s shoulders a last squeeze. “If

you’re ready, you can stand up and take your jeans

down.”

Shit. Somehow time always sped up in the seconds

before a punishment. Aiden stood, unbuttoned his jeans,

and struggled to get his breathing and heart rate in order

as Keaton took his wrist and guided him over his lap.

Aiden wriggled forward, making sure his torso was

properly supported by the couch, but this sent his

bottom high into the air. Keaton wasted no time, sliding

Aiden’s briefs down to midthigh and raising his own

knee to tilt Aiden’s rear higher still.

“Are you comfortable?” Keaton asked.

Aiden shut his eyes. He hated that question. Of

course he wasn’t comfortable.

“This isn’t going to be quick.”

“I’m fine,” Aiden said. And really he was. His heart

thudded, his butt was naked and high in the air, and his

throat was tight with anticipation—but he was all right.

Everything here was familiar—the couch, Keaton’s lap,

his acute sense of awkwardness and dread… He was

going to come out of this sore but in one piece. There

was a rustle of paper as Keaton took Aiden’s list and set

it on the couch, in Aiden’s line of view.

Keaton rested his hand on Aiden’s rump, rubbing a

gentle circle on the tense flesh. “What is this spanking

for?” he asked.

Another question Aiden hated. He closed his eyes

again. “Because I’m an idiot,” he mumbled.

Keaton patted his bottom. “Try again.”

Aiden didn’t respond, hoping Keaton would get

frustrated and start swatting.

Keaton gave him a brisk rub and another pat. “This

happens on my terms, not yours, young man,” he said.

Aiden winced. Why was this concept so hard for

him? Keaton was in charge. Aiden needed to submit.

“Because I went with Scott,” he said.

“That’s part of it,” Keaton said. “Meeting with Scott

was dangerous. This punishment isn’t for any of the

feelings that led you to that decision. This punishment is

for breaking rule number five. I’m not a mind reader.

You need to tell me when something’s bothering you.

Scott harassing you isn’t something you should have

kept from me. Same with your concerns about our

relationship.”

“I know,” Aiden said. “I’m sorry.”

Keaton lifted his palm and brought it down hard.

He did it again, and again.

Shit!
Aiden never remembered how much Keaton’s

hand hurt. He clenched his teeth and tried not to buck as

Keaton covered his butt with a hail of sharp swats.
How

did I ever think this wouldn’t hurt enough?

Keaton’s second circuit left Aiden breathless. Aiden

dug his fingers into the upholstery of the couch. He

promised himself he wasn’t going to beg, wasn’t going to

squirm. He took a breath and held it, then was forced to

let it out when a third round of swats brought tears to his

eyes. He reminded himself that he deserved every

smack, and willed himself not to plead out loud for

Keaton to lessen the severity of the blows.

“Let it out,” Keaton urged, pausing for a few

seconds to rub the small of Aiden’s back.

Aiden choked back a sob and shook his head.