Broken Promise (16 page)

Marla shook her head. “I can’t.”

Duckworth slid the photo of Rosemary Gaynor toward her again. “Was this your angel?”

Marla gave the picture another look. “I don’t know.”

“What do you mean, you don’t know? Either this is her or it isn’t.”

“I . . . have trouble,” Marla said. “With faces.”

“But this only just happened in the last twenty-four hours.”

“It’s the prosopagnosia,” Marla said.

Confusion flashed across the faces of both lawyer and detective.

“I’m sorry. Proso – what?” Duckworth said.

“I have it,” Marla said. “Not real bad, but bad enough. Prosopagnosia.” She paused. “Face blindness.”

“What’s that?” Duckworth asked.

“I can’t remember faces. I can’t remember what people look like.” Marla pointed to the picture. “So it might have been that woman who gave me Matthew. But I just don’t know.”

TWENTY

David

“WHOA,”
I said, backing away from the door, putting my hands in the air. The last thing I wanted to do was appear threatening as Sam—make that Samantha—Worthington pointed that shotgun at my head.

“Who’d you say you were?” she asked. “What are you doing asking about my boy? Did they send you?”

“I think there’s some kind of misunderstanding here,” I said, slowly lowering my arms, but still keeping lots of space between my hands and my body. For all I knew, she thought I was carrying a gun and might reach for it. Why else would you show up at the door with a shotgun?

I continued, trying to keep my voice even. “My name’s David Harwood. I’m Ethan’s dad. Our boys go to school together. Ethan and Carl.”

“What’s the name of the school?” Sam asked.

“What?”

“Name it. Name the school.”

“Clinton Street Elementary,” I said.

“What’s the teacher’s name?”

I had to think. “Ms. Moffat,” I said.

The shotgun began to lower. If she shot me now, it’d be my chest that got blown away and not my head. A slight improvement, perhaps.

“Did I pass the test?” I asked. Because that was certainly what it felt like.

“Maybe,” she said.

From inside the house, someone shouted, “Who is it, Mom?” A boy. Carl, presumably.

Sam whirled her head around, no more than a second. “Stay in the kitchen!” she said. There wasn’t another peep out of Carl.

“Brandon’s folks didn’t send you?” Sam asked me.

“I don’t know a Brandon,” I said.

She studied me another five seconds, breathing through her nose. Finally she lowered the shotgun all the way, pointing it at the floor. I let my arms go limp, but I didn’t move any closer to the door.

“What is it you want?” she asked.

“Right now, a change of shorts,” I said. I looked for any hint of a smile and did not find one. “My son gave your boy an antique watch. It was a mistake. It wasn’t his to give. It belongs to his grandfather. Actually, it was his father’s. It’s kind of a family memento.”

“A watch?”

“A pocket watch.” I made a circle with my thumb and forefinger. “A little bigger than an Oreo.”

“Just a minute,” she said. “Stay right there.” She closed the door. I heard a chain slide into place.

So I cooled my heels out front. Put my hands into my pockets. Smiled as an elderly woman wheeled past with a small grocery cart. She ignored me.

Here it was, only midafternoon. I’d found a body, been interrogated by the police, and now had been threatened with a shotgun. I was afraid to wonder what the rest of the day would bring.

My phone rang.

I dug the cell out of my pocket and looked at the number. It was not one I recognized. Maybe it was Detective Duckworth with more questions. I accepted the call and put the phone to my ear.

“Hello?”

“Is this David Harwood?” It was a man’s voice. Gruff, and louder than it needed to be.

“Who’s calling?” I asked.

“Randall Finley. You know who I am?”

It would have been hard not to, particularly in my line of work. The former mayor, whose bid for higher office crashed and burned when it got out that he had used the services of an underage prostitute.

“Yeah, I know who you are,” I said.

“I used to read your stuff in the
Standard
. You were a good reporter. Think you interviewed me more than once in the past.”

“Yes,” I said.

“So anyway, why I’m calling. I hear you got hired back by the paper just as it went down the toilet.”

I said nothing.

“That had to be a hell of a thing. You’d gone to Boston, am I right?”

“That’s right,” I said slowly.

“And then came back. Raising a boy on your own, that’s what I hear. After that business with your wife a few years ago.”

“What can I do for you, Mr. Finley?”

“I don’t know if you know what I’m up to these days.”

“Not really.”

“Since I got out of serving the people I started up a business. Bottling springwater. Pure, delicious, chemical-free water,” Finley said. “It’s a thriving business.”

“Great.”

“But I’m also thinking of getting back into public service. Going to take another try running Promise Falls.”

What a thought.

“Well,” I said. “That’s something. But the thing is, I’m not a reporter these days. The
Standard
is gone. I’m not freelancing for anyone, either. Freelance has totally dried up. If you want publicity for your plans, if you’re putting out a release or something, you’re probably best contacting media in Albany. They still cover stories up this way if they’re interesting enough, and I think I can say a comeback bid by you would get their attention.”

“No, no, you’re way off,” Finley said. “I’m offering you a position. A job.”

I couldn’t think of a thing to say.

“You there?”

“Yeah,” I said. “I’m here.”

“You sound pretty excited,” he said.

“I don’t think I’m your guy,” I said.

“I haven’t even told you what the job entails. Thing is, I can’t manage everything. I can’t manage this company, run a campaign, do PR, answer phone calls, field media inquiries, get the word out, all that shit, without my fucking head blowing up. You know what I’m saying?”

“Sure.”

“I need an administrative assistant, I guess you would call it. Handle the media, do publicity, put shit up on Facebook and Twitter, which I totally fucking don’t understand, but I get that these days you have to use everything that’s out there. Am I right?”

“Like I said, I don’t think I’m your guy.”

“Why?” Finley asked. “Because I’m an asshole?”

He caught me again at a loss for words.

“Because that’s what I am. Ask around. Hell, you don’t need to ask around. You worked for the paper. You know what I’m like. I’m an asshole. So what? Do you know how many people would have jobs if they refused to work for assholes? The whole fucking country would be unemployed. So what if I’m an asshole? I’m an asshole willing to pay you a thousand bucks a week. How does that sound?”

The door opened. Sam was back.

“I have to go,” I said, raising an index finger at Sam.

“You’d start right away if you’re interested,” Finley said. “Tell you what. Think on it overnight and let me know tomorrow. You’re not the only guy from the
Standard
who’s out of work, you know. But from asking around, sounded like you might be the best. A grand a week. Think about it. It’ll be fun. We’ll be stirring up some major shit.”

Randall Finley ended the call.

Dumbfounded, I put the phone back into my jacket and looked apologetically at Samantha Worthington.

“Sorry about that,” I said.

“My kid doesn’t have that watch,” she said, and closed the door.

TWENTY-ONE

BARRY
Duckworth didn’t have enough on Marla Pickens to hold her. He had no choice but to let her leave with Natalie Bondurant. But he didn’t think it would be long before he had her back in that interrogation room. The techs were at her house, looking for evidence. He’d already heard they’d found blood by the front door, and on the handle of the stroller. A DNA analysis wouldn’t be coming overnight, but if that blood matched Rosemary Gaynor’s, Marla Pickens was going down. And with any luck, Duckworth thought, he’d have something on her even before that.

The fact that she had Rosemary’s baby—Jesus, it just hit him that he’d stumbled into a horror movie—was not in itself proof that Marla had killed the woman. Damning, yes, but not proof. Her story about an angel coming to the door and handing over Matthew was pure and utter bullshit, with no supporting evidence, so it didn’t worry him much. It wasn’t that he had to disprove that story. He just had to prove Marla was at that house on Breckonwood Drive.

And he had to find the nanny.

Sarita.

Bill Gaynor had been no help there, but they had found his wife’s cell phone in her purse, which was sitting in plain view on the kitchen counter. If Rosemary Gaynor’s killer had taken anything from it, and there was nothing to suggest he had, he’d apparently had no interest in her cash or credit cards.

He?
Duckworth thought. More likely
she.

When Duckworth was finished with Marla Pickens, he checked his own phone, which he’d felt vibrate during the interrogation. An e-mail from one of the officers on the scene informed him that there was a contact listing for “Sarita” in the Gaynor woman’s phone.

No last name.

So Duckworth tapped on the number, automatically dialing it, and listened.

After three rings: “Hello?”

The voice sounded female, so he asked, “Is this Sarita?”

“Sarita?”

“That’s right. Are you Sarita?”

“Sarita who?”

Duckworth sighed. “I’m trying to get in touch with Sarita. Am I talking to Sarita?” Bill Gaynor had suggested Sarita was an illegal immigrant, but the detective did not detect any kind of foreign accent.

“I don’t have a last name. I’m looking for Sarita. She works as a nanny.”

“Who is calling?”

He hesitated. “Duckworth. Detective Duckworth, with the Promise Falls police.”

“I don’t know any Sarita. There is no Sarita here. You have the wrong number.”

“I don’t think so,” he said. “It’s very important that I speak to Sarita.”

“Like I said, I don’t know how you got this number.”

“If you’re not Sarita, then do you know her? Because I—”

The call ended. Duckworth had been hung up on. “Shit,” he said. He never should have identified himself as being with the police.

He returned to his desk, and just as he’d suspected, word had gotten around about his first call of the day. Placed in front of his computer monitor was a jar of salted peanuts, with a yellow sticky note attached that read,
For paying your informants.

The twenty-three dead squirrels. Was that actually today? It seemed like a week ago.

He cracked the lid, poured out a handful of nuts, tossed them into his mouth. Then he entered the phone number he’d just dialed into the Google search field on his computer. If it was a landline, there was a good chance the name of the person who owned that phone would come up.

No such luck.

But not all was lost, even if the phone was a cell. Unless it was a throwaway, they’d be able to attach a name to it in no time. Duckworth could get someone on that. The Internet abounded with firms offering to track down cell-phone identities for a price, but they often promised more than they could actually deliver.

Duckworth forwarded the officer’s e-mail containing Sarita’s number to Connor Stigler, in communications, with the words:
Whose number is this?

Then he phoned his wife, Maureen.

“Did you have one?” she asked him.

“Have one what?”

“On the way to work. A doughnut.”

“I did not.” It was nice not to have to lie for once. “It was a close one, though.”

“You sound like you’re eating something right now.”

“Peanuts,” he said. “What’s for dinner?”

“Gee, I don’t know,” she said. “What are you making?”

“Seriously?”

“Why is it always my responsibility? Maybe you didn’t get the memo. I work, too.”

“Okay. I’m bringing home a bucket of fried chicken, mashed potatoes, and gravy.”

“Well played,” Maureen said. “I’m serving fish. Pickerel.” She paused. “And some greens.”

“Greens,” Duckworth said. “Maybe I
will
pick up fried chicken.”

Maureen ignored the threat. “Will you be late?”

“Maybe. I’ll keep you posted. Heard from Trevor?”

Their son. Twenty-four years old, looking for work. He didn’t live with them, or anyone else, for that matter. Not anymore. The love of his life, a girl named Trish, who’d traveled across Europe with him, had recently broken things off. Trevor, devastated, now had a two-bedroom apartment all to himself. Barry and Maureen didn’t hear from him as often as they’d like, and they worried about him.

“Not today,” Maureen said. “Maybe I’ll give him a call. See if he wants to come for dinner.”

“For fish? Good luck with that.”

“It doesn’t have to be today.”

“Okay, do that. Listen, gotta go.”

He’d noticed that he already had an e-mail back from Connor.

It read:
L SELFRIDGE 209 ARMOUR ROAD.

As he was pushing his chair back from the desk, uniformed officer Angus Carlson walked past, glanced at Duckworth and the jar of peanuts, and smiled.

Before Duckworth could level an accusation, Carlson said, “Wasn’t me.” Paused, then added, “I’d have to be nuts to mock a superior officer.”

•   •   •

The Armour Road address was a rooming house, a three-story Victorian home that had been broken down into apartments. There was a buzzer by the front door labeled M
ANAGER
. Duckworth buzzed. Moments later, a short, heavyset woman with little more than a few wisps of hair came to the door and opened it a few inches.

“Yeah?”

“Ms. Selfridge?” he asked.

“Mrs. But the mister died a few years back. We don’t have any vacancies, but you can leave your name if you’d like.”