Authors: Agatha Christie
A
t 19, Wilbraham Crescent the machinery of the Law was in possession. There was a police surgeon, a police photographer, fingerprint men. They moved efficiently, each occupied with his own routine.
Finally came Detective Inspector Hardcastle, a tall, pokerfaced man with expressive eyebrows, godlike, to see that all he had put in motion was being done, and done properly. He took a final look at the body, exchanged a few brief words with the police surgeon and then crossed to the dining room where three people sat over empty teacups. Miss Pebmarsh, Colin Lamb and a tall girl with brown curling hair and wide, frightened eyes. “Quite pretty,” the inspector noted, parenthetically as it were.
He introduced himself to Miss Pebmarsh.
“Detective Inspector Hardcastle.”
He knew a little about Miss Pebmarsh, though their paths had never crossed professionally. But he had seen her about, and he was
aware that she was an ex-schoolteacher, and that she had a job connected with the teaching of Braille at the Aaronberg Institute for handicapped children. It seemed wildly unlikely that a man should be found murdered in her neat, austere houseâbut the unlikely happened more often than one would be disposed to believe.
“This is a terrible thing to have happened, Miss Pebmarsh,” he said. “I'm afraid it must have been a great shock to you. I'll need to get a clear statement of exactly what occurred from you all. I understand that it was Missâ” he glanced quickly at the notebook the constable had handed him, “Sheila Webb who actually discovered the body. If you'll allow me to use your kitchen, Miss Pebmarsh, I'll take Miss Webb in there where we can be quiet.”
He opened the connecting door from the dining room to the kitchen and waited until the girl had passed through. A young plainclothes detective was already established in the kitchen, writing unobtrusively at a Formica-topped small table.
“This chair looks comfortable,” said Hardcastle, pulling forward a modernized version of a Windsor chair.
Sheila Webb sat down nervously, staring at him with large frightened eyes.
Hardcastle very nearly said: “I shan't eat you, my dear,” but repressed himself, and said instead:
“There's nothing to worry about. We just want to get a clear picture. Now your name is Sheila Webbâand your address?”
“14, Palmerstone Roadâbeyond the gasworks.”
“Yes, of course. And you are employed, I suppose?”
“Yes. I'm a shorthand typistâI work at Miss Martindale's Secretarial Bureau.”
“The Cavendish Secretarial and Typewriting Bureauâthat's its full name, isn't it?”
“That's right.”
“And how long have you been working there?”
“About a year. Well, ten months actually.”
“I see. Now just tell me in your own words how you came to be at 19, Wilbraham Crescent today.”
“Well, it was this way.” Sheila Webb was speaking now with more confidence. “This Miss Pebmarsh rang up the Bureau and asked for a stenographer to be here at three o'clock. So when I came back from lunch Miss Martindale told me to go.”
“That was just routine, was it? I meanâyou were the next on the listâor however you arrange these things?”
“Not exactly. Miss Pebmarsh had asked for me specially.”
“Miss Pebmarsh had asked for you specially.” Hardcastle's eyebrows registered this point. “I see ⦠Because you had worked for her before?”
“But I hadn't,” said Sheila quickly.
“You hadn't? You're quite sure of that?”
“Oh, yes, I'm positive. I mean, she's not the sort of person one would forget. That's what seems so odd.”
“Quite. Well, we won't go into that just now. You reached here when?”
“It must have been just before three o'clock, because the cuckoo clockâ” she stopped abruptly. Her eyes widened. “How queer. How very queer. I never really noticed at the time.”
“What didn't you notice, Miss Webb?”
“Whyâthe clocks.”
“What about the clocks?”
“The cuckoo clock struck three all right, but all the others were about an hour fast. How very odd!”
“Certainly very odd,” agreed the inspector. “Now when did you first notice the body?”
“Not till I went round behind the sofa. And there itâheâwas. It was awful, yes awfulâ¦.”
“Awful, I agree. Now did you recognize the man? Was it anyone you had seen before?”
“Oh
no.
”
“You're quite sure of that? He might have looked rather different from the way he usually looked, you know. Think carefully. You're quite sure he was someone you'd never seen before?”
“Quite sure.”
“Right. That's that. And what did you do?”
“What did I
do?
”
“Yes.”
“Whyânothing ⦠nothing at all. I couldn't.”
“I see. You didn't touch him at all?”
“Yesâyes I did. To see ifâI meanâjust to seeâBut he wasâquite coldâandâand I got blood on my hand. It was horribleâthick and sticky.”
She began to shake.
“There, there,” said Hardcastle in an avuncular fashion. “It's all over now, you know. Forget about the blood. Go on to the next thing. What happened next?”
“I don't know ⦠Oh, yes, she came home.”
“Miss Pebmarsh, you mean?”
“Yes. Only I didn't think about her being Miss Pebmarsh then. She just came in with a
shopping
basket.” Her tone underlined the shopping basket as something incongruous and irrelevant.
“And what did you say?”
“I don't think I said anything ⦠I tried to, but I couldn't. I felt all choked up
here.
” She indicated her throat.
The inspector nodded.
“And thenâand thenâshe said: âWho's there?' and she came round the back of the sofa and I thoughtâI thought she was going toâto tread on
It.
And I screamed ⦠And once I began I couldn't stop screaming, and somehow I got out of the room and through the front doorâ”
“Like a bat out of hell,” the inspector remembered Colin's description.
Sheila Webb looked at him out of miserable frightened eyes and said rather unexpectedly:
“I'm sorry.”
“Nothing to be sorry about. You've told your story very well. There's no need to think about it any more now. Oh, just one point, why were you in that room at all?”
“Why?” She looked puzzled.
“Yes. You'd arrived here, possibly a few minutes early, and you'd pushed the bell, I suppose. But if nobody answered, why did you come in?”
“Oh that. Because she told me to.”
“Who told you to?”
“Miss Pebmarsh did.”
“But I thought you hadn't spoken to her at all.”
“No, I hadn't. It was Miss Martindale she said it toâthat I
was to come in and wait in the sitting room on the right of the hall.”
Hardcastle said: “Indeed” thoughtfully.
Sheila Webb asked timidly:
“Isâis that all?”
“I think so. I'd like you to wait here about ten minutes longer, perhaps, in case something arises I might want to ask you about. After that, I'll send you home in a police car. What about your familyâyou have a family?”
“My father and mother are dead. I live with an aunt.”
“And her name is?”
“Mrs. Lawton.”
The inspector rose and held out his hand.
“Thank you very much, Miss Webb,” he said. “Try and get a good night's rest tonight. You'll need it after what you've been through.”
She smiled at him timidly as she went through the door into the dining room.
“Look after Miss Webb, Colin,” the inspector said. “Now, Miss Pebmarsh, can I trouble you to come in here?”
Hardcastle had half held out a hand to guide Miss Pebmarsh, but she walked resolutely past him, verified a chair against the wall with a touch of her fingertips, drew it out a foot and sat down.
Hardcastle closed the door. Before he could speak, Millicent Pebmarsh said abruptly:
“Who's that young man?”
“His name is Colin Lamb.”
“So he informed me. But who is he? Why did he come here?”
Hardcastle looked at her in faint surprise.
“He happened to be walking down the street when Miss Webb rushed out of this house screaming murder. After coming in and satisfying himself as to what had occurred he rang us up, and was asked to come back here and wait.”
“You spoke to him as Colin.”
“You are very observant, Miss Pebmarshâ(observant? hardly the word. And yet none other fitted)âColin Lamb is a friend of mine, though it is some time since I have seen him.” He added: “He's a marine biologist.”
“Oh! I see.”
“Now, Miss Pebmarsh, I shall be glad if you can tell me anything about this rather surprising affair.”
“Willingly. But there is very little to tell.”
“You have resided here for some time, I believe?”
“Since 1950. I amâwasâa schoolmistress by profession. When I was told nothing could be done about my failing eyesight and that I should shortly go blind, I applied myself to become a specialist in Braille and various techniques for helping the blind. I have a job here at the Aaronberg Institute for Blind and Handicapped children.”
“Thank you. Now as to the events of this afternoon. Were you expecting a visitor?”
“No.”
“I will read you a description of the dead man to see if it suggests to you anyone in particular. Height five feet nine to ten, age approximately sixty, dark hair going grey, brown eyes, clean shaven, thin face, firm jaw. Well nourished but not fat. Dark grey suit, well-kept hands. Might be a bank clerk, an accountant, a lawyer, or a
professional man of some kind. Does that suggest to you anyone that you know?”
Millicent Pebmarsh considered carefully before replying.
“I can't say that it does. Of course it's a very generalized description. It would fit quite a number of people. It might be someone I have seen or met on some occasion, but certainly not anyone I know well.”
“You have not received any letter lately from anyone proposing to call upon you?”
“Definitely not.”
“Very good. Now, you rang up the Cavendish Secretarial Bureau and asked for the services of a stenographer andâ”
She interrupted him.
“Excuse me. I did nothing of the kind.”
“You did
not
ring up the Cavendish Secretarial Bureau and askâ” Hardcastle stared.
“I don't have a telephone in the house.”
“There is a call box at the end of the street,” Inspector Hardcastle pointed out.
“Yes, of course. But I can only assure you, Inspector Hardcastle, that I had no need for a stenographer and did notârepeat
not
âring up this Cavendish place with any such request.”
“You did not ask for Miss Sheila Webb particularly?”
“I have never heard that name before.”
Hardcastle stared at her, astonished.
“You left the front door unlocked,” he pointed out.
“I frequently do so in the daytime.”
“Anybody might walk in.”
“Anybody seems to have done so in this case,” said Miss Pebmarsh drily.
“Miss Pebmarsh, this man according to the medical evidence died roughly between 1:30 and 2:45. Where were you yourself then?”
Miss Pebmarsh reflected.
“At 1:30 I must either have left or been preparing to leave the house. I had some shopping to do.”
“Can you tell me exactly where you went?”
“Let me see. I went to the post office, the one in Albany Road, posted a parcel, got some stamps, then I did some household shopping, yes and I got some patent fasteners and safety pins at the drapers, Field and Wren. Then I returned here. I can tell you exactly what the time was. My cuckoo clock cuckooed three times as I came to the gate. I can hear it from the road.”
“And what about your other clocks?”
“I beg your pardon?”
“Your other clocks seem all to be just over an hour fast.”
“Fast? You mean the grandfather clock in the corner?”
“Not that onlyâall the other clocks in the sitting room are the same.”
“I don't understand what you mean by the âother clocks.' There are no other clocks in the sitting room.”
H
ardcastle stared.
“Oh come, Miss Pebmarsh. What about that beautiful Dresden china clock on the mantelpiece? And a small French clockâormolu. And a silver carriage clock, andâoh yes, the clock with âRosemary' across the corner.”
It was Miss Pebmarsh's turn to stare.
“Either you or I must be mad, Inspector. I assure you I have no Dresden china clock, noâwhat did you sayâclock with âRosemary' across itâno French ormolu clock andâwhat was the other one?”
“Silver carriage clock,” said Hardcastle mechanically.
“Not that either. If you don't believe me, you can ask the woman who comes to clean for me. Her name is Mrs. Curtin.”
Detective Inspector Hardcastle was taken aback. There was a positive assurance, a briskness in Miss Pebmarsh's tone that carried
conviction. He took a moment or two turning over things in his mind. Then he rose to his feet.
“I wonder, Miss Pebmarsh, if you would mind accompanying me into the next room?”
“Certainly. Frankly, I would like to see those clocks myself.”
“See?” Hardcastle was quick to query the word.
“Examine would be a better word,” said Miss Pebmarsh, “but even blind people, Inspector, use conventional modes of speech that do not exactly apply to their own powers. When I say I would like to
see
those clocks, I mean I would like to examine and
feel
them with my own fingers.”
Followed by Miss Pebmarsh, Hardcastle went out of the kitchen, crossed the small hall and into the sitting room. The fingerprint man looked up at him.
“I've about finished in here, sir,” he said. “You can touch anything you like.”
Hardcastle nodded and picked up the small travelling clock with “Rosemary” written across the corner. He put it into Miss Pebmarsh's hands. She felt it over carefully.
“It seems an ordinary travelling clock,” she said, “the leather folding kind. It is not mine, Inspector Hardcastle, and it was not in this room, I am fairly sure I can say, when I left the house at half past one.”
“Thank you.”
The inspector took it back from her. Carefully he lifted the small Dresden clock from the mantelpiece.
“Be careful of this,” he said, as he put it into her hands, “it's breakable.”
Millicent Pebmarsh felt the small china clock with delicate
probing fingertips. Then she shook her head. “It must be a charming clock,” she said, “but it's not mine. Where was it, do you say?”
“On the right hand side of the mantelpiece.”
“There should be one of a pair of china candlesticks there,” said Miss Pebmarsh.
“Yes,” said Hardcastle, “there is a candlestick there, but it's been pushed to the end.”
“You say there was still another clock?”
“Two more.”
Hardcastle took back the Dresden china clock and gave her the small French gilt ormolu one. She felt it over rapidly, then handed it back to him.
“No. That is not mine either.”
He handed her the silver one and that, too, she returned.
“The only clocks ordinarily in this room are a grandfather clock there in that corner by the windowâ”
“Quite right.”
“âand a cuckoo on the wall near the door.”
Hardcastle found it difficult to know exactly what to say next. He looked searchingly at the woman in front of him with the additional security of knowing that she could not return his survey. There was a slight frown as of perplexity on her forehead. She said sharply:
“I can't understand it. I simply can't understand it.”
She stretched out one hand, with the easy knowledge of where she was in the room, and sat down. Hardcastle looked at the fingerprint man who was standing by the door.
“You've been over these clocks?” he asked.
“I've been over everything, sir. No dabs on the gilt clock, but
there wouldn't be. The surface wouldn't take it. The same goes for the china one. But there are no dabs on the leather travelling clock or the silver one and that is a bit unlikely if things were normalâthere ought to be dabs. By the way, none of them are wound up and they are all set to the same timeâthirteen minutes past four.”
“What about the rest of the room?”
“There are about three or four different sets of prints in the room, all women's, I should say. The contents of the pockets are on the table.”
By an indication of his head he drew attention to a small pile of things on a table. Hardcastle went over and looked at them. There was a notecase containing seven pounds ten, a little loose change, a silk pocket handkerchief, unmarked, a small box of digestive pills and a printed card. Hardcastle bent to look at it.
Â
Mr. R. H. Curry,
Metropolis and Provincial Insurance Co. Ltd
7, Denvers Street,
London, W2.
Â
Hardcastle came back to the sofa where Miss Pebmarsh sat.
“Were you by any chance expecting someone from an insurance company to call upon you?”
“Insurance company? No, certainly not.”
“The Metropolis and Provincial Insurance Company,” said Hardcastle.
Miss Pebmarsh shook her head. “I've never heard of it,” she said.
“You were not contemplating taking out insurance of any kind?”
“No, I was not. I am insured against fire and burglary with the Jove Insurance Company which has a branch here. I carry no personal insurance. I have no family or near relations so I see no point in insuring my life.”
“I see,” said Hardcastle. “Does the name of Curry mean anything to you? Mr. R. H. Curry?” He was watching her closely. He saw no reaction in her face.
“Curry,” she repeated the name, then shook her head. “It's not a very usual name, is it? No, I don't think I've heard the name or known anyone of that name. Is that the name of the man who is dead?”
“It would seem possible,” said Hardcastle.
Miss Pebmarsh hesitated a moment. Then she said:
“Do you want me toâtoâtouchâ”
He was quick to understand her.
“Would you, Miss Pebmarsh? If it's not asking too much of you, that is? I'm not very knowledgeable in these matters, but your fingers will probably tell you more accurately what a person looks like than you would know by description.”
“Exactly,” said Miss Pebmarsh. “I agree it is not a very pleasant thing to have to do but I am quite willing to do it if you think it might be a help to you.”
“Thank you,” said Hardcastle. “If you will let me guide youâ”
He took her round the sofa, indicated to her to kneel down, then gently guided her hands to the dead man's face. She was very
calm, displaying no emotion. Her fingers traced the hair, the ears, lingering a moment behind the left ear, the line of the nose, mouth and chin. Then she shook her head and got up.
“I have a clear idea what he would look like,” she said, “but I am quite sure that it is no one I have seen or known.”
The fingerprint man had packed up his kit and gone out of the room. He stuck his head back in.
“They've come for him,” he said, indicating the body. “All right to take him away?”
“Right,” said Inspector Hardcastle. “Just come and sit over here, will you, Miss Pebmarsh?”
He established her in a corner chair. Two men came into the room. The removal of the late Mr. Curry was rapid and professional. Hardcastle went out to the gate and then returned to the sitting room. He sat down near Miss Pebmarsh.
“This is an extraordinary business, Miss Pebmarsh,” he said. “I'd like to run over the main points with you and see if I've got it right. Correct me if I am wrong. You expected no visitors today, you've made no inquiries re insurance of any kind and you have received no letter from anyone stating that a representative of an insurance company was going to call upon you today. Is that correct?”
“Quite correct.”
“You did
not
need the services of a shorthand typist or stenographer and you did
not
ring up the Cavendish Bureau or request that one should be here at three o'clock.”
“That again is correct.”
“When you left the house at approximately 1:30, there were in
this room only two clocks, the cuckoo clock and the grandfather clock. No others.”
About to reply, Miss Pebmarsh checked herself.
“If I am to be absolutely accurate, I could not swear to that statement. Not having my sight I would not notice the absence or presence of anything not usually in the room. That is to say, the last time I can be sure of the contents of this room was when I dusted it early this morning. Everything then was in its place. I usually do this room myself as cleaning women are apt to be careless with ornaments.”
“Did you leave the house at all this morning?”
“Yes. I went at ten o'clock as usual to the Aaronberg Institute. I have classes there until twelve fifteen. I returned here at about quarter to one, made myself some scrambled eggs in the kitchen and a cup of tea and went out again, as I have said, at half past one. I ate my meal in the kitchen, by the way, and did not come into this room.”
“I see,” said Hardcastle. “So while you can say definitely that at ten o'clock this morning there were no superfluous clocks here, they
could
possibly have been introduced some time during the morning.”
“As to that you would have to ask my cleaning woman, Mrs. Curtin. She comes here about ten and usually leaves about twelve o'clock. She lives at 17, Dipper Street.”
“Thank you, Miss Pebmarsh. Now we are left with these following facts and this is where I want you to give me any ideas or suggestions that occur to you. At some time during today four clocks were brought here. The hands of these four clocks were set
at thirteen minutes past four. Now does that time suggest anything to you?”
“Thirteen minutes past four.” Miss Pebmarsh shook her head. “Nothing at all.”
“Now we pass from the clocks to the dead man. It seems unlikely that he would have been let in by your cleaning woman and left in the house by her unless you had told her you were expecting him, but that we can learn from her. He came here presumably to see you for some reason, either a business one or a private one. Between one thirty and two forty-five he was stabbed and killed. If he came here by appointment, you say you know nothing of it. Presumably he was connected with insuranceâbut there again you cannot help us. The door was unlocked so he could have come in and sat down to wait for youâbut why?”
“The whole thing's daft,” said Miss Pebmarsh impatiently. “So you think that thisâwhat's-his-name Curryâbrought those clocks with him?”
“There's no sign of a container anywhere,” said Hardcastle. “He could hardly have brought four clocks in his pockets. Now Miss Pebmarsh, think very carefully. Is there any association in your mind, any suggestion you could possibly make about anything to do with clocks, or if not with clocks, say with
time.
4:13. Thirteen minutes past four?”
She shook her head.
“I've been trying to say to myself that it is the work of a lunatic or that somebody came to the wrong house. But even that doesn't really explain anything. No, Inspector, I can't help you.”
A young constable looked in. Hardcastle went to join him in
the hall and from there went down to the gate. He spoke for a few minutes to the men.
“You can take the young lady home now,” he said, “14 Palmerston Road is the address.”
He went back and into the dining room. Through the open door to the kitchen he could hear Miss Pebmarsh busy at the sink. He stood in the doorway.
“I shall want to take those clocks, Miss Pebmarsh. I'll leave you a receipt for them.”
“That will be quite all right, Inspectorâthey don't belong to meâ”
Hardcastle turned to Sheila Webb.
“You can go home now, Miss Webb. The police car will take you.”
Sheila and Colin rose.
“Just see her into the car, will you, Colin?” said Hardcastle as he pulled a chair to the table and started to scribble a receipt.
Colin and Sheila went out and started down the path. Sheila paused suddenly.
“My glovesâI left themâ”
“I'll get them.”
“NoâI know just where I put them. I don't mind
now
ânow that they've taken
it
away.”
She ran back and rejoined him a moment or two later.
“I'm sorry I was so sillyâbefore.”
“Anybody would have been,” said Colin.
Hardcastle joined them as Sheila entered the car. Then, as it drove away, he turned to the young constable.
“I want those clocks in the sitting room packed up carefullyâ
all except the cuckoo clock on the wall and the big grandfather clock.”
He gave a few more directions and then turned to his friend.
“I'm going places. Want to come?”
“Suits me,” said Colin.