Authors: Jane Caro
âSurely, as your loyal subject, he should have known.'
âAye, my lord. Surely he should. As a loyal member of my privy council he should have arrested Ridolfi on the spot and brought him to me for trial immediately.'
And then I was overwhelmed with a feeling of utter sadness. âHe carried the crown at my coronation. Do you remember, Cecil?'
âI do, Your Grace, I do.'
I leapt from my chair, suddenly furious. I paced up and down in front of Cecil, shaking my fist and venting my fury. âHow dare the first lord of my kingdom betray me in this way? Am I surrounded by such weak and vain fools that their sworn allegiance can turn on the mere promise of riches and glory? Who can I trust on my council if I cannot trust my lord of Norfolk? I will have his head for this. Surely he must know that?'
âHe must, Your Grace.'
âWho else is involved in this plot of the Italian banker â what was his name?'
âRidolfi, Your Grace.'
âIs he safely arrested, at least?'
âAye, Your Majesty.'
âAnd the traitor Norfolk?'
âMy agents search his house at this very moment.'
âAnd the Queen of Scots, what of her? Does she know of this plot, my lord?'
âIt is hard to say, Your Grace, although she has sent you a most curious letter.' Cecil searched through the sheaf of documents he held, found the one he wanted and passed it to me. I began to read. Once I had absorbed the gist of my royal cousin's communication, I looked up at him in astonishment.
âMy cousin claims to know a great secret that she can only confide to me in person.'
âYou must not allow yourself to be drawn into her presence under any terms but your own, Your Majesty.'
âBut what great secret could she be referring to, my lord?'
âI imagine she is ready to betray Norfolk, or perhaps bargain a passage to Europe in return for what she knows.'
I gave Cecil a sharp look. He and I still differed over the rights and wrongs of deposing a queen. He met my gaze steadily.
âYou must not meet with her, Your Majesty, certainly not on her terms. If she has something to tell you, let her tell you in a letter. You must not appear to be at that shameless woman's beck and call.'
In response I took up my quill and began to compose my reply. Once I had finished, I signed the letter and blotted it carefully. Then, with a flourish I lifted the paper and read aloud what I had written.
âYou have caused rebellion in my realm and you have aimed at my own life. You will say you did not mean these things. Madam, I would that I could think so poorly of your understanding.'
Cecil chuckled.
âThose who would work on me through my fears know little of my character. You tell me you have some mystery which you wish to make known to me. If it be so, you must write it. You are aware that I do not think it well that you and I should meet.'
â
Touché
, madam,
touché
.'
I handed the letter to an attendant and commanded it be delivered immediately. Then I turned back to my closest advisor. âI am glad you approve, Sir Spirit.'
âIt is the letter of a wise ruler, Your Grace, who cannot be easily manipulated by a scheming woman.'
âWhat is the next order of business?'
âWe must recall parliament, I think, Your Majesty. The times demand it.'
My buoyant mood faded immediately and my smile with it. â“Must” is not a word to be used to princes.'
âMy advice is to recall parliament. We need money to deal with the threats to your safety and that of your kingdom and only parliament has the power to give it to you.'
âI hate parliament. They always want to lecture me about my unmarried state and lack of children and to preach sermons about correct religious observance. They are dull and sanctimonious and do not know their rightful place.'
âBe that as it may, Your Majesty, they have powers which even you do not and they have not been called together for over ten years. It is time you let them have their say so that you may get your money.'
He was right, of course. I knew that I needed parliament to help me deal with the traitor Norfolk. My heart sank when I thought of his now inescapable fate. Silly, vainglorious man, he had sealed his destiny not with anything definitive or courageous, however foolhardy. No, entirely in keeping with his vacillating character, he had sealed it with an equivocation. With âwell'. Sadly it would not go well for him.
Sixteen
The robes of state I had to wear to open parliament made movement difficult, forcing me to look regal. The weight of the crown meant that I could only move my head slowly and I had to tense my neck to keep it upright. I looked down my nose at people, no doubt, but as much from necessity as choice. That night, after I had removed the crown and my attendants had placed it reverently back into its velvet-lined case, the relief from its weight left me feeling light-headed and giddy, as if my head really did float on air. The next morning, I woke to find my neck stiff and sore and as hard to move as when it actually bore the weight of the crown. To this day, whenever I must don my royal regalia, I know that my muscles will exact a price from me. Indeed, as I age and the ague intensifies, the weight of the crown grows heavier.
One evening when Blanche Parry and I tarried late over our supper, Blanche told me what my mother had said when told she was to be executed the next morning.
âI remember it like it happened yesterday, Your Grace.' Blanche put her own hands on either side of her neck. I said nothing, terrified that if I interrupted, she might stop speaking.
âThe rest of us were reeling from shock, but Queen Anne laughed and circled her neck with her fine, long fingers â like this.' And she demonstrated the gesture.
âWe watched her in horrified silence, but she looked at her gaoler and spoke. She had a lovely voice, low in tone and with the very slightest of French accents; I can hear it still.'
I was impatient to know the words of the woman who bore me, so dear to me and yet so unknown, but I held my tongue and let Blanche take her time.
â“Such a little neck,” she said and then she laughed. Not hysterically, mind you; she was in control. It was an eerie kind of laugh, Your Grace. It contained within it the knowledge of all the futility of everything she had done and everything that had happened. I think she was laughing at herself. She often laughed in moments of despair, at the irony of it all and the absurdity of life. She was a slight woman, as she said, Your Grace, but I never met a larger soul.'
I spent the day of the first sitting of parliament for ten years more conscious of my own neck than I had been since my sojourn in the Tower, when I had lived in daily fear of it being severed. I knew I was recalling parliament because I needed the money only they could provide to help preserve it â and theirs.
I had learnt the tricks of majesty well. I knew I had to impress those who occupied the benches of the House of Commons with my authority and my power, so I intended to employ all the pomp and ceremony at my disposal and count an aching (but intact) neck a very small price to pay. We must have made quite an imposing sight, my dignitaries and I as we sat in state in the parliamentary chamber.
As usual, even after a hiatus of so many years, the House of Commons and I were at cross-purposes. I suppose I should be more generous in spirit towards them â Cecil often chides me about my disdain for the parliamentarians â but they never fail to annoy me. They see themselves as having the right to lecture me on subjects that are none of their business.
The clerk of the parliaments, a nervous little man that Cecil later informed me went by the name of Fulk Onslow, began the proceedings, calling upon the new speaker. Sir Christopher Wray stood slowly and, after making the suitable obeisance in my direction, began his oration. No doubt the things he said were serious and meaningful, but I can recall not one word now. What I do recall is the fly that buzzed about me during Wray's speech. I could not easily shoo it away because I was afraid that too sudden a movement might dislodge my crown. Instead I waved my fan furiously in front of my nose to keep the creature at bay â I mean the fly, of course, not the honourable speaker.
It was hot inside the closed hall and soon the assembled multitude began to sweat. I was sweating too, beneath my ornate gown. A stench began to assail my nostrils of unwashed bodies packed too close together. I waved my fan even more furiously in front of my face. Otherwise, I sat perfectly still, impassive and immovable as befits a great queen. I noticed that others on the benches were also feeling the heat and discreetly fanning themselves with the sheaves of paper that MPs and councillors seem never to be without.
Sir Christopher talked on. He spoke slowly and occasionally jabbed the air to emphasise a point. He must, at last, have said something about the moneys that had caused me to recall parliament after so long, for I felt Cecil suddenly stir behind me.
When Wray finally resumed his seat, however, the ordeal was not over. Others on the benches had to have their say. Someone proposed a bill to reform the Book of Common Prayer. I kept my expression under control with some difficulty as the mover of the motion fulminated about the blasphemous idolatry the Book of Common Prayer contained. Why couldn't people leave well enough alone? It was popular with the common folk and as many people would object to any suggested âimprovements' as would praise them. God save me from self-righteous men, convinced that they and they alone know how other people should worship. When the man resumed his seat, I had trouble restraining an urge to sigh out loud. I restricted myself to a cough, but fixed him with a cold stare as he resumed his place and had the pleasure of seeing an uncomfortable flush rise over his features in response.
Then someone else got up and chastised me directly. This MP warned me sternly against becoming a tyrant and cautioned against behaving like the âGreat Turk'. The memory of this effrontery offends me still! All I could do at the time was oscillate my fan at an even more furious speed. Great Turk indeed! Am I not the most reasonable and merciful of sovereigns? I am only harsh on traitors and those who would have my throne from under me and even then I wish most heartily that I did not have to shed their blood to save my own. I may have begun to tremble a little with suppressed rage because Cecil â or Lord Burleigh as he had just become â leant discreetly forward and whispered in my ear. âNot much longer, Your Grace. Allowing a few foolish hotheads to spout words that disappear into the rafters as soon as they have been uttered is the price we must pay for access to the money we need.'
Then the discussion took a more pleasing turn. The House of Commons debated the recent Papal Bull and agreed that it would be high treason for anyone to declare that I was not their rightful queen, or that I was a heretic, schismatic, infidel or usurper. A voice at the back interjected âor tyrant' and I could not help turning my head (very slowly) and smiling at the source of such a welcome interjection.
As the debate proceeded, it was agreed that any Catholic priest discovered to be travelling about my kingdom in disguise could be whipped and set in the stocks like a common gypsy or vagrant. Finally, after what seemed many hot and tedious hours, a bill was passed declaring it treason to import any papers, writings or religious icons, objects or beads from the Bishop of Rome.
My royal cousin's name came up often in the seemingly endless pontificating of my MPs. Irritant although she was to me, I did not like to hear the name of a queen who was my closest living relative bandied about. One MP got so carried away he called her âa monstrous and huge dragon, and a mass of the earth'. If he thought to please me with such high-flown protestations he was deeply mistaken. I wished to squash him as fervently as the persistently buzzing fly. At least I eventually had the satisfaction of doing the latter. Towards the end of the session, I terminated that annoying creature's life with a well-timed swat of the heavy ivory stem of my fan.
Almost as an after-thought, parliament at last voted to give me the 100,000 pounds I needed for my treasury. Once this motion was passed I sensed Cecil almost slump with relief behind me. Poor Sir Spirit, his feet ached easily and as the years passed he suffered more frequently from the gout, so the many hours spent standing had not played kindly with him. I would have nodded my head at him encouragingly but the crown had grown heavier by the hour and I now felt as if I could no longer trust my poor aching neck to move my head at all.
âThe Queen of Scots is deeply involved in this conspiracy, Your Majesty.'
Cecil, Winchester, Knollys and Robin Dudley were gathered in front of me, their faces stern with the urgency of their mission.
âWe must take steps immediately against her. We have evidence, hereâ'
Cecil gestured to Robin who held up some papers.
âWe have evidence that the Queen of Scots has plans to escape and flee to Spain.'
âThis is not such a surprise, is it my lords? We have known for some time that a conspiracy of some kind was afoot.'
âAye, Your Majesty, but now we have the proof of her treachery and enough evidence to bring both the Queen of Scots and the Duke of Norfolk to trial!' There was excitement in Robin's voice as he spoke these words. Not one of the men in front of me would be sorry to see the head of either the Queen of Scots or their erstwhile colleague fall. Men's thirst for blood puzzles me sometimes.
âWhat steps have you taken to ensure that the Queen of Scots cannot put her plan into action?' The idea of Mary free to plot mischief against me somewhere in Europe made my blood run cold.
âI have sent a fast horse, Your Grace, to the Earl of Shrewsbury to redouble the guard around the treacherous queen. I marked the message “haste, post haste, haste, haste, haste, for life, life, life”.' So, it was as urgent as that.
âGood. And Norfolk, what of him?'
âHe is in the Tower, Your Grace, and the evidence we found in his house is brought safely here.' Again Robin held up more of the papers he clutched in his hands. They included coded letters, the key to the code found hidden in the foolish Duke's roof and a letter from Mary herself.
On the face of this evidence the Duke of Norfolk was lost. I could save Mary Stuart â the evidence against her was relatively flimsy â but for poor foolish Norfolk there was no remedy but a traitor's death. I had hoped that I could merely have imprisoned him for a time, maybe even a long time, rather than take his life. But there was no help for it, I would have to sign his death warrant; I would have to take responsibility for his dreadful punishment. I, who had indulged him, who had ignored the history of treachery in his family, who had given him a place on my privy council, and treated him with the honour and dignity that the greatest lord in the land deserved. I, who had turned a blind eye to his Catholicism and who had tried to warn him away from the path of treachery and conspiracy. The Howards had no business plotting and intriguing. They did not have the brains or the stomach for it, so their conspiracies always failed.
Norfolk was tried and convicted. Cecil told me later that he denied that he had ever conspired in my death or the taking of my throne, but the die was cast. For myself, I believed the man. The Thomas Howard I knew was a big enough fool to simply ignore the consequences of what he was doing. Whatever comforting tales he told himself, his marriage to a freed Queen of Scots could only lead to an attempt on my throne. Anyone with the eyes to see and the brains to think would come to that conclusion. I did not doubt for a moment that Mary was well enough endowed with both. Thomas Howard's tragedy was that he had neither. My tragedy was that now I had to kill him.
âThe hinder part of my brain does not trust the forward parts of the same, my lord. Each time I sign the warrant, I am overcome with horror and must unsign it. He is my cousin and I am so light on for kin of my own blood, my lord. I have no wish for his death, no desire to spill his blood. On the contrary, I shrink from it. Can
we not just lock him up, my lords? As you love me,
can we not just imprison him until God takes his life?'
I was sobbing as I said this, the tears running unchecked down my face. I had been in my bed for three days and three nights and Robin and Cecil had sat beside me, holding the third warrant for the Duke of Norfolk's death. I had revoked the other two and torn them both asunder.
âHe has been sentenced to die by a legally constituted court and the sentence must now be carried out upon him and it is your duty as queen to sign the warrant. You have no choice in this, Your Grace.' Cecil was using his mildest tone, but he and Robin were weary unto death after three days of soothing words, argument and tantrums. âIt is no kindness to him, Your Grace, to leave him hanging, so to speak, like this, not knowing when the end is to come. You do him no favours by raising his hopes of reprieve falsely in this way.'
I wept at Robin's words and buried my face in my pillows. I knew the truth of what he said, yet I still searched in my mind for a way out of my dilemma. In my thirteen years on the throne no person of noble blood had been executed. I had been proud that the scaffold on Tower Hill was derelict. Indeed it had become so neglected from lack of use that when Norfolk had been condemned, another had to be built in its place.
âI have no wish for blood, no thirst for it. It is a serious thing to take another's life, my lord. God commands against it; “Thou shalt not kill”, He tells us. He does not say “Thou shalt not kill â except for traitors”. I do not wish to burn in hell, my lords, for taking this man's life.'
âNow is not the time to argue theology, Your Grace. This is a matter of the law. Your cousin has conspired against you, he has plotted your demise, he has been judged guilty of these capital crimes. The punishment of the court must be carried out, otherwise you risk fatally damaging the authority of your own legal system and the consequences of that for the stability of your kingdom do not bear contemplation.'
âLeave me, leave me, let me sleep and perhaps I will sign the warrant in the morning.'
âNo, Your Grace, we will not leave you; not until you have signed the warrant. It must be done and, forgive an old man's impertinence, but it must be done now.'
At this I grew angry and repeated a phrase that I had used many times before. â“Must” is not a word to use to princes!'