Hellbound: The Tally Man (21 page)
Read Hellbound: The Tally Man Online
Authors: David McCaffrey
Dr. John Franklin, BS.c. HONS, PH.D. M.A., M.CLIN, PSYCH. A.F.PS.S.I.
Case Number: 01020541/27
Subject: Stark, Obadiah James (a.k.a. The Tally Man) cont.
Victim history continued:
The subject murdered a further two women during 1993; Rebecca Collins and Wendy Marrin. Sara Morgan, attacked that same year but survived her assault, has been the topic of much debate over the years, with suggestion that the circumstances surrounding her kidnapping and subsequent ordeal were deliberately orchestrated by the subject in order to enhance the legacy he was creating for himself, however this is pure conjecture. As far as I am aware the subject never knew of her survival.
Twenty four year old Sara Jayne Morgan was living and working in Monroe, Louisiana at the time of her kidnapping. Picked up in a bar by the subject on 18th June 1993, she was subsequently discovered lying at the side of Highway 80 just outside Ruston. Unconscious and barely alive, the lower half of her face appeared to have been blown off, with little remaining of her jaw. During my interview with the subject, he acknowledged that he had taped a firecracker inside her mouth and lit it. When asked why he had done it, he replied that whilst “she was extremely attractive and one half of me wanted to get to know her, the other half of me was curious as to how pretty she would be if part of her face was missing.”
Sara Morgan was treated at Northern Louisiana Medical Centre and, to everyone’s surprise, survived her ordeal, though not without having to undergo intensive facial reconstruction and skin grafts. Unable to speak at the time and to this day without using an electrolarynx she was however, following her extubation in Intensive Care, able to provide the Police with a crude drawing that would associate the subject with the media name that would forever be associated with his crimes. Sara had drawn a picture of a tattoo seen on the subject’s back during her ordeal; a tombstone etched with the tally marks in batches of five. From that point onwards, though the police tried to keep the information hidden from the newspapers, the subject would forever be known as The Tally Man.
Though her survival was seen as a small victory, it was believed in some quarters of law enforcement that she had been allowed to escape rather than procure release herself, lending itself to the theory that the subject had let her escape in order to secure publicity. A key analyst within the FBI stated that Obadiah Stark was too meticulous and calculating an individual to let something as easy as an escape route go un-noticed and it was more than likely he was unaware of her survival.
Excerpt taken from interview with Obadiah Stark (dated 15th April 2010):
“Legacy? I don’t know about that, but what I do know is that there are two types of people in the world; those who make things happen and those who wonder what happened when all is said and done. I made things happen. Those people don’t know how to make things happen for themselves, so how can they hope to make things happen for others?
“As to the legacy issue, that isn’t something which can be left to chance. It’s something that requires determination, based upon the life you lead. I fashioned my life to ensure that I touched people, made a difference in my own way. I wasn’t trying to make the world better than I found it. I was trying to show those who try to structure the world and make it fit into a specifically shaped box, that they were wasting their time. I simply showed them how pointless they efforts at controlling everything is. Besides, a legacy is just an idea that encompasses the past, present and the future. It shows you where you have been and where you are going. My actions were a journey from success to significance. I’m not a monster; I was just ahead of my time.”
It was following the murder of Wendy Marrin that Obadiah Stark appeared to pause his activities for a six-month period. The reasons for this sabbatical remain unclear, During our interview, the subject failed to divulge exactly what he did during the aforementioned period, but whatever his actions, December 1993 saw the discovery of Siobhán Duggan’s body in an alleyway in Slane, Ireland. No link was made initially between the subject’s crimes in America and a murder in a small town on the bank of the Boyne. However when Katherine Keld’s body was discovered in a cave outside Ardfert near Tralee, the local police force or Gardaí theorised a link between the murders due to similarities with the victims in the USA. Subsequent liaisons with the FBI and Interpol identified a high probability that Obadiah Stark had proceeded to continue his work on the shores of Ireland. The subject’s links to the country were not realised at the time and therefore it was implied that his choice of location was arbitrary.
‘The basic tool for the manipulation of reality is the manipulation of words. If you can control the meaning of words, you can control the people who use them.’
Phillip K. Dick
Chapter Seventeen
October 3rd
00:26
Fenit (An Fhianait)
County Kerry, Ireland
THE act of deceit is something that some find easier to commit than others. Some may do it to protect those they care for, others to gain a stronger position for themselves. Deceit is often seen as the raison d’être of the politian, whose very existence is seen by some to be solely for the purpose of inveigling and obfuscating the truth.
It must be used delicately, for like a snake coiled around the wrist, it can have a nasty habit of causing a serious injury if you don’t handle it with care. For those who use it to serve their own ends, very few would weep when it all comes tumbling down around them.
But for those who use it in the pursuit of protecting those they care for, it can become an altogether different beast. In those circumstances, deceit can be seen by the deceiver as the right thing for the wrong reasons. It is always a matter of perspective, and how the deceived will choose to view it. Will they see it as a noble sacrifice, or a selfish act?
* * *
Joe closed the front door with more relief than he cared to remember. Moving through the living room to the kitchen, he poured himself a large JD and grabbed a packet of peas from the freezer before crashing onto the settee. Swirling the bourbon around the glass, he took a large mouthful, enjoying the warm, astringent sensation before swallowing it.
Pressing the peas to his cheek, Joe allowed himself a moment to consider how he had ended up the focal point of a murder attempt. The intricacies surrounding Stark’s execution were becoming a little more sinister and suspicious with every passing day. Someone’s cage was obviously rattled, someone who perhaps stood to lose a great deal if he actually uncovered anything solid. Right now all he had was supposition, heresy and chary behavior, but based on tonight’s escapade he knew he must be close to something others would rather keep hidden.
He stared at the ceiling, hoping for a revelation. There was something linking a number of people involved in and witness to Stark’s execution, he just couldn’t put his finger on it. Acts committed by someone like Obadiah Stark left a resonance, lingering in silence. The family members had an enmity, he had seen it during his interviews. Animosity from evil gone unpunished.
Beginning to irritate himself, Joe rose from the settee and poured himself another JD, placing the peas back in the freezer to chill again. The glass was almost to his lips when the doorbell made him start, causing him to spill the drink down his shirt.
“Shit!” He placed the glass on the bench and grabbed a tea towel to wipe his front as he approached the door. Joe noted the small shape through the glass before he opened it, subconsciously registering her frame.
Vicky waved a bottle of wine gently in front of his face. “I figured we’d give Sean Og’s a rest tonight…”
Joe felt slightly uncomfortable as she began to register his injuries, her eyes scanning him repeatedly.
“Jesus, Joe, what happened to your face?”
“I was attacked by a Crayola. Come in.” He pushed the door open wider and ushered Vicky into the hall. She slowly traversed under his arm, staring at him as she moved into the living room.
“When did this happen?” She asked as he closed the door behind them.
“Just this evening, or should I say yesterday,” he replied glancing at his watch and standing awkwardly still. “Don’t worry, it’s not as bad as it looks.”
Vicky frowned. “Figuratively or literally, because it looks pretty bad to me. Have you been to the hospital?”
He shook his head. “No, my bag of Bird’s Eye are currently recharging in the freezer…better than anything they could do. Besides, after the Gardaí were done with me, I honestly couldn’t be arsed.”
She moved in front of him, frowning. “Gardaí? What are you going on about?”
“I had a flat tire at work,” Joe replied whilst massaging his bruised jaw. “This guy offered to help me change it, I was tired so I accepted. Then he attacked me.”
“Do you know who it was?”
“Oddly, he didn’t introduce himself.”
“Why’d he want to hurt you?” Vicky pressed, ignoring his sarcasm as she sat down, resting the bottle of wine between her legs.
Joe looked at her with an exasperated expression. “You know, it’s funny, he didn’t punctuate kicking the shite out of me with exposition so I don’t really know.”
“How do you know he wanted to kill you?”
“He had a fuckin’ gun, Vicky so I figured he wasn’t simply trying to get my attention.” Noticing her hesitant gaze, Joe sat down beside her. “Sorry, just been a crappy day.”
She gently touched his arm whilst raising the wine bottle and giving it a shake. “It’s okay. We now have a better excuse to open this. That’s if you don’t mind downgrading to something a little less inebriating?” She nodded towards the empty glass on the bench.
Joe smiled. “No, it’s okay. Most of it ended up down my shirt anyway.”
Following her into the kitchen Joe leaned back against the bench and pointed towards the drawer holding the bottle opener as she glanced around.
“So, what do you think it’s all about,” Vicky asked as she began removing the cork. He acknowledged her with a sigh and accompanying frown. “Honestly? I’m not sure, but I think it all has something to do with my digging into Stark’s execution.”
Vicky looked puzzled as she grabbed two glasses from his cabinet and filled them, handing him the fuller of the two. “How so?”
Joe hesitated for a moment, his expression closed. “The night Stark was executed. Something’s ‘off’ about the whole thing, and I think tonight pretty much confirms it.”
Vicky gave a startled laughed. “Joe, being beaten up is hardly confirmation of a global conspiracy.”
“Ordinarily, I’d be inclined to agree with you, but aside from being a shite raconteur there’s nothing else I’m doing that would get under someone’s skin enough for them to want me dead. When aforementioned beating involves someone actually trying to shoot you, it tends to indicate they want you dead for a reason.”
Joe noted her skeptical look before taking a drink. “Yeah, I know. But it still doesn’t change the fact that something’s not right about it all.”
Vicky studied Joe’s face. “Okay, Sherlock. Let’s assume for a moment that I believe you…”
“I know it sounds a little mad, but bear with me. Stark was executed last month, big event, the world’s media in attendance, the victim’s relatives and yours truly. The lethal injection seems to go as planned and, aside from Stark having some sort of seizure and scaring the crap out of everyone, dies on schedule. Curtain down, exit stage left, case closed, right?”
“Okay,” Vicky replied cautiously.
“Boat visits Absolom where Stark’s body is loaded onto it, standard procedure. Boat sets sail for the mainland where the body is to be delivered to the Royal Victoria.”
“Well, the site isn’t directly attached to the hospital, and they have a contract with the Government regarding the storage of bodies. I imagine if you boil it down to its common denominator it comes down to money. Anyway, there they are supposed to stay until the state decides on the funeral arrangements, that sort of thing.”
“Okay,” Vicky said rolling her eyes. “It’s fascinating, but I’m not really feeling conspiracy here and I already know all of this.”
Joe drew in a deep breath and held it for a moment before releasing it slowly as he spoke. “The boat transporting his body took nearly four hours to make an hour and a half trip?”
“And?”
“…and, his body never made it to the mortuary.”
Vicky frowned. “You can prove this?”
“Well, not exactly, but I think what I have is pretty conclusive. When an hour’s trip takes three times longer than it’s supposed to and there’s no record of problems or weather issues, it’s a fair bet that something’s a little funky.”
He could tell she wasn’t satisfied with his answer.
“Okay,” Vicky announced. “Let’s just say for the sake of argument that your right and that something unusual is going on, what purpose does it serve?”
“I don’t know,” Joe replied, his gaze falling to the floor and then back up again. “Yet.”
He sighed and stood up, moving back towards the living room shaking his head. He was tired and miserable and aching from head to foot. It was all fucked up and he knew it, but really needed someone to believe him.
He slumped onto the settee, folding his arms across his chest. “It’s not just the boat, it’s everything. I’ve interviewed every witness, relative, prison guard and criminologist this side of the Liffy because I felt like I owed a service to the relatives. To ensure that instead of reporting crap like other papers did, I could give what had happened to them some gravitas. And then, after Stark’s execution I had this idea to write a book about the man, his life and crimes. I didn’t want it to be just another cash in, I wanted it to be justified and balanced. Your offer of help came at the right time. You’ve given me the credible stuff that adds more than just the ‘he was a killer because his parents held him too tight or not enough’, shite.
“But since looking into it all further, something’s wrong. I don’t know what or why, but it is. Before Stark died, these people were angry, now, they’re like a bunch of hugger-muggers.”
“Hugger whats?”
“Hugger-mugger; cloak and dagger kind of thing.” She started to laugh, but then looked at Joe’s expression and fell silent”
“I’m not imagining it, Vicky. Stamford started this whole thing, and had nothing to gain by lying to me. Sabitch and Evans are definitely hiding something to do with his execution file and death certificate, and…”
“And?”
“…and, Evan’s got all funny when I challenged him about something called The Brethren.”
“The Brethren,” Vicky repeated, her face twitching slightly.
“You’ve heard of them?” Joe challenged.
“No,” she replied quickly, her face flushing as she averted her gaze. “Wow, I feel a little light headed all of a sudden. Must be this wine.”
Joe watched her as she moved into the living room and sat down in the chair opposite. Vicky’s gaze cast towards her feet before rising again.
He felt his head tilting wearily, prompting him to give an exasperated sigh. “I don’t know, maybe you’re right. I’m tired, getting slowly drunk and look like I’ve gone four rounds with The Rock. I think I just need to go to bed. I don’t blame you for thinking it’s a little far-fetched. I’m not sure I believe it myself. I guess after everything today, I just needed to share it with someone. And why not a beautiful, smart criminologist…”
His voice faded as though afraid to say anything else.
A moment passed between them and seemed to hang in the air.
Joe cleared his throat and rose quickly from the chair. “Definitely time for bed I think. I’ll walk you to your car.”
Vicky smiled and stood up, following behind him. She placed her hand on his shoulder and spun him around to face her.
“Time for bed, you said.”
She touched his face before kissing him, her body folding into his and forcing him back against the front door. Shocked by her sudden actions, he nevertheless found himself pulling her closer to him, his hand sliding beneath her blouse and pulling it loose. Her hands moved across his chest, unbuttoning his shirt and moving down towards his trousers with an unexpected urgency.
Joe pushed her back, staring directly into her eyes and seeing a stark need that forced his body to unconsciously react.
“I don’t think this is a good idea,” he uttered in a low voice.
Vicky gazed back at him, biting her lower lip. “Why not? You promised me a good time the other night at Sean Og’s. I just want to collect.”
She kissed him again, her hands exploring his body as she pulled him down towards the floor. Joe pulled his shirt over his head and lay down beside her, his hands pulling at her blouse and finding her bra strap.
“Don’t lose respect for me if this doesn’t happen with one hand.”
“Just get it done,” Vicky murmured.
Mindlessly colliding with her body, Joe found himself thinking that his evening had taken a dramatic turn for the better. And yet, the darkest corner of his mind continued to process his refusal to give up on the fact that he was close to uncovering something about Stark that was desperately trying to stay hidden. And like any secret, he knew that the only thing you got when digging up the past was dirty.
